Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A testament to the quality of atoma stones

Posts

A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#1

A testament to the quality of atoma stones

david weaver

https://s1.postimg.org/8wihrnjcjz/20171023_170235.jpg

I have been flipping stuff on etsy, japanese stuff. Just something to do, not that I expect to make much money, but it's a way for me to order stuff from japan that goes for a little more here and get a look at things and see what I might want to keep.

I like watches. Not as much as someone who is absolutely nutty about them, but as a matter of them being something made that is still very human and mechanical at the same time. I also want watches that are made entirely in the western or eastern first world, and that's not that easy to find. There are brands that have stepped up in quality since the early days and their older watches have gotten expensive because of it, and there are brands that were super quality to start but due to age, don't cost that much relative to new watches.

King Seiko is one of those. Seiko set up two competing factories in japan, King Seiko and Grand Seiko, I guess in the 1960s. Right around the same time that Seiko invented the quartz watch. Seiko's objective was to run the two factories parallel without using outside parts, and the better of the two factories would survive - the other would be shut down. Grand seiko survived, and still makes quartz, automatic and spring drive watches (the last being something nobody else makes). They are expensive, because they're made entirely in house in japan, as opposed to just being assembled from global parts. When you see terms such as "swiss made" or "made in japan", those don't really mean much.

http://www.japan-onlinestore.com/SBGA149

Back to the king seiko. King seiko didn't survive, and though seiko invented quartz at the time, they also developed what they called the hi-beat automatic watches. These can be had in japan for about $300, but they are smaller than current popular watches in the face size. They also often need a bit of a polish, and the original bracelets usually long gone. Once in a while, you'll find one that has a lot of scratches on the sapphire (which is as hard as alumina). How that happens, I don't know.

I bid on the watch in the picture a couple of months ago because it was chronograph rated, and it has a standard bracelet size (so the strange thing in the picture can be replaced inexpensively). However, the crystal was very scratched, and deeply. Bizarrely so. A new crystal is about $100 or a little more, even if you install it yourself. No thanks. I thought I cancelled my bid, but I must've forgotten and I got an email at the end of the auction saying I'd won the watch for $298. Oops. Now I've got to figure out how to get the scratches out of the sapphire and since it's a lens, it needs to be clear and uniform.

Years ago, I got into a craze of trying various types of diamonds, and I have gobs of powders around, and probably (I should be ashamed) a dozen diamond plates. Most of them cheap, but two are eze lap, two dmt and two atoma. There's one practical way to grind off sapphire from a lens.....diamonds.

So I put some diamond powder on an oilstone (an old green english novaculite stone that's only ho hum), and I put some on a stick of walnut and proceeded to rub away. Slow progress would be an understatement. I had the ezelap handy, and I was surprised to find that it completely ruined the lens with random deep scratches. I really don't want to sell the watch as salvage for half of what i paid, so I was going to put it aside and think about it later. My atoma is a 400, which is not particularly fine. I decided to try it just to see if I could get uniform scratches, and then I could go back from there. To my surprise, it almost put a polish on the lens, it is absolutely perfectly uniform and there are no random scratches at all.

It literally can be followed with one grade of diamond powder on a stick (half micron is fine) for about 10 minutes and all is done. Knowing what I know now, flat sapphire lenses are a project of about 10 minutes time.

I really like the ezelap a lot, and not every single japanese product is superior, but I have to admit that the unexpected extreme difference in quality control and manufacturing and grading precision between these two brands of plates is surprising. DMT is out of the question, I already know their grading is very loose and there are random big diamonds on the plates.

I have been using this atoma on natural stones - I didn't bother to clean it, the natural stone powder wouldn't touch the sapphire and if there is a bit of aluminum oxide - natural aluminum oxide - in one of the japanese stones, it would only polish the sapphire. The dust is literally sapphire. It would be interesting, since it's alumina, to take that dust and try it on a jasper, but I think I've already brushed it off. The dust I collect from japanese razor hone flattening is actually very useful on a jasper.

