Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wiley - Knife Updates?

Posts

Wiley - Knife Updates?

#1

Wiley - Knife Updates?

david weaver

Wiley - have you taken receipt of either of your new wares?

I know you're not the kind of person to boast, but I've located something I've been trying to find and am waiting for it (a regular tidioute congress - thankfully, they have not escalated in value).

Curious given that I know you have fine taste.

Separate and aside, I noticed that tidioute claims that they temper 1095 either 55-58 or 56-58. I vaguely recall having a discussion with George about this, because you can tell such things aren't true pretty easily when you're using natural stones.

I know it's not your objective, but I've noticed that most non-standard pattern tidioute knives (and northfield) appreciate significantly. I don't think the #48 that you bought is a standard pattern, so it will go out of production and give you the warm and fuzzy feeling when the market price begins to go up. The overhead view of the link that you showed us showed very tastefully beveled blades - a detail that some probably won't appreciate, but it sets them apart. Queen does the same thing, but they are sort of smudgy and not crisp.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#2

Photos & comments tomorrow morning


Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#3

A few photos...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Both knives from my recent WoodCentral-instigated spree have arrived. They are, Case Seahorse and Northfield Trapper (Improved). The Case is stainless steel; the Northfield 1095. Both stag, a completely unwarranted vanity.

To my eye, both knives have a lot of charisma, and so far I haven’t brought myself to hone either one. BTW, they both arrived quite sharp from the factory—not sharp enough to do surgery or whatever, but sharp enough to do the job of a pocket knife. Carving the protective foil out of the top of Tylenol bottles and such...

What I like, both have good size in the hand, 4”, and have heft.

Some photos. The Case is above; the Northfield is below in the photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157688758798944/with/26350721059/

Looking forward to seeing your Congress when it arrives!

Wiley

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#4

Re: A few photos...

david weaver

Two absolutely fabulous looking knives. I love the top bevels on the GEC knife, but really like the stag that's on the case and it, too, is an overall striking knife, too. Can't help but repeat - two really wonderful looking knives.

I'll picture the congress when I get it. I think I was able to find it reasonable because it's orange bone (an undesirable color from what I can gather, but fine by me).

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Great-Eastern-Cutlery-61-Tidioute-Square-Bolster-Congress-Burnt-Orange-Jig-Bone/292300774491?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649

This is the ebay link - i prefer the newer knives with nothing written on the blades, but the 4 blade congress appears to be NLA and the GEC knives in general are getting hard to find anywhere in stock. The next usual step is for a manufacturer to either start outsourcing, or to raise prices. If anything, I hope it's the latter.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#5

The tidioute...

david weaver

.. the congress. I have to admit, the orange bone is sort of a strange sickly looking color!

There's a bit of corrosion on the top of the blades, so this one makes a good candidate to sharpen and use.

https://s1.postimg.org/83pg9p3yen/20171104_153454.jpg

https://s1.postimg.org/2sajp00ygv/20171104_153529.jpg

The shocking thing about the knife is the walk and talk. TTTTHHHWWWPPP. Loud, but smooth getting there and by far the best I've ever seen. Almost sounds like someone cracking their knuckles.

Nothing is guaranteed on these, of course. The second wall street wharncliffe that I have is a bit on the weak side in that department - opens and closes very easy.

Looked for the seahorse in chrome vanadium today. Am I correct that case makes that only in stainless?

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#6

One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

I asked George to send me pictures of a knife that he made for one of his friends as a retirement gift (the friend's name is in the spine of the knife, and on the side). Since these are only viewable on sawmillcreek, I'm posting them over here.

The knife is a hunting knife with ivory scales (coke bottle style), old w1 steel for the blade (which would be dreamy). Not sure what the bolsters are, but the inlay is 24 karat gold, and the spinework is freeform/freehand filing with the name in the middle.

The blade grind and top profile (as well as the false edge on the clip part of the blade) is done freehand.

If you're not much into pocket knives or folding hunting knives (or more classic knife designs), then this might not look like much. If you're ever thinking of making a knife (and this type is a type that you can make entirely without power tools if you desire), you can never look at too many good ones or too many blade profiles.

