Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A milestone for me...

Posts

A milestone for me...

#1

A milestone for me...

david weaver

...I don't know if I posted this already, can't remember. I thought about it last week, but don't think I did.

This past weekend, I burned my router table :)

Every single thing I've ever done on it, I resented doing as it cheated me out of doing the same job in a way that I've liked more (making doors, cutting grooves, applying a chamfer, etc). I've even used my router table to joint wood thanks to a connected friend who had an aluminum fence made for me with one face 0.2mm higher on the outfeed than on the infeed.

My RT was right in the middle of my garage shop. Not really in the way of anything, but taking up space nonetheless.

Re: A milestone for me...

#2

Re: A milestone for me...

Patrick Chase

Well, if you'd had a proper phenolic-topped router table then that wouldn't have been possible...

Seriously, congrats! I'm not quite there yet...

Re: A milestone for me...

#3

Re: A milestone for me...

John Aniano in Central NJ

David,

Congrats!

I keep my little router table because it hangs from the wall and is not in the way. However, I'm seriously considering selling my little Inca modelmaker's ~7" blade, tilting top table saw. Last time it got used was while Bill C. was president. It takes up space in the corner of my shop and I pile my hand saw collection on top. Seems fitting. If anyone is interested, ping me.

John

Re: A milestone for me...

#4

Re: A milestone for me...

david weaver

I'm sure if I had the desire, I could find lots of uses for the router table. I considered keeping the router and trying to make a sort of stub sized table for it just in case I ever have a use....but I already have a problem like that (keeping stuff I really don't need "just in case") and would like to solve it.

I'm going on the theory that anything I did on the router (I never do a run of 5 of anything), I'll actually do faster with hand tools. Not perhaps each individual "act" itself, but just the fact that I'll actually do the work with hand tools as opposed to putting it off.

Re: A milestone for me...

#5

Re: A milestone for me...

John in NM

That is a good point David - there is one router task I do a lot of that I kind of dread still, so I'll often put it off until after lunch, only to find plenty of other things to keep me busy the rest of the weekend!

If you did save the router, you can always get by with a piece of plywood screwed to any sturdy base if you need a router table again.

Re: A milestone for me...

#6

Re: A milestone for me...

Patrick Chase

Believe it or not the only router bits I've used recently are my set for making wooden toy railroad tracks for my kids. I'm not dedicated enough to both doing that with hand tools (and curved sections are a pain without the bit IMO).

Re: A milestone for me...

#8

Re: A milestone for me...

TM Stock

It seems to me that celebrating David's accomplishment would be the goal here, Derek. We all have our own unique path to tread through life, and whether that path takes us out on the porch to wave our cane at the rotten neighborhood kids running through our yard or down to our basement workshop/dungeon to spend some pleasurable hours making up a graduated-size set of truly authentic 18th century ball gags (no phenol-laden plastics or harsh 21st century chrome-tanned leather, please!), it is simply good manners to avoid questioning the pleasures, perversions, or indeed, the sanity of the others here enjoying the fellowship and good natured camaraderie of this place.

Re: A milestone for me...

#10

Re: A milestone for me...

David weaver

The original post is gone. But I'm not offended if someone thinks dumping the router table is a dumb idea. I'm still going to keep a festool of1400 in case I need it for house work.

Re: A milestone for me...

#11

Re: That seems a little extreme


Re: A milestone for me...

#12

Re: That seems a little extreme

david weaver

The burning, or the disposal of the router table in general?

I burned it only because it wasn't really worth anything, and I hate putting wood in the trash (i'm in the burbs). I made my table somewhat along the advice of pat warner, and it was flat and useful, and very plain. 2x4 base, laminated in some spots. Deck screws (pat wouldn't have approved of that) and bolts with washers elsewhere. It stayed flat over the 10 years that I had it and I believe the cost was about $30 to make it. The 7518 wasn't as cheap, and I recall the router plate being about $60, but I'm sure I got a sale deal on all of those things at the time.

Otherwise, there's so little that I keep a router for that the table doesn't make much sense to have. Even on kitchen cabinets, I've resented raising panels and making the door sticking with the bit set. I made a panel raising plane after I started this, and would much rather have used it, but it's one of those things where a few doors are done already with the bit set and the pattern is set in stone.

I think back at the things I've done with a router. The very first was some household door work, widening the opening for door hardware (my doors are old and won't fit standard hardware). I had a catch with a nice bosch plunger and spent a while soft-handing everything carefully to open the doors.

I did three more this year with a rasp in ten minutes.

I do still have a small tablesaw that I'm likely to keep only because I don't know any other good way to slot deep boxing (on moulding plantes) other than dovetails. I had a wing cutter for the router table, but never much liked using it.

Re: A milestone for me...

#13

Re: A milestone for me...

Brian Holcombe

Nicely done David! I hang onto mine for when I do production type work (unless rabbeting for instance) but really don’t love the sound it produces.

Re: A milestone for me...

#14

Re: A milestone for me...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nah .. each to their own ... I posted that, as you got rid of yours, I had made a router table. :)

Not that I use one often (once or twice a year), but I could tuck it away on my table saw (a new acquisition), where it does not take up space.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A milestone for me...

#15

Re: A milestone for me...

david weaver

Ditto that. I couldn't find my ear muffs for the last door panel (kids like to wear them and pretend they're air traffic control) and I must admit I didn't favor the noise!

Re: A milestone for me...

#16

Re: A milestone for me...

david weaver

New tablesaw, eh? Clearly, it must be a Martin slider?

