Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

Posts

Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#1

Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

Patrick Chase

I redid my experiment exploring achievable cut depths as a function of cap iron setback, this time measuring wood removed instead of shaving thickness.

To recap, I used an 8" x 1.5" curly maple [*] specimen, and took increasingly thick shavings until surface quality was noticeably degraded. I measured thickness in a fixed location before and after each pass.

This time around I used a 4-1/2 with a stamped-type cap iron. Bed angle is 45 deg, and the steepest part of the cap iron's leading edge was 50 deg. The tested setback this time was 5.5 mils, measured using a camera with a scale in the frame for calibration. The cutting edge is therefore 5.5*sin(45) = 3.9 mils "deeper" than the leading edge of the cap iron.

I was able to take cuts up to 4.2 mils deep with moderately increased planing forces and without significant surface quality loss. I was able to achieve cuts up to 5.2 mils deep with greatly increased force and modest dulling of the surface.

The upshot is that cuts with the leading edge of the cap iron at or slightly below the plane of the sole again proved feasible and usable, though both planing forces and quality suffered when going significantly deeper. I'm becoming more convinced that profiling the corners of the cap iron can be a reasonable thing to do (though I'm still not doing it myself as I don't want to add another variable to my setup right now).

One interesting note is that the difference between shaving thickness and cut depth proved to be depth-dependent. For example, a 1.8 mil deep cut produced a ~2.1 mil shaving. A 4.0 mil cut produced a 4.2 mil shaving, while the aforementioned 5.2 mil deep cut produced a 5.2 mil shaving (no detectable difference).

[*] Acer macrophyllum as far as I can tell

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#2

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

david weaver

For some reason, Patrick, I'm not able to duplicate what you're doing with my setup. I don't know if my cap is steeper or what.

If I get a bit of time this weekend, I'll measure a set by microscope.

Stepping back from this a little bit, though, in over 5 years and I don't know how many board feet dimensioned, I've never been able to set the cap iron into the wood, but I have set the cap too close a few times and gotten a "hairy" surface, or got stopped in my tracks. Something easy to do intentionally.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#3

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For best performance, you want to set the cap iron as far away as you can get away with, not as close as you can get away with. The configurations you are talking about give me the heebie jeebies.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#4

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

Patrick Chase

Agreed. The purpose here was to see how far I could push it, not for everyday use.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#5

The importance of applicability

david weaver

When I first said "warren, you were right" on here (which could be found, I'm sure), it wasn't long after that Warren told me that it sounded like I had the cap set too closely at first. He was right, and his comment is an important one.

The difference between talking to Warren or George is that you will get what's applicable.

I'm still keen to measure this and see if I can duplicate what you've done, but I haven't had an applicable case in 5 years where I've needed to go that close and where it made a difference (I have set a cap "too close" or on the edge of the envelope a couple of times to try to deal with really soft earlywood on a quartered board, but it's never made a real difference. If the chip straightens and you still have problems, check direction and cap set. If adjusting those for a best case scenario doesn't solve the issue then, the wood is probably not suitable to be planed).

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#6

Not unprecedented

Patrick Chase

I know I've said this before, but: The geometries I'm playing with here have precedent.

Kato/Kawai's "best" configuration used 4 mils of setback on a 40 deg bed and 4 mil cut depth. We know from their results that that configuration works provided you can supply enough force to stay in the cut, and that's exactly what i saw. There is nothing new, strange, or unique here. It's nothing more than a validation of a previous, widely-accepted result.

Before you say "Kato/Kawai wasn't about hand-planing", bear in mind that my setup was (intentionally) more similar to theirs than to typical furniture work. Specifically the fact that I planed a narrow specimen such that I didn't have to worry about edge effects.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#7

Curly Cherry Challenge

Brian Holcombe

Curly radial grain cherry usually gives me a reason to set the cap iron insanely tight. Might be worth trying out for practical application of this.

Outside of that, Doug Fir from the home center will always provide a sincere challenge since Fir does not like super thin shavings and home center variety has bigger summer growth than the good stuff.


Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#8

Re: Not unprecedented

david weaver

The fact that it's not about hand planing is important if we're discussing the potential for modifying cap irons that may go below the sole on a plane (but won't in the course of practical planing).

The initial conclusion when I wrote an article years ago was that an 80 degree cap iron ledge is a good idea because you can set it back more, and it worked in the video. That is, however, a bad setup for a plane (not necessarily for a machine, though).

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#9

Curly Cherry

david weaver

Curly cherry is the only thing that I've ever planed that required me to set the cap iron close on a jack plane.

I guess cocobolo could cause that, too, but I've never planed a really large piece of cocobolo.

Curly maple gets talked about a lot, but quartered curly cherry is far harder to plane cleanly. Agree on the DF, too - it has the nasty combination of potentially hard earlywood and very fragile latewood.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#10

Re: Not unprecedented

Patrick Chase

Yes, I agree about angle/setback, but in this case I used a 50 deg cap iron angle, as did the Kato/Kawai case that I cited. What was the point again?

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#11

Re: Not unprecedented

david weaver

The point is whether or not there is any reasonable set that has the cap iron below the plane. Not necessarily can you, but is there any reason to.

