Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planecraft and the Cap Iron

Posts

Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#1

Planecraft and the Cap Iron

david weaver

I finally broke down and bought a copy of this book, and the cap iron part is pretty early, so I'm already past it.

(the version I got was published in 1959 or so). The early part of the book itself is quite nice. Then it gets to full on record puff piece after that.

The line that Charlie references is in a box after the sentence and then here and gone. In order for someone to have gone to the expense and trouble of making the double iron originally, it must've been a lot less subtle than that.

The puff piece part robs from a page or so of real discussion that would really get users going in the right direction. It's instantly into the superiority of the modern metal plane and the ability to move the frog around (and maybe it was before or after that part, but a discussion of really tightening the mouth up). I suspect the movable frog has a lot more to do with being manufactured separately, and not because it was ever actually needed. Norris panel planes have never failed for me, and there's no frog on them.

Otherwise, decent text. It's funny when you read things (they have a microscopic picture of the record tungsten steel vs. cast steel, but we really don't know if the cast was any good. The message is that the tungsten steel is better and tougher, but I've found the record irons to be subpar vs. the stanley laminated irons, and certainly vs. i.sorby or ward types). Other noted things, early on the author states with authority that chinese planes are definitely pulled because they have a cross bar. The opposite of that is true, I guess he never saw someone grip one (just a curiosity, none of this is of any real issue).

Other bits and bobs - the plane iron must be ground exactly square. Not quite, it should be ground to match the cap. The cap could be square, but once in a while, they're not perfect, and it's better to adjust the iron than the cap.

Leafing through the rest, it looks like the first 20 pages or so were probably the most interesting. The rest may lead a beginner to unnecessary purchases, but so does every other piece of sub-200 year old reading material that talks about planes.

(I doubt that many day to day craftsmen moved the frogs around on their planes).

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#2

Re: Planecraft Sharpening

david weaver

Shortly after the cap session is a pretty nice discussion on sharpening. Following it literally would have a user in a bit of trouble, though.

The nice part - Paul Sellers need not apply - Planecraft recommends bevels as flat as you can get them, and since they are dealing with laminated irons, they also recommend a single bevel for the skilled.

The not so nice part - I believe they're suggesting 25 degrees as the single primary bevel, as other sources have. Not a great idea for finishing planes, or even try planes. I think an honest tinkerer will end up in the low 30s if they're trying for the longest lasting edge.

The other nice part - they are really high on washita and arkansas oilstones. Someone may say that at the time, there wasn't anything equivalent to modern waterstones, but that's not the case. There were bench stone versions of the resin based razor hones, but they never caught on, despite being about the same price. I like the good ones of that era better than modern waterstones, and they'd be longer lasting and a little slower cutting (which is a benefit to a skilled user).

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#3

Resin-based razor hones

Patrick Chase

Do you happen to know what resins and abrasives those used?

That sounds a little like "ye olde Shapton" :-)

I prefer porous ceramic polishers to resinoid myself, but you can clearly get outstanding results with either.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#4

Re: Resin-based razor hones

David weaver

I can't tell you how they were bound, but some may have been shellac based. None were porous that i know of. Some of them had natural abrasives with synthetic binders, like frictionite.

Most of the synthetics had aluminum oxide abrasive, usually a red alumina, and a few had silicon carbide.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#5

Re: Resin-based razor hones

david weaver

Some names to look up:

* aloxite

* swaty

* american hone co (frictionite, super punjab, and a whole gaggle of others)

* tonsorial gem

* OVB (there's a cross reference to woodworking, they have some reasonably nice razor hones that don't cost much)

* Raven

* Norton (beware of the cost of these, they are a favorite on the axe circuit in australia and new zealand - 2.x by 5 inches may be in the range of $1k)

* carborundum corp other than aloxite

(using the words "razor hone" with any of the above will get you a whole bunch on google images).

Most of the above hones are made in the following fashion:

* a relatively coarse abrasive, like what we'd call 2k, is embedded in a binder, and then the surface is finished to a gloss. They are never intended to be conditioned or the coarseness of the actual abrasive will be seen quickly. their use is to thin the bevel of a razor in most cases, but not remove the edge. A very rough shave ensues until linen and leather recondition the actual edge if one goes that route.

