Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

Posts

German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#1

German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

steve voigt

Someone posted this on SMC. I had never seen it before. Very interesting; some overlap with the Kato Kawai, but more practically oriented. It uses a real plane, and variables like mouth size and wear angle come into play.

Can anyone speculate on when and why this might have been made? There are two copies on youtube, but neither poster seems to respond to comments, unfortunately.

My guess is that it's an instructional video for some kind of trade school; the purpose seems to be to show both good and bad setup and technique. The failures are as intersting to watch as the successes, actually. If anyone wants to cut to the chase, the best viewing is right at the five-minute mark.


video

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#2

lots of questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some in depth study of this video could reveal some useful information on how the assembly works in the situations illustrated. For those with unlimited high speed internet repeat viewing and study is not a problem. Just reload. For us in the hinterland, is there a way of saving the video on our computer for repeat viewing?

Anyone have insight on how the video was made? Was part of the plane cut away for camera access? Was the plane stationary and the wood moving? Planing pine...now there is a challenge.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#3

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

david weaver

Stewie linked to that on either this forum or another one several months ago (? - maybe longer).

No clue on age, could be just about anything, especially since we have no way to tell if a video has been adulterated to make it look older, or if it was taken through a close-up lens, which can alter the perception of the light level.

You and I, of course, have been through what will not necessarily be that interesting to most, but becomes instantly interesting when you build a plane and it clogs - and that is the relationship between the cap iron (shape, thickness and initial angle), wear angle and closeness of the wear.

The other instructive thing in the video, that may not occur as such to some, is the optimal use of the plane is both no clog and no shaving breaking. The shavings don't break immediately at the point of cut, but if you watch the video, you can track most of the breakage back to a point in the surface where the grain was lifted a little bit. This is the subject of a bit of a bad-mood post (or series of posts) I made on another forum yesterday when it was implied that regardless of what you do with your plane, if you take through shavings, you'll create a hump.

That's simply not true, though, and at 8:00, you see the plane functioning properly, even though what's happening just behind the blade during the cut suggests that it's planing into the grain. When the plane is working in that condition, as long as the sole is reasonably flat (or even just a bit convex - toe and heel proud of the mouth) a user can take as many shavings as they want from a surface without stop shavings, and may even end up making a flat surface slightly hollow.

If the shavings break, consistent thickness isn't taken off everywhere and that may not hold true - it takes some experience to know whether or not the amount of chip breakage matters.

Just another demonstration of why the cap iron, despite the higher initial cost, probably eliminated the single iron plane due to economics. With it, a plane becomes point and shoot, even in most bad wood.

Everything I just said is embedded in what Warren has been telling us for years, and it is why a discussion between people who dimension wood by hand - and do it well, will have so much more meaning when talking about completing a planing task than the same discussion between people who don't dimension by hand. Economic savings implies economy of effort, economy of time, safety and consistency in use, ... all of those things that are rewarding to a user, but that you don't necessarily look for if planing is a tiny bit of the work.

(of course, a lunch box planer is interesting to some folks when it comes to economy of time, but I don't personally have the attention span and project management skills to work quickly with a bunch of power tools and not royally ruin a piece or half a dozen pieces of nice wood.....and using a bunch of power tools is like being a combination crew chief, tire changer and gas man in a race - you do a bunch of planning and organizing and then you're involved in the action in sporadic fits - hurry up and wait, hurry up and wait. Using hand tools is much more like being the driver. All of your senses are involved and you have a deeper understanding of all of the details, not necessarily in a way that you can elucidate every time).

(it's a wandering mind day).

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#4

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

steve voigt

Yes, the most interesting thing is the inclusion of mouth and wear. It's an excellent illustration of why a shallow wear, say 65°-70°, doesn't work with a double iron. Also interesting is that you can see when the plane is functioning properly, at 5:00 and 8:00, the mouth could have been much tighter and it still would not have clogged.

A couple other random observations:

* When the plane is functioning best, the cap iron like it maxes out right around 50°, because the included angle is just a bit more than 90°.

* Conversely, it's interesting that they go to some trouble to show that a too-steep angle (90°) is not optimal.

* I would guess the film is pretty old, probably pre-WWII, but I doubt much newer than mid-century. That's just a guess, based on the shape of the cap iron, the dress of the workman, the style of the illustrations, etc. I'd welcome more informed guesses, though.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#5

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks for posting this excellent video. I'm curious on one point, and that is, how tight can the mouth be, and still work with a double iron set-up? I ask, because I have read that Norrises sometimes have mouths in the 10-thousandths ballpark. Would such a mouth have to be opened up, to work with a double iron set-up?

