Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

Posts

Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

#1

Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

Chad P

The Japanese chisel discussion below got me to thinking about the first set I ever bought. I was on a business trip to Tokyo and purchased a set of chisels (2 pictured below) at a little tool shop near the US. embassy there.

Does anybody know who may have made these?

Here is a picture


Thanks for the help!

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

#2

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

david weaver

I only recognize a few marks, and not that one. You might want to go over to sawmillcreek where Stan Covington posts - he's in japan and can read the kanji.

Be prepared for his thoughts on the brand. He'll tell you what he thinks, flattering or not. Even if someone doesn't like the make, I've found all of the japanese chisels that I've had to be good performers. Some are spectacular, but all have been good.

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

#3

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

Chad

Thanks David. I’ll take your advice and seek out Stan’s help. Not worried about his POV on the chisels. They are more of a souvenir than anything. I was on business trip and looking for something Japanese that I would appreciate. The storekeeper in a tiny shop down by the US embassy had a picture of Jimmy Carter in his shop. I always have imagined JC doing the same thing I did, look for the nearest shop to peruse some tools. I had no appreciation for any differences in the maker at the time. I doubt the chisels will touch any wood anytime soon, as I have plenty of others set up and tuned.

I agree with you about Japanese chisels in general. Even the “value” chisel set I bought from Grizzly has been an excellent purchase.

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

#4

Re: Help Identify a Japanese Chisel

david weaver

I see Stan responded. I'd figured that he'd comment on the finish, only because a lot of export only and gift shop chisels aren't finished to the level that someone like older Ouchi would do (I haven't seen new ones, they're probably excellent) or on the extreme end, someone like Shimamura (Kiyotada) in his later work or Konobu, or Kiyohisa.

The first set of chisels I ever got was multi-hollow ebony handled chisels that had an obscure saying like yours. Their kanji said 3000 Chrysanthemums or something like that, which is a very showy name. A few people told me they were rough looking (I had been hoping that I found a real deal), and nobody could speculate on exactly what they were except that they were marked for export and "nobody does their fine work on export chisels" was what I was told.

I set them up and used them, and they were excellent users. The level of finish doesn't really matter if someone didn't charge you $200 for them. If they are marked with a ceremonial name, you may never figure out where they actually came from (I never figured out mine), but I do hope that you use them some day and then when you're done, leave them in a case with some literature stating their significance for someone down the road to find.

In short, I think they'll be nice chisels, but you might not find out who made them. They are probably technically better than grizzly chisels (we'd need to see the edge to get a guess at that, so that we can see if the lamination was folded up on the corners), but I find the grizzly-sold chisels to be awfully good once you set them up properly. I don't have their chisels specifically, but I have the gouge set (from Grizzly) and it took a short period of time to solve their setup and then I found that I could literally cut plane mortise curved parts with a mallet with them (and a heavy hand) and they're none the worse for wear.

Some of my favorite tools are little unlabeled and unrecognizable things that have a little bit of literature with them. Either a stone with a sheet of paper tucked in the box that tells where the stone came from or who used it and where they worked, etc.

(my friend has my export only chisels now and loves them. I'd still have them, but I got a little out of control and ended up with four sets of japanese chisels at one point).