Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Router plane for tenons, nothing new

Posts

Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#1

Router plane for tenons, nothing new

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was reading the Popular Mechanics' "Shopnotes" from 1920, and a little article describes rough-cutting tenons (to within about 1/16", they recommend), then gang-clamping identical pieces of stock (for instance, the stretchers and/or aprons for a table) to the bench end-to-end, with the tenons butting. The illustration shows four pieces of stock - two side by side, with the two pairs butting at the tenons. Then, says the article, you can use a router plane to smooth all four tenons to final dimension.

Nice plan: no need to find a block of wood to support the outboard side of the router plane, and you can work all the matching pieces at once.

I haven't followed the various conversations about using a router plane on tenons, so this may already have been suggested here or elsewhere; but, if so, it's following on a nearly century-old idea.

-----

Digressing: several pages later, there's an article with an excited discussion of a portable machinist's toolbox. The illustration shows a mechanic's rollaway and top box, although the rollaway is enough wider than the top box to accommodate a metalworking vise on one end. Brilliant idea, a portable toolbox like that...I wonder if I could find somebody that makes such a thing?

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#2

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

Gary B.

Good Idea.

I watched a video earlier where Paul Sellers sawed a tenon, but the then left 1/2" at the end of the tenon full thickness to ride the router on. It was a large tenon, so this eliminated the need for the second board. However, that technique would eliminate the option of sneaking up on a fit.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#3

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, just a note that I have never felt the need for an outrigger on my router plane. Off the top of my head I cannot imagine tenon cheeks being longer than 1 1/2" for furniture. I can balance the half of the router plane on the stretcher. A little downforce is needed ...


If I were to gang cut cheeks, I would use a rabbet-type plane, not a shoulder plane. For example, rabbet block plane or wide shoulder plane. Plane to the lines. However, I have never done this, preferring to tune each individually (... just how many tenons does one make at any one time for the average piece of furniture), using either a router plane or a wide chisel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#4

20th century

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The idea that skill development ought to be replaced with gimmicks and gadgets is an old 20th century idea. It would be a lot more surprising to see such an attitude in the hand tool era.

Writing in 1812, Peter Nicholson suggested that one could adjust a tenon with a chisel or a rabbet plane if he had sawed carelessly, but that generally the tenon was made straight from the saw. Nicholson apprenticed as a cabinetmaker around 1779. I think learning to saw to the line is a valuable skill that is useful for a lot more than just making tenons;

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#5

Re: 20th century

Brian Holcombe

My first thought is that purposefully oversizing then trimming to fit should be avoided for normal work. It's an exceptionally slow process and so I tend to avoid it for anything other than exposed through tenons that require a planed finish for reasons of appearance.

Sneaking up to a fit with a router plane requires use of two reference faces which is a poor practice.

Learning to use single reference faces and square corners is an important part of doing consistently accurate work quickly.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#6

Re: 20th century

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The value of the router plane lies when the sawing goes askew. I aim for an off-the-saw fit, but stuff happens. The router plane is a good method for using the reference face of the stretcher to return the cheek to parallel.

As far as deliberately sawing thicker, it is not a method I would choose, but it is used by a number of well-regarded woodworkers. Some cut their dovetails like this as well. Again not my preference, but it gets the job done. It's all good.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#7

Re: 20th century

Brian Holcombe

I avoid using a router plane because I find them so impractical for me. I really only use them for blind dados and even then I try to avoid planning blind dados.

There are situations, such as a keyed through tenon (tusk tenon is the common referral) where I wanted a finished surface on the tenon face, I also want a clean result at the mortise and so I'm left with one option which is to use my chisel to work to the finish.

How would I do that with a router plane? 3"-5" long tenons are longer than the router plane's reach or at the far end of it and so unreliable at the extremes.

This is why I think foundational methods should be stressed, it is our job to determine the best and/or fastest method for each aspect of the work but we can only do so if we are confident in our ability to do so.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#8

Re: 20th century

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Brian, there are so many ways to skin a cat. Like you, I will reach first for a chisel when tuning a tenon, however I do not want to ignore all the other methods. At times they are the simpler, quicker, more appropriate method.

In addition to a router plane and a chisel, one could use a ...

wide shoulder plane

rabbet block plane

skew rabbet plane

float

rasp

file

Others? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#9

Re: 20th century

david weaver

I think this kind of thing, cutting and then trimming back, works well when your income source isn't really what you're making.

It's definitely safe, but it's also completely unrewarding. Doubly unrewarding is overcutting a joint, spending all the time trimming it to size and then finding that one of your references is wrong.

I don't make tenons and dovetails as often as some people, unless you count joints in planes, but anything that stops the flow in the shop really sucks. I'd rather make something with a mistake or two (and repair it) than constantly stop and ponder.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#10

Re: 20th century

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

There are all types of people doing woodworking. Some are professionals for whom time is money. Very few of them would take the time to make joints with hand tools if time is important. The rest are amateurs, and for many I imagine that the priority is to get the joint to come out correctly.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#11

Re: "Notable Woodworkers"

david weaver

I think the bar for "notable woodworkers" has dropped a lot, and that's a shame.

