Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Roubo Hollows & Rounds

Posts

Roubo Hollows & Rounds

#1

Roubo Hollows & Rounds

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

In the (I think it is the) April 2016 issue of Popular Woodworking, Caleb James has an article on making Roubo Hollows and Rounds.

I would like to have a pair of #'s 4 & 6 and try making some moldings.

I thought I would give this a shot this winter - yes it would probably take me all winter to make just one...

It looks like just about any wood would work, but of course beech is recommended.

Since the search function is not working, would anybody like to suggest an on-line source from which I could order some beech from?

It doesn't have to be perfect-for-plane-making beech, just functional. I just want a couple planes that are functional and don't have to be perfect works of art. My biggest challenge will likely be the irons anyway... :b

I tried to use the search function as I recall many beech billet conversations here over the recent years.

Thanks for any suggestions.

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

#2

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

david weaver

It should be quartered and pith centered when sawn (as in, you can follow a line along its length without having any grain runout in any direction).

The reason for that is if it's not centered, even if it's quartered, the plane will twist.

It would be better to have rift sawn beech that's pith centered along its length than quartered that's not. I wouldn't go so far as to recommend flat sawn, even though it might be OK, it'll be horribly ugly.

Cherry, Beech and hard maple are all fine - the former better than the last, and beech the best (cherry makes a light plane that dents pretty easily). The trick is finding them rift or quartered.

The only sure source I know of is horizon (their current stock is european):

http://inventory.horizonwood.com/product/beech-misc-lumber-391630

It can take a while to get stuff from them sometimes, and it's not cheap, but compared to the people selling sawn billets online, it's not that expensive. They ship small quantities UPS, and two sticks would probably be about $135 shipped and would be enough wood to make a lot of pairs of planes depending on the thickness.

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

#3

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

TomD

Getting beech is oddly difficult given the amount of the stuff there is around. I ended up cutting my own. That said, I have been making hand planes since the late 70s, and most of them have been made of either white oak, or maple. For the most part maple. I can think of a single one that has given me trouble. Normally using regular shop tools (mainly a bandsaw, but I didn't have one of those to start with), I set aside 45 minutes to make a functioning plane that will do good work in any format. This isn't some speed exercise of a master, it's a tiny piece of wood into which you are sawing a slot. I am not that proficient and hand mortising, though I have been at it for 35 years that I would get a mortised plane done that fast, but in a class of pretty much newbies to plane making, everyone will turn out a plane in a morning.

The Roubo era plane could probably be made pretty quickly. I never timed any of the side slot planes I made. But they are fast. I tossed off this Osage rebate to get into the dovetail plane I made the bit out of a 1/2" lathe cutter, hard to grind, but hardly ever needs sharpening. There is a maple japanese style plane, I made in the 80s under it, not a good combo, but I still use it regularly as I switched it into a thicknessing plane for 1/4" strips. I could probably make that Osage plane faster than I can unearth all the parts of a router set-up to do the same thing. If I had to choose between making a plane and installing a lockset with hand tools, I would choose the plane on speed.

So there are two approaches to all this. One is to make the plane, make the molding, and move on. The other is to have the experience of making the plane using the tools and techniques and wood of the period. Step one for the latter: build a Roubo bench... Step two is build a forge and make your own hold-downs. I've done all that stuff, but there are endless rat holes one can get caught up in if all you need are some tools.

In the alternative, maple works great Square up a block, make a few saw cuts, break out the waste with a chisel or router plane, whittle a wedge, make some shavings. For a somewhat more durable plane you can glue a wedge across the opened slot. If you do that you can reduce the thickness of the beam of the Roubo plane as the loads will be carried more efficiently.

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

#4

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds *LINK*

Larry Barrett

Try Dan Schwank at Red Rose Reproductions. His web site says he will have beech billets in early Oct.


http://redrosereproductions.com/

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

#5

Re: Roubo Hollows & Rounds

Dan Schwank

I now have a few molding plane billets available in 3/4", 1", and 1 1/4" thicknesses. These are available at: http://redrosereproductions.com/beech-billets-for-plane-making/