Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

Posts

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#2

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

David Weaver

There again is the recommendation to make it match the edge. "Slightly rounded", but why? So that one can relate an iron laterally and use one side or the other only?

I do like the discussion of feeding. I have noticed from time to time that the trashiest stuff that just can't put a shaving together will clog even a good plane, or at least make the feeding poorer. A well formed shaving is up and gone like sheet metal being unrolled.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#3

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie

Planecraft, Hayward, Wells & Hooper... no reason any of this should have been lost on early to mid 20th century British woodworkers. He writes as if he's passing along what was common knowledge amongst professionals, not a breathless 'rediscovery' of a lost technique.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#4

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

Charlie's on kayfabe again!

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#5

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie

"With planes that are finely set, a certain slight jaggedness will at length appear along the edge of the back iron."

Yep.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#6

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

This must not occur on mine. I have a lot of planes that I use only a little, but the cap iron in pictures below is one that's seen a whole bunch of wood in the last several years. Maybe 90% of the smoothing I've done (from try plane, not planer) and it's been used to make a couple of cocobolo planes, for the entire process.

Perhaps I'll get a picture of the try plane cap iron tonight - it's a different iron.

it strikes me that warren made the comment here quite a while ago that either he hasn't done it in decades or he's done it rarely.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#7

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie

Don't know brother. I think they need relatively regular maintenance but there are those who don't.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#8

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie

A little historical synthesis seems to be in order. Hayward and Planecraft sold by the tens of thousands through several editions. Surely it sank in with some people in Britain. Had to have, no?

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#9

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

I'm not sure it "unsunk" completely. If you go to the UK forum, you can talk to someone like Custard and many others who said they were taught it, but didn't really get it until I and others beat everyone over the head with it.

Recall the thread where he was jacking a bubinga table top and you used your "many ways to skin a cat" line? And he said, sure, but none of the others work as well or as quickly.

The loss seems to be two phase:

* over here, most people seem to have forgotten it completely, but they "remember" they read it after the fact

* in the UK, people seem to remember that they were taught it by someone

Few seem to use it or use it well.

Here's my gimmick for everyone who likes all of the other ways to skin a cat.

Force yourself to use a stanley 4 only for everything you do that's flat for a month. Each time you have something you'd scrape, figure out how to do it with the plane instead. You'll probably come to the same conclusion that I have, that the other stuff becomes a relative last resort. In order to get a finished surface, you have to have:

* the ability to plane something in general (meaning the forces have to be reasonable - obviously a big deal on larger cases that might have a bit of give if you have to finish plane them for some reason)

* the ability to do it without tracks (this takes fairly little time to figure out)

* the ability to have the plane leave a uniform surface (this is more about good sharpening and a properly set cap)

I just don't see much discussion to that level. Except from Warren. It speeds everything up, including smoothing, even though that's perhaps not the most useful part of cap iron use. I was drawn to it in terms of laziness with dimensioning - single iron and tight mouth doesn't cut it. But it unexpectedly taught me to finish a surface smoothing much faster, too.

I yield to your comments about customers not caring. I don't have customers. And I yield even further to who is actually doing this stuff to make money? Not many people - teaching is far more lucrative, apparently. So, does it really matter? probably not. At one point, I saw Rob Millard as the standard, because he was just making pieces, but even he is teaching classes now.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#10

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

William Duffield

The problem with the description in Hayward is that it doesn't explain the physics of the process. It is all mumbo-jumbo. Obviously, Hayward had not seen the Kato-Kawai videos ;) , because he has no idea how the chip breaker is functioning.

Trying to put it on a splitting axe, even as a thought experiment, is ludicrous. A splitting axe works on entirely different principles, where it is desired to split the wood as far forward of the blade edge as possible, and where additional "tearout" is achieved by the rotation of the head as it begins to penetrate the wood. I might suggest a perusal of Leonard Lee's book on sharpening for an explanation of the differences in geometry between a felling axe and a splitting axe.

Printing this seems to me to be an exercise in obfuscation by the HABU party. Is it intentional "alternate facts" or do they really not understand.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#11

Kayfabe

Patrick Chase

Feats of strength!

Amazing magic!

People who claim to be able to plane wood both ways without tearout!

Clown cars!

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#12

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie

Let's dig Hayward up and drown him in the Cohansey.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#13

Re: You don't have a smoothing axe?


Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#14

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

William Duffield

It's not Hayward's fault. He just wrote what he thought he knew and understood, and he did not have access to the Kato-Kawai moving pictures with circles and arrows and explanations, that have since cleared up lots of the mysticism. Some modern writers, however, should not be excused for promulgating misinformation.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#15

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

Charlie Stanford

You know William I could know far more than I do about botany but I'm not going to let it keep me from cutting wood. Just sayin'

As it turns out the design of the tool makes it possible to use the cap iron, and all the other possible adjustments, effectively enough. And the designer didn't have the benefit of electron microscopy either, and yet it works.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#16

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

Who are these writers?

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#17

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

Must be modern ghost writers with no names. :\

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#18

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

William Duffield

They know who they are. We know who they are. But if we write their names here, Google will find them and send them here to harass us with their higher truths. Things could get ugly, for a lot of the same reasons we try not to discuss religion or politics.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#19

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

david weaver

I don't know who they, are, but we don't need fire on the water on the Cohansey.

I figured I might be one of the people who "writes, but doesn't know what he's talking about". I usually write too much about too little (but am by no means a writer) but have a fair idea about what I'm discussing.

I'll leave the stuff about throwing Charles Hayward into the Cohansey to you guys, though, because I don't know who he is unless he's related Craig and spelled his name incorrectly. I doubt Craig knew much about the cap iron.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#20

Re: Who Was Hayward?

William Duffield

https://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/the-woodworker-the-charles-h-hayward-years-vols-i-iv

It is a very useful set of books, with lots of well explained woodworking processes, techniques, materials, plans, etc. However, I think Megan picked one of the less lucid explanations in her recent blog post promoting the books. Reference the link Derek provided at the top of this thread.

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#21

Re: Who Was Hayward?

david weaver

I said that sort of as a spoof. I remember when those books were released, but I'm such an undisciplined reader that I've only gotten through holtzapffel so far, and I haven't done any ornamental turnings. And part of planecraft...

...and I guess bits and pieces of other things.

Oh. Hasluck's book on carving a few times.

I'm a fan of Craig Heyward's work, though!

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker

#22

Re: More .. (shudder) .. on the chipbreaker 

ian neuhaus

There again is the recommendation to make it match the edge. "Slightly rounded", but why? So that one can relate an iron laterally and use one side or the other only?

not intending to be condescending ...

it's simple geometry.

If the plane iron is very slightly curved -- which is the recommended shape to avoid plane tracks and to assist with edge jointing -- then it follows that the chip breaker (or back iron) should have the same curvature. Otherwise when a straight chip breaker is set 1/64th back from the edge of the iron near the sides, it will be 1/32 or possibly 1/16th back from the cutting edge in the middle. As Haywood notes, in some woods 1/64th from the cutting edge is the desirable set back. Conversely, if the set back is 1/64th at the center of the iron, the chip breaker will overlap the cutting edge towards the corners of the iron, with all the "chip under the cap iron" problems that will entail.