Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Searching WoodCentral

Posts

Searching WoodCentral

#1

Searching WoodCentral

Patrick Chase

Full disclosure: In my day job I work for "a search giant", so I can't provide links.

With that said, and since this has come up twice in 24h, the best way I've found to search WoodCentral is to add a site restrict to your query. So if you wanted to search for stuff Warren Mickley has written about cap irons on WC, you might search for:

"warren in lancaster" "cap iron" site:woodcentral.com

The quotations around "warren in lancaster" and "cap iron" cause those to be treated as single search tokens (all-or-nothing matching) which further improves the results. Both quoting and the site: restrict work on all major engines.

Another forum's search function simply does exactly this - it takes the string you enter, tacks on a site: restrict, and sends it to a search engine.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#2

Re: Searching WoodCentral

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the reminder of the use of "site:"

Don't know why I didn't think of that for searching WC. :\

I use site:stackoverflow.com all the time at work... :D

Thanks!

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#3

Re: Searching WoodCentral

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for writing this about searching, Patrick. I almost wrote the same thing this morning , but decided my post was long enough already.

We used to have a really fine search operation on WoodCentral. If you wanted to see what "RJ" Whelan said about cap irons in December of 2007, you could limit your search to posts containing cap iron, posts written by Whelan , December 1-10, and just the Hand Tool forum. David Barnett and I complained loudly when the site was upgraded.

There are some things that do not show up in a search. For instance David Weaver compared my use of Arkansas stones and 19th century steel to older craftsmen in March, 2011.

I wonder what the hard core bronze users thought when the iron age came along.

Try searching for "hard core bronze users". You more likely would get this post than the older one.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#4

Re: Searching WoodCentral

Patrick Chase

Hmm, that sounds suspiciously like the time I accused you of "honing like it's 1899" on The Other Site (tm). I guess it's a phase we all pass through on the path to knowledge.

I still use higher alloy steels, particularly PM ones, and believe they have their place (haven't achieved full enlightenment I guess), but I've come to appreciate your point.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#5

Re: Searching WoodCentral

Patrick Chase

I could explain why forums like this can be problematic for generic web-search ranking/relevancy algorithms, but then I'd be unemployed. Suffice it to say that I'm not surprised that the results end up having a strong newest-first bias.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#6

Yuck

david weaver

...I've got all kinds of embarrassing posts like that in the past, but they're all part of learning. I couldn't tell what Warren was saying sometimes because it's 1/2 advice and 1/2 you have to go figure it out for yourself (that's sort of what woodworking is, though - it's not a matter of more and more detailed and precise specific steps that apply universally).

Patrick's statement about V11 is probably true. At some point, he's going to let go of the thought that it really does anything better than carbon steel. When you've invested your time into making a decision about it, though, sometimes it's hard to let go.

At any rate, it's quite nice for what it is, but what it does has nothing to do with getting more or better work done except maybe for folks who haven't worked out a very practical sharpening routine. And that should be a temporary problem.

Of course, my practical setup involves just what I was jabbing Warren about - novaculite.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#7

Steels and their places

Patrick Chase

I still think Steels With Carbides (tm) have their place in modern toolmaking and even hand-tool making.

HCS is very homogeneous, and that makes it very chip-resistant when hardened as for Western tools. That in turn enables use of low edge angles as in a straight razor and provides fairly "graceful" failure characteristics in general (provided it doesn't fold).

Adding some harder carbides adds abrasion resistance, though with the caveat that that resistance only really "kicks in" once the surrounding matrix has eroded to the point where the carbides are slightly exposed. How sharp an edge you can hold therefore depends on the grain structure of the steel, and the effect is much worse at lower edge angles. I'm personally not a huge A2 user (nor have I ever been) because I think that its abrasion resistance advantages mostly manifest themselves when/if you allow the blade to dull excessively. When I do use A2 I always hone to at least 35 deg, to minimize that penalty. I think that the newer PM steels largely avoid that trap by having much finer microstructure, though.

I acknowledge your point that abrasion resistance needs to be balanced against ease/quickness of honing (a tool that lasts 2X as long between sharpenings adds no value if it takes >2X longer to sharpen) but I still think that steels like PM-V11 are very workable.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#8

Re: Steels and their places

david weaver

The point that I'm making is that in the context of making things, it doesn't really do anything - it doesn't save any time or increase productivity at all, except for beginners.

