Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

Posts

Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#1

Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

David Charlesworth

I am starting a new thread because I think the other one is entirely missing the point.

In the forty odd years we have been setting up planes here, I have virtually never seen a new or replacement C/B, which did not need work.

This consists of checking the fit to the blade back and checking or creating a 45 degree polished slope on the top of the edge.

A little clearance angle, say 1 or 1 1/2 degrees, is desirable for the underside. We frequently found this area to slope the wrong way inviting choking.

The front of many chipbreakers have significant square edges, another cause of choking.

The 25 degree slope found on some is really weird since Stanley and Record were clearly aiming at 45 degrees for the last century or so. 25 degrees would be too easily damaged and not be steep enough to work well.

So a pox on all their houses for not informing customers that C/B edges need work!

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#2

Re: fast Fitting

david weaver

I have something that I think is essential for anyone serious about woodworking. A run of float glass 42 inches long with PSA 80 grit stuck to it flat and tight.

In the event that you come across a cap iron that is out of whack as you mention, it is extremely quick work to refresh the undercut (or establish it) and have a cap iron that can be finished on a washita and strop. Total time for the worst offenders is just a few minutes.

Agree on the manufactured caps. There's no great reason to cut the entire bevel at anything shallower than 45 degrees unless it's assumed that such an angle might interfere with a tightly set mouth (which is a waste of time to begin with).

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#3

Option 2

david weaver

For the average person not cycling through as many planes as me, an inexpensive norton fine india stone.

Another thing (like the sanding lap) that you can always tell yourself that you don't need. But if you have it, you'll find yourself using it - especially on things like card scrapers for rough work, knife sharpening, etc.

A fine india will do all but the most coarse correcting on a cap iron and have it ready for whatever is necessary for final finish.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#4

Re: Option 2

Patrick Chase

One point that I know you know, but that may not be obvious:

Softer steels like those used in many cap irons have a nasty habit of "exfoliating" abrasives from media with weak binders. Your first suggestion of sandpaper on glass is a good solution because it has a very durable binder. If you must use a stone then a non-Crystolon oilstone of some sort as you suggested is probably the next best choice. Waterstones (even harder ones like Shapton) and Crystolons both tend to wear quickly when used on softer steels. I learned that lesson the hard way.

Obviously granite surface plates are a workable alternative glass (except when using thin lapping films, in which case the surface of the granite plate can telegraph). Everybody should have at least one such granite or untempered glass reference surface anyway IMO.

Rolls of PSA sandpaper are fairly cheap and have an incredibly broad range of uses. Don't bother with the expensive "gold" stuff, because the stearate anti-clog coating that differentiates those from cheaper rolls is useless with metals. Save the fancy paper for sanding back finishes. I use 3M "red" or Mirka "grey" rolls for metalwork.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#5

Thanks!

Patrick Chase

I cleared up the wording of my post that touched on cap-iron maintenance, in particular to clarify that you need to undercut the edge in the first step. I assumed that was common knowledge, but that probably wasn't a safe bet.

I think other than that we're actually saying the same things.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#6

Re: Option 2

david weaver

India is good because it settles down pretty quickly and is hard. if you don't use it day to day, it will stay flat for a long time.

The fact that it's hard doesn't much matter on mild steel, though, it'll cut like crazy in anything soft (see my oft complaining about oilstones in general and soft pocket knives - they expose how big the particles actually are in oilstones, and how important it is to have a steel that's in a reasonable hardness range).

Can't push a chisel or gouge into one, can't groove it with a card scraper.

I haven't thought too much about the paper other than that it's better worn a little at 80 grit, it'll still cut things really fast, and it will flatten any iron that's worth recovering if you make a fixture to hold the iron.

In terms of undercutting, i vaguely recall that the hock cap irons are just flat. I just got one more LN plane last year, and prepped the cap iron without thinking too much about the flat step, but David's right - a new user who buys that in isolation would probably be wondering about it. They'd be better surfaced to an edge at 45 or 50 degrees, but maybe they're concerned that a user will ding the edge. Who knows?