* there are some exceptions - the frictionite 825/#00 fine side is relatively fine. Like 8k-10k and won't ruin your day. The very fine swaty, the same (there are various types), the norton axe man is very fine, but probably not more so than a shapton. An axe man is made to be used dry or wet, though, and is far better for rubbing a race axe than anything new (thus the desire for them). Same is true of frictionite.

I have pulled some old synthetic WA and other stones out of japan. They're interesting, and a lot like modern hones, but they do have some vitrified 8x3x1 sized india stones that are finer than the india stones here. I like those a LOT.

How we got from those to marshmallow kings, I have no idea. Someone (a population as a whole) lost their touch, I guess. Presumably kings were really cheap. Otherwise, I can't see how that style got much of a hold in a society where most woodworkers would've been professionals.

George handed me a pile of frictionite hones to sell for him a while ago. All but one ended up being bought by a guy in Australia who was passing them out to friends (or customers) on the wood circuit. The 2 1/2 x 5 stones averaged about $225 or something, so they're not exactly a practical choice for woodworking, but they have a superb feel.

I have a small gaggle of the other types (the more coarse ones) and use one from time to time as a novelty, but they're not good for woodworking, even though they're far better than the stones that carborundum corp sold as replacements for ark stones. I'd figure if there was a desire for stones of that type, the 8x3 hones and 8x 2 1/2 stones of alumina would've been picked up by woodworkers, but they never were. I can only assume the fine carborundum stones were a preference for carpenters. The coarse stones are nice for grinding, but the fine ones pretty much make a whole bunch of loose grit everywhere, and it's not fine enough to finish an edge, but not fast enough to do much grinding. Chunking 2x4s with a jack plane - it's good enough for that.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#6

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

TM Stock

A useful text, considering what was available in the early 1960's, and apparently still used, given the number of reprints. Keep in mind that Woodcraft was carrying Record products as well as Stanley (and suggesting the Stanley was the inferior) in the 1970's and early 1980's and appears to have had Planecraft reprinted as much to hawk Record products (which included the more modern combo planes as well as the 073 and the 778) as to have something to contribute to the hand tool woodworking resurgence which Fine Woodworking had jump-started in 1975. Record resisted the cost engineering that infected Stanley after WWII for a longer period of time, and only went to stuff like stamped, two piece yokes and screw caps, etc. in the mid 1980's.

I bought a copy of Planecraft when Woodcraft reprinted the book sometime in what must have been the late 1970's/early 1980, as my dad's copy of the 1950's edition was 1000 miles away. Yes - there's a lot of advertising for Record Tools, and it's obvious that the chapter on the T5 was intended to sell a bunch of technical jacks and copies of the book. THere's also good basic info on setup and use (including the same guidance that I considered general knowledge on setting the cap iron.."....as close as possible to the edge" for fine work in uncooperative woods).

We can rightly complain about the chapters on fiberboard planes and other period-specific tools developed by Stanley and Record as hand tool companies gamely tried to stay relevant in an age of power this and that, but they do answer the questions to the why and how of these odd-duck tools. As a bonus, the chapter on the Stay-Set capiron covers Record's rationale for use and - between general setup and the sales pitch for the Stay-Set - is quite specific on use and setting of the capiron. Like Blackburn's 1998 Traditional Woodworking Handtools, Planecraft appears to have been one of the few woodworking books still providing correct info on at least the how of tuning and setting of the chipbreaker, if not so much the why - a common problem with craft knowledge not seen in engineering or the sciences until recently.

I'm not at all certain how many copies of Planecraft are in circulation, but it was definitely a staple item for Woodcraft through the early 1990's when competing texts must have slowed sales down to the point where - with the move to WV from Wolburn, MA - the company ceased to reprint the title and sold out remaining stocks. Judging from the number of copies on the used market, the title was quite popular, so that speaks to perceived usefulness if not to whether the book actually delivered.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#7

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

david weaver

I wonder what the later texts have that earlier texts don't. Bill H advised me to buy one of the earlier versions, so I did (I'm assuming it probably predates woodcraft, and was paid for partly by record originally - or completely by record. Maybe there's a obvious back story that I missed).