Not sure how the locking mechanism works.




Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#7

Re: One more picture of a special knife

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Fabulous usable art by George. Thanks for showing. That filing/gold fill on the spine is magnificent—in fact, the whole production is.

For some reason, I’ve been under the impression that W-1 and 1095 are one and the same. Is this incorrect? I still have a W-1 iron in an early model LN4,and for some years it was said that LN still had some discontinued W-1 irons around, and would dig them out of the boneyard on request. I recall it was quite a job in those days to get the back flat due to warp during quench.

Wiley

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#8

Re: One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

I think they generally are the same thing (W-1 and 1095). George has called it both while talking to him.

I'm going to resist the urge to look at the acceptable alloy ranges on google, but I'm sure there's some overlap between the two (in practice if not on paper), and both can be driven up to very high hardness if they're used in a low toughness application. At 59/60 hardness, they wear pretty quickly, but wear is all (which means sharpening is brief). They do rust quickly, though.

I don't think LN ever figured out W1 (my opinion, I haven't asked them and they probably wouldn't be open to discussing) and they reported to at least one person that they didn't harden the entire usable area (due to warpage). Brent Beach's page suggests that they weren't able to make it as durable as other stuff like eskilstuna carbon steel (but I'm sure it could still be used to good effect).

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#9

Re: One more picture of a special knife

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Water hardening steels do present problems due to warp on quench. The microstructure of straight carbon steel also makes it difficult to through-harden carbon steel—while maintaining fine grain—as the thickness of the billet gets to the neighborhood of 1/8”. Here’s a reference by Prof. Vermuelen, ‘steel metallurgy for non-metallurgists’, which explains it, starting p. 78 in the Hardenability chapter,

http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf

Briefly, as carbon steel cools during quench, and we’re talking water quench here, the goal is to convert all the austenite over to martensite, which is very hard. But there are competing species trying to form as well, and they are softer—bainite and pearlite for example. As the billet becomes thicker, approaching 1/8”, the center of the billet is cooling more slowly than the outer shell, which favors the softer species forming first, before martensite. If this happens, you don’t get through-hardening. One can sacrifice fineness of grain to get through-hardening of thick billets of carbon steel. But there you are. One reason for adding metals manganese, or chromium, molybdenum, chromium, etc, is that these retard the formation of the undesired softer species such as bainite and pearlite.

The magic of the better Japanese smiths, and presumably Western smiths back in the day, is to get both through-hardening with fine grain. Perhaps lamination Helps by keeping the hard steel thinner.

My apologies to any actual metallurgists in the crowd.

Wiley

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#10

Re: One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

Thanks for the explanation, Wiley. I didn't ask George how he quenched the blade, but I'd guess he sandwiched it.

I thought about making chisels out of W1 last year, brute force (just sawing and filing them out of drill rod), but the guidance I got was that I may make them and then find that I couldn't harden them without cracking. The suggestion at that time was to try quenching in oil to see if it would satisfy (since the items are thin), but I never got there. I can't remember if someone suggested sandwiching them against someone else.

I think you're right about laminating. I haven't seen a single japanese tool that's truly hard but not laminated. Even the kamisori that I've been flipping are laminated. IIRC, george said something about quenching thicker W1 items in brine (jewelry dies, etc), but I haven't talked to anyone who did thin items.

George was the one who suggested to LN that they should use A2 before they started (due to stability and wear), but I'm sure they got that suggestion from more than one person. I'm not sure why they didn't use O1 instead of W1, maybe due to raw material cost? Makes no difference at this point. They've settled on something that works well for them now.

I'll probably default to O1, it's predictable and though it does warp, it's not that bad. It still takes a decent edge, but until I tried to set up an O1 razor for someone last weekend, I wasn't aware of just how much better W1 is at the bleeding edge (I never did get a satisfactory result with 01).

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#11

Re: One more picture of a special knife

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I gushed over that knife on SMC. It’s a beauty. I don’t recall seeing the construction details. I thought he ground the blade but now it seems that the bevel is flat and thus could be filed. Do you know?

