Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
I'm setting for this year's Kez in NYC, and have detailed the efforts taken in a blog post.
Please have a look, and I look forward to your comments.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
I'm setting for this year's Kez in NYC, and have detailed the efforts taken in a blog post.
Please have a look, and I look forward to your comments.
Re: Let's Plane
david weaver
Very nice! like the wood choice - your billets are sawn properly and will do just fine.
There have, for years, been people talking about how there is no suitable dai making wood in the west and pushing people to buy $40 little blanks of white oak to experiment on, but properly sawn beech will do just fine.
I understand the sentiment - it's different, it's not tradition, etc. If you brought white oak to a planemaker in the early 19th century in the west, they probably wouldn't have found it as favorable as beech (too dense, etc). Same sentiment - it's different than what's used, but not unusable to someone who hasn't gotten themselves completely on the rails with a very specific process. (the harder things like japanese red oak and ebony, those I can't find much favor with - they're too hard and not as nice as either beech or kashi).
Re: Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
Thanks David!
I agree completely, I decided to continue with beech especially since I have a jointer plane that I made last year which has kept its tune well, worn well and holds the blade exceptionally well.
I made a bubinga dai which was supposed to be the 'it' material for kez, but for the life of me I can't find the appeal. It's a nice dai and basically stays in tune well but it does not hold the blade anywhere near as well as beech or kashi. I feel ebony would likely be about the same.
You might not have seen it in the post, but I made one the day prior also in beech that wound up in the firewood pile. I got a hair too aggressive in the cutout and had one chisel mark that was a few thousands too deep right where the blade needed to seat. I decided to chuck it and start over.
Re: Let's Plane
david weaver
I have a partially made coffin smoother with ebony. It just has no directional strength and I don't think I'm going to finish it (if it's used, the mouth is just going to chip, anyway - it barely holds together for mortising at the mouth, and I've had to repair some small chips that shouldn't have occurred in the first place).
As far as bubinga goes, maybe there is something to having an extremely rigid (and heavy) platform in a contest (that you just get tuned perfectly at that moment), but it wouldn't be that much of a pleasure to use day to day when it moves and has no give to keep a good blade and abutment seat.
Weight and rigidity is the essence of wood show planing (like if you're trying to sell a 7 pound infill smoother by taking tiny shavings that nobody can feel coming through the plane), but not very elegant for day to day work!
(Hopefully you can take the title, too, of course)
Re: Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
Ah, yeah similar experience to what I've had working with ebony, it's a difficult wood to work entirely clearly. I've used it for mouth inserts but even then tiny chips can form with ease and make the work look like hell.
I don't mind the bubinga so much, but overall it's a bit too heavy. I've gone the same direction in that I very much like light finish planes that give a good feedback.
Thanks! I hope so as well, but I have some serious competition, I know a couple of the guys went to Kez-USA last year and turned out 3.5 micron shavings!
Re: Let's Plane
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Brian,
Thank you very much for sharing this exacting work with us. While this is all far beyond my skill level, and perhaps that of others, I think we would all appreciate seeing photos or videos of the event. Please let us know if there are such available, once the event has taken place.
Much thanks,
Wiley
Ditto.
Re: Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
Thanks Wiley, I'll try and take some photos and I'm sure some of the others in the group will take them and share.
I'm sure you would do well in this, and you are being modest!
Re: Let's Plane
steve voigt
Looks great Brian! I really enjoyed reading that, and I hope you do well!
Since you brought up the issue of beech v. exotics…I am obviously a big fan of beech, but if you want to try an exotic (for next year or whatever), I'd recommend rosewood. Not cocobolo, real rosewood. South American is the most prized, but the Indian works very well too. It works by hand beautifully (and easily), and performs very similar to beech, but it is a bit heavier and a lot more stable. That extra stability doesn't matter much for day to day planing, but it might matter in a competition. It wouldn't surprise me if you got to Brooklyn and found that the beech had moved just a bit. Not a problem if you are prepared to tune on the spot, but it's nice not to have to…
Re: Let's Plane
John Aniano in Central NJ
Steve,
How about cocobolo? Is it similar enough to South American rosewood for making planes? I've seen it used for infilling purposes...
John
Re: Let's Plane
david weaver
I've made four planes with cocobolo now (two infills and two coffin smoothers). It's just not quite right for wooden planes - it's a strange combination of some really hard wood (late wood) and sometimes some sketchy areas (earlywood - really brittle in spots).
Much better for planes than ebony, I think, but not as good as rosewood.
I've made a plane out of purpleheart, too, and thought it was quite nice to work, but it's a bit ugly due to the pores. https://postimg.org/image/6ljctwu57/
The other nice thing about PH is that you can find it (same with padauk) kiln dried in reasonably large bowl blanks, which means it won't be that expensive compared to stuff that's sold for more exotic purposes. I have a block of padauk that will be going into a brass and steel A13 copy.