I'm almost done with it, and I think it's quite good. As far as fiberboard and plywood advice, the stuff is around and was around, and I've never used any of the purpose made planes, but I just built the shell of my last kitchen cabinet with hand tools only and found it to be not that bad (it's a grade of ply that's a lot more wood than glue, though). That includes dadoes and rabbets.

At any rate, I like it quite a bit, but there are some absurd things in it. They recommend cutting an ovolo at the edge of a table with a shoulder plane, which one will not do twice. If you have an entire day and nothing to do but stick your finger through the opening in a shoulder plane to push shavings out, maybe, but in a world of cheap vintage rabbet planes and surplus broken saws to make scrapers (let alone purpose built moulding planes).

Otherwise, as a first text, though, quite good. I recognize that the cap iron thing doesn't get that much press because it's well into the era of doing mostly finish and fitting with planes, but it'd have been nice if it was expanded on. It's kind of my gimmick, I guess, but I have yet to find someone who works entirely by hand who hasn't found it to be a gigantic labor reducer and at the same time, risk eliminator.

For those of us who can visualize and who are not list followers, a set of general rules for cutting joints would also be good. You learn them by experience if you do them wrong, though (like not sawing the sides at the back of a dado and experiencing subsequent breakout). Some of the routines in the texts for certain joints are fairly intuitive just based on general rules, and might give some readers the idea that they should buy the entire product line from record to make sure that they can do them.

Far and away, I'd recommend this text to a beginner over most stuff that's come along later, though. Like the practical advice in it of things like "yes, you can work plywood with regular tools, if you're only doing a little, then there's no need to buy anything special".

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#8

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

Charlie

Here's what Audel's has to say in the 7th edition of "Carpenter's and Builder's Tools, Steel Square, & Joinery"

"The term double iron means a plane iron equipped with a supplementary iron called a cap. The object of the cap is to break the shaving as soon as possible after it is cut. [a diagram of this is provided in the book].

... the set of the iron is the amount of cutter exposed below the edge of the cap. The plane iron is set coarse or fine according to the amount of cutter face exposed ... for softwoods the set should be 1/4" for the jackplane, 1/16" for the jointer plane, and 1/32" for the smoothing plane. If the wood is hard or cross-grained, allow approximately one-half of these settings."

End quote.

As best as I can tell, the first edition of this book was printed in 1927. I suspect the verbiage above is essentially unchanged from that edition but would need the first edition to know for sure. Maybe somebody on the board has it.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#9

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

david weaver

"as close as possible" is listed in the table in mine for the last step. But the discussion launches right into a long narrative about narrowing the mouth and using all of the features of the "record plane".

As a maker of planes, I suspect that the moving frog has little to do with function and a lot to do with manufacturing cost and ease.

The book advises moving the frog around a lot (I guess to make you feel like you have a lot of options), but this is something I've heard few people talk about actually doing, because it's a pain and to truly get tearout control, you have to close the mouth off to about twice the shaving thickness (which leads to dumb things like filing mouths, etc).

I tend to agree with Warren's conclusion that it's written from the point of view of users who lost a few nerve endings since Nicholson's book was written, but excerpts of Nicholson text are probably a difficult go for a new user.

I prefer Mark H's recommendation for a beginner. Just do a lot of it and see what you figure out. If you have no insight, maybe you won't figure out much. If you do, you'll be using the double iron without a couple of hundred board feet (perhaps with the exception of someone working only in pine).

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#10

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron *LINK*

TM Stock

Until the aerospace industry settled on the decimal inch in the 1930's, the finest grad on a rule was commonly 1/64", and discussion of mils or thousandths was not common outside of the engineering and machinist's communities. In look through older woodworking books, the discussion of the cutting list, thicknesses, etc. is generally fractional inches, so I am not surprised that 1/64" seems to be the smallest increment noted.

For those involved in more precise work with tighter tolerances (miniaturists, model makers, luthiers, some cabinetmakers), working to the nearest thousandth in wood is not uncommon, but Audel's and other books of the time were aimed as much at framing carpentry (where 1/8" was a fairly tight tolerance) as trades where 1/32" or 1/64" was more common. I suspect that several things happened along the way between the craftsman's utterances and their translation to paper by author and editor:

- The nebulous 'as close as possible' for fine work in difficult grain probably ended up being stripped out of some book drafts as editors sought to avoid the extremes of overly vague 'about a pinch/just a smidge' common units or seemingly persnickety, unfamiliar measurements such as 'thousandths of an inch' or 'tenths of millimeters' when editing books for as broad an appeal as possible.

