Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Old Steel vs. New Steel

Posts

Old Steel vs. New Steel

#1

Old Steel vs. New Steel

david weaver

In order of the quality of edge steel after adjusting for variability:

japanese white 2 (and other similar mid-level steels that the japanese use in commodity tools) > good vintage steel > modern process steel of reasonable quality > (tied for last is two - bad vintage and bad modern process)

Cue Itchy and scratchy theme music with the topic..."fight, fight, fight.... fight, fight, fight...."

I took some pictures with the microscope earlier this month (last month?) to flesh out really perfecting sharpening razors and identifying dud razors (some don't hold an edge as well as others, and when the angle is 16-18 degrees, mediocre stuff is found quickly.

One of the things that i noticed is that at a true level of about 150x or so, I could see all sorts of voids in a set of ashley iles chisels. These are obviously modern process steel (I bought them last year). I wasn't looking at chisel steel, I was looking at what the various stones do to steel of different hardness to see if I could prove what's generally well known - that harder steels will take a better edge off of a given stone because the grooves aren't as deep.

Anyway, this is a picture of the Iles chisel. This was actually one of the better sections. I didn't want to show the sections that had bubbles right at the edge because they looked terrible due to the magnification, but are not visible to the naked eye or look like tiny flaws (the edge just looks uniformly polished otherwise). Even in this relatively clear section of chisel, there was still a bubble at the edge and you could see other small voids.

https://s1.postimg.org/8rxbsfmd1r/slurry_okudo.jpg

I bring this up, because on another forum, we often see criticism of old steel and discussion of the superiority of modern steel because based on reading books about steel process, etc. I've never thought the new steel in western tools was better than the better old stuff, for more than one reason, but the assumption by new process proponents is that all newer steel is defect free or close to it because of modern process controls.

I am going to look at more old irons (I probably have 75 from various makers on the doomsday scenario that I lock myself in the garage and attempt too make a whole bunch of planes in a row at some point). And perhaps more japanese stuff.

My supposition from use is that once you discard the 5-10% of older stuff that's just not that great, the rest is at least as good as modern and some better.

Modern steel is uniform, and often defect free, but no better than the better vintage stuff (in edge holding, etc).

And generally, white 2 japanese steel is better than both. As much as I like vintage steel, it's not as good as yasuki (hitachi) white 2 and probably nothing is more consistent. I use white 2 for two reasons- it's apparently not that hard to heat treat properly (white 1 is a different story), and because it's out there in droves in tools that don't cost that much.

As for the iles chisels? the bubbles or voids are ugly, but they really don't make a difference in day to day work because they are so small. I like the chisels plenty enough that I just don't care. And those chisels like natural stones and have reasonable hardness, which is another bonus - they don't make a huge ratty wire edge that they don't want to let go of.

Razors are a different thing entirely, but interesting with them, the razors made in the 1800s aren't really that great. I don't know why that is. Of course you can shave with them, but the cutlers didn't perfect the grinding, heat treating and finishing process until later on. Maybe 1900s, and perhaps a little after that. The difference in result is not one that would matter much for woodworking tools, but when you put the edge on your face and shave with a razor for a month, it's definitely noticeable (a good razor will start sharper and stay sharp longer, all other things being equal - like hardness, etc).

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#2

Over-generalizing?

Patrick Chase

I don't think it's safe to generalize from the limited number of chisels that you inspected to entire classes of steel.

The voids you saw in the Ashley Iles chisels are probably where carbides fell out of the ferrite matrix. AI uses HCS, so they *shoudn't* have that problem, but there are all sorts of ways get coarse microstructure via botched processing. I'm honestly not impressed by the modern English edge-tool makers, and not altogether surprised that your chisels have that problem.

More broadly HCS (new or old) and Hitachi White are more similar than different in terms of composition and achievable grain structure. When you measure "differences" between them all you're really doing is measuring the quality of the processing that was applied to specific tools IMO. I'll go ahead and stipulate here that the best Japanese chisels receive exquisite processing.

Even if AI's HCS were optimally processed you can't generalize from that to "modern processed steels" the way you did, because the larger category includes exotics like PM steels that mop the floor with their older counterparts in all objective respects save cost. You can't really generalize unless/until you've looked at those comprehensively.

In short, your data entitle you to draw conclusions about a couple/few specific tools, and *maybe* some weak conclusions about their makers (though you'd ideally want a much larger sample for that). You certainly are not on solid ground when you generalize to entire eras/categories.

