Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The Correct Tool

Posts

The Correct Tool

#1

The Correct Tool

CJ in MPLS

I've been working on finishing up the first of a pair of saw handles lately and it has been a bit difficult. Using what you have on hand is the frugal approach to woodworking, but I've come to regret using a chunk of what I think is lacewood for the handles. I've been using a collection of files and relatively fine rasps to shape the handle and frankly, it is has been a real pain.

Until today. On the way home from work I stopped off at Woodcraft and picked up a Grobet rasp. The first handle is now done and is waiting for a second coat of tried and true. It is so nice to use the proper tool for the job. Unfortunately this type of thing seems to reinforce the 'purchase a tool for each project' kind of thinking. ;)

Re: The Correct Tool

#2

Re: The Correct Tool

Todd Stock

Other good tools for the job are 00 and 0 cut Swiss Pattern half-rounds (8", 6", 4") and a smaller half-round bastard (4" length). The Vul-Crylic and the 8" Nicholson XF half round in 00 and the 6" Heller in 00 see a lot of use on curved, shaped work like instrument necks. Tool marks get cleaned up with shop-made narrow scrapers.

Link to 8" XF 00 for about $15 delivered on eBay:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Nicholson-36557-8-Inch-XF-Half-Round-Swiss-Pattern-File-USA-00-Cut-/400522588795?epid=1418878552&hash=item5d4101b27b:g:NswAAOSw1S9WgZ~3

Re: The Correct Tool

#3

Re: The Correct Tool

CJ in MPLS

Got em' already. They take forever to shape stuff from square, which is why I am singing the new rasp's praises. Using the finer files was starting to feel like using 120 grit sandpaper to chop down a tree. Conceptually possible, but . . .

Re: The Correct Tool

#4

Re: The Correct Tool

William Duffield

I agree. For shaping a saw handle, nothing beats a hand stitched half round pattern maker's rasp. Mine are Auriou from the Forge de Saint Juery, but those made by Liogier are also competent. I used to use old made-in-USA Nicholson #49 and #50s that worked almost as well. Note that the made-in-Switzerland Grobet rasps (Lee Valley and Rio Grande no longer carry them, but Woodcraft does) are not hand cut, so you have to compromise either speed of material removal or smoothness of finish to use them. This just means that your next step in the surface refinement process requires more work. No rasp leaves a surface that is ready for finish.

Re: The Correct Tool

#5

Re: The Correct Tool

Bruce, a MN Galoot

What's the next tool after the rasp? Scraper?

Re: The Correct Tool

#6

The tools and the product

CJ in MPLS

The first handle is done and dusted.


I used progressively finer files, a spent jointer blade still useful for scraping, and sand paper. The files are shown here:


Anyone got any advice on getting sawdust out of the gullets of files? The file card leaves behind some stubborn dust.

CJ

Re: The Correct Tool

#7

Re: The tools and the product

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I use a brass bristled brush to clean files.

Re: The Correct Tool

#8

Re: The Correct Tool

William Duffield

Usually, a half round file or two, and then a scraper.

Re: The Correct Tool

#9

Re: The tools and the product

William Duffield

getting sawdust out of the gullets of files

We had a discussion on this a while ago. Annealed copper water pipe works better than a brass wire brush, because it is softer, and dulls the files less quickly. It's also fairly easy to wrap some hockey tape around one end for a makeshift handle. Of course, brass is still much better than a steel file card.

I had been using a fingernail. It is effective but slow, and the fingernails wear out very quickly, so I started using very large toenails that I get at a pet food store: cow hooves :) . I think they would work a lot better if I put a handle on them, but I haven't gotten around to figuring out how to do that yet.

Re: The Correct Tool

#10

Re: The Correct Tool

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Bruce and all,

I really like these for final finish on all kinds of handles, because you can easily hold them in any curve you want with one hand (they're thin), while holding the work in the other. Leaves a bright hard finish with no tooth at all. They hold their edge, too.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=49548&cat=1,310,41069

FWIW! Your handle looks fantastic, so what you did is great!!

Wiley

Re: The Correct Tool

#11

Re: The Correct Tool

steve voigt

A slightly contrarian response: IMO a rasp isn't the right tool for the heavy stock removal involved in taking a saw or plane tote from square to full 1/2" radius curves--it's just too slow, and the rasp is a wasting asset: it can't be (easily) sharpened. I use a chisel to remove 90% of the material on a handle. Sometimes I use a sloyd knife a little bit on tight radii, but mostly it's just a chisel. I switch to a coarse rasp to remove the facets left by the chisel, and to fair the curve. Then I finish with a mill-tooth file.

I agree with Wiley though; the tote looks great!


Re: The Correct Tool

#12

Re: The Correct Tool

CJ in MPLS

I would normally tend to agree with you about the use of a chisel, but the wood I used was so hard as to make this difficult. At least for the inside of the handle.

And thanks.

Re: The Correct Tool

#13

Re: The Correct Tool

david weaver

Not sure what grobet's rasps are like (machine made?). I like to use a coarse rasp with sparse teeth for the first phase of faceting. Steve's already chimed in that he likes a chisel, I haven't been able to get faster with one than a coarse rasp, but that may be repetition. I have seen Ron Brese mention that he also does the same (chisel) to do most of his removal, and his handles are exceptionally finely finished.

Anyway, for me, follow the coarse rasp with a relatively inexpensive simonds double cut file and then card scraper and inexpensive pocket knife of the locking type ("coast" brand soft knife from HD that was $3 and can be sharpened hard without worrying about wasting a good knife) to scrape the areas that are hard to get with a scraper.

Same process works on cocobolo (actually, cocobolo rasps really nicely - it just fractures off in hard little dust granules, but quickly).

With a saw handle maker's rasp or something like that, which is more of a finisher, working those facets on a handle is torture.