Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First Pictures off the Scope

Posts

First Pictures off the Scope

#1

First Pictures off the Scope

david weaver

Posted separately because these would get lost in the other thread.

This is a razor made by fukataro tanifuji, these are the finest razors that I've ever used, and he was probably the finest razor finisher to ever live. These razors are hard and not brittle, at least the good ones, and take a better edge (when the combination of smoothness and sharpness is considered).

The first four pictures are the four magnifications of the scope I bought. i didn't write down exactly what they are, but the last is 600x. The first is about 100x, I'd guess. It's almost a match for my prior scope.

The width of the bevel shown is probably about a mm.

https://s26.postimg.org/dfg4zhuy1/image.jpg

https://s26.postimg.org/kjxy8j27d/image.jpg

https://s26.postimg.org/u1xp8knvt/image.jpg

https://s26.postimg.org/69odx1lux/image.jpg

https://s26.postimg.org/c331bcmw9/image.jpg

The last picture is after stropping.

The sharpening was done on a coticule that I have (the finest I've ever seen of that type, they're often not that great) and the stropping done on an old NOS japanese strop made of french shell (that's cordovan for folks who don't look at much leather). Nothing special about the stone and strop other than that they work really well. I found 6 of the strops for $240 and quickly sold 5 of them for a lot more than that. The coticule was just a forlorn looking relatively modern stone (bonded to slate, older coticules were generally bonded to belgian blue architectural stone, or cut at the seam where the two meet in the ground), and wasn't expensive.

the razor wasn't, either. Generally tanifuji's razors are about $100-$150 used, this one someone dinged the end on and it cost me about $40. I reground the tip and cleaned it up. It's not bound to be gillette's favorite thing - this razor could shave someone for five lifetimes.

Not that anyone should care about those details (tanifuji is long dead, anyway, so it's not like you can call him and ask for a new one or tell him that he did a good job, but his razors are around - he was a prolific finisher).

I also took some pictures of mild steel plate that I ran a deburring wheel over. From low to high magnification. These are 2s Fine wheel finished, they look slightly matte to the naked eye, but the deburring wheel doesn't leave any prominent lines. It looks more like the surface of the ocean from 5000 feet.

https://s26.postimg.org/ty8h627s9/image.png

https://s26.postimg.org/zdh770zc9/image.png

https://s26.postimg.org/fgb9y2gh5/image.png

https://s26.postimg.org/y9x2v2ep5/image.png

(I really have no clue what the lateral lines are in the first four razor pictures, and no idea if the surface of the mild steel was dug up before I deburred the oxide off of it, or if the deburring wheel did that).

A good start. This scope was inexpensive as far as scopes go, but I still cursed the price (just under $450), but the camera is cast aluminum, it's got a halogen light to illuminate things and a freestanding solid state light intensity controller. the camera could knock an intruder out if you took it off and threw it at them, and the coarse and fine control for height is quite nice, and the table's lateral movement is smooth.

600x is so sensitive that if I click the touchpad on the computer to take the photo, the focus is lost for a split second.

Even the software is reasonably good with it, far better than the stuff that came with the $11 hand held scope (that thing is a steal for $11, though).

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#2

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

Patrick Chase

The power sequence amply demonstrates the distinction between magnification and resolution. It appears to me that the camera is capturing all of the detail that the optics can resolve by the second magnification setting (200x?). The two higher settings appear to mostly magnify blur, even in the plane of best focus.

I think this scope will do nicely for your previously stated purposes. It's not a SEM, but as you say you don't really need one for what you're trying to do.

Nice sharpening porn, BTW :-).

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#3

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

David weaver

It's not so much the scope that's a problem at high magnification, but the software is trying to adjust light and focus in real time. I'm going to have to play with it to turn those functional off, especially since I can control light very well with the machine itself.

I did browse used sems, knowing nothing about them. Looked like a potential maintenance hassle, and some were the size of a sofa. This one will do quite well for what I want to do with it.

The sem does a spectacular job with 3d surfaces on stones. They are an optical challenge.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#4

Thanks for work and a dumb question.

Chuck Nickerson

Is '2s fine' a deburring wheel specification?

I have not yet dipped my toe into the deburring wheel world.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#5

Re: Thanks for work and a dumb question.

david weaver

Yes - 2 is the hardness (soft, I don't know the range of grades, though) and fin "i think" suggests it's for finish work.

Pretty much a more rigid version of the gray scotchbrite pads you can find. Much faster to use when it's spinning on a buffer, but it can round over detail quickly (even the finish type) if you're not careful.

For the dope like me who just needs something to pair with a buffing wheel, it is about right.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#6

Chisels

david weaver

Holding the chisels for pictures is a challenge. three free-handed chisels with a diversion on one (so more than three pictures).