IF you ever have a flat lens sapphire watch and develop a scratch and you have an atoma, too. You are 5 dollars away (in a graded paste or powder of about 1/2-1 micron) from removing the scratches and making the lens new. Having kept all of the strange sharpening mediums that I have (but don't use) has saved me a lot in this case.

(but don't ever put a watch on a DMT or eze lap).

Over the last ten years, I've used more stuff from the woodworking shop to fix things completely unrelated than I ever would've expected to. Yesterday, I used a bessey clamp to depress brake calipers on the car when the brake tool I have wouldn't do the job (two calipers, and the tool I have only does one. I never should've bought the tool in the first place - a bessey clamp does the job very easily on the cars that I have).

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#2

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Good grief David, you are nuts!

There are diamond pastes and compounds that are available for this task.

Incidentally, there is a history of the King Seiko here: http://forums.watchuseek.com/f366/history-classic-automatic-king-seiko-comparison-5626-7113-5256-8010-a-1034554.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#3

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

david weaver

Yes, and I think those pastes (DMT for example) are great for shallow work, but the grades recommended just weren't cutting out the deep scratches this sapphire had. I'm really clueless as to how it could've been beaten up so badly without more than minor scratching on the rest of the case.

(the guy on that link sure was proud of that chronometer!! EDIT....oops, missed that the dial was teal. Definitely brings extra money).

Some of the crystals are hardlex on the KS, but I don't think this one is. Alumina wouldn't touch it. But, I'm no expert. Diamonds worked great, and I'd never thought about how consistent one plate is vs. another, but the consistency of the atoma plate (I can't imagine that it really needs to be so consistent as it is) was really shocking (and it's flat, which is fairly important for something like this).

Just as happy with the bessey as a brake caliper tool!!

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#4

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

steve voigt

Dave, slightly OT question:

I use loose silicon carbide on glass to flatten my oilstones. I've thought about getting an Atoma instead. Any thoughts on grit size? I would've thought 140 I see some people recommend 400. (Darryl Gent uses different grits for each oilstone, but I'm not going to go there)

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#5

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve and all,

Haven’t tried oil stones, but I prefer the 140 to the 400 on water stones. Why? It’s faster—makes it happen right now. There’s a trade off: 400 would be less disruptive to the stone surface in depth, but the 140 is really fast. On waterstones.

Wiley

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#6

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

David weaver

400 on anything less coarse than a soft ark. A 140 would probably be better for a soft ark

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#7

Thanks Wiley and Dave!


Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#8

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

Patrick Chase

The Atomas are indeed tightly graded and very flat. I don't use diamond plates often, but when I do...

The EZE-Laps have a couple traits that might have come into play here. I don't think they're as flat as Atoma, and they also use a mix of mono- and poly-crystalline diamonds, whereas Atoma is entirely monocrystalline. Poly diamonds are somewhat friable, which means that they continuously break down and expose fresh edges (until they're depleted obviously). A polycrystalline plate like the EZE-Lap will keep exposing new/jagged edges long after a monocrystalline plate like the Atoma has broken in, and I suspect that may be what you saw.

With that said, I would never use a diamond plate for this. It's basically as perfect an application as you will ever see for a cast iron or steel lap with a tightly-graded diamond compound. To wit:

1. The surface that you're lapping is much harder than any lapping plate, which (counterintuitively) minimizes wear on the plate and maximizes lapping speed.

2. The surface that you're lapping is so hard that transfer is a non-issue. Just clean up reasonably well between grits and you're good to go.

3. You're literally trying for optical flatness here, and the compounds are tightly graded and available down to ~0.1 um, whereas plates stop at ~3 um (and your Atoma 400 is ~40 um).