(re: the paper, I'll buy mirka gold when it's cheap, but last I checked, it was $28 a roll and the porter cable branded paper was $11 delivered. Mirka gold isn't better by that ratio, and only a large flat metal surface - like a plane - really benefits from the paper holding that tooth for a long time. It's generally a bit too much for back flattening when fresh because of the groove depth. Great for grinding bevels, too, if you can handle the heat it generates. )

There are a lot of oddball things that you can buy that will not get use (specialty squares, gotta have it weirdo combination gauges, etc.), but a glass and paper lap isn't one of them. Same with an india stone. A beginner would curse one because a little touch is required with them, but they are fantastic. I'd much rather have india, washita and then (fill in the black for a follow up stone) than any synthetic regimen. Even for razors.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#7

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When the "improved chipbreaker" came out I took it as evidence that the Lie Nielsen

people had no idea how to use a double iron plane. However some wondered if they were not made deliberately ineffective so as to sell more high angle planes. I give them the benefit of the doubt.

I have used a rounded "bevel" on my cap irons for over forty years. As Nicholson says 205 years ago "The bevel should be rounded and not flat." A low flat bevel just will not be as effective. It is difficult to estimate the actual angle where the cap meets the iron, but let's just say it is closer to 80 than to 50 degrees. A 45 degree flat bevel gives a weak action.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#8

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

david weaver

45 degrees to me is sort of the cap iron version of an car with a slipping automatic transmission.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#9

What angle?

Patrick Chase

You said in one of these threads that you use 50-55 degrees, right?

I use 50, mostly out of conservatism. I keep meaning to experiment with higher angles and correspondingly higher setbacks.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#10

Re: What angle?

david weaver

I roll them all freehand. I'd estimate something between 50 and 60.

I did try specific angles several years ago, and 40-45, thereabouts helps but not quite enough. Don't know how to explain it - the plane is easier to push and the surface is better, but not quite what it should be.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#11

Re: What angle?

Patrick Chase

That's consistent with Kato & Kawai [*], which showed that increased face angle allowed higher setback while achieving ~equal tearout mitigation.

In particular they showed about the same degree of tearout reduction with 0.1 mm of setback and 50 deg face angle (on a 40 deg bed) as they did with 0.2 mm of setback and an 80 deg face angle. The 50 deg face angle had tearout at 0.2 mm setback.

This might also explain the residual differences in our respective setback-vs-depth results. The fact that I was using a shallower face means that I would get less effect from the cap iron at any given setback.

[*] I know, not directly applicable to handplanes, but informative nonetheless IMO.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#12

diagram, please

Howard Pollack

For those of us who have a hard time translating the words into visual pictures, I think it would be most useful for someone to post a diagram of a properly set up chip breaker. Thanks, in advance, to whomever posts such a diagram.

-Howard

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#13

Re: What angle?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Patrick,

What Kato/Kawai reference can I refer to, to find these results on tearout?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#14

Re: What angle? *LINK*

Patrick Chase

It's a video. I've linked a version with subtitles from Wilbur Pan's blog.

There is also a translation of an accompanying paper (but more specific to handplanes) on Steve Eliott's site as well. http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html

David referenced both of these from his WoodCentral article on cap-iron setting.


http://giantcypress.net/post/23159548132/this-is-the-full-version-of-the-video-created-by

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#15

Re: it depends on the plane

steve voigt

Replying to several posts here…

Warren: Nicholson was of course talking about a wooden plane when he talked about a rounded bevel. I make cap irons for wooden planes, so I use a rounded bevel. But I don't think it matters for a metal, stanley-type plane. The purpose of the curve is to get the cap iron out of the shaving's way, quickly. This is crucial in a traditional woodie that has a steep wear somewhere between 70° and 85°. A Stanley-type plane has a much more forgiving escapement, so I don't think the curve is a big deal.

Some numbers: a so-called "improved" cap iron is 1/8" thick and has very little spring, so the 30° bevel will start around 7/32" from the tip, if my math is correct. When I make a cap iron, the curve starts about 9/16" from the tip, nearly twice as far. the angle stays relatively shallow as long as possible, then accelerates rapidly near the tip. Put simply, it gets out of the way faster than a flat bevel does. That is the point of the rounding.