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#12

Re: One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

Freehand ground on a belt grinder. I asked him about that because I will probably have to file mine. I can't remember what he said about the shoulder, whether it was filed there or if it was ground all the way back.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#13

Re: One more picture of a special knife

David Bassett

I attended a plane makers panel at WIA 2016 and one of the questions ask was what steel do you use. Thomas L-N said they use A2 because that's what their heat treatment sub-contractor is best at treating. (When ask why they don't still use, I think it was, O1 he answered the guy that heat treated that had shutdown his operation and that's why they switched.) I'm sure their analysis was more complex and thorough, but the summary is they use what they can heat treat best.

(In every other case the answers were O1 and because it is the only steel they could reliably heat treat. All the other makers were smaller operations than L-N.)

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#14

Re: One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

Thanks for that, David.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#15

Re: One more picture of a special knife

TomD

I have never had O1 warp much as far as I could tell, though to a certain extent, for me, I am in the realm of stuff I don't care about at that point. When I do that kind of tool, I will happily grind the hell out of it, if I need to , or a variety of other things. So if the blade goes off I will touch it to the 2x72, or maybe it won't mater. But mostly I have made plane blades, and they never give me very much trouble as one would notice that they didn't mate to the ramp and wedge. I like to leave them blue from the fire, so though corrective grinding is a possibility, I haven't done it much. One thing I do is only harden the last 2 inches or whatever gets hot. So much of the blade is not hardened. Why bother, it does nothing for me. And if you can harden, in the event the Singularity occurs in my lifetime, and I live long enough to use all the steel, I will just touch it off again as required. The priorities are different when you make the stuff.

I have cracked the heck out of O1 when quenching during winter. I end up with large enough pieces I don't care too much.

O1 is theoretical a gauge steel, so it is configured to experience minimal distortion during heat treatment, as a priority.

I once read a description of heat treating and quenching, and I went "Oh so that is why Japanese blades don't blow up". Can't remember what it was though. The thing is they seem to be using water in the quench tank. That will blow up nearly anything that can be hardened effectively. Even with W1 you are only going to get away with it in certain dimensions.

Three other things that can help are: quenching in bacon fat or goop; diff tempering with a torch; clay mask tempering. There are a lot of ways that artisans have modified the process to get what they want. There those folks who say you only can't go wrong if you use strict controls or send your product out to the likes of Paul Bos, whose reputation stands for itself. But the other option is to manage the process. And that works well for artisans over the ages. You may not have controls but changing up the process will manage the same results.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#16

Re: One more picture of a special knife

david weaver

I don't think O1 is bad at all. W1 and 1095 have a known reputation (when not laminated) for bad behavior. The kind of movement that happens with O1 is a couple of minutes on a sandpaper lap, but I think that manufacturers making a few hundred irons a week just don't have much tolerance for anything other than predictable.

I also only harden the last two inches or so (or if a little more gets it by chance - I'm shooting for hardening to the slot, and I am so sparing sharpening an iron, that there's no way I'll wear one out without selling off all of my other planes - and that'll never happen).

But, that's far different than hardening an iron only halfway up to the slot and then selling it as a premium products. FAR different.

I never talked much to George about heat treat, he's fiddled with just about everything as a toolmaker (including the superalloyed steels). He likes knives that take a crisp edge, and since this was a retirement gift for one of his very good friends, I'm sure plain carbon steel was his only choice. I think he expected Jon to use this knife to dress animals, too, but that hasn't happened. I'm sure it would do well.

I have never hardened anything 1095 that I know of, and I've only ever used an oil quench. It works, that's all I need. I don't plan to go to anything more alloyed than O1. I don't plan to look for anything with perfect behavior, either. That kind of thing always comes with some unwanted price attached to it - either in materials, complicated routine, etc. No thanks.

Re: Wiley - Knife Updates?

#17

Re: One more picture of a special knife

TomD

+1. O1 is so nice, I'm fine with it. I don't really consider it a compromise, but even if it is, the fact I can handle it myself makes up for anything it might lack compared to another steel. A lot of worries go away if one can knock another out at any time, harden it up, etc... And while I handle any tools with care, I can grind or buff on it if I think it will make my life easier, because I only have a buck or two into it, so who cares.