These are all ashley iles O1 chisels.

First is my trusty washita, followed about somewhere around 5-10 seconds of light stropping on bovine leather that's oiled. This leather is nothing special, it's been on the same strop for years. When it gets dirty or contaminated, i card scrape the surface until I see nothing sparkling.

The washita leaves a lot of uniform scratches (i sharpen on a diagonal) and releases the wire edge very easily. What's left at the actual edge (which is what matters) is a very uniform crisp edge. The scratches look significant, but they are not that deep, which is evidenced by the next comment.

The very tip of the edge reflects light, which is how you can tell it's been stropped, but the reflection is very thin and generally unbroken:

https://s26.postimg.org/88jwks5ih/washita_-_AI_Chisel.jpg

Off of a freshly ground edge, this is a 30 second process total, maybe less. that includes honing a small single bevel, working the back briskly for a few seconds, then thinning the bevel by a couple of alternating strokes with light pressure and the 5-10 seconds of stropping. No stone maintenance except the addition of Wd40 - a few drops.

The second is an edge with a 1200 grit diamond hone. After brisk stropping, it didn't want to release the wire edge on leather. This is a pain, and it makes the edge feel more dull than it is. you can see the foil with the naked eye. Doesn't shave arm hair.

https://s26.postimg.org/46y81dnu1/1200_eze_lap_-_leather_strop.jpg

After a brisk session of harsh stropping on my pant leg (not preferable for many reasons), the foil is gone. Marginal hair shaving:

https://s26.postimg.org/go9h2a8dl/Eze_Lap_-_1200_-_pants_strop.jpg

And then the royal treatment, a true barber linen and then a couple of strokes back on the bovine leather:

https://s26.postimg.org/84lhqsand/1200_Eze_Lap.jpg

It now shaves easily, but the edge is not as crisp as the washita. This edge will fail less consistently than the washita because it is not uniformly crisp or uniformly thick. It is a workable edge, but there are several complications:

1) the foil leaves a ragged edge when torn off

2) if you used something that worked well with it, like a linen, it would contaminate the linen ("it" being the bits of foil). This would have no effect on normal work, pared surfaces and smoothed surfaces would easily show the effect of the damage from the little pieces of foil in the linen. They leave deep scratches.

3) it's just not really that sharp. I'm sure it would take a thousandth plane shaving on a plane blade, but it wouldn't go as low as a finished edge. That said, any beginner who says they're not able to shave arm hair is well short of this.

And finally, honing on the shapton (japanese market) cream (1.2 microns). A good stone, but once it's dry, it loads a little, and the next time you hone on it, the edge isn't that great. It needs to be slurried and that chances contamination, which may be the reason the scratches aren't perfectly uniform. Looks better than the washita and is marginally sharper. It will fail less uniformly than the washita, though. i don't know why this is. Both shave hair equally well, better than the diamond edge.

I stropped the shapton edge lightly to be fair in comparison to the washita, and this edge was first honed below this final bevel with the 1200 eze lap. Takes about twice as long as the washita, maybe slightly less, but that doesn't count screwing around with the stone. I've only honed two tools on this stone. It's remarkable how much it wore just doing that. The washita can easily be kept flat just with regular use.

https://s26.postimg.org/iu3rwsbu1/shapton.jpg

The background for these edges is a sheet of paper attached with a magnet, but it is not at the same angle, so it shows up dark. The stropping was less on the shapton, but I wanted to make sure no particles were dangling. If I'd have stropped it a little more, I'd probably get the white line.

It looks like a polish to the naked eye, but so does the washita. The diamond edge looks matte.

Some natural stone edges next time. following the washita with a black or translucent arkansas stone will match the shapton in skilled hands, but the edge is less transient and the maintenance far less. I never slurry arkansas stones (at least not for tools), which is why that statement holds true. If you do slurry an arkansas stone, it can cut quite aggressively and still leave a pretty good edge, but not one like I'll show this weekend.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#7

Re: Chisels - shorter summary of pictures

david weaver

Summary post for those who felt the verbiage was too long in the prior (i tend to get obsessed with details, and wrote the previous post right after taking all of the pictures and being short on sleep at the same time).

Washita edge - stropped with bare leather:

https://s26.postimg.org/88jwks5ih/washita_-_AI_Chisel.jpg

Diamond hone (ezelap 1200) after leather stropping:

https://s26.postimg.org/46y81dnu1/1200_eze_lap_-_leather_strop.jpg

Same hone after royal treatment with barbering linens (not practical):

https://s26.postimg.org/84lhqsand/1200_Eze_Lap.jpg

Shapton 12k Kuromaku (japanese "shapton pro" version). Technically, scratches could be more uniform, but few carry all the way to the edge. Consequence of the amount of screwing around that has to be done to make this stone cut perfectly with no particle aggregation or contaminants:

https://postimg.org/image/e87nofqat/

Not really sure what the magnification levels are, as the scope that I received isn't the one I ordered - it's got more lenses on the turret than what i actually ordered. Probably 200x or so, and true 200x. No stone is going to produce invisible scratches unless they are below a half micron or so. I'll test this another day with graded shaving powders.

any requests for the edge from a specific type of stone? Indias, carborundum, coticules, japanese naturals, trans arks, black arks, honing films (boring)? oxides of various types (i've got them down to less than a tenth of a micron - also boring and a waste of time)?