I get that a lot of people want to cut their skills short and still make certain things, but it becomes limiting at some point.

(not talking about the guy who goes into his garage and has one set of home depot chisels and uses them rarely but likes to make stuff out of plywood, etc, that person isn't ever going to cross our paths, anyway - they'll be watching John Heisz videos or stumpy nubs or whatever).

I am not notable at all, I'll admit - I aspire to finish my working life with enough left in the tank to do some notable work later (my spouse is not wired for me doing that while I'm still working), but when I have arguments with "notable woodworkers" like one we had on the UK forum a couple of months ago, where it was asserted that you can't plane an edge or surface without making it convex, and the "notable woodworkers" assert that is the case...well, I'm just baffled. At the same time, it was asserted that squaring and flattening an edge can't be done at the same time, and the context involved a table saw (and not removing the squareness that you started with). I had to make a video (twice) of taking a layer of thickness off of a board edge without affecting its flatness to make my point - it's kind of ridiculous. We are apparently devoid of what Warren describes as "craftsman's subtlety".

I have no idea why we even read about most of the modern "notable woodworkers" if we're doing hand work in the first place. The procedures that some described to true an edge or face, to sharpen, etc, all of that make the work so cumbersome that I wouldn't have the patience to do it. Much of it was written about in the past with better context than the present, but even more promising is just to go to the shop and do something without making it a 14 step process that must be followed (with the need for additional tools). Lay something out, mark it, and be willing to invest in getting better at it so that you can do it fluidly. The tastefulness of the work will show both in large and small details down the road. Fussy work either looks robotic, or there is evidence of slow things (fussy small strokes with tools, etc,) left behind.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#12

Re: 20th century

Brian Holcombe

Derek,

With respect, I don't believe that to be accurate at all.

There is a sliding scale to this type of work, not either/or. Many find themselves building accurate work, well made, quickly.

We're driving well of course in any case, I don't mind the methods presented I just don't find them to be quick enough.

This joint was cut off the saw and assembled without fixing, I chopped the baseline and may have cleaned up some of the baseline with light paring (I don't actually remember).


Cheers

Brian

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#13

Re: 20th century

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Brian, we are not talking about dovetails, however there are many who use jigs for these and do so happily. As you know, I do not - my handskills are fast enough for me. Most joints can be made quickly by hand, and that is my preferred way. Still, I will not turn this into a criticism of those who use machines. I am more interested in what they build. I read on Sawmill Creek that you were purchasing a Felder morticing machine. I assume that you discovered the limitations of handwork in a production run? I don't have an issue with power tools. There is a place for all tools and many different methods in creating an efficient shop.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#14

Re: 20th century

david weaver

It's not a criticism of people who use machines, it's a criticism of people who use a ramp to bowl and want to write a book about rolling a hook.

Or convince people who can roll a hook that a ramp is just as good.

The folks who want to do their joints with a machine are in a separate group, that's not what we're addressing. It's more the folks who have a ten step process for cutting a tenon rather than just cutting at the line and cleaning up only when necessary.

(the person who got me into woodworking gets strange pleasure out of setting up machines and then finding out that he has a tenon exactly 2 thousandths less than the mortise he's just machine cut...for "glue expansion". I have no idea if those numbers are right, but that's the kind of thing he talks about. I told him I hope to never expose a tenon (personal choice) or have any clue how many thousandths shy my tenons are of the mortise, because they're too rough to tell and I'd rather go with what feels right until I actually have one come loose - and even then, I'll probably revise that to one that comes loose and can't be easily fixed. My friend thinks that's preposterous).

Same with dovetail joints.

When someone is new, certainly you do what you need to do (I think learning to repair issues is probably more valuable than learning to be really really careful all the time, but to each their own). Having that as a standard to aspire to is a good way to not get much done.

The arguments are always relative. The guy with a kreg jig and shop cabinets and a guided circular saw can certainly tell us that we don't build many pieces very quickly. Things that keep a lot of people from making much in the shop, though, are those things such as the idea that a drawer will take 7 hours to make, or that it will take 9 minutes to sharpen.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#15

Digressing: I like that design!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Nice touch, having the space between the tails extend out beyond the pin board; and nicely finished, with the little chamfers.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#16

Re: 20th century

John Schtroumpf

I don't' know about others.

But for me this is a hobby, I make what I feel like making, when I feel like making it. Hand tools are just a means to an end (what I am making), and can be fun to use (I like sharp objects). If doing extra steps, or using some jig enables me to make what I want, I will do it. As for practicing, forget about it, I would rather make something (better use of my hobby time). I will say, the more I make, the better my skills get, so my reliance on crutches is slowly decreasing.

Of course hearing/seeing/learning about how to do things in a better way, is always useful. So people who do know what they are doing should definitely speak their minds.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#17

Re: Digressing: I like that design!

