Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

Posts

Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

#1

Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Before the bar clamps that use pipe as the bar, many companies made castings that fit on wooden bars - the examples I own use nominal 2x3s (which creates an interesting issue, since the finished dimensions of nominal 2x3s have changed quite a bit since these castings were poured). These castings were actually "modern" copies of older, all-or-nearly-all wood designs, like these:


Are there advantages to the wooden bar clamps over pipe clamps? Disadvantages?

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

#2

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

david weaver

I don't have an answer to any of your questions, but thanks for posting these clamps. I'm going to track down an appropriate vintage thread tapping box and make some.

I despise the post K-body german bessey clamps - they're monstrously heavy (especially if you get 4 or 8 or something and then have to move that something) and have all kinds of garbage that any dextrous individual doesn't need.

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

#3

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

AlanWS

Advantages: They look better, are lighter, and won't stain tannic wood.

Disadvantages: They can't produce quite as much force as a bar clamp. They are not as readily available.

The amount of force, wear, and stiffness will depend on the specifics. I have some wooden bar clamps that are stiffer than pipe clamps and competitive with some steel ones. But they're big, and they operate with wedges rather than screws. I have made a screwbox intending to make some bar clamps similar to these.

If you go by the dictum that you can never have too many clamps, they are always useful as more clamps. As you use them, you will likely find situations where they are preferred.

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

#4

Re: Wooden vs. pipe bar clamps

Patrick Chase

They certainly aren't historically correct, but I like the Aluminum Dubuques. They aren't as stout as proper pipe clamps, but I can get a whole lot more of them on the work for the same weight.

As you say K-bodies only make sense in certain circumstances. For most stuff it's just a lot of weight and hassle.