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#8

Re: Chisels - shorter summary of pictures

Patrick Chase

I'm curious to see a good JNat polisher and maybe a well-broken-in translucent or black Ark (*not* a la Larry :-)

I have the Shapton 12k, so I'll give that a go on my camera system to get a sense of relative scale.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#9

Re: Chisels - shorter summary of pictures

david weaver

that'll be interesting to see. I'll go to the trouble of cleaning my diamond hone thoroughly, lapping the surface of the stone thoroughly and raising a slurry on it that's wet and see if I can get something that looks a little better.

This is representative of what I've done in the past though when I actually used the shapton. It's capable of a little more, but there is a time cost to it.

Finding a settled in arkansas stone won't be hard. Lapping one is something i can't bring myself to do.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#10

Re: more stones - pictures

david weaver

trans ark

https://s26.postimg.org/eajcxm221/trans.jpg

Slurry gray chinese stone:

https://s26.postimg.org/apnhedxih/slurryphig.jpg

Slurry fine Okudo suita:

https://s26.postimg.org/q9uv4x7mx/slurry_okudo.jpg

Mystery stone - you have to guess what it is:

https://s26.postimg.org/c256g9uy1/mystery.jpg

The chinese and okudo stones could cut more finely if they weren't slurried, but they'd be a lot slower at the same time. Their scratches would look more like the arkansas stone scratches.

Important to focus on the edge (what you can see of it) and how straight and uninterrupted it is. These scratches will not prevent a polished surface, so the edge is what counts.

You can see on the okudo picture that the steel itself has pits in it. Some of these show up in the edge, also. These are AI chisels - I like them quite a lot. I don't notice anything from them in normal use. It'll be interesting to see if we see anything like that in japanese chisels......oops, scratch that. One of the pits is right on the edge at the right side of the picture.

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#11

Kamisori

david weaver

Someone bought a kamisori from me, and these are really hard and with a relatively low angle (probably 64 hardness with an angle less than 20 degrees).

https://postimg.org/image/5hjjzpee3/

the only way I can get them sharp with certainty is to go through the sharpening routine for razors (an extra fine india followed by two japanese stones) and then follow that with a balsa strop and graded 0.5 micron chromium oxide.

This will be uncomfortably sharp for the purchaser, but that's sort of the idea.

Notice the little bit of rounding at the edge. Even chromium oxide will pull a little bit of a wire edge (and this stuff is much slower than the sticks that LV sells that are 70% or so aluminum oxide).

This sharpening routine takes about 15 minutes (from someone who takes probably 1 minute with a chisel), so it's not practical for tools.

You can get fascinated with the bevel on something like this because the chrome ox can make extremely small grooves, but the edge itself is just a little better and less ragged than it would be with a stone. There is still a little bit of finesse in this method. The scratches generally terminate before the edge, but you can see one that got there (and still see the edge behind it, so it didn't result in a nick, which is what happens with razors if grooves meet the edge). Nobody would ever notice on this razor if it got to the edge, though - it's still the kind of scratch you'd get off of a stone like an 8k king.

Bottom line, just a little better than a natural stone edge usually is, but can look a lot better.

Stropped on shell cordovan, no linen (that would widen the edge a little bit, which would be comfortable, but I'll let the buyer decide that).

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#12

Re: circular

david weaver

by the way, the larger scratches are sort of all over the place in terms of direction, because each step on a razor like this involves honing with light circular strokes. It inhibits the formation of a wire edge to some extent.

The final work with the chrome ox doesn't involve it only because it would cut the balsa hone. I do move the razor in an S pattern on the hone even though the strokes are all edge trailing.

there is the slightest tooth to the edge on this still, but some of that may just be because of how fragile the edge is at the sub 20 degree level (maybe it's 20 on these, I don't know, but it's nowhere close to an angle that we'd use in woodworking).

Re: First Pictures off the Scope

#13

Why Balsa?

Patrick Chase

Why are you using Balsa with the CrO paste?

Are you just aiming for something stiffer than leather but with more "give" than a hard (iron or plastic) lap, or is there something specific about balsa that causes you to choose it?

I've had good luck with relatively hard polyurethanes for that sort of thing FWIW. Not exactly traditional, I know.