- When confronting new drafts, and with authors sometimes weeks away in terms of correspondence or off contract and onto their next project, those same editors may well have looked to competing texts to sanity check their own. This is not limited to craft - once an error or omission is made in a text or other frequently referenced guide, undoing the damage can be quite painful.

- Science and engineering practice typically couples the 'why' of a practice to the 'how', if for no other reason than that degree of formalism is the minimum accepted standard for most written work. Craft knowledge is quite different in nature, because too often the 'why' of a practice is fully separable from the 'how' of the thing when the guidance is in the form of annotated, bulleted text - especially where an 8 page magazine article is an exception and guides such as Audel's were expected to be both comprehensive across the field and very concise on any one topic. Look at any engineering structures text and you'll see each new topic developed from first principle to actual practice, thus, coupling the 'why' and the 'how'. Look at most craft texts - especially the ones produced as series at set-piece rates, and that formalism is lacking. Further complicating the issue is the fact that often, authors were - like many of us - talented amateurs in the craft of interest, attempting to relay the rudiments of what had been learned from primary sources.

My observation after 40 years of teaching complex tasks and the last ten teaching instrument building and repair is that once the 'why' of something is separated from the 'how' of the thing, it only takes a further magazine cycle of 7-8 years or a book publishing cycle (closer to 10 years) to lose both.

While the craftsman instructor may continue to provide rationale for choices made or techniques used, those beyond his or her immediate circle of students effectively loses access to both technique and rationale. The knowledge may continue forward, but it becomes more and more difficult to access - especially where research skills rely more and more on digital media versus the talents of reference librarians and first print editions carefully held away from the public.

On the subject of Audel's economy:


On Audel's Style

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#11

Re: The why...

david weaver

I have always struggled with anything that excludes the why. I have a terrible memory for random things, and a sometimes superb memory for things that are tied to something else (perhaps always).

I've noticed with other people that anyone who searches for "the why" also has the same thing. Discomfort on talking about things they don't know a lot about, and extreme comfort on everything else.

I like the "as close as possible" language, but found very early on that you can set the cap ion top of the iron if you have good eyesight, or easily at 2 thousandths or so. the setting I measured last week for the first time is what i'd term as "comfortable". I'm sure my eyes will go soon (runs in the family), but I couldn't give a better tip to someone than "as close to the edge as possible, but then back off as little as you can so that you just see the edge of the cap iron".

The next question is always (these days) how may thousandths is that? the answer to that is "who cares?". the only time I ever measure thousandths is making infill plane bodies. A gap of several thousandths will be garish with them because it creates a dark transition.

Which leads back to the why. There are probably lots of people who could remember that length of a board on a piece of casework is fine if it's off a 64th (I wouldn't know, I'm sure mine are worse than that when I'm dimensioning by hand). I'll bet lots of people could memorize it if I said that an infill should be within a thousandth on every area that will show, but I wonder if they'd remember. If they asked why, I'd say "try making one with the infill four thousandths undersized, then one within a thousandth and look at both planes and let me know how it turns out".

I still have no clue how people can remember anything without the why. I don't think a lot of the magazines care that much about that, because it leads to volumes of text that beginners don't really grasp.

I am one of the people who would read planecraft and see the "as close as possible" and literally set a cap iron right on the edge of an iron and then conclude that the plane was too hard to push and that the whole operation wasn't that useful compared to a back beveled iron.....

....that's exactly what I did many years prior to experimenting in earnest after getting older and learning that when things are a certain way (e.g., that all old planes that you find are generally double iron, despite a huge surcharge), it's unlikely that there isn't a very good reason for it.

(by the way, my buddy who is a pilot and never applied any method to anything that I could see turns into mr. method when it's time for a pre-flight. He flies politicians now, and the pre-flight is the first time I ever saw him do something in earnest...and then do it a second time. He's had one gear up in his career, but it was the fault of a mechanic....who didn't double check. I enjoyed your post about that).