4. Compounds also avoid "projection height" variance from the nickel-electroplating process that bonds the diamonds to plates. From starting at SEM images in a couple places I think that this is one of the causes of DMT's "rogue particle" problem.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#9

Diamond paste grades *LINK*

Patrick Chase

DMT paste is marketed to hobbyists, and covers a very narrow range of grades. The coarsest is 6 um, or the equivalent of a #2000 JIS-compliant waterstone. DMT also doesn't state whether they conform to PS62-74 or its successor (the statistical control spec for sub-sieve diamonds) which isn't reassuring.

Norton makes a very good, tightly-graded line of pastes and Joel sells them up to 45 um (~7x more aggressive than orange DMT) at TFWW. If you search you can find plenty of non-WW outlets that sell the full line (0.25 um to 60 um IIRC).

McMaster-Carr resells the Sandvik-Hyperion line of pastes, which are also excellent and range from 0.5 to 60 um.

Precision Surfaces International makes a pretty decent 0.1 um paste, which might be useful for an optical surface like this. I can send you a little bit if you want.

In my experience either Norton or Sandvik-Hyperion pastes are better for uniformity than any metal-bonded plate (Atoma, DMT, EZE-Lap, etc). The only bonded/non-loose solutions that are competitive in that regard are resin-bonded films like 3M 661X/668X (what LV resells) and Shapton's resin-bonded diamond lapping plate. The problem with those is that they don't last very long for working hard materials, which is why Shapton tells people not to ever use the plate to tools. The films would probably last long enough to be viable, though.


McMaster diamond compounds

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#10

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

Patrick Chase

I just looked at Stu's site to see how much he wants for Atomas these days, and all I can say is that I'm glad I stocked up on replacement topsheets while they were cheaper.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#11

Re: Diamond paste grades

david weaver

0.1 is actually what's on the piece of wood in the picture. For some reason, at one point, I got 8 grits from 100 to 0.1 micron.

I always bought powders because they're a lot cheaper than pastes when all is said and done.

re: DMT, I'm not too familiar since I've only bought loose diamond powder, but recall that the watch website that I looked at recommended them. As shallow as the diamond cuts the lens, even if it's not graded too close, it's probably OK. You get a matte finish with nothing necessarily out of order with the 400 grit atoma. I was a bit shocked by that, and once you get going, the powder comes off pretty quickly. I don't remember exactly, but maybe 5 minutes or less for what's shown on it there.

For giggles, I tried a couple of other alumina based things (autosol, 10 micron alumina buffing stick, etc), but none of them would do anything to the crystal.

Still not sure what was on the EZE lap. I should've taken a picture of the lens after it went over it. It was horrific. Fortunately, the lens is pretty thick.

I hopefully am over the watch jones and will probably peddle the king seikos, but it's been interesting. Still have vials in 1, 0.5, 0.25 and 0.1 micron (I got them from a lapping supply place here, I think, but I could be wrong - I know I got them through the mail, but there are times I will do that, anyway, because a 10-15 mile trip on the weekend might be two hours round trip and it's just not worth it).

Thanks for the offer to send some, though. I've got more lapping products than anyone who has no real need for them should have. Including CBN suspensions, etc (that didn't come from razor suppliers). Those were a waste, even the "heavy concentration" isn't very heavy. There must be a machine that works them that I don't have, and maybe that's what I'm missing. And, the pigments, of course. Which you find out when they spill ....they're definitely pigments, and they go a long way before you finally get the last of the colors cleaned off of whatever they spilled on. Even painted wood, you'll find every single crack you never knew existed in a painted surface that hasn't been breached.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#12

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

david weaver

You'd be surprised how well the atoma worked here. Making a steel lap would've been a waste of time, though I'd have done it if needed.

My stick (in the picture) has something I acquired a long time ago - "6500" grit. Must be 4 microns or something. It actually leaves a pretty good surface.

Well, that's one side of the stick. The other side is the 0.1 micron. That combination worked really well.

For a watch face like this, only the first step is really critical (for flatness). Most of the tutorals appear to recommend a rag after the first step, but I'm not going for that. (one of them recommended a rag and hand buffing for all steps. Recipe for ugly, maybe - in this case, it wouldn't have done the job).