Really the only thing you can safely and objectively say about modern vs older steels is that the modern ones have higher background radiation (due to atmospheric nuclear weapons testing during the Cold War).

Also, if you want to see some serious voids have a look at the D2 Ray Iles pigstickers. He actually does a good job with the processing, but there's only so much you can do to refine the grain structure of a conventional steel with 12% Cr.

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#3

Re: Over-generalizing?

Patrick Chase

One more remark: When you're talking about things like surface void formation you also have to consider and acknowledge interactions with sharpening media.

SiO2 can't cut carbides, period, so by using Washitas and JNats you basically guarantee that any alloy with significant-sized carbides will look like a void-ridden PoS under the scope.

There's nothing wrong with that, and I actually agree with many of your comments in other threads about why coarser-grained high-alloy steels requiring hard abrasives are overrated. With that said I think that you still need to appropriately qualify your remarks. Instead of "AI chisels have voids" it should be "AI chisels develop voids when sharpened with SiO2".

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#4

Re: Over-generalizing?

david weaver

These aren't carbide voids. The chisels are O1. I don't think we'd be seeing voids as large as the larger ones I have pictures of from O1 steel, and if we did, the steel would be defective.

In terms of edges with silicon dioxide, all of the other chisels were sharpened with washita and japanese stones (which have about 17% natural alumina, but mostly Si O2).

White 2 has about a tenth or two more of carbide than O1, far lower tolerances for impurities, less chromium and is processed better. Even in the cheapest of irons (fuunji comes to mind, JWW no longer sells them, but they make an iron that's in reality about 60 hardness in white 2) made with white 2, which is probably just cut out of rikizai and not processed any other way (the whole plane was $60 at the time I bought one) - even those are sublime compared to anything put in western tools.

In terms of whether or not a tenth or two makes no difference, to say it doesn't is similar to saying that 1080 and 1095 are almost the same. They're definitely not once you get to higher hardnesses. Except at least both of those are plain steels, whereas nobody is making anything with water hardening steel these days in the world of tools.

In terms of generalizing, I probably have enough chisels and experience with various chisels to be able to make these comments, though I no longer have anything with D2 (that's a good thing - it's a white collar tool steel). I would venture to guess that right now, I probably have a dozen various chisel sets, a whole bunch of loose ones, and have had somewhere between a dozen or two dozen others. My comments are from those (iron comments follow) and my experiences with irons more than they are from these pictures - steel quality wasn't what I was looking for when I took the pictures, rather edge quality, but I got sidetracked).

I've got vintage irons from about 1800 to the mid 1900s and still some modern irons. Over the coming weeks, I will take more pictures of these irons and chisels, and perhaps with various sharpening media to see what we can find out. I doubt anyone has more from a larger cross section on hand, or has spent more money and actually used more different tools (different geographical origins and different eras) than I have.

Anyway, while a washita technically won't cut carbides (though iron carbides it will have an even odds battle with), when it's slurried, it will cut just about everything other than HAP 40. The need to refresh the slurry is undesirable.

I'll see what I see on the scope with the various tools, but it's not carbides being pulled out of O1 that's causing those voids. They're just voids in the steel.

I've sharpened just about everything i have on washitas, and haven't seen those voids on anything japanese and not on razors (razors will fail right at the edge on the strop if the steel isn't up to it). Could the O1 be better if it was made better - I'm sure - but the lack of care is evident.

The chisels are otherwise excellent, though. I didn't post the pictures with much bigger voids, because the last thing I need is for people to start posting threads with "ashley iles chisels are junk!" and using my pictures. Most people read the internet and comment very heavily with theory vs. what they've actually tried, and i'm sure the part where I mentioned that the chisels worked fine, anyway - that part wouldn't make it into other peoples' posts.

I'm pretty pleased with the chisels overall, they're reasonably hard, they have lovely proportions (much like an older chisel) and I can't think of a current western chisel that I'd take over them. plus, they have people hand finishing them, and desiring identical tools with a lack of humanity is, again, a white collar magazine woodworker thing.

There has been an elimination of a lot of English tools relatively recently. Footprint red acetate handled chisels that are stamped sheffield are really lovely, aside from the handle itself. That could be changed. They're thin, light and hard with very nice steel (we'll see what the scope says about voids).

