Re: Out of curiosity ...
steve voigt
Derek, like you, I assumed that 1/2" would be the most useful size. IIRC, I talked to Brian Holcombe about it some months ago, and he also liked 1/2". But recently, I did a little series (on instagram) on making skewed floats for fillister/dado/rabbet planes etc. I was surprised at the interest expressed in dado planes. When I informally polled those people, 3/4" was the most desired size. These are folks who are pretty hardcore, accomplished hand tool users, building period (mostly 18th c.-style) furniture, so I take their opinions seriously.
I think the issue is that you, Brian, and I all tend to like more contemporary designs, where exposed large dados tend to be looked down on, but that is not necessarily the case with older styles of furniture.
If I get around to making them, I'm sure I'd make more than one size, but 3/4" would definitely be in the mix.