Wiley

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#6

OT: downloading videos

Steve Elliott

Bill,

There's an add-on for Firefox browser that makes it possible to download almost any video. When this German planing video was first mentioned on another forum I downloaded it for future reference.

Both Firefox and the add-on (Video Download Helper) are free.

If you're interested in further details why don't you email me.

Steve

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#7

Mouth size and clogging

Steve Elliott

My main smoother, an old Spiers with a custom-fitted blade and chipbreaker, has a mouth of 8 thousandths and doesn't clog. I haven't seen any need to try a tighter mouth than that.

I've owned a few Norrises and they typically have a much larger mouth that 10 thousandths, probably because over the decades the blades have become thinner with honing and use.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#8

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

david weaver

The mouths on those old norrises are filed so that they provide additional room compared to the wear on a wooden plane (they go in the opposite direction). Since the sole won't take any significant wear, the front of the mouth is filed about 90 degrees for a very small amount of the height and then the remainder of the height (height being the thickness of the sole) is filed sloping away from the cap iron, usually about the same slope as the bun wood on a no 6 or no 13).

It's a very nice setup because it gives enough room for the cap iron to be set up properly, but the mouth can still be tight. The old norris planes get a lot of accolades for how well they work without a cap iron, but they work much better with it. Even the cap on the later beech norris planes is a superb design, but the mouths are larger - they're cast or C channel steel. It's the adjuster on those planes that's terrible. The wood is bulky, but even the bulky wood isn't uncomfortable, actually quite the opposite. The later smoothers would be dandy planes without the adjusters.

Anyway, the cap iron on the early one is the same as the late ones - it's a lovely design - a more precise version of the earlier caps.

On woodies, in terms of how tight things can be, it depends on how the cap is shaped. Some early mathiesons and all of the earlier wards that I've gotten have a lovely long shallow cap that still has some spring, but that stays out of the way of the wear. You can make a tighter wear and mouth with them, as the griffths planes had and the early mathieson planes had.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#9

Re: OT: downloading videos

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill's problem is monthly bandwidth restrictions. One video can wipe out his total usage for a month.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#10

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

steve voigt

Hi Wiley,

To elaborate a bit on what David said, it depends a lot on the cap iron. The one in the video has an included angle (bed angle plus cap iron angle right at the tip) of about 95°. Now let's say the wear is 80-85, the normal range for good quality British woodies. There is thus a negative differential of 10-15 degrees, so the opening of the mouth actually narrows as the shaving travels upward, until it (the shaving) reaches the point where the cap iron bevel becomes shallower and the opening gets wider.

If the cap iron bevel is steep--say 45-50 degrees--only at the very tip, and slopes rapidly away, the narrowing of the opening can be kept to around .010" which implies that the mouth would have to be at least .012", even in a smoother meant only for wispy shavings. I have made smoothers with mouths of about 1/64" that didn't clog, but I would rather have them in the .020-.030 range.

For an infill, as David notes, it's a different kettle of fish. I see no reason you couldn't make the wear 95° or greater, which would eliminate the bottleneck; then the mouth could be as small as you want. But I'm not sure why anyone would want to. It's just cosmetic--the cap iron is doing all the work.

Hope that's clearer than mud!

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#11

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

Dennis

The logo on the plane pictured at about 4:47 is a Steiner patent plane, the patent is from 1930, so the film is from 1930 or later.

The caption above picture with the 90° angle, translates as "cap with broken edge"

In comments under the other posted YouTube, a fellow states that his instructor in "trade school" had a copy of the film. The title basically means mode of operation of a plane.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#12

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

Brian Holcombe

That's been my experience as well, the tight mouth is practical in certain circumstances but I've never noticed much effect on the shaving when combined with a cap iron. Without, of course the tight wear and mouth are critical.

They do show very poorly a single iron, the single iron plane I have that actually works well in various grain situations has the wear set to allow a few degrees if clearance (1-2 perhaps) and the mouth literally overlaps the blade. You can see light when you sight down the blade but if you look at the sole from the bottom it appears as if there is no clearance.

Of course I prefer the double iron for 99% of the planing operations I perform, but I think it would better show the two if showing optimal setups for both. They do show a tight mouth, but that wear angle is coming no where near helping, IMO.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#13

four thousandths

david weaver

I am repeating something, and apologize for that. I know i've typed this a whole bunch of times.

