My hand cut dovetails does not glide effortless together with a light tap as you see on youtube....
Instead I have to use XXL Bessey Revo clamps to force them together. I glue drawer back and one side together and when dried I glue the front. Normally that is no major problem, but I do have to apply force to get them to close completely. Lastly I glu the second drawer side. Often this turns out to be an exhausting wrestling match. The glu tack and I have to use several clamps at maximum force them together. This problem is of course worse on larger drawers.
I use Titlebond Extend Wood Glue. Are there any alternatives with slower speed of set?
You don't say how you have cut these dovetails, but the simplest answer is to cut them a bit looser so they come together more comfortably. You should not have to use extreme force.
Tell more about your technique, and perhaps we can give more specific advice.
On many factors, the deeper the joint the more work it will be. I cut very tight through dovetails for a bench earlier in the year, they took almost the entire open time of the glue to get them together. It was a careful process of applying pressure with a pair of bessey clamps and tapping them with hammer/wood sacrifice.
Other dovetails, like those for art frames or drawers go together with a few taps.
Well I test assemble them half way and that goes pretty easy with a wood sacrifice and hammer (if the joint is too tight I carefully file the pins). But it is more difficult with glue. I am positive that applying glue takes only 2 minutes. They enter fine but just after some mm it get stuck. I have to apply a lot pressure until a sharp click is heard and they enter a few mm. They immediately get stuck again and I have to build up pressure with the clamps. This has to be repeated 3-4 times and the last gap is very tough to close.
The drawers are of ash and some 20 mm (3/4") thick. I dilute the glu with some water to get it less thick.
I have made a lot of drawers but not experienced this problem before. The glue is 2-3 years old - could that be the problem?
I agree with others that you are making them too tight, but you may get away with it with a different glue. Personally I like hide glue for this kind of work - it is very slippery before it tacks. Try it on a test joint and see if its any better.
I usually glue up the entire drawer box to ensure that its square. If you're having trouble doing that, it sounds to me like you need to make a change to process or glue.
The stick-slip behavior you describe sounds like what happens if you let the joint get crooked while you're clamping. You have to be careful to advance all of your clamps in tandem to keep everything square. Could that be part of the problem?
Liquid hide glue--comes in a bottle--will give you the open time you need, and won't be so nerve-wracking. Has to be liquid hide, as hot hide glue has fast tack. Hide glue also has the property of cleaning up beautifully with a moist rag, and won't discolor your finish.
Re: Gluing up drawers - Ditto Hide Glue suggestion
David Charlesworth
Clamps are generally a very bad way of gluing up drawers. It is highly likely that the delicate structure will be distorted,by the weight or the pressure.
A large hammer is a good tool for dispensing delicate or more forceful "taps".
I am building a sideboard with 7 drawers. They are quite big and clumsy to handle so the first time it took some time and I guess the glu had time to tack. Now I had improved the speed so I can close the joint to 95% with hammer taps. The last part I still rely on my Besseys...
I will try hide glu next time I have a colplicated glu-up.