Dave: continuing with your automotive metaphor, I have long compared 50° to a comfortable sedan, or even better, my neighbor's lovely old Benz wagon, and 80° to my uncle's corvette. In the Benz wagon, there is a huge range on the accelerator pedal between coasting and flooring it. On the Vette, it's all or nothing. Same with the clutch--I vividly remember failing on the vette as a kid because the clutch was too sensitive. For me, with 80° it feels like the difference between "too close" and "not close enough" is just a few thousandths, whereas 50° or so feels more forgiving.

Patrick: it would be interesting to do some math here, and you're probably better equipped than I. The simple part is that the greater the angle, the closer the "impact point" will be for a given setback. The complicated part is that the chip will be bent at a greater angle as well. So obviously a greater angle will potentially reduce tearout more, but it will also increase the required force a great deal, which matters because we are humans and not Kato/Kawai planing machines.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#16

Re: diagram, please *LINK*

Larry Barrett

Howard, a god place to start is David Weaver's article right here on WC.


Setting a Cap Iron

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#17

Re: it depends on the plane

Warren in Lancaster

I think the rounded bevel is much more sophisticated than what you are imagining, Steve. When the cap iron is fairly far from the edge, the rounded cap iron behaves more like a mild angle cap iron, equivalent to 45 degrees or less. The shaving never gets into the small area near the juncture of the cap iron, but instead rides the cap iron higher up. As the cap iron is put close to the edge, the steeper part of the bevel, 70 or 80 degrees,comes into play, giving a stronger effect. It is as if the angle becomes steeper as the cap iron distance is made less.

Peter Nicholson (1765- 1844) was a cabinetmaker in London in the early 1790's, a time when figured woods were all the rage and the city was awash with exotics

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#18

Re: it depends on the plane

david weaver

That has been my speculation, but it's nothing more than speculation on my part. Except that I don't believe that i roll the final part of the bevel that far.

It's the type of thing that you, Steve and I would discuss, but when you start talking about it on forums with someone who doesn't even know how to use a cap iron, everyone thinks they have an equal stake. It would be like me pretending I had stake talking about instrument making with George just because i played several musical instruments for a couple of decades.

My speculation on that part, I've thought of as being, though, a little bit of firm contact just at the edge, and then less resistance further up, which gives a better range of operation (anything that makes the range less sensitive will be better for a person vs. a machine). If the bevel is flat, then it probably takes difficult wood to really see a difference, but it feels like a bit more effort to me to get the same effect. That is subjective, though, and I have no idea how you'd quantify it other than to talk to someone else who has used both (for longer than me).

Some of these things don't make for great testable subjects by an engineer or actuary who just got into woodworking (and I fell into that trap) and who likes to set up models to get consistent data.

Sharpening is another. I can explain uniformity of the edge being more important than absolute sharpness to start, but I don't think most people really follow what that means. Uniformity in:

* the quality of the edge through the sharpening cycle

* the lack of existence of variation at the beginning of the sharpening cycle

Any time I bring that up, at least one person says "maybe you can work with subpar edges, but I can't".

I'm getting off track a little bit - I like the curve, though. I think it offers a bit more range and freedom for the person using the plane (but also agree with steve about why it's got another benefit on a wooden plane - as the ward caps that I've seen allow the steepest wear without restriction, and that's how they're shaped).

Concentricity of cap iron and edge has me more confused, but maybe that will eventually be resolved in greater detail - I think I'll have dementia before I figure it out, though.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#19

Bevel angle

Patrick Chase

Your math is right for a 30 deg bevel, the modern cap irons are more like 25 deg :-)

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#20

57 degrees, give or take one or two..

david weaver

..that's what I can figure my cap iron leading edge to be. Kind of difficult to be exact because it's curved.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#21

Re: diagram, please

TM Stock

Concise & from Blackburn' 1998 Traditional Woodworking Handtools:


Sorry about the highlighter - students borrow books and they come back pretty well marked up. Grrr...