Indian rosewood is nice to work, but the plantation stuff is highly variable in terms of density. Some of it feels about as dense as beech, and some more. It bears no resemblance to vintage stock that I've seen at Hearne (they sell both there), but the vintage stock at Hearne is reserved - by price - for people who need to match something vintage. I believe it was $125 a board foot when I was there for a very small log (which means that there'd be a fair amount of waste in that log). Cheap compared to some gross looking brazilian they had there for $2K in a very small board.
Re: Let's Plane
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi John and all,
Some years ago, well many years, I was standing in the right place at the right time, and obtained a cocobolo smooth plane from Bill Clark (of C&W), that he had made for himself. He decided to let it go, because he had grown extremely allergic to cocobolo. This is not unusual, I understand, and is something for plane makers to think about when considering the options.
Anyway, this cocobolo plane is a sensational doer. Heavy for a wooden plane, but light for an infill--it puts you in the mind of an infill. 2", 55 degrees. Only thing negative is that I should ease the arrises and pointy places--don't really notice these edges on a beech plane, but they are sharp in cocobolo.
Simply as a personal preference, and speaking only of bench planes, I like beech long planes and heavier-than-beech smooth planes.
Wiley
Re: Let's Plane
steve voigt
Hi John,
I more or less agree with David's comments. I've made a number of planes from cocobolo, and it makes a decent plane, but it is much less nice to work with than rosewood--harder, yes, but also more splintery/chippy, and not as capable of holding fine detail. For folks who want as heavy a plane as possible, I guess cocobolo is a good choice, but that's not my preference.
I haven't experienced the variation in density that David mentions, but then my experience with rosewood is not that extensive. In general, it is supposed to be only about 15% heavier than beech (obviously as a bow maker you know this already). Every blank I have handled felt about the same--a little heavier than beech, which is nice for a small smoother and a pain in the ass for anything bigger, IMO. But really it is the working characteristics, and the way it feels in use, that make it preferable to cocobolo.
Re: Let's Plane
steve voigt
Wiley, I guess I was typing while you were answering. I've seen you mention Bill's cocobolo plane before--I'd love to see that some day!
This past spring, I had the opportunity to make two planes of the same size (1-1/4"), side by side. One was E.Indian Rosewood, the other was a hybrid rosewood/cocobolo, which basically behaved and felt like "pure bred" cocobolo. Not surprisingly, they were both nice, but I definitely preferred the rosewood plane.
I have to say, while I do enjoy these exotics--especially the way they look--I've sold or got rid of all of them. For smoothing and small work, I use two beech coffin smoothers (1-1/4" and 1-3/4). I use them hard, pretty much every day, and I've no desire to change at this point. Beech is really just so dependable, and it just feels right.
Re: I like the same thing..
david weaver
.. something a little heavier than beech. it's about 2/3rds of the weight that I want a smoother to have, but some of that is due to the technique difference (bump and swipe quickly with a coffin smoother, less abrupt with heavier planes).
I like the cocobolo smoothers that I've made, I just don't like working with it that much. It's not bad, but not great.
The one plane that I have left that I use some is a 2 1/4" wide cocobolo coffin smoother, which is super for taking planer chatter off of something, or for spot removing an area without tearing it out. I keep it set with some camber (at least for a smoother) and to take a shaving about 5 thousandths. One pass or two passes for wood out of a planer and all ripples and bruises below the surface line are gone. I'd use it for more, but the iron is sorby and not hard enough for regular work with thin shavings. It holds up just fine, however, with a shaving about half a hundredth and I'm tired before it is.
One oddity of it that I noticed, though, is that it formed a belly a couple of times that required re-truing the sole. I haven't used it recently, so I don't know if it's grown another one yet.
Re: Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
Thank you Steve! I was happy to see so far this year that I'm not the only beech dai, there is one other guy, Andrew, who is turning out some impressively thin shavings with a beech dai.
I'll keep the rosewood in mind for next year, if it grips the blade better than bubinga it's likely to be a winner.
Only trouble I have with the dark woods is that it is very hard to see the blade protrusion, where with beech or oak it's extremely obvious especially with a white background.
Re: Let's Plane
steve voigt
I am sure the beech will be great; the rosewood is something to keep in mind only if you have an itch to play with exotics. You are right about the darkness; in addition to making it harder to see the blade protrusion, it adds quite a bit to the difficulty of making the plane in the first place!
Re: Let's Plane
Brian Holcombe
Absolutely, I am sure I will be tempted and I appreciate the suggestion!
The beech did very well. I was inches away this year, the shaving fuzzed slightly on the right side of my last pass for about an inch, but it was quite thin.
There was another contestant who had also made a beech dai, and had pulled a 6 micron pass in practice rounds.
I took a shaving on my practice beam without changing the setting:

Wilbur took some fantastic video of the event, it's on his blog currently.