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Bill! :D

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#18

Re: 20th century

steve voigt

the person who got me into woodworking gets strange pleasure out of setting up machines and then finding out that he has a tenon exactly 2 thousandths less than the mortise he's just machine cut...for "glue expansion". I have no idea if those numbers are right, but that's the kind of thing he talks about. I told him I hope to never expose a tenon (personal choice) or have any clue how many thousandths shy my tenons are of the mortise, because they're too rough to tell and I'd rather go with what feels right until I actually have one come loose

I generally lose interest in threads like this that bang away on the same old arguments that we've all heard a hundred times (and that inevitably make the OP feel beaten up), but Dave's comment above is useful and actually makes a productive point.

One of the problems with "machine thinking" is that it creates unrealistic expectations of handwork. If a novice expects his hand-sawn tenons to look like they just came off a Multi-Router or other dedicated machine, with the same .002 tolerances, he is going to get frustrated and discouraged, and then fall back on a router plane or some other jigged, relatively slow approach. But if you take apart pieces of period furniture, including those that have stayed tight for centuries, you'll find that hand-sawn tenons don't look like that. As Dave says, they are rough and made to fit so they "feel right." If you try to saw a tenon so that it's very snug, the ones that are a little small will still be tight enough to use, and the ones that are a little big can be quickly trimmed with a broad chisel. Even the ones that are just too sloppy can be fixed easily with a shim, and fixing the occasional tenon that's too loose will be faster than going through some arduous setup to make sure that all tolerances are within .002.

Certainly some people, like Brian, can saw with machine-like precision, but most don't and no novices do. And even Brian,as he already said, will saw fat and pare for something like an exposed through tenon.

Derek is right that anyone can do what they want in their shops, and they shouldn't have to feel defensive about it. But I think this argument misses the point. The point is that people who want to do handwork are missing an opportunity if they get frustrated and fall back on failure-proof setups that produce machine-like results but take three times as long. Most would ultimately be happier if they learned to make tenons and dovetails right off the saw, but that will require being accepting of certain imperfections, not requiring machine-like surfaces when they're not needed, and above all being willing to fail as part of the learning process. Brian/Dave/Warren aren't trying to pick on people for their router plane setups (I think!); they're just trying to point out a better way.

*caveat: sometimes, for reasons of disability or age or otherwise, people simply cannot make a tenon off the saw, no matter what. That's obviously an exception and those people have to find another way. But I don't think that's what we're talking about here.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#19

Re: 20th century

Brian Holcombe

I don't recall criticizing machinery or machine users?

David and Steve make the point well, we're talking about handtools and effective use of them. I am of the opinion that one should drive toward an ideal in using them effectively. I think it best teaches how effective they actually are.

I commented on the way I see this and the way I'm doing it, I respect your opinion and wether or not you disagree with my approach.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#20

Re: 20th century

david weaver

"make something" is the practicing. It's fine to try things while you're making something and allow yourself to make mistakes, too. Repairing errors is a super-useful skill.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#21

Re: Repairing Errors

Ron in Sterling, CT

David,

I worked in a woodshop with a good friend who always said about "repairing errors" that he had to "MAKE AN ADJUSTMENT" Repairing errors or making an adjustment is definitely a valuable asset that only comes with experience.

Ron

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#22

Re: Repairing Errors - and our egos

david weaver

And just as important as repairing errors is comfort with allowing yourself to make them.

I think our egos get in our way when we start woodworking later in life. We've got careers and failures behind us, and we take ourselves too seriously and think that we have to guard against the goal that some unknown mistake monster is trying to score against us.

We forget that we probably got to what we're good at (our day jobs, etc) with much learning and time spent making mistakes and learning from them. Why would woodworking be different? If we didn't ever take any risks at work or invest in ourselves, we probably wouldn't be very good at anything.

As uncomfortable as it may be to forge ahead sometimes, we have to just break through it - the error is always less bad than worrying about it (excepting really stupid errors that aren't part of reasonable practice or reasonable care).

I had a great deal of trouble with this for a long time. Now all I say to my self is if it's *that bad*, I can build another one.

The other thing that small mistake avoidance triggers is concentration on the wrong things. Visualizing good proportion and good design, cohesiveness of the different parts in making the whole, etc - we can only think of so many things at once. There's not a lot in art museums where someone blew it on the designs but had really tight tenons and really super glue lines.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#23

Re: "Notable Woodworkers"

North of the Border

snipe

- they'll be watching John Heisz videos or stumpy nubs or whatever).

Snipe

Question: Are these real woodworkers or simply video/content producers?

Answer: It all depends on what kind of a woodworker you are or you want to be!

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#24

Re: "Notable Woodworkers"

david weaver

I have watched a couple of Heisz's videos, I like them.

I think he said that he was a contractor prior to doing what he's doing now, and he did say people give him a lot of grief about not doing "fine work".

That's not what his channel is about, and fine work wouldn't draw so many views, anyway. If you want to try to do fine work, fine work is interesting. If you're just looking for a video that looks like something you could do if you tried to, then fine work isn't very encouraging.

Re: Router plane for tenons, nothing new

#25

'...something you could do...'

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Perceptive comment, David. I think that was part of the magic of Roy Underhill. He made it look like it was something you could do, bloody chisel wounds and all. I believe hand tool woodworking is only awaiting another Roy--who could be one of those in our midst.

Wiley