Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tell me about the adze

Posts

Tell me about the adze

#1

Tell me about the adze

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I plan to build a few windsor chairs, beginning with three stools. I have very nice scorp, a couple of favourite drawknives and spokeshaves, and am in the process of building a few travishers.

The wood for the seat at this stage is dry Pine or Tasmanian Oak (a eucalyptus).

This is a new area for me. I have done a good bit of reading in regard to a decent curved one-handed adze, and the following stand out: Hans Karlsson, Svante Djarv, Gransfors Bruks and Tim Manney. Everything but the TM appears to be out of stock. Perhaps this is a good thing as they are pricey and I am saved from an impulse purchase :)

Probably closer to my beginner status is the newish Narex, which is cheap by comparison. Has anyone used one?

Any favourites? Your pearls of wisdom would be most appreciated.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me about the adze

#2

Re: Tell me about the adze

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Derek,

Having built only two sackback Windsor chairs, I may not be the best to comment, but...

I'm assuming you are using the adze for the initial hollowing of the seat. If you aren't making a lot of chairs, you might consider using only a good, sharp scorp to hollow out the seat. I have two gutter adzes and I probably used them for 2 minutes per seat. You are only hollowing out ~3/4" max, right? Spend 5 minutes and use the scorp, which has lots of control. I followed with a sharp compass plane. My travisher does work, but my compass plane gave a better finish, and was more intuitive for carving, at least for me...

Why when typing the word "scorp" does the software insist you mean to say "Scorpio"? Now that's a question that needs answering!

John

Re: Tell me about the adze

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Tell me about the adze

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek I have carved maybe 40 chair seats and I’m still waiting on delivery of my adze through country workshops. It is merely a tool to ease the work required for initial hollowing. I find the scorp handles the job just fine. I think you will enjoy using an adze but it is not necessary for the job. ...Jack

Re: Tell me about the adze

#4

Ken Vaughan

Kestrel adze

Ken Vaughan

Your list did not include a non-european style adze. Suggest you take a look at Kestrel Tools hand adze choices. They have over the years added the lipped adze and the D adze which have european heritage.

And you can make your own handle from local woods.

Re: Tell me about the adze

#5

Re: Tell me about the adze

Kevin Adams

Hi Derek,

As others have said, you really don’t need the adze, esp if you are only making a few chairs. The inshave or even a large gouge can do the job. The adze is like a very rough scrub plane and the inshave more like a traditional fore plane. You’ll be surprised how quickly the inshave will work and you’re really not going all that deep with the saddling anyway. If we were closer, you’d be welcome to try my Tim M or Kestrel. They are both great, I prefer the former and have been close to selling the Kestrel as it isn’t used.

Please take some pics (I know you will!) when you get going.

Best,

Kevin

Re: Tell me about the adze

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Tell me about the adze

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek,

If you do purchase one,please post a review. ---Jack

Re: Tell me about the adze

#7

Re: Tell me about the adze

TomD

"This is a new area for me. I have done a good bit of reading in regard to a decent curved one-handed adze,"

I use a guttering adze for this, and the one I got came from Country Workshops, which I think has closed down. They sold them unhandled at a great price. While these were two handers, I would say the heads were on the small size, very easily controlled. With two hands you rest the work on the ground, brace both elbows on your knee area. Even the first time you pick the tool up, you are relatively surgical. Far preferable to blazing away single handed in my view, and almost impossible to cut yourself.

All that said, I would wonder for the scope of work you intend whether a Krenov style scrub plane would not be faster and more controllable. One can crank one of those out in about 45 minutes if one has a bandsaw and a planer, or reasonable wood to start with. In this case it would involve making a hollowing plane with a double cambered sole, which is a little intimidating, but in this particular instance, one would just saw a longi curve; cut a bevel on the edges; blend with a spokeshave. All the complexity related to matching curves an mouth opening to the blade would be superfluous in this style of plane. You probably already have several scrub or agressive Jack blades you could use.

Of course part of the fun is playing with the big boy toys. So I looked up that list that used to be out there for Dunbar approved tools, and I found: This one that took me back to COuntry workshops:

http://handtoolwoodworking.com/tool-list/

http://www.countryworkshops.org/Adzes.html

The midsize one is the one I made. I think the heads were like about 79 bucks in my day. Ouch. To bend the handles, you need a wacking big piece of wood, or to be making two at a time. I laminated mine out of two pieces of wood, and it kinda ended up looking flattish.

and the following stand out: Hans Karlsson, Svante Djarv, Gransfors Bruks and Tim Manney. Everything but the TM appears to be out of stock. Perhaps this is a good thing as they are pricey and I am saved from an impulse purchase :)

"Probably closer to my beginner status is the newish Narex, which is cheap by comparison. Has anyone used one? "

You can't ever be a beginner again, you have too much tool savvy and general experience. Not to my taste that Manney one, looks like it might rotate a bit, with the weight where it is. Though bagging one out from a plane blade or something, might soften my prejudices on the mater. My own feeling on the mater is there is so little adze work in a chair that it is not a big deal whatever you use. Pros have them in their hands for only a few minutes. And in my efforts I have stopped shy of the line, so they seem a little unnecessary. My reason for the scrub.

Another option would be the Barr adze, which is patterned after a Dunbar tool, so it should be OK. Kinda plain vanilla to my eyes. But maybe the lack of cranked handle, et all is because the underlying geometry is right. I have a set of their chisels; their framing chisels; and their carver's drawknife, which I think is the best I have ever used (other than a fragile antique I own). I bought a lot all this stuff, maybe 20 years ago, and at that time it lacked edge holding relative to other O1 tools out there, but they were working on it, so by now they should have it down, as there is nothing really to it, and there is masses of info on places like blade forums.

Re: Tell me about the adze

#8

Re: Tell me about the adze

TomD

On the edge holding, I found even back when, that the edge holding/sharpening cycle was fine, short of very hard or abrasive woods, so even if it was still around today, would probably not affect the tool in use for saddling, too much.

Re: Tell me about the adze

#9

Re: Tell me about the adze

Darrell LaRue

I made four windsor chairs, a couple of benches, and some stools. I used a 2 inch gouge with an 18 inch handle for roughing out the seats. You can really put your weight behind the tool,and it rips right through the pine and basswood seat blanks. Never saw the need for an adze.

Re: Tell me about the adze

#10

Have you considered LV's Pull shave?

ian neuhaus

I had the opportunity to have a short play with one about 2 weeks ago.

Initial impressions are that sharp and correctly set, it would quickly hollow out a chair seat ready for finishing with a travisher or convex block plane.

In use it's a bit like a one handed convex shave with a short radius round mouth. Balancing the tool so that the cutting edge cuts rather than skates across the surface should take less than 5 mins practice before you were confident.

Re: Tell me about the adze

#11

Re: Tell me about the adze

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks to everyone who offered advise.

My take away is that I can do without the adze. The scorp is possibly sufficient to rough out the seats, however I am going to look at the Veritas Pull Shave as it seems to be my kind of tool - more finesse and more control. I've done a little reading, and those that use it for roughing out suggest a small modification (rounding the toe), which increases the depth of cut.

I am in the throes of making blades for a couple of travishers, before building the bodies. I will post the results when these are done.

Thanks again.

Regards from Perth

Derek