Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints - Deleted

Posts

Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints - Deleted

#1

Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints - Deleted

North of the Border

Surprised that Bill had chosen to delete his post because he felt frustrated with some of the responses from the advocates of the hide glue. I have not found them offensive, though their viewpoints are not for the use of TB glue for various reasons.

When we post something, we can always expect responses from others who hold a different or opposite stand. When I say I like to cut tails first, I know someone will come back with a pin theory. Some with facts and some with sarcasm. If I want to stand my ground or have one to stand on, I always hit back -- with facts or sarcasm, sometimes harder, depending on what responses I am addressing. Of course, I ignore those who troll or those deemed to be trolling. The last thing I would do is to delete my post or thread.

Bill has done a test and presented a result that anyone who buys into it can use. That is all the original post was about. He has never used hide glue (presumably) but he is not suggesting TB as a replacement of hide glue, is he? I use both and I won't be persuaded by anyone who tells me one is better than the other. I am the shop owner and I dictate what is right in my shop. Period.

There is no need for the deletion of the first post. Yes, if some replies were a bit blunt or not as courteous as they should be, that's the nature of Internet communication. I have seen much worse and if I were the receiving end, I know I wouldn't be the one who is ducking. Don't let anyone -- even if they were Sam Maloof or James Krenov reborn -- silence you. In any forum, you create a thread, you own the platform and you are the boss. Don't feel sorry for anything!

Now, Bill, please put that back so the latecomers can enjoy your wisdom (without going over to the Power Tool section).

Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints - Deleted

#2

Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints - Del

TM Stock

So let me do what Bill made a conscious decision not to when he deleted his post - defend his premise:

I understand that AR/PVA glues may not always be the choice that others make for use as a general purpose adhesive, but the fact remains that the stuff is ubiquitous in furniture making...a chair coming in for tenon reglue or carcass with drawers failing probably got glued with TB, so no matter the stellar nature of other sticky stuff, we are stuck with repairing an AR-contaminated joint or similar more often than not.

That said, most joints fail not because of ultimate strength issues, but instead because of the seasonal cycling of cross-grain construction and gradual, progressive cohesive or adhesive failure in that joint. While long grain to long grain joints may last for a very long time common cross-grain joints - lap, bridle, or more decorative variants - will eventually need attention. So yes - it is worth considering how to reglue an AR/PVA joint, and also worth understanding that because ultimate strength is very seldom the root of the issue with joint failure in most furniture, a partial strength joint repair may be not only good enough, but ultimately less disruptive than full disassembly, complete glue removal, and reglue.