But I still haven't gotten to the "can" part, and maybe it's because I'm not measuring. If I have time this weekend or next, I'll measure setback with the microscope and try again.

To date in five years, though, I've never had the cap iron protruding into the cut. As warren says, those kinds of sets would give me the willies, and I've found things to go backwards quickly before you get to them.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#12

The other part of the point..

david weaver

..as information trickles into my brain a little at a time. Maybe it's age, I don't know.

Anyway, the whole thing started as a question about why Nicholson uses the word "concentric" when he talks about the cap iron. That's an interesting question to me. I don't believe it has a practical purpose on my planes, but as warren points out quite often, I've been wrong before, and I suppose I might be too dumb to be worried about being wrong again!

So, I'm still listening to this to see if I can find out over time why Nicholson would've made such a recommendation.

That brings us back to potential reason number one. Cap iron hangs over the edge of a cambered iron in a given cut. This has occurred for me with curly cherry a couple of times (two that I can remember - jack work, thicknessing), but the part of the iron that had been overlapped was also recessed inside the plane.

So to understand why Nicholson would recommend concentric, if it's reasonable for the cap iron to extend below the plane, that helps us with our conclusion (we can never know if we're necessarily right without his reason in writing). If it's unreasonable for the plane to be used with the cap iron extending into the cut (which to me is just a matter of reality. Not an issue of impossibility, but an issue of zero practicality), we're back to guessing again why the edges where a shaving would be thinner would benefit from the cap iron being profiled to the iron.

It's sort of a pain to measure all of this stuff (at least for me), because I have things I want to make right now, and it's kind of going backwards (Steve and I talked about this a long time ago, and we experimented a bit - me with trying to plane with the cap iron below the plane and steve possibly so, but also, I'm pretty sure he radiused a cap).

I'm leaning on two potential things, let's go with three (with nicholson). I have clue if they have stayed constant, my memory is shot:

* the radius helps feeding. I'm almost sure that could be the case sometimes based on my experience as a builder. I could be cast as not a very qualified builder because I've probably only built 20 wooden planes of this type, but the variety of irons that I've used has forced me to think a whole lot more about feeding than I've wanted to. Or rather, the variety of cap iron profiles.

* the radius conquers the most likely part of the tearout in the middle of the shaving but relieves a bit of effort at the edges. That's possible, too. It may relate to less labor, but I'm not sure about that.

* gutter type or less than flat jack planes may have been more common years ago (warren would have to comment, I haven't read nicholson). There's a potential labor savings here, too. In boat building, it would be a necessity, as it is in making actual gutters, and possibly hand rail planes (I haven't looked at a lot of hand rail planes, because who needs to make enough of them to justify one, but I wouldn't be surprised to find one with a cap iron on it).

When you start to sweat dimensioning wood, and I don't mean doing ten board feet of it, but when you're doing a project where you're sweating at ten and you have another 190, then you start to think about these things. Even then, they're not vital. I usually do my woodworking two hours at a time because that's about the point where I start making mental mistakes and getting in a hurry. But for someone running a shop 200 years ago, economy in this part of the work would've been a HUGE deal. There's not that much time to be saved in smoothing.

Some of this to me is like legalized gambling. I could read more. Charlie can always troll me when he wants to because I haven't read most of this stuff, and i'm not motivated to because my brain isn't stimulated that well by just reading. So, I'm going along learning all of this and supposing things based on understanding "the machine" and how "the machine operates in context". The gambling part is that I'm often wrong.

The "machine in context" has to do with what's probable or what's likely.

I think it's likely that the lower effort of the double iron was above all what eliminated the single iron, despite the higher cost. I don't know if that's written anywhere. My time (perhaps my wood isn't as good as it should be) dimensioning decreased significantly when I learned to use the double iron, and planing with the butcher long plane is what sent me in that direction (that plane is made in a spec very similar to the CW longer planes - tight mouth, 50 degrees, single iron).

Very long explanation going back to what Warren says quite often, though - subtle experience doesn't tell me for certain that I'm right and Nicholson's wrong. if I was betting at LLoyds, I wouldn't know what odds to take. But subtle experience does tell me that in planing stuff from pine to cocobolo, I haven't encountered any useful set with the cap iron below the plane, and I've set it too closely more than one time.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#13

Re: The other part of the point..

david weaver

to quote the anchorman...

...well, that escalated quickly!

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#14

(Non-) Escalation

Patrick Chase

I think this is actually a pretty reasonable and well-reasoned conversation. The content is all on-point and sufficiently respectful, etc.

I like how this community interacts, thanks for letting me come over and play :-).

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#15

Re: (Non-) Escalation - yes

david weaver

Not a real escalation (as in people start getting yucky), more of an expansion or tie-back to the original questions.

Much prefer discussion on points rather than "credibility of the discusser" as these things often go toward elsewhere.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#16

Re: Curly Osage

TomD

Weird, given it is a fantastic bow wood. But a lot of is like splitting wood when it comes to planing.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#17

Re: haven't planed it...

david weaver

..but some of the blanks that I got show what you're talking about when you turn them. Looks great and then random part splits out. Like some of the "straws" aren't connected together with much strength.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#18

Re: So, I measured....

david weaver

And it resulted in this. I was working on a cabinet yesterday and decided to go for nutty sharp, and then after that, test the shaving thickness vs. cap iron set.

