Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

Posts

Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#1

Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Steve,

Fantastic article you wrote for Popular Woodworking!

I know it's been referred to in previous posts below, but I thought I'd thank you personally, in sort of a very public manner...

I read it once, then again, and several more times to get all the steps in my head. You did a very thorough job, super readable, and explained several points I had always wondered about. Now, thanks to your article, and armed with this new found knowledge, I feel confident in making replacement wedges for those "project" planes that follow me home.

For a start, I've got a cute 4-1/2" boxwood coffin smoother that needs a proper wedge. But it is a single iron plane. Can you point to some resources to best deal with the plane's mortise and wedge geometry for single iron planes vs. the double iron versions

your article describes?

Thanks again!

John

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#2

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW... *LINK*

steve voigt

Hi John,

Thank you so much for the kind words. There is nothing so gratifying as getting kudos from a professional maker with great skill and high standards. I feel like I should print your post and pin it on my shop wall!

Regarding single irons, here are the two big differences.

(1) the wear angle is 15-20° more than the bed angle, though in rare cases (like the Seaton single iron jack) it is 10° higher than the bed, and thus coplanar with the abutments.

2) The plane of the abutments goes through the mouth, usually just a bit behind the front of the mouth (a factor that makes sawing the abutments easier than on a double iron plane).

3) I want to say that the wear is often a little shorter, but I could be wrong about that--I haven't studied enough historical examples of single irons. (Wiley, if you are reading this, I'd love to hear your thoughts)

Bob Roz. has an excellent post on the geometry of single irons, ugly double irons, and nice double irons.--I'll link below.

I think that's about it...if I think of some more, I'll post later.

Thanks again!


throat geometry

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#3

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

First off, agree with John, that Steve wrote an article to save and keep. Also, that John is a supreme craftsman (anyone who hasn't been there, go to his website to see the stringed instrument bows).

http:/www.jbabows.com

John, it sounds like you are pretty well locked into the plane's geometry, given that you have the plane in your hands, and perhaps the iron. I have a small single-iron smooth plane (C&W, 2005). Look at the last two photos in this Flickr album, for an overall shot and then a wedge shot:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157632126114344

Be glad to provide further photos or dimensions if they will help. NOte that the plane's abutments taper to nothing, into the corners of the mouth. Accordingly, the horns of the wedge are flush with the abutments all the way down, so as not to impede the shaving, and so they taper to nothing as well.

For what it's worth, the plane is 5-3/4" long with a 1-1/4" iron, bedded at 55 degrees. The wear is 17.5 degrees off vertical, and the upper escapement(?term?) is 25 degrees off vertical.

Lemme know if You need something more specific--like the plane to examine!

Wiley

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#4

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

steve voigt

Hi Wiley,

If you've got the time, I would really love to know the height of the wear in a couple of those CW planes. And if you've got any vintage single irons, I would love to know how they compare on that dimension.

I'm amused that I told John that the wear is 15-20° higher than the bed, and yours is 17.5°, splitting the difference perfectly. It's also interesting that the wear is both 17.5 above the bed, and 17.5 off of vertical, an interesting coincidence (though of no consequence, since it's an arbitrary result of the bed angle).

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#5

Yes, super article

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The one enhancement that occurred to me while reading it would have been a sidebar on what a float is. People who haven't been keeping up in this area might have been wondering what a soda fountain drink was doing in an article on planemaking.

But the level of detail and, particularly, clear explanation of why each step is important was great.

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#6

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Wiley,

Thanks for the kind words, but all bow makers are a bit anal retentive and attention to details is a prerequisite to the craft! Having worked as an engineer for 20 years only makes is worse...

I'll have to measure the pair of ~4-1/2" single bladed coffin smoothers I have. One, a ~1890's (?) Marshall, Glasgow, in beech, is in very nice condition, except for the wedge tips - they seem too short, as per your comments, and a bit mangled. I was thinking that I could attempt to splice (glue) new tips to the wedge to improve them, but honestly, I haven't even sharpened the blade to see how it performs at present. Might be just fine, I don't know.

The other plane, the boxwood one, marked "Matthews" (possibly E. L. Matthews of Baltimore) has a beech wedge from another plane and the blued (burnt!) end of the blade is too narrow, as per comments from Bob Rozieski's site. The mouth opening is a full 1-1/2" and the iron is 1/8" less, so no wedge tips would properly hold the blade and guide chips from the mouth. This plane is in need of both a new blade and a new wedge. I'll have to dig through my small stash of irons to see if anything might work. I think I have a Peugeot Freres blade that I could cut to size.

Since these planes have no chip breakers, is it advisable to close up the mouth with a Dutchman patch? They are small detail planes and would never be used to smooth a large panel. I can see them breaking an edge or beveling a board but not much else, imo.

Small planes (and boxwood tools!) always follow me home and I'd enjoy getting this little Matthews smoother back to useable condition.

John

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#7

Re: Yes, super article

steve voigt

Thanks Bill. I would've loved to include more on floats, but the article was already 50% longer than it was supposed to be. Hopefully I'll get a chance to write on some of these supplementary topics in the future.

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#8

Long article (yay!)

Patrick Chase

To be honest I was pleasantly surprised that they allowed you to run that long. My impression is that PWW typically assumes that their readers have short attention spans, and edits accordingly.

Yet more kudos on convincing your editors to accept a long-form article!

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#9

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

John,

Don't cut that Peugeot Freres iron yet. Got something to show you tomorrow.

Wiley

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#10

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Wiley,

The two Peugeot Freres single iron blades I have are new, old stock and measure 30 mm wide, so they wouldn't work for this little Matthews smoother. I have another, unused, no name tapered blade of the correct width (1-1/2") but it is only 3-1/2" long. Compared to the Marshall plane, this plane should have a ~4-1/2 to 5" long tapered blade to be correct. If you have something that might work in those dimensions, please let me know! I have plenty of boxwood for a new wedge, so I'm covered there.

Thanks,

John

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

#11

Re: Super article by Steve Voigt in PW...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi John,

One boxwood calls another. Take a look at last 3 items in this album:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157650771983555

That I. Sorby iron is 1.5" wide by 5" long. Will send along. The boxwood itself has great patina, but I never chamfer anything, so am glad to give the plane new life.

Wiley