If I were going to do a whole bunch of doors and I was organized, the router table would make a great deal of sense (but it would still be bliss for me to raise those panels by hand - off of the plane, they require a lot less finish work - I am not sure I'm sold on the time benefit, but there's little chance I could organize my kitchen project and do all of the doors and panels separately without making a mistake. My brain seeks safety in making things, and one at a time is easier, though slower).

By hand, some things are not as accurate, but did a lot of the dimensioning, etc, by hand on the cabinets, and to date (I am finished with everything now), I threw out one stick of cherry about 2x16, it should've been 2.25, and two small pieces of plywood. There is something about having the blood flowing while doing the work by hand that makes everything easier to focus on.

Re: A milestone for me...

#17

Re: A milestone for me...

TM Stock

Count me as gobsmacked - I took David's original post as a jest, and Derek's as being delivered in kind. I don't usually find myself in the fraction of the population which Scott Adams (Dilbert's creator) suggests lacks the ability to sense humor, but I have to admit to being a little flummoxed by the notion that both posts were anything other than clever parody. My apologies for treating them as such.

Re: A milestone for me...

#18

Re: A milestone for me...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

As you know, in recent years I have preferred to rough out my rough sawn timber with machines. These are my apprentices that do the basic dimensioning, and then hand tools take over.

The old contractor table saw I had for over 20 years has been replaced by a small Hammer K3 Winner (49" slider). It has a small footprint (smaller than the contractor saw!). As with you, space is at a premium for me. And, as like you, I cannot justify a stand alone router table. It was possible to fit one into the out feed of the K3. If I could not, I would not have one. Routers are valuable tools, and have their place, but I prefer to use them free hand. A router table would be used for duplicating parts on a template.

As I mentioned, I was struck by the timing of your post - you getting rid of yours as I was installing one! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A milestone for me...

#19

congrates

Joseph Piotrowski

i checked my big router table last year. i need space!. i'm selling off all the tools i have not used in forever.

my power tools have largely gone untouched over the last year. i dread the day i need to turn on a power router again. the noise and the dust is unwelcome.

this week i was using up materials laying around my shop that involved plywood and used my 18v circ saw. i couldn't stand the dust flying around, breathing it in.

unplugged for me as much as possible!

Re: A milestone for me...

#20

Re: A milestone for me...

david weaver

I did actually burn my table, but I do consider it sort of a joke, because 99% of the population is dreaming about having a router table with a hammer of a router like the 7518 in it.

If I did a whole bunch of template type work, I might've had a reason to keep it. Certainly (IIRC, you've posted pictures of guitars), it might be pretty valuable for that. I hope to build some guitars at some point, but I will trim them by hand only because it makes me feel good.

It wouldn't feel so good if I had to make 14 of them for a price, and they were otherwise identical, but I could rig up something small and heavy if I wanted to make a few.

I kind of like stuff that's fitted by hand and has a little life, but still has enough skill that any variations from machinist standards are life, and not defect.That is one of the reasons I don't have set patterns or jigs for any of my planes.

It's just sort of a thing.

Re: A milestone for me...

#21

Housework...

John in NM

Completely off the wall, I had the image for a sec of a festool router that also washes windows :D

Re: A milestone for me...

#22

You might be surprised...

John in NM

Making 14 of something for a price can be extremely satisfying. Having people line up to part with their hard earned money for something you made is actually pretty incredible.

On the other hand, when I worked for a furniture shop for a couple years I hated it. There is something fundamentally different (at least for me) about being a hired hand producing whatever the boss says to produce.

Re: A milestone for me...

#23

Re: You might be surprised...

david weaver

I worked for three years at Aristokraft while I was in college. Talk about something that is far removed from woodworking as a hobby. I did get to sand, drill, etc, things there, but usually was either in a subgroup doing pre-assembly work or on a production line doing assembly.

My last year, we made 3350 cabinets a week.

If I had a trademark item, I wouldn't mind making it, but my household environment isn't really conducive to that at this point. I also wouldn't mind making planes for pay, but I always have this hitch that I don't want to have someone paying me for something and thinking I should make it the way they want me to make it.

There is something generally nice about making the 10th of an item rather than the first, because you've gotten to the point where every single step doesn't require so much thought. But I like it best when all ten things are done by hand.

My mother (retired now) has a little side hustle (I guess it's probably not little) that she does semi-production painting things simplistically. The stuff isn't my style, but it's repetitive enough that she can do most of it without thinking too hard, but there's enough hand work in it that you can tell someone did it by hand, and there's some skill involved. Her painting reminds me of good carving where the carving work is done in a fluid cut. She lays the brush down at the beginning of an element and in one stroke, it's done. She has a legitimate business, though, and I'm pretty sure I don't want to.

Re: A milestone for me...

#24

Re: Housework...

david weaver

Not sure what the lowest speed level is, but you could probably dust with one if you had a buffing pad. Windows sounds like a good idea, too.

Not totally sure about keeping the festool, though, as I have (wring my hands) a third router, a hitachi kit that was really cheap. It's not as nice as the festool, but I'm sure it's nice enough for me. One or the other is taking a hike real soon, it'll just depend on how stingy I am when I pick which to sell.

Re: A milestone for me...

#25

Re: You might be surprised...

John in NM

You should make the planes. Just make a couple that you would want and see if you can sell them. If they sell make a couple more.

You're right about having to make to others' specs, I ended up doing a lot more of that than I liked and it can be trouble. But the flip side is the custom stuff often generates talk and referrals in your niche. It can be a delicate balance to maintain, just enough custom to keep it all fresh, but enough standard stuff to be profitable.