Re: German Chipbreaker Video
david weaver
Stewie linked to that on either this forum or another one several months ago (? - maybe longer).
No clue on age, could be just about anything, especially since we have no way to tell if a video has been adulterated to make it look older, or if it was taken through a close-up lens, which can alter the perception of the light level.
You and I, of course, have been through what will not necessarily be that interesting to most, but becomes instantly interesting when you build a plane and it clogs - and that is the relationship between the cap iron (shape, thickness and initial angle), wear angle and closeness of the wear.
The other instructive thing in the video, that may not occur as such to some, is the optimal use of the plane is both no clog and no shaving breaking. The shavings don't break immediately at the point of cut, but if you watch the video, you can track most of the breakage back to a point in the surface where the grain was lifted a little bit. This is the subject of a bit of a bad-mood post (or series of posts) I made on another forum yesterday when it was implied that regardless of what you do with your plane, if you take through shavings, you'll create a hump.
That's simply not true, though, and at 8:00, you see the plane functioning properly, even though what's happening just behind the blade during the cut suggests that it's planing into the grain. When the plane is working in that condition, as long as the sole is reasonably flat (or even just a bit convex - toe and heel proud of the mouth) a user can take as many shavings as they want from a surface without stop shavings, and may even end up making a flat surface slightly hollow.
If the shavings break, consistent thickness isn't taken off everywhere and that may not hold true - it takes some experience to know whether or not the amount of chip breakage matters.
Just another demonstration of why the cap iron, despite the higher initial cost, probably eliminated the single iron plane due to economics. With it, a plane becomes point and shoot, even in most bad wood.
Everything I just said is embedded in what Warren has been telling us for years, and it is why a discussion between people who dimension wood by hand - and do it well, will have so much more meaning when talking about completing a planing task than the same discussion between people who don't dimension by hand. Economic savings implies economy of effort, economy of time, safety and consistency in use, ... all of those things that are rewarding to a user, but that you don't necessarily look for if planing is a tiny bit of the work.
(of course, a lunch box planer is interesting to some folks when it comes to economy of time, but I don't personally have the attention span and project management skills to work quickly with a bunch of power tools and not royally ruin a piece or half a dozen pieces of nice wood.....and using a bunch of power tools is like being a combination crew chief, tire changer and gas man in a race - you do a bunch of planning and organizing and then you're involved in the action in sporadic fits - hurry up and wait, hurry up and wait. Using hand tools is much more like being the driver. All of your senses are involved and you have a deeper understanding of all of the details, not necessarily in a way that you can elucidate every time).
(it's a wandering mind day).