The issue with the ezelap is something else other than polycrystalline. There are a couple of giant strays on it, which I know is common on DMT (they usually get ripped out, though), but the atoma, no such thing. The diamonds are in piles (as I'm sure you've seen) with the piles lined up like a marching band. Because of that, i don't like them so much for honing, they feel like honing on a zipper, but i always use them for japanese stones because they are the flattest economy diamond hone you'll find. This whole process with the deep scratch could be 10 minutes the next time I do it, but like said in the other post - hopefully not soon.

The favorite that I settled on has a curved sapphire lens. If it gets a deep scratch...well, I guess I'll have to fashion a concave lap, but it probably has compound geometry. I hope it never gets more than would hand buff out with half or quarter micron.

It's nice to try all of this stuff once, though. Just like it's nice to learn to take interior panels out of cars, and replace brake pads, rotors, etc..... Timing belts on a turbocharged european car...not so much.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#13

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

david weaver

I can't remember where they started on stu's site. Both of mine predate stu being in business (alex gilmore carried them way back when for about $110 with a base).

For no good reason, I have two 400, but like them better worn as they are because they don't leave deep grooves in a finishing stone (think japanese barber hones).

I'd go check a yahoo japan auction, but I'm sure the price would be similar to stu's, plus you have to pay shipping twice (once inside the country and again to get an ordered item to the united states).

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#14

Patrick, I hope you're not offended

david weaver

That when you bring stuff up (the composition of the diamonds, the availability of powders, etc) that my response often seems to be "yeah, I have that already".

I have been criticized more than once (charlie stanford did it all the time) with lines like "there's no way you've ever tried all of this stuff or have every owned it".

Well, there's always someone who gets carried away - I'd say that was me, but it still is. I wanted to nice watches in this last shift, and now I have 7 that I need to sell. Oops. Every single one of them is a Seiko....that's a bit of an Aspergery thing, though. Not that I've ever been diagnosed, but as I get older, I get a little more Aspergery, I think. (oh...and two pocket watches, one that was made long ago near Warren's stomping grounds).

So aspergery thing aside, we're generally on the same street. And when I wanted to try everything. Well, I sort of did.

When I wanted to try every kind of steel I could think of. Well, I sort of did. Except S30V - never got the urge for that. Super blue sort of cured me of going to the really alloyed stuff.

So, anyway, I'm not trying to make it a contest, I've just "been bad", I guess.

The thing that came into my mind about the diamonds before all of this is that at one point, I felt like "nah...not for me" and considered throwing the vials away.

The baggies of bigger stuff, I always got on ebay (haven't in a while given the surplus), because at one point, they were about $22 for 100 karats.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#15

Absolutely not

Patrick Chase

I've read your stuff on "the old forum" and this one long enough that I know where you're coming from. I know you passed through your "waterstone phase" and "loose diamond phase" long ago.

I enjoy your perspective and our interaction.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#16

Re: Patrick, I hope you're not offended

Charlie Stanford

David, I don't recall having ever said that. If I did, though, I do stand corrected. I have no doubt that you've tried all of this stuff.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#17

Interesting to see a McMaster Carr recommendation.

Chuck Nickerson

In other materials (files in particular) they're happy to change sources without mentioning it. Are the tubes of paste labeled such that if they change source I'd know it?

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#18

Jackson Lea

david weaver

That's the name on the box. It's gold/yellow in color, but I can't find something that matches what I remember in microns.

It may have been 5 microns. My memory isn't what it used to be!!

Still is fast cutting compared to what we're used to, and looks like it's 10 bucks for 3 pounds at McMaster. Generally, they're not the lowest price, but they are really close and deliver in a day where i live (plus, they charge accurate shipping instead of a larger flat charge. Something like this costs me $4-$5 in shipping).