Round 1 of infill building for me was single iron design (even if planes had double irons, they were designed to be used with the cap set off). I made three planes. The first was a smoother with a mouth of a hundredth and 55 degree pitch. It wasn't tearout free (it's pretty good, though).

The second was a smoother with a 3-4 thousandth mouth, 55 degrees. It's pretty good, pretty easy to use. Not so great for softwoods, but it does what it does well, and is very pleasant to use. I'm sure I could sell it and whoever got it would love it, especially if they just wanted to sharpen an iron and drop it in a plane and go.

The third was a panel plane with a mouth of a hundredth - 47 degree bed. It wasn't really that nice to use. I filed the mouth straight up and down, and only later after figuring out how to use the cap iron, filed it away toward the bun and then there was enough room. Only then did it really become an asset for anything beyond really thin shavings. a hundredth was just too much mouth, even for a 5 thousandth shaving. Any unpredictable grain led to tearing shavings, which leads to inaccurate dimensioning, and inaccurate is ultimately slow.

The try plane that I sold to you will clog if someone can't set the cap iron correctly. That's why I never considered trying to make them and sell them to the open market - I was afraid I'd get them back and deal with the 10% of the market who just never gets anything, either sending them back or asking questions over and over. Even with something as simple as sharpening stones, Stu Tierney just gets inundated with tire kickers and people who want 3 hours of his time for a $10 profit. Probably his biggest seller is the three stone set that he packaged with an atoma. I pushed him to put a set together because it would lighten his load with people asking him to pick them the perfect set.

Anyway, point being (as warren is always implying), that you have to know the aspects of what you're working with, the subtle things that become trivial once you know them, but that are not so trivial at all when you don't.

And a properly set single iron plane when working well is pretty nice - in the case of an 8/10 bu smoother working downgrain, the finish can't be topped - at least not that I've seen.

Even with the cap iron set, in all but the very worst of stuff, the last pass or overlap of a couple of passes is a shaving so thin that the cap iron really isn't doing anything, anyway.

(but to complicate even that, there are woods that finish better, especially if an iron isn't ultra perfectly prepared, when the cap iron is engaged. Beech is one of them. It finishes perfectly with the text book cap iron setting, even with an iron that will show defects with a thinner shaving.)

Are we getting esoteric enough yet? :b

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#14

Re: four thousandths

Brian Holcombe

Haha, we seem to live in the area of esoteric. :D

I agree completely, the single iron is a fun plane in the right conditions/circumstance and setup. I've been cedar obsessed as of late and the single iron shines in that circumstance once I get down to finish shavings.

They're impractical for most circumstances, but once in a while they're king of the hill.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#15

Re: German Chipbreaker Video

steve voigt

Dennis, thanks for that info! From looking at the holzwerken.de site, I gather that Jos. Steiner and Sons closed in 1991 but was pretty much a shell from about 1960 on. I wonder if the video was produced by Steiner? Back to hunting…

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#16

Re: just an illustration

david weaver

http://www.norrisplanes.com/files/2013/03/Norris-No-13-Smoothing-Plane-16.jpg

I don't have a picture of my 13, but from looking in it, the mouth (and wear as it exists as a part of the plane sole) follows the bun.

I did find the picture above, which is nicer than my 13, anyway! Not sure about the angle, but it's probably 15 degrees or so.

One of infills that I have has a really fine mouth, most of the other older ones have a fine mouth, but even the norris 2 that I have looks like someone filed it some.

I can't argue that the mouth doesn't really amount to much being tight, but when it's tight and the wear is filed in a way that still allows a tight cap iron set (doesn't happen on a stanley because the casting is rounded, but they could be filed this way if it was important - it's not), I'm thinking they saw it as a display of skill, or maybe a chance to please people who didn't want to use the cap iron. Who knows? I haven't seen any vintage planes much tighter than a hundredth, though, and it's pretty easy to make an infill plane with a mouth down to 4 thousandths.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#17

Wear?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In these discussions you all have referred to "Wear" What are you describing?

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#18

film size

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think the film size and type is a date clue. If "modern" film it likely would have been color, allowing that modern is relative when it comes to film. Doubtful it was made during war years. So 1930's or 1950's is my guess.

Re: German Chipbreaker Video *LINK*

#20

Re: Mouth size and clogging

David Charlesworth

Steve,

I set my favorite 5 1/2 at 4 thou", it does not clog, (UNLESS I try taking shavings thicker than 4 thou)!

David Charlesworth.