Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Posts

Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#1

Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

david weaver

This is sort of an obscure question, but we often see people having forum wars about who is a better craftsman. This comes to mind because as a maker and in terms of design sense, I haven't seen too many people who can compare to our accessible and helpful friend, George, who you only get a tiny idea about his depth of thought and knowledge (and capability, and drive for perfection or expectation of results) online.

Often the follow up is "Paul Sellers says", "Rob Cosman says",....fill in a hundred names, and all of those guys are capable makers, but I haven't seen anything to suggest they're even remotely in the same league. If there's one George on our forums, there must be 100 makers like him sprinkled around the country that we don't hear from or hear much about.

On the engraving side, Lynton Mckenzie comes to mind. The quality of his engravings is spectacular and the work so tasteful. Even just looking at it can only benefit us.

https://www.google.com/search?q=lynton+mckenzie&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjstreSr7TXAhWi5oMKHf5aCyoQ_AUICigB&biw=1920&bih=974

I can scroll through names of cartouche award winners and see some makers and their work that are really inspiring.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/2006/07/01/self-taught-hobbyist-wins-cartouche-award

How do we find out about more like people?

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#2

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Brian Holcombe

John Aniano would be on the top of that list for me.

Craig Thibodeau, Chris Hall, Jim Blauvelt, Yann Giguere, Warren Mickley and Andrew Hunter to name a few.

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#3

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Patrick Chase

That's easy: You just visit the forums and see who's yelling "hey, I'm 1337!". Nobody ever exaggerates.

(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leet)

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#4

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

david weaver

And John is here, and I wasn't fully aware! (I knew he was a pro, but I've not been sharp enough to go track down his work, I guess).

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#5

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Charlie Stanford

Not a directory, per se, but perhaps worth a moment of your time:

http://furnituremasters.org/

http://furnsoc.org/contribution/award-of-distinction/

Be warned. Some of these people might not be experts at using the cap iron, though they apparently have other talents. :-)

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#6

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

david weaver

the first list is quite a bit more impressive than the second.

You're right. I don't think they use the cap iron. They probably use the Carvewright.

This carver definitely knows how to program the carvewright just right.

https://retireediary.wordpress.com/2012/11/15/

(sounds like China is undergoing the same thing where they're losing their classic arts to modernization).

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#7

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

TomD

It is one of the features of modern US woodworking that it seems to be poorly organized. Which actually has it's strong sides. Knifemakers, as an example, seem to have guild like elements, and publish regular lists of people who are making things. And there is the annual. Yet you don't have to do any of that stuff yourself, you aren't banned by law from selling if you don't do a 7 year apprenticeship, for instance. The likes of Lee Valley regularly picture on their catalogs excellent work by people of whom I have never heard, and many are from my area. I suspect there are a great number of very talented people out there we never hear about. I think Brian is doing excellent work, and yet he hasn't the book, the video, the whatever it is that would have made someone stand out in the past, pre-internet.

Unless your objective is to be known, why would you waste time on making yourself known? In something like Woodturning, you have such a potential for surplus production that getting known is necessary almost out of self-defense.

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#8

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Charlie

You might find the various volumes of the Fine Woodworking Design Book helpful. Most larger city libraries have these.

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#9

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

TM Stock

See what they charge and are actually getting for their work. Pros usually charge as much as they can demand for their services, and the market does a fairly good job of ensuring that those overvaluing their work have the input needed to correct that misperception.

Of course a hefty discount on hourly labor charge should be applied for those insisting on using non-WC approved tools or methods :)

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#10

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Gregory v Forster

Early American Life has an annual "Directory of Traditional American Crafts";

IIRC for over thirty years.

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#11

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Charlie

Silas Kopf would certainly be on any list:

http://www.galleryhenoch.com/artists/kopf/images/SK-313-Checkmate.jpg

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#12

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Mutual admiration society... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Wow Brian,

I just looked at this thread and saw your response and I'm humbled. All I can say is that it goes both ways! It's not often that I meet a craftsman, no, maybe an artist, as you. Although I've only watch you work at sharpening and a bit of sawing, I can see in you the mark of someone extraordinary. And you are still quite young, so you can continue a good long time making furniture, teaching, etc.

As for a directory for "elite" violin and bow makers, there is a trade organization in North America called the AFVBM(.org) - the American Federation of Violin and Bowmakers. Membership is granted by recommendation by existing members and examples of one's work is judged by the entire membership. The Federation lists all its members on their website and is a who's who of the violin world, at least here in the USA and Canada.

I would guess that there are similar organizations for other specific trades - this is one I'm familiar with.

John


http://www.afvbm.org

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#13

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Mutual admiration society...

Brian Holcombe

Thanks John! Very much appreciated!

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#14

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom! Appreciate your comments!

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#15

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Hank Knight

I think Craig Vandall Stervens (http://www.craigvandallstevens.com/work/) fits the profile for general woodwork and furniture.

Mary May certainly fits the profile for carvers.

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

#16

Re: Elite Craftsmen - Any Directory?

Gregory v Forster

just curious if anyone took the opportunity to peruse this excellent directory of skilled artisans?