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#22

Re: diagram, please

Howard Pollack

Thanks.

Howard

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#23

Support for Warren’s analysis

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Warren’s explanation of the combined effect of chipbreaker setting and geometry seems to be borne out by studies done by Professors Kato and Kawai of Yamagata University. A few years ago, Bill Tindall arranged for Ms. Mia Iwasaki to translate one of the 1989 papers into English. Bill and Steve Elliott edited and published the translation on Steve Elliott’s website:

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html

The data were generated by a machine planer, taking 0.002” (2 thousandths) shavings from a birch species, with the cutting iron bedded at 40 degrees, and the chipbreaker set back to 4 thousandths or 8 thousandths. The control was ‘no chipbreaker’.

Figure 6 below shows the horizontal and vertical forces at the cutting edge. The horizontal force, P-sub h, is the force required to take the shaving—in a hand plane situation it would be the pushing or pulling force. The vertical force, P-sub v, acts downward initially as the sharp blade is pulled into the work, then goes positive, as the blade dulls and must be held in the cut.

In the legend, the chipbreaker setback distances of 100 and 200 um (micrometers, or microns) are approx. 0.004” (4 thousandths) and 0.008” (8 thousandths), respectively.



The upper part of Fig. 6 shows the horizontal forces, for setbacks of 4 and 8 thousandths, and for 40, 50, and 60 degree angles on the chipbreaker face.

In general, there is a sharp increase in ‘pushing’ force in tightening up from 8 thou to 4 thou, but as an exception note that the pushing force for 4 thou/40 degrees is quite close to the force required at 8thou/60 degrees. These specific figures are of course particular to the Kato/Kawai setup, but qualitatively they seem to bear out the more general principle Warren stated—that the shaving is hitting the breaker higher on the bevel at 8 thou than it is at 4 thou.

Warren also made the point several days ago that you want to use the farthest setback that works. Note in the horizontal force data that there is a sweet spot around 8 thou, while the pushing force increases by about 50% (with the exception of the 40 degree bevel) when the setback was tightened to 4 thou.

As a side comment, the vertical force data seem to show that the 4 thou setting led generally to faster dulling, as the cutter stopped pulling itself into the work quite a bit sooner at all the 4 thou settings, except the 4 thou/40 degree setting where there was less breaking effect.

Pardon this long post, but I was struck by how the data lined up with Warren’s analysis.

Wiley

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#24

Re: Support for Warren’s analysis

david weaver

Warren has excellent perception. All I could glean from rounded vs. flat bevel (having tried both) is that "rounded seems to work a little better and maybe be a bit less effort). "

But it is relatively noticeable if you work through a pile of stuff. Just a little bit, but noticeable.

Re: Replacement cap irons or chipbreakers!!!

#25

The bevel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Here’s a notion. It doesn’t rise to the level of a theory. Just a thought that occurs: Warren’s recommendation of the farthest setback that gets the job done, combined with the rounded bevel, have the effect of reducing friction between shaving and bevel. Bending the chip to a critical angle, rather than ‘breaking’ it. Minimize back-pressure by not letting the bent shaving become a ‘spring’ flexing back onto itself and increasing the pushing force required. He creates just enough friction and back-pressure to get the job done—note in Fig. 6 that the pushing force required at 8 thousandths is only 10% or so greater than ‘no chipbreaker’, and this is with a flat bevel rather than a rounded one. And yet there is concave wear below the chipbreaker at 8thou, showing that the chipbreaker is doing real work on the shaving.

Question: How does the above notion relate to the straightened shaving? I wonder if Warren is going for a straightened shaving, which would seem to require ‘breaking’ the chip, or whether he is trying to find a sweet spot just before physically breaking the shaving.

The picture I see, and maybe it’s incorrect, is that there is a continuum from ‘bend shaving’ to ‘bend to critical angle’ to ‘break shaving to produce straight shaving’, to ‘accordion shaving’—as the bevel steepens and the setback is tightened.

Wiley