Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

when to Camber during sharpening?

Posts

when to Camber during sharpening?

#1

when to Camber during sharpening?

Joseph Piotrowski

give than i am using stones and not a wheels, my question is during which phase of the process do establish the camber? given my limited knowledge, i define 3 phases. in a simplified explanation: shaping (grinding the primary bevel angle), sharpening(creating the burr) and hone/polishing.

for reference the stones i have are 320,1000,5000,12000. given any simple set or very course, medium , fine, very fine.

after flattening, where do i focus on the camber? after i create the burr on a 1000 stone(medium), them continue on the remaining stones trying to maintain the bevel and camber. or do i go through polishing step and come back to the medium stone?

thanks,

Joe P.

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#2

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

david weaver

There are a million ways to do it. On a smoother, it doesn't really matter as long as you're establishing it with stones sometime before the final polishing stone. Once you've got it established, you just maintain it with even sharpening and corrections as needed (for example, if the smoother takes too narrow of a shaving, you can hone biasing to hone mostly the middle of the iron on the next sharpening cycle. If it's too flat, you can work a bit more of the corners off).

This is reliable for smoothers, jointers, try planes, etc.

For less gradual camber than that, you'll want to establish the profile on a grinder and then hone the ground profile.

For the process in general, use the feedback from the tools to tell you whether you have enough or too much or not enough, etc. Don't worry about specific methods of applying camber unless you want something as a starting point. It's a lot more intuitive than it seems to be in online discussions.

(this is another area where using a single stone like a washita excels - you establish everything and hone with the same stone. Maintenance and correction are easier and faster since there's only one stone).

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#3

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

There are two stages here: firstly, when you are establishing the camber for the first time and, secondly, when you are maintaining an existing camber.

To create the camber, I hone the blade straight across with the 1000 grit, raising a wire. Now, whether you do this freehand or with a guide, the process is the same: divide the width of the blade into five points. The first point from the centre, place your finger on this spot, exert downforce, and take 3 strokes. Now at the outside take 5 strokes. Repeat on the other side of the blade. This creates the camber. (You can take more strokes, as you prefer, which will deepen the camber).

Now you can hone the camber with the higher grits, in turn. Simply hone the bevel evenly with each grit. Don't forget to remove the wire only with the final polishing medium.

The second stage is to maintain an existing camber. The important factor here is to create a wire across the width of the blade. If the micro bevel (either secondary on a flat primary or as a result of a hollow) is small, then may be able to just use the middle stone. As it increases in width, then you will need to return to the 1000. Just focus on keeping the honing even across the blade. Feel for the wire, which tells you that you have honed the edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#4

When there is heavy camber

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.[/AP2M

(I meant this to reply to the OP, not to Derek’s fine post!)

For jacks and foreplanes, or any plane where the camber amplitude will be, say, 1/32” or more, I suggest you mark the camber on the face of the iron before you start, so as to have a reference to grind and hone to.

One way to do this, is find a likely can, whose radius yields the amplitude you want (which will depend in part on the blade width). If you know the radius, just find the right-sized can. If you know the amplitude, then draw a line 1/32or 3/64 or whatever you want, distance from the blade’s edge, then find a can which fits the line-ends and the midpoint of the existing edge. Add a scosh to give yourself room to mark and grind. To mark, the quick and dirty way is just take a Sanford sharpie or equal and trace the can’s border, A more precise way is to blue or redden the face of the iron, and scribe through the color, to get a finer line.

Grind to just short of your marks, so as not to destroy your witness. Grind blunt, rather than trying to preserve the primary bevel while you grind. The reestablish the bevel, and proceed as David and Derek describe.

The above is my suggestion for your consideration—there are other ways, as there are with every topic we discuss here.

Wiley

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#5

Re: One other way for the challenged

david weaver

...which includes me is to do everything that Wiley says, but grind facets off in the curve (as wiley says, always grind the iron edge at 90 degrees and then restore the bevel. The work will be much safer and faster) until you have a near curve, and then the curved work will be easy.

I no longer draw lines, but do the facets (but I have done a lot of irons, so that's not a suggestion for a first). It's just easier to see than judging a curve. If the facets are even, when you knock the points off to make the thing a continuous curve, you'll have a nice smooth curve.

This is good practice for a lot more than irons, but I'm sure the first place I ever saw it was a handle-making tutorial from Mike Wenzloff. It's invaluable in that case.

I have an iron that I need to grind to a curve and can illustrate or take a video if it's helpful.

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#6

Yet another approach

Patrick Chase

A small variation on Wiley's approach:

A long time back I made templates out of phenolic sheet for the radii that I commonly use (3" for scrubs, 6", 12", 20"). The templates have registration features for the iron widths that I use each of them on.

When I want to shape an iron I paint its back with Dykem, position the template, and then scribe the desired leading edge with an awl.

I grind the leading edge to the scribed line, with the wheel at 90 deg to the iron. I then finally grind the primary bevel to whatever angle I want.

Grinding the camber profile first minimizes the degree to which I have to work adjacent to a thin edge when establishing the bevel.

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#7

Re: One other way for the challenged

david weaver

It took me a while yesterday to realize why I facet, because I have long since forgotten.

I've never used a specific radius, it's a nuisance to find something the right radius or make a template or whatever, and I'm always looking to make things, not make templates.

I recall at one point applying a template to trace to the end of an iron, and I found it cumbersome, so instead of doing that, I guess about where I want the depth of the camber to go to, mark it on both sides, and then cut the facets.

If Chris Schwarz says he uses 9" radius for camber, I don't really care what he says, because he's an editor and printer. If warren knew the number he had, I'd certainly pay more attention - but he may work different stuff than I do, or work slightly differently with his jack plane and prefer something different.

I'm not getting to the point well here, it's two fold.

1) the faceting is a quick method, you don't actually have to lay out the whole curve, just the facets and then round them, cutting to depth at the corners and none in the middle

2) evaluate in use. If the camber is too much, hone the center a bit hard the next few times you use the iron and grind biased toward the middle. If it's not enough, do the opposite

It's pretty hard to *not* figure out what works best given the effort in hand dimensioning, unless you only ever do a little bit. If you do a significant amount, you'll figure out what works best pretty quickly, even if you only have a small amount of insight.

(the narrower the iron, the more difficult it becomes to trace a template, or set one up. Making the hollow and round irons comes to mind. Fortunately, if you don't do a perfect job with them, nobody will know unless they come to one of your mouldings with a template).

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#8

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?  *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Joe,

I know you stated you don't use powered grinding wheels, but I thought I'd mention my old posting from 2004 about the Tormek radius jig I made and continue to use. The link is below.

John


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3104/md/read/id/34297/sbj/blade-radiusing-jig-for-tormek/

Re: when to Camber during sharpening?

#9

thanks

Joseph Piotrowski

this will be useful to me for an upcoming project. although i am learning to free hand sharpen, i am currently working on what i feel to be an awesome sharpening jig. this will be a nice accessory i can add to it.