Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Float Question

Posts

Float Question

#1

Float Question

William Duffield

What is an appropriate rake angle for side floats to be used with dense tropical hardwoods?

Re: Float Question

#2

Re: Float Question

steve voigt

William, I sharpen my floats with 10° of positive rake (the opposite of how a saw is usually sharpened). I've used them with beech, maple, rosewood, and cocobolo, and haven't felt the need to alter the rake for denser species. Historically, floats have been sharpened between the 10° I mentioned and 0°.

Re: Float Question

#3

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

William Duffield

Thanks, Steve.

Just to make sure we were speaking the same language, I did a little research, but am still unsure. Generally, it appears that hand saw angles are usually expressed as rake, while circular saw angles are expressed as hook. Some diagrams of circular saw teeth show a positive rake angle to be the same as a positive hook angle, while others show a positive hook angle to be equivalent to a negative rake angle. Hand saw diagrams, OTOH, most often wisely avoid even mentioning hook angle. When I looked for float rake angle, all I found was rakes for harvesting bivalves with floats to keep them from sinking, thus no help at all.

When you describe a negative rake, which of these configurations do you mean?


Re: Float Question

#4

Re: Float Question

david weaver

I sharpen mine at zero, but aim for a little bias toward negative. I haven't found a difference for tropicals vs. beech (as in, the same rake angle seems to work fine for all - frequent sharpening is the key to the float feeling "right"). You have a lot of options with touch and how many teeth you choose to engage.

Aside from that, I've noticed that for cross grain work in a lot of things (indian rosewood, cocobolo, ebony), the harder woods tend to be willing to yield to the straw-stripping action of a float and there isn't as much of a difference as there would be in something like planing the hardest face of a given billet.

End grain work on the beds goes better with a scraper, though.

Re: Float Question

#5

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

Patrick Chase

The definition of rake is as your picture shows: Positive rake is aggressive (tooth "leans into" the cut), negative rake is relaxed.

Western handsaws are typically filed with negative/relaxed rake, so Steve's comment is self-consistent in that respect. He's saying to undercut the teeth :-).

Re: Float Question

#6

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

steve voigt

Hi William,

for some reason I can't see your pic--my mac is cranky--but Patrick explained it very well. Also, larry Williams has a good (free) video on sharpening an edge float.

Re: Float Question

#7

Re: Float Question

Patrick Chase

A more basic question: Are you making your own floats, or just trying to figure out how to sharpen the ones you have?

The reason I ask is because as with sawtooth geometry, this is one of those cases where different people will have different preferences. Your best bet may be to start with something widely regarded as "reasonable" (for example LN's Williams-designed floats or the Philly planes floats) and then iterate as you sharpen.

Full disclosure: I currently use a mix of L-N and Liogier floats, all at stock angle. I've sharpened the L-N's a couple times, but haven't changed the angles (i.e. I've tried to keep the file in the existing gullets and not twist them at all).

Re: Float Question

#8

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I don't know where the positive/negative convention is defined, but I have been understanding it to be that,

Positive rake = relaxed

Negative rake = aggressive or hooked

Well, this isn't the hill I want to die on, so whatever the group decides is fine. However, my post elsewhere on this page about the rake observed on Japanese rip saws is intended to say that they are aggressively raked. Leaning into the work.

Thank you. Over and out.

Wiley

Re: Float Question

#9

Re: Float Question *LINK*

William Duffield

For starters, I'm planning to make 1/8" a side float from O1. It's first use will be to make a spill plane from Dan Schwank's kit.

Wife is a closet pyromaniac. She should get a kick out of it. Temperature is already up to 65° this afternoon, but she still has a fire burning in the parlor.

I have a block of bocote that I'm hoping will be suitable.


Red Rose Reproductions - Making a spill Plane

Re: Float Question

#10

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

steve voigt

Hey Wiley,

I don't want to die on any hills here either! :D But just FYI, the positive/negative thing is pretty standard over a number of domains--lathe tools, circular saws, and straight saws. I first learned the distinction in the machine shop, before I worked any wood. Positive always means more aggressive. Hopefully not passive aggressive. ;)

Re: Float Question

#11

Re: Float Question

steve voigt

Not to discourage you at all, but making a side float with files is somewhat daunting. My usual advice is that edge floats are worth making rather than buying, side and cheek floats are iffy, and bed floats should definitely be bought rather than made (unless you have a mill or metal shaper). After a couple hours the filing really gets old.

The biggest difficulty with side/cheek/face floats is hardening them. There is vastly more surface area on the toothed side, which means the two sides cool at different rates, and that sucker will look like a banana when you pull it out of the quench bucket. Been there, done that. The best solution I've heard of, from Jim Hendricks, is to make two floats and wire or clamp them together, teeth facing in, when you heat treat them. But that's twice as much filing. Alternatively you could clamp the float to a dummy piece. That's how Auriou keeps their rasps straight--it's in one of their videos.

Re: Float Question

#12

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

I now recognize the correctness of what you say. And it's more intuitive that way as well. I had formed a convention around Henry Disston's 'Lumberman Handbook' and later workers like Pete Taran, who spoke of tooth pitch or rake in positive numbers, and by that they meant 'relaxed' or trailing rake. The thought of using aggressive rake doesn't arise in their world, so they just assigned absolute value to rake.