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#19

Re: Patrick, I hope you're not offended

David weaver

If your last name was mugglewarf or something, it'd be a lot easier to find via a Google search.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#20

Re: Interesting to see a McMaster Carr recommendat

Patrick Chase

The ones I have from McMaster are all labelled Sandvik-Hyperion or Hyperion (Sandvik bought Hyperion a while back)

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#21

Surprisingly

david weaver

I haven't found the same stuff anywhere else for nearly the same price.

5 micron jackson lea, 3 pounds. I can't tell which one it is from my old email receipts because the part numbers have been changed, but I got four bars of stuff ranging in price from 6.92 (for 3 pounds!!) to $10.

Total shipping for 12 pounds of stuff was $8.

I think the $10 stuff at the time was blue for plastic or the iron oxide rouge. Didn't find anything in any of them worthy of trouble to use for sharpening (though the 5 micron compound would work fine, it's like the green sticks, you have to add a drop of oil to get it to work well), but the yellow has been a very good go-to for general buffing, and combined with a gray scotch brite wheel, there's nothing that you can actually recover reasonably that you can't remove the rust from very quickly.

Whatever the case, this is one of the few times mcmaster is competitive. Another in the "old days" was when they sold USA nicholson and simonds files for $4-$5 per for various triangular sizes. Of course, you had no guarantee about what brand they would be, but nicholson and simonds were what I got at the time.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#22

hmmm...

John in NM

I don't see anything on their diamond page that is $10 for three pounds.

I think you're mixing something up - I could see them selling some kind of rouge compound for that price, but typically diamond grits and compounds sell for 2-3 grams for $10.

McMaster is good for what they are good for. Letting you know what brand they supply is not what they are good for. A huge selection of stuff you need and really fast shipping is what they are very good at. But if the brand matters to you, shop elsewhere.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#23

Re: hmmm...

david weaver

Sorry. The run-up of titles is misleading. We went from diamond to buffing compounds.

The Jackson Lea 5 micron aluminum oxide yellow stick is AlOx only, and is described by McMaster as a combination "cut and polish" compound, which is accurate.

I have always purchased diamond compounds off of ebay, because there's always someone on there (this may no longer be true) taking a huge lot of diamonds and putting them in baggies for a low price.

The last time I bought, 100 carats of diamonds (dry, no paste) was about $22 from a seller who had the name "yuri???" on ebay. I've gotten diamonds from 100 grit to what they term 100,000 "grid", and then specific micron sizes from 1 down to 1/10th in vials (far fewer carats, but much more specific labeling). 100 carats is a LOT of diamonds for sharpening purposes. Perhaps a lifetime supply.

I've never bought a diamond compound in a wax bar.

Not that it's germane to this conversation, but in case anyone is reading it, I noticed that my #1/10 micron compound has, over time, clumped a bit and the clumps could do damage before they're broken. For my watch face, I smoothed them with my thumb. I've had other oddities from time to time with graded diamonds that are most likely due to clumping (they happen and then disappear) or something rough on the substrate.

Electroplated hones are a far different story. There are some monster strays on DMTs plates and the one EZE lap that I've tried had a horrible rogue diamond(s?) on it somewhere that really beat up the face of my watch and forced me to go to the atoma 400 to remove the damage it did.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#24

McMaster Diamond Paste

Patrick Chase

As I said in another post, McMaster sells Sandvik-Hyperion diamond compounds, specifically their "SJK-5" grade monocrystalline powder in oil, water, or oil+water-compatible media.

Their prices are VERY competitive for a quality monocrystalline compound.

Re: A testament to the quality of atoma stones

#25

Re: McMaster Diamond Paste

John in NM

From what I've seen their prices on diamond compound is on a par with lapidary suppliers.

On the whole McMaster is a good vendor, and generally price competitive. Their biggest plus is that they carry a huge amount of stuff and some of it can be hard to find elsewhere. If they would just tell you who's product you're buying, I wouldn't really have a complaint with them (that one has bit us a few times at work).