Uniformity is important in edges for smoothing. In heavier work, edge retention is essentially a non-issue because we use a grinder (if we hand grind - even if you hand grind, the advantage of carbon steel will become instantly evident) to do most of the bulk work in sharpening and then maintain camber by eye, sharpening with a single stone or maybe two. On top of that, those planes that take heavier shavings go very far into the work cycle because the time that lack of clearance becomes an issue is highly dependent on how thick of a shaving we're taking.

It's uncommon for me to sharpen a jack plane more than once each time I'm in the shop. Try plane, I don't really know, but you can go very far into a wear cycle with a try plane before you have to sharpen it - enough to be physically worn out twice or three times. What'll drive you nuts is anything that breaks the shaving, but we don't get those things with carbon steel. Maybe with A2, but I can't think of any good reason to ever put A2 or anything like V11 in a try plane (they're not available in the right geometry, anyway, at least not if you're going to use a cap iron).

For smoothing, efficient smoothing is done with a heavy smoother shaving and then a thin one. it's a fleeting thing in all but the very finest of smoothing like Brian might do for a custom piece. In that case, edge retention is again not the top issue, but uniformity is extremely important because anything that threatens it threatens the ability to plan a clear surface that won't show anything at all after a quick burnish with shavings. That kind of thing is where carbon steel excels because of the way it wears, and because of the way it's doesn't hang onto a wire edge so the sharpening result is highly reliable.

Abrasion resistance is an issue for beginners, because they take a lot of very thin shavings to try to make up for lack of elegance and economy in their technique, or to play it safe. And then they take a very long time to sharpen. A very hard or highly alloyed iron that's done properly will last longer in a contest of the most feet of one thousandth shavings, but there just isn't much of that in normal work - except for beginners.

Hard and abrasive woods are often brought up as a need, but once you develop some planing economy and use the right types of planes, even those aren't very difficult to work with standard carbon steel (and carbon steel-ish irons). The bigger issue with those woods above and beyond edge retention is that they're just not very nice to work. Scrape and sand is probably the standard method to finish them, but any large volume of planing is not occurring in many pieces before someone gains some experience and searches for wood that works nicely by hand and takes detail without surface problems (Derek notwithstanding because he uses local wood in WA).

I think the alloyed steels are probably better for what they were developed for - diemaking (or manufacturing) and high temperature or metalwork applications. They have a clear economic advantage there, but not in woodworking for experienced woodworkers.

Not trying to say that you can't do work with A2 and V11, there just comes a point where there's no real advantage to it, unless you're going about working in an inefficient manner in the first place. In that case, efficiency is easily gained by improving how you work. The easiest way to gain efficiency is to do some pieces entirely by hand - the physical expenditure involved and the desire to stay connected to the process will do two things:

* it will cause you to quickly figure out what works the best in terms of removing a volume of wood for a given amount of effort - and without undue risk. The things that you figure out also coincide with amount of work done per sharpening cycle.

* it will cause you to want to be able to sharpen relatively quickly when you do sharpen, because it's just not pleasant to work up a sweat, then stop for 8 minutes and then start again, the same way it's not pleasant to run for 15 minutes, stop for 8 and then go back into a high impact run again.

Just my thoughts. Disorganized, maybe (apologies for that - I'm tired).

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#9

Re: Yuck

Patrick Chase

Sorry about the double-reply, but...

Let's ignore me since I'm a rank amateur. Let's consider George Wilson for a moment. He doesn't post here, but is well known to sharpen freehand and presumably very quickly on Spyderco Alumina-Ceramic hones.

Those can unquestionably handle PM-V11 almost as quickly as HCS. It seems to me that for him the wear resistance to sharpening time tradeoff of a higher alloy steel would be favorable as it's all gain (longer interval between sharpenings) and no pain (similar delay per sharpening). Perhaps unsurprisingly he has good things to say about PM-V11 in particular.

Am I missing something here? It seems to me that his chosen combination of medium and alloys is eminently reasonable, for him if not for everybody.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#10

Re: Steels and their places

Patrick Chase

It's interesting that we seem to be circling back to something we touched upon several days ago, namely the idea of what's "good enough" in terms of edge quality and how often you need to re-hone.

As I noted then the idea of going straight from Washita to leather causes "cognitive dissonance" for me, as does the idea of letting my Jack iron go for an entire session. I know intellectually that both should be fine, but I seem to have a belief in uber-sharp edges that is more religious than rational.