Wiley

Re: Float Question

#13

Re: Hook vs. Rake, Positive vs. Negative

Patrick Chase

That's actually fairly typical when discussing Western handsaws. The rake is assumed to be negative, so people sometimes just use the absolute number.

There are plenty of saw types that can have positive rake, though. For example Japanese handsaws, circular saw blades, etc.

Re: Float Question

#14

Re: Float Question

John Aniano in Central NJ

Steve, et. al.,

Good discussion!

I've made several floats over the years and used old files as the blanks. I heated them to get the tempering color to just past blue, almost gray, and although hard, you can still file them into floats. As long as the tool's edge isn't super long, at 1/8" wide, it's not all that bad to file the teeth by hand. Maybe take 10-15 minutes for, say a 4-5" long cutting edge. Use as big a 3-corner file as you can find. I got some at the local flea market that are ~3/4 wide on a side. Must have been for filing circular saws. Also quite aggressive.

I've never done the hardening treatment; was easy to touch up with a file when not cutting well...

The widest float I've made was 1/2" wide and I use it to define the non 90 degree corner of my violin bow's ivory (now faux ivory) tips. One side cuts, the other is safe. It took over an hour to file these teeth over a 4" long cutting edge. So, yes, consider buying the wider floats unless you have a horizontal milling machine...

John

Re: Float Question

#15

Re: Float Question

William Duffield

Sorry, Steve. I misspoke, due to lack of familiarity with the terminology. I'm making an edge float, not a side float. I'm going to attempt to cut the teeth with a dovetail end mill, if I can figure out how to set up the milling operation. I don't have the machine (e.g., a Bridgeport) that I should mount the end mill on, so I'm working on a kludge. I'll report back if I can make it work.

Re: Float Question

#16

Floats the hard way

Patrick Chase

Wow, that's a hard way (literally) to make floats.

Tempering a file to blue-gray would probably take its hardness to about Rc50 or about 475 Brinell. That's a good/typical hardness at which to *use* a float, and soft enough for sharpening, but not so good for *making* one.

Annealed O1 is about 200 on the Brinell scale, or ~Rc13. If I were going to make my own float then I think I would work from annealed stock and heat-treat it. Better still, I'd pay somebody with a milling machine to do it...

Re: Float Question

#17

Re: Float Question

david weaver

I'd echo Steve's sentiments. I made an edge float (even then, if you don't have a proper setup, you make concessions on heat treating). I heated the first two inches of my edge float).

After filing the first two inches on a bed float, I called my parents and the topic of Christmas gifts came up and I got the side, bed and cheek floats from Lie Nielsen (that may be a decade ago now, they had just come out and you could still find gray market retailers and get a few bucks off). The LN floats are really spectacular tools that work well and file easily, and you can build other specialty tools to supplement them if you need an oddball (skew edge float, etc).

Like everything else LN, I'll bet you could use them for 10 years, and then resell them for a very large % of what you paid.

I'd still make a cheek float if I hadn't gotten a gift, but side and bed floats, no way - perhaps a version with only a short run of teeth and only that part hardened so as to have some stability.

Re: Float Question

#18

Re: Float Question

steve voigt

Hi William,

Yes, an edge float is much easier!

If you can use a mill, that's great, but an edge float is not at all hard to make with a file--it's just a thick saw that's only a few inches long. I made 6 edge floats this summer--4 skewed floats and two "normal" floats--and I would guess it only takes about an hour to file the teeth.

Re: Float Question

#19

Jigs for float-making?

Patrick Chase

Do you use any sort of jig to guide your file when cutting a float, or do you do it all freehand?

Re: Float Question

#20

Re: Jigs for float-making? *LINK*

steve voigt

Patrick, I use a rake guide--a piece of scrap wood jammed on the end of the file, such that the file will be at the correct rake when the guide is held level. Costs nothing and takes 5 minutes to make. I imagine you're familiar with this, but if anyone isn't, they can see a picture at the link below. The jig isn't necessary for sharpening, but for cutting a new float (or saw teeth) it helps.

I've been meaning to write a multi-part blog series on float making, covering basic floats, skewed floats, and specialty or oddball floats. One of these days I'll get it done.


Vintage saw

Re: Float Question

#21

Re: HAck saws - whatever floats your boat

TomD

I found making the edge float easy, but the ones where you file the whole face of the piece of metal are hard to make without rounding. I tried my usual trick of "always be hollowing" but it still came out mostly rounded. I always mean to finish the job by setting up on the mill, but I get by so motivation is lacking.

There are several levels of float need:

- There is the need to make good planes - floats not needed.

- There is the need to make planes as they were intended to be make - a few floats needed

- There is the need to make planes efficiently with clean surfaces all over.- Need a lot of floats.

- The above and make all kinds of planes - all of the floats are needed.

I have found you can get remarkably far with hack saw blades, consider you are on a desert island, and you need to make some great planes to build a boat, and all you have for floats is one very narrow edge float in both push and pull variation, and maybe the means to gang them.