Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

West Australian Woodshow 2017

Posts

West Australian Woodshow 2017

#1

West Australian Woodshow 2017

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It's that time of the year again. The West Australian Woodshow was this past weekend. Chris Vesper, toolmaker extraordinaire came to stay, as he usually does, and I spent the weekend on his stand. Usually we get up to some form of mischief, but this year Chris brought along a few boxes of NOS saw files ... which were the very best I have ever seen ... 5" Nicholsons needle files made in Australia and sold last in 1998 ...


And so I spent a couple of days demoing filing saws. It's amazing how many people will stop to watch and ask questions. Got through a few ...

I was also there for the furniture competition. I had entered the Sofa Table (with hidden drawer) ...


This year I won first prize.


Second prize went to this hall table. It was really nicely done with some of the most amazingly fiddleback Sheoak ...


Third prize went to the winner of the past three years in a row. Ian specialises in veneer. This piece had a waterfall edge, the product of a recent workshop run by Michael Fortune ...


He also did this chest, below, which was one of my favourite pieces. The drawers let it down (not dovetailed) ...


Another good piece was this bombe (let down with some poor finishing) ...


There were interesting boxes, although I did not find that these were up to the standard of last year. First prize went to this unusual piece ...


This piece was the second place ...


The winner of the past few years, who has built some amazing boxes, came in third. He actually entered a trio of boxes, and this may have been his undoing. Here are two ...



There were some fantastic embellished turned pieces. This was first place ...


First in collaboration ...


There was also a category called "small treasures". I didn't really get the first place ...


And a last picture, from the carving section ...


Until next year ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#2

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

John Schtroumpf

Congratulations Derek!

And thanks for posting the pictures of the other entries.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#3

Congrats Derek! Fine work!


Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#5

Congratulations

Ron in Sterling, CT

Your work deserves the honor. Thanks for taking us along for the ride during the build.

Ron

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#7

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and all,

Congratulations on your 1st Place--Furniture, and thanks for showing us as you went along the design and build thought that went into it!

In regard to the photos, they are excellent and appreciated. And I especially want to say, that wonderful 3rd Place--Carving submission makes me wonder who got first and second?

Wiley

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#8

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

William Duffield

Congratulations, Derek. It is a well deserved award for a very elegant table, especially when pitted against some very tough competition.

Did the show have a different judging team than the last couple of years? ;)

I don't quite understand why the "trio of boxes" should be discounted because there were three. They are Boulle work, and it is the nature of the process that there are multiple patterns created and displayed together, with the same design but contrasting colors and even different materials.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#9

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William, I don't always agree with some of the decisions made by the judges. I know what their criteria are for the competition generally, but I would really like to read how they marked each piece individually. There could be a valuable learning area.

For the past few years I have missed out on even a place. Although my Lingerie Chest was voted Best Overall by the members of the club last year, the judges did not give it vote it above (what I considered were) three not-as-good pieces. Before this my copy of Hans Wegner's The Chair did not even rate a place .. yet was voted first place for chairs last year in the Pop Wood competition. This is not sour grapes (well, maybe a little), but I would have liked at the time to have known why they did not do as well as I thought they could. I suspect that others must feel this way as well about their contributions.

I think I am now in a position to suggest that judges provide feedback on the pieces they score. I think that this information would be helpful to all who entered, and all who have aspirations of improving their standards. What do you think?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

#10

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2017

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

Thanks for the kind words.

I do not have the photos for 1st and 2nd in the carving section! I do not know why ... but that is the reason why only 3rd was posted.

Regards from Perth

Derek