I would nitpick one tiny point: I think that the PM steels have grain structure fine enough to delay the onset of detectable tracking. Certainly what you say is true of A2/D2/HSS etc: By the time the edge has "developed" enough for the carbides to help, it's already leaving tracks in fine work. I think that's one of Warren's arguments as well.

Thanks for the interesting discussion.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#11

Re: Steels and their places

david weaver

I have two V11 irons. They are good, sort of like Friodur steel but harder, and I don't remember lines, but I haven't seen the longevity advantage that is claimed (from prior, I think it goes back to the fact that I'm not doing a lot of what it would excel at - taking a ton of thin shavings in a row).

can get through more work with a try plane iron in my try plane than i can in a fore plane sized plane with V11. The plane is better suited to the work, and can take a heavier shaving without additional resistance. I know this is the case because I sized billets with both and I got through a billet with sharp to spare with the try plane, but not with the fore plane and V11 - that's also not counting how much easier it is to work a wooden try plane for 20 minutes vs. a metal fore plane). I don't have one in a smoother, but smoothing is a short part of the work if the try plane work is done right.

I generally resharpen an iron when the I have to influence a plane to stay in a cut, and I just don't have to do that very often. The reason I do that then and not when an iron is completely dull and not before is that's what results in minimal physical effort for me.

I'll get some scope pictures of one of my washita edges, though it won't tell the right story, I'm sure. But the story is that they're probably sharper than you think, but a step off of shapton 1 micron-ish edges. The feel of the edge is more even and less transient through the sharpening cycle and the total time spent in the wood before clearance is gone is about the same.

The difference between me and me 5 years ago is how much wood I remove with each stroke, and the percent of strokes that don't result in continuous wood removal from start to finish (far fewer). That's due partially to experience and quite a lot due to learning to use the cap iron.

If someone magically made a V11 iron that was tapered along its length and width, and had a nice hollow cut out of the back (like vintage wooden plane irons do), would I get more work done? I don't know. I'd probably have to take a break and stand around for a minute or two to catch my breath when I'd normally be sharpening. But I'd sure miss the feel of carbon steel on the washita - nothing modern comes close. The ease of thinning the wire edge and then removing it is something that doesn't occur on anything A2 or more alloyed.

(I had another wondersteel plane that I used to get longer edges out of vs. my regular use, noticeably, and that's the mujingfang M2. It probably lasts about as long as V11. For some reason, the gap has narrowed between that and my carbon steel stuff, too. Working style, I guess).

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#12

Re: Yuck

david weaver

I can't speak to George's reason. I don't know when he went through his great sharpening stone experiment - I sold a lot of his stones for him on ebay (a bunch of american hone company products). In terms of now, George doesn't do a lot of hand work with planes - he states that fairly regularly, he's used the gas in his tank for that kind of work.

I do recall him saying that he liked those stones because they will sharpen all kinds of wondersteels in knives. I know he liked A2 in irons over the 1070 they were using in williamsburg (he could elaborate on why that is, but I think some of it has to do with how well behaved it is in heat treatment).

I also recall him saying he doesn't like oilstones that much, though spydercos are a little more like oilstones (save the harder particles) than anything else around. They're a bit slow, and I recall that he starts with a diamond hone rather than the spyderco medium.

I like a washita better, even for stuff like V11.

In terms of opinions about actually doing work just in regard to woodwork, though (well, or metal work, or planemaking, etc) my opinion doesn't amount to much if George has any opinion at all.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#13

Re: Steels and their places

Patrick Chase

Sorry about the partial replies to your very well-thought-out posts, but I'm somewhat pressed for time:

w.r.t. "edge standards" I usually hone to 0.75 um on waterstones (the infamous Sigma 13K) or 0.5 um on diamond.

I've come to suspect that for most practical woodworking uses "good enough" is probably up around 2-3 um, provided the scratch pattern is uniform, but ingrained obsessions die hard.

The scratch patterns in your pictures look to me to be solidly in that "good enough but not excessive" range BTW (taking your estimated scale as fact).

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#14

Re: Steels and their places

david weaver

You mean the scratch patterns on the razors? They are an entirely different thing than tools because you can't hone with pressure. The bevel angle is about 16 degrees. Plus, the bevel has been sharpened with natural stones, so there is no scratch uniformity like you'd see with synthetic pastes of powders. The concentration on a razor is edge only, the bevel is relatively meaningless unless what's on it transfers to the edge (which will happen with deep damaging scratches, but not really shallow ones.