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#12

Fiberboard planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You said, "We can rightly complain about the chapters on fiberboard planes and other period-specific tools developed by Stanley and Record as hand tool companies gamely tried to stay relevant in an age of power this and that, but they do answer the questions to the why and how of these odd-duck tools."

According to Patrick Leach, Stanley's fiberboard planes were produced mainly in the 1930s, which I don't think of as the "age of power this and that." Yes, more power tools, but it was a transitional period. I think they were developed in response to the (thank goodness, brief) period when fiberboard was the Newest Best Thing for interior walls. My bride and I have stayed in cabins built during the 1930s that used fiberboard above the wainscoting, and it's a different material than other fibrous panels: softer, and more gentle in texture, than particleboard, its closest relative. Definitely harder than celotex. The various cuts made by fiberboard planes would be important to the effect of an installation, and actually fairly difficult to make with any power tool except a routah.

But sheetrock, which allowed for finishes that resembled plaster, drove fiberboard off the market.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#13

Re: The why...

Charlie

I believe the authors of Planecraft assumed that if somebody set the iron so close as to cause the plane to cease cutting, which is what happens, that they would have enough sense to back it off a little from there.

Some authors say "as close as is practicable" which is a better choice of works since clearly it isn't practicable to cause the plane to stop cutting and expect to get any work done.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#14

Re: The why...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is the material that convinced me to work on the double iron back in 1973. Fortunately, I thought that an 18th century plane maker knew more about this stuff than I. Many have taken the opposite view.


Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#15

Re: The why...

TM Stock

I like the 'as close as possible' language - but I want the author to explain why in clear language and perhaps note your concern for 'too close'.

I also want my work boots to feel broken in the first day I wear them and my daughter to date guys that are not 'working on their music' and don't wear baseball caps with the tags and stickers still in place...I can dream, right?

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#16

Re: The why...

TM Stock

It takes all kinds, def...better your friend is attentive when he's flying and kicks back out of the cockpit than the reverse.

Agree on the wording...

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#17

Re: Fiberboard planes

TM Stock

I imagine that there must have been a metric crap ton of these planes stuffed in company and distributor warehouses after that brief fad...I can just see the Planecraft editor at Record getting a call from the VP of sales circa late 1950's and telling him to stick a chapter in the book hawking fiberboard tools.

I know we had better materials by the 1960's but my grandad loved the stuff (and died of emphysema...coincidence???) - made me a very cool 4' or so long battleship...some pine scraps and lots and lots of 1/8" brown stuff for planking, decks, etc. Being 8, I promptly dragged it to the local park's duck pond and gave it a dunk. Not my favorite memory watching the ship try to drink the pond dry.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#19

Re: Inattentive pilots

TM Stock

I am always amazed when we see a year go by without an air carrier mishap. Like shuttle launches became later in the STS program, the amazing becomes the routine. Even the participants (pilots, mechanics, controllers, dispatchers, etc.) do not usually grasp all the stuff that needs to go exactly right for each and every flight to avoid a mishap.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#20

Re: Inattentive pilots

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

And they hadn't bothered to perform preflight checks in 98% of the previous flights? Beyond inattentive into stupid.

Heck, I have a preflight checklist for my RV*, and it will (I hope) never become airborne!

-------

*Developed after I...modified...the swingout assist handle for the side door by leaving it out as I passed the tree at the top of the driveway. The tree won.

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#21

Re: Inattentive pilots *LINK*

Patrick Chase

Yeah, a friend who flies some very high-profile clients pointed that report out to me. Apparently the accident pilots have achieved a certain degree of posthumous notoriety within that community. The crash was news at the time because it killed Lewis Katz (see link).

My friend's take is that the pilots had decided that they were so good at what they did that administratrivia such as checklists needn't apply to them. Even with all of that they could have saved themselves if they'd rejected the takeoff as soon as they realized what was wrong, but they apparently feared losing their licenses in the ensuing FAA investigation more than death.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewis_Katz

Re: Planecraft and the Cap Iron

#22

Ironic...

Tony - Memphis

I saw a few minutes of Sunday Morning where they were talking about the crash of the plane with a Brazilian soccer team on board. The plane ran out of fuel!