But none of these chisels really hold a candle even to the iyoroi chisels that I have. Not even my older wards, which are really good chisels, but in edge holding, they can't hang even with white #2 iyoroi chisels. When you go up the ladder, the chisels have better edge retention than the iyoroi, topping out with the properly done white #1 chisels, but there are also white #1 tools that are temperamental (won't sharpen without chipping on synthetic abrasives, and can hardly be sharpened on any natural, even a strong cutting suita despite a reasonable amount of aluminum oxide).

one other side comment. There are some dumpy english tools. These are my opinion - sorby chisels are too soft and rubbery feeling on the stones. No clue what they are. Their turning tools are usable but also soft (I recall george also mentioning that he rehardened a bunch of these at the museum). Crown's chisels, also uninspiring. But the Iles and footprint chisels are not in the same category. The footprints have gone overseas, so that leaves just the iles. I started years ago with the LN chisels when they first came out. I wouldn't trade the AI chisels with LN for even money, let alone at somewhere between 1/3rd and 1/2 the cost. I haven't used LV's chisels, but I know they like to look at things under the microscope, so I'd be very surprised if they sourced steel with voids like the steel I showed (picture voids about quadruple that size in some of the other pictures).

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#5

Just to be clear...

david weaver

I'm not talking about the potential of the various steels, I'm talking about what we see in the end result.

If I have a chisel with voids in it, I'm not really interested in what it would look like if it could potentially not have voids. I'm more interested in what we see when examining finished tools.

So, if the japanese steelmakers deliver steel that can be pretty much cut and heat treated and that looks like this as it wears (these are blue, #1 or #2, I'm not sure - I've seen them sold as both, but I doubt tsune makes more than one type):

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/TSUtest.html

Or they can make relatively low priced chisels (iyoroi) that don't get much special attention other than a quick smash by a power hammer and run through some grinding dies, that make a difference at ground level.

If Austrian O1 steel was used, and of the highest quality, for western tools, the issues for O1 would be different, but it doesn't appear that that's the case.

(other references for visuals to compare against the Tsune)

LN A-2- http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/LNA2test.html (there is a gigantic difference in using an iron like this to smooth vs. the tsune - the tsune will still provide a line-free cut all the way until it stops)

LV A-2 http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/LVA2test.html

( I didn't test an A2 blade from LV about a decade ago when I stroke tested IBC vs. LN, at least I don't recall it. I don't remember feeling like an LV A2 iron was lacking, but recall that they weren't cryo treated at one pint)

And for comparison to those:

Berg: http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/EKtest.html

Hock O1: http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/Hocktest.html

Note that the berg is a couple of clicks softer than the hock, and it might be slightly different in alloy if it uses swedish ore.

I always felt the hock iron was too hard to be good. Ron disagrees with that and states that you ruin his iron if you temper to straw. I have since made my own O1 iron out of starrett O1 stock and tempered it too light/medium straw. It holds up better than Ron's. George has since stated the same thing, that the Hock irons are too hard to hold up well for A2.

To quote Hillary, what difference does it make? Well, I tossed my O1 irons when I had only hock O1 and went to the hock A2 (which holds up about as well as LNs) because I had a single plane that I was using both in at the time. There was a marked difference between the two in use. If the hock O1 went a distance of 3, it chipped early and the A2 would go 5. Pick your favorite unit. I was flattening panels with both, so I could go through a whole sharpening cycle on same wood same size. The tsunesaburo and a subsequent shark iron (something from esikilstuna) would last about the same as A2. My O1 iron is close but not quite up to that level, but lasts longer than the hock and doesn't have bad surface quality.

So, noting the difference in all of these rikizai tools and wonderful low-priced kitchen knives that are light and a dream to use and that hold an edge very well, and the expensive hand forged tools and irons? Not much until you start doing bad things. For example, take a $30 violin knife made of rikizai and try to trim an iron ring on a japanese chisel. The result is bad. Take a plain carbon steel knife or chisel made by someone who is known for their forging skills and you can cut iron with carbon steel.

In use with wood, there is probably a noticeable difference between the two, but it's relatively small. In terms of the rikizai tsune iron, I can't imagine a forged iron would do much better. Rikizai's limitation is generally toughness, but the iron shown on beach's page lacks nothing. The one I had also lacked nothing and never failed by chipping. When you sharpen it, it holds almost no wire edge. It's just better.

If western makers would be willing to offer it and follow the same schedule that tsune does, they'd have something wonderful. Tsune's irons are fantastically thin (but still fine with the cap iron, they'll stop you in your tracks). Catalog buyers wouldn't be able to get over the thinness, so something a little thicker would be needed. Deba (thick) are made with rikizai, so I'm sure something suitable could be found.