As far as the shave from that edge went, it was at the upper end of comfortable and would benefit from a trip across a linen (which will wear it and round it a little bit). Nobody is woodworking with an edge as sharp as that one.

The other thing about the scratches is that they are coticule particle scratches, which are about the shallowest grooves you can find. A 7 micron coticule scratch is probably not as deep as a 1 micron shapton particle, and the edge is smoother with them. In terms of the sigma (I have used it on a razor), it is not capable of an edge as good as this one when it comes to a razor. For a more blunt edge, like 28 degrees or something on a chisel, the same edge wouldn't be achieved because we wouldn't take the time. More pressure with the coticule would result in deeper scratches from the ball shaped abrasive particles. This is what I mean when I talk about the natural stones having a much wider range or some dimension.

I've got some chisel pictures coming.

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#15

Re: Yuck

david weaver

By the way, I consider myself rank amateur, too.

Yesterday, i was tired. Thus the wordy posts with no compass - it happens.

I would implement the washita challenge as something for some folks to do. It would go like this (you have to sharpen freehand to do it, but if you don't, this is a good time to go to that, too - you can see from my finished edges below that there's no deep scratches left at the edge, and the touch you get freehand outweighs any geometric perfection of guided sharpening easily).

Anyway, something like this (this is how I came to appreciate it, and the same thing with the cap iron).

Two weeks of heavy work in the shop (heavy as in choose a time when you'll be doing a lot).

Washita stone, bare leather (and if you're using V11, a fine india is OK as a starter - it's better than a diamond hone once it breaks in because it isn't so brash - not the same story when it's new, though - very brash).

Two weeks of work, nothing but the washita to finish - no pastes, polishes, etc.

By the end of the two week period, you'll be surprised how well you can get it to work, especially if you use a cap iron. The only time I've ever wished for a little more is paring one end on a plane (one end always pares better than the other due to grain direction), but even then, you can get by fine.

The same is a good way for people who use all kinds of stuff to get comfortable with the cap iron. Common pitch planes only, finish by planing and no sanding or scraping for a two week period. It's a lot easier to get that stuff mastered when you give yourself no other options.

(another btw...none of this is to slight Lee Valley - they're my favorite of the new tool makers and retailers. I guarantee they are doing what the market wants - the fanatics on the forum are a very small segment of the market)

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#16

Thanks, Patrick!


Re: Searching WoodCentral

#17

Re: Searching WoodCentral & "-"

CJ in MPLS

Patrick:

Do any of these wondrous search engines still support the exclude character "-" or the require character "+"?

CJ

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#18

Problem I have

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Patrick,

Very helpful post!

No matter how I try to search Woodcentral, I get the following:

Software error:

Byte order is not compatible at /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/perl/5.20/Storable.pm line 424, at sub RL::Basic::deserialize_bin line 10.

For help, please send mail to the webmaster (webmaster@woodcentral.com), giving this error message and the time and date of the error.

I've searched woodcentral for years, and never had an issue. However, this must be something to do with me, since no one else is reporting the problem.

I'm using a first generation iPad Pro with up to date iOS, and Safari. My profile is filed and in order I believe.

Wiley

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#19

Re: Problem I have

Patrick Chase

I see the same thing. That's why I posted instructions showing how to use public Web search engines instead of the site's built-in search. WC is crawlable, so all of the content is indexed by the major engines.

Although that error is nominally about byte order (whether the most significant byte comes first or last) some digging reveals that it most likely means that the search path is trying to read from a BerkeleyDB table in an obsolete format (one that uses 32-bit integers in the header instead of 64-bit). I think that WC may rely on some fairly "vintage" tools, which is unfortunately not as good for software as it is for neander woodworking (sorry, couldn't resist).

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#20

"vintage"

John in NM

We still have two VME crates at work! :D Those things were old (and surplus) when they were put in 20 years ago!

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#21

Oh, now I get it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Patrick, your advice intended us to go to google or bing or whatever to enter your search string. I was inserting the string into the w/c search box--duh. I'm gonna claim vintage too :) .

Wiley

Re: Searching WoodCentral

#22

Re: Oh, now I get it

Patrick Chase

Yes. I was somewhat obtuse about that part because I didn't want to specifically recommend either my employer search servive (potential terms-of-service violation) or one of the others.

Sorry about that!