As to whether or not I was putting enough force on the plane - still debatable (this is just a re-break of a glued handle), I think so.

(If I had not dropped this plane in the past and broken the handle, It wouldn't have broken during this activity, but I've never broker a glued handle, either, and admittedly was horsing the plane much harder than I would've anything in regular daily use).

https://s1.postimg.org/164ftet6pb/20171104_162511.jpg

What I found was this: I could get just under 4 thousandths out of a set that was about 5 1/2 or 6 thousandths (cap iron distance from the edge). Around 3, the resistance was more than I'd tolerate on an edge that was about 1.1 inches wide (so planing the face of a board, I wouldn't be planing a 3 thousandth shaving with this set). A just under four, the handle let go.

I freehanded the front bevel of the cap iron on this plane, it's probably somewhere around 50-60 degrees.

I'd attribute some of the difference in our findings to the fact that beech is probably quite a bit stiffer than bigleaf maple.

I also noticed (re: the discussion about being able to see an edge that's not even) that I'd set the cap iron visibly different in projection, but only just so. So I took two pictures - one with the edge at the left and one at the right. I intentionally honed the edge straight across since I was playing with edge quality for pictures - to be posted separately. the front edge of the cap is straight end to end, so the center of the blade is somewhere between these two pictures. Point being, you can see very small differences in projection with the naked eye. If this looked even to me, I'd have taken a picture of the center only.

Left:

https://s1.postimg.org/60bagcnxsv/cap_left.jpg

Right:

https://s1.postimg.org/1hm0rjnh4f/cap_right.jpg

And for calibration, a picture of a piece of wire that is exactly .007"

https://s1.postimg.org/4c5rcm0t27/7_thou_wire.jpg

I may try this in the future with cherry, but will need to do what I should've done a while ago - make a new handle for this plane instead of gluing a broken one.

(separate thought - the cap iron in the picture is where the line becomes uniformly black - it's above the edge and not below it. when I got this plane, it was sent to me just pre-production, and since the cap and the iron are both flat bevels and very well finished, I couldn't easily see the point where the cap met the back of the iron, so I used oxpho blue on the cap and made it easy to see. I suggested that to Lee Valley. I think that for all of us, oxpho bluing or any kind of cold blue on the cap iron is a large visual improvement. I have better sight than anyone I know, so I'd consider that to be an improvement for everyone no matter what you can or can't see. Seeing the difference in projection with the cap black (looks like about one thousandth) is something I can see clearly without much thought. Seeing where the cap met the iron with two flat surfaces was harder than seeing that thousandth).

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#19

Similar results

Patrick Chase

It looks like we're getting broadly similar results here.

We both agree that the forces are reasonable until the cap iron is

somewhere between 0 and 1 mil above the sole. We both agree that below that there is a range where cuts are technically feasible but increasingly difficult to the point of being undesirable. The point at which we each had to call it quits probably doesn't matter all that much, since we both agree that we wouldn't want to operate there anyway. The similarity in our respective "reasonability thresholds" is probably more significant.

As you say the remaining difference between our results probably comes down to the wood (and perhaps willingness to apply brute force :-). IIRC K&K used a softwood, so that might also explain why their preferred configuration was lower than either of ours.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#20

Re: Similar results

david weaver

I can apply as much brute force as anyone of my weight can (195). I was beyond the limits of good taste when my handle let go.

I thought we had previously had posts suggesting that it was possible to plane with the cap iron below the sole, and not in a "nobody would ever do this" kind of way? The latter is what I'm suggesting.

This is the first time I've ever measured the cap iron in any way that provides something other than, I don't know, it could be 2 thousandths or it could be 8?

So, it appears my "standard set" on a smoother is about 6. If I have trouble at this setting, I may use something that's half of this, but it's awfully restrictive for obvious reasons, and it takes something like ash running out right into the surface to need it - and that kind of stuff is usually best left in the burn pile.

Re: Cut depth and cap-iron set redux

#21

Re: The Reserve Plane

david weaver

I remember when the school bus would go down for the count in the 1980s, and we'd get one of the older reserve buses. They were usually old buses from the 1960s or early 1970s. They looked wild, but most were almost dead and they were super slow.

Since I was actually working on something, after breaking the handle on the LV plane (again, but at least not dropping it on the floor this time), my shop version of the reserve school bus is this:

https://s1.postimg.org/2l6nh10xpr/20171104_164244.jpg

(while I really like the wooden try plane for nearly everything, if I have to joint a whole bunch of narrow edges, I don't love the way that doing that can bungle the bottom of the plane a bit)

This Sorby plane is just simply the nicest metal plane I've ever used, and it has a strangely soft very thin iron. When I received the plane (used), it had the factory finish on the sole still and was less than 1.5 thousandths out of flat along its length. Fortunatley, I got it from the UK before the global shipping program started seizing planes with wooden parts.