(the discussion above with rikizai may not be as true when you're trying to squeeze all you can out of a kanna -there may be a critical angle where it falls apart and hand forged stuff does not).

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#6

This may be more interesting..

david weaver

..of the Iles chisel pictures that I have, those voids are in some chisels and not in others. Same stone, different chisel, different picture. It could've been a bad blank or two. I'll see if I can go back to the chisel rack and find the one that looked the worst and take the pictures of the worst parts of it (they're right in the edge, like someone bit them out).

As I mentioned, I never noticed them in use. It's one of those things where if you're cutting sockets in something and you see the tiniest line, you probably never attribute it to anything other than a chip, but those look different (and different on different chisels - I started taking pictures of chisels with different levels of edge failure on them and different hardnesses, but I sort of ran out of steam. Maybe I'll dig them up. I need to organize all of this. I've got, perhaps, 10 different makers of japanese chisels, but only three that I know just what they are - iyoroi, kiyotada and the name of the third escapes me. At some point, *you can have too many*, so I have only kept one set of bench chisels, but for some reason, I find it defensible to have about 10 sets of western chisels, including two separate sets of vintage parers.

Not a one-week project, but if I find more that are outright defective, I'll take pictures of them. Getting pictures of the edges of a 13 inch long chisel is sort of a pain. the bevel edge needs too be just about in plane with the table on the microscope and I don't exactly have an industrial setup to make that happen. It's more like an assortment of books until you find a setup that gives you the right angle at the edge.

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#7

Not surprised

Patrick Chase

I'm not surprised that the voids aren't present in all, and that's what I was driving at earlier.

I also wouldn't discount the possibility that they were left by carbides out of hand. As you say O1 *shouldn't* have that problem, but it seems clear that these chisels are not as they should be, so there's no inherent contradiction. As I said in my initial reply, this screams "processing issue". It's possible the billet had internal voids, though more likely IMO that something happened to screw up the microstructure, leading to coarse grain/carbides.

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#8

Re: Not surprised

david weaver

We'll find out, but I think you'll be convinced by the ones at the edge in other pictures that they're not evacuated carbides. A couple of them are big enough to see with the naked eye if someone tips you off. I'll sharpen them out and see if there are more under.

I generally find that the washita is easier on an edge rather than harsher. Failure is more common coming off of diamonds, but the washita looks fantastically coarse because the grooves are wide.

There were several other pictures on here a couple of weeks ago before I ran out of steam.

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#9

Re: Just to be clear...

Brian Holcombe

I can attest to the Tsunesaburo rikizai, I have one in my LN 7 plane and it just cuts forever. I have taken it out of the plane and have done a double take on how dull it is and still cutting.

When I brought it to kez I did not want to sharpen it at the event, I used it to joint two 10' long 10/4 pieces of yellow cedar, one with a significant bow, and it was still clean enough to use as the zero-pass for anyone who requested it for the competition. Cutting full passes without voids, skipping, etc.

In spite of how cheap those blades are, they're wonderful.

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#10

Re: Just to be clear...

david weaver

All of this discussion makes me want to order another one. I "lost" the one I had in a plane sale iron shortage (as in, when you dump a few planes and you find that you don't have enough good irons to sell the planes you want to sell, so you scavenge whatever you can).

And the O1 iron in my stanley is one I made, and it's a very good iron because the stock was good and it's not overhard (but the tsune is better).

Sounds like Patrick has a couple he doesn't really need!

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#11

Re: Just to be clear...

Philip Duffy

I know plenty of professional blacksmiths and knife makers who would laugh at the argument that steel from Japan is in any way better that the beautiful steels we make in this country. And to top it all off, the Damascus steels that the knife makers are producing is phenomenal. Philip

Re: Old Steel vs. New Steel

#12

Re: Just to be clear...

david weaver

Where are they in the woodworking tools? It's generally on the ground in basic tools in japan.

The world of knives has definitely been ahead of tools in terms of blade steels, but there is a market for oddball stuff there and people will tolerate a $400 knife that doesn't even work that well.

(I remember reading a review on a "richmond addict" knife in some kind of powder metal. One of the reviewers said "it's really hard to sharpen and the knife chips easily, but it's a really great knife!!")

:)

(I also saw someone beat a 3v knife on the top of a metal barrel and the knife edge was, I'm sure, dulled by it, but it didn't have any significant damage, so it's not all bad).