Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Antique handtools

Posts

Antique handtools

#1

Antique handtools

Mark

This may all come down to, do what you want and can live with, but anyways...

I recently picked up a couple of tools that belonged to my Grt. Grandfather , and I am conflicted about how to properly or respectfully restore them.

I don't want to be that guy who gets a hold of a 19th century antique, and thinks restoring it means taking the belt sander to it !

I picked up an old Crosscut handsaw, with a smooth, intact handle that has three rivets ( no bolts) , and no visible makers medallion or stamp.

Also a Stanley Rule and Level co. Direct Brace.

Both are very functional, and I think need some serious rust removal.

The saw needs sharpening, and the handle rivets tightened. The brace is just rusty but the Head, Handle and chuck are working fine.

Is there some conventional wisdom from the hand tool aficionados here as to what is considered a respectful restoration? ( if there is such a thing ?)

Looking for some suggestions and opinions on how best to treat these tools.


Re: Antique handtools

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Antique handtools

Jack Guzman from Maine

For the saw besides tightening the rivets,I would clean the saw plate of any crusty rust. I use a razor blade to scrape off crust and using wd-40 or light oil sand it with 220 grit . Then sharpen it. If the handle is solid,do nothing to it. The brace ,as long as everything moves freely,just oil all moving parts. They are tools,the best thing you can do is put them to use. My personal opinion,no expert. Neither tool looks to be anything rare or collectable so I wouldn't worry about harming value by tampering with their pristine condition. Most of my user tools are antiques that I salvaged from flea markets and such places..---Jack

Re: Antique handtools

#3

Re: Antique handtools

Ron in Sterling, CT

I agree with Jack on using a razor blade scraper to remove the crusty rust. Be careful not to press to hard and scratch the saw plate. I would start with a 320, or maybe even a 440 grit paper, with WD-40. 220 grit will sometimes scratch the saw plate.

On the bit brace I would clean it up with some 0 or 00 steel wool, apply some light oil and put it to use.

My 2 cents. Good Luck

Ron

Re: Antique handtools

#4

Re: One Minor Difference

William Duffield

Todd Hughes always recommended using 600 grit sandpaper and not coarser, on a flat block, and only sanding parallel to the front of the saw (where the teeth are). The reason is to emulate the scratch pattern of the original grinding of the saw and to not obliterate any of the etch that might remain under the rust. Of course, 600 can take a lot longer than starting at 220 grit, and won't make the saw function any better, but the etch can be beautiful or at least interesting.

Re: Antique handtools

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

good point

Jack Guzman from Maine

I would never sand out a good etch. If one is evident I would be more careful in cleaning the plate. The main object is to make the saw slide smoothly through the wood when cutting.