Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The Roubo planes

Posts

The Roubo planes

#1

The Roubo planes

Kees

I have purchased the English translation of the Roubo manuscripts about the joiners and furniture making trades, "With all the precision possible". It seems to be a collection, I don't know the exact sequence of articles in the original French version. The makers of fine furniture, the Ebonist, is in the other translated book "To make as perfectly as possible". The original books were published about 1770.

Anyway I enjoy reading this new book a lot. Great effort. And maybe fun to discuss a few things. A book like this deserves discussion!

First about the planes. There is much that is new or strange to me. Just a few things.

- The French foreplane is very long! It seems that the half plane is being used for rough work and this plane is 21" long! Quite a contrast with the Germans, who do everything except edge jointing with short 8-10" planes. And the English had their jack planes of 14 and later 17" length. The Dutch had roughing planes in all lengths, the very short Gerfschaaf, a longer Roffel and an even longer Voorloper. I guess snooping a bit from every tradition.

- All French moulding planes seem to have an open mortice (open on the side). And they never learned to make them properly with a closed mortice it seems. Way into the 20th century they had an open mortice often with a batten glued or nailed to the side to close it up. Maybe this was because at that time the French didn't have a real planemakers trade? It seems that Roubo explains carefully how the workmen had to make their own planes while they bough the irons (which seem to come from Germany mostly).

- There is a bit of confusion about the fillister plane. Plate 13 clearly shows a fillester, it has a fence, but in the text it is called a rabbet plane. Error from Roubo or the translators? Plate 17 shows the real rabbet planes. The fillester is being used in making boards flat and square. As I understand it, after sawing or cutting the board to width, the fillester is used to remove most of the wood up till the marking line. And then the egde is made straight and square with the half plane and the jointer. I don't really see the need for the fillester in this context.

-The end [grain] plane. The word grain in brackets is an addition of the translators. Here is al the time used in combination with high angle planes. Even an end [grain] rabbet plane with 60 degree bedding. I thought that was an error and it should have been read end-plane as in "the last plane". A plane to finish cantancerous wood with a high cutting angle. Well, until we arrive at the mitre box and the mitre plane. That surely is a plane for endgrain (cut at 45 degrees) but it is a 60 degree plane too! That's peculiar, an extra high bedding angle for an endgrain plane!

Now I think about it, the Germans had mitre planes, often made of iron, in a bevel up configuration but bedded rather highly. A 25 - 30 degree bedding with a 30 degree sharpening angle also gives an endgrain plane at a very high cutting angle.

- Roubo doesn't know about the chipbreaker! Or he thought it was such an abominable new fad that he didn't give it a place in his book. The chipbreaker (capiron, double iron plane) was most probably an English invention. It's date of birth must have been somewhere around that time or a little earlier.

Maybe someone else read other interesting little facts about planes in these books. Please discuss.

Re: The Roubo planes

#2

Re: The Roubo planes *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The French did have two additional roughing planes: the galere and the riflard. Neither is mentioned in this text. Roubo does illustrate the riflard in a later work, but I think he might have thought that the menuisier was above that kind of work. He does state that they were above using green wood.

The plane Illustrated at the bottom of Plate 13 is a feuilleret (fillister). In English this plane was called a common fillister, as opposed to moving fillister.

If you take the open mortise planes as a sign of lack of skill, I think you are on the wrong track.

I wrote about Roubo's winding sticks and the fillister on this forum some years ago. Here is a Link:


Roubo winding sticks

Re: The Roubo planes

#3

Re: The Roubo planes

Kees

Yes of course, those guys were highly skilled. And making planes isn't really that difficult. I do understand from Roubo's text that they made all their planes themselves. And when you need such a large number of moulding planes and making them is a non paying job, then it's not a bad idea to choose a quick and easy method. In England and in The Netherlands were specialised planemakers, and for them it would be logical to put some extra effort in making them, if only because they were proud of their job too.

Later in the 19th century with Peugeot and Goldenberg and all those other large plane making facturies I can also understand why they continued making the moulding planes with an open mortice. This style lends itself to be made with machines. And because the French joiners were used to this style, they could get away with it.

How about the high angle endgrain plane? Why would the French choose that design?

Re: The Roubo planes

#4

Re: The Roubo planes *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kees, you wrote

-The end [grain] plane. The word grain in brackets is an addition of the translators. Here is al the time used in combination with high angle planes. Even an end [grain] rabbet plane with 60 degree bedding. I thought that was an error and it should have been read end-plane as in "the last plane". A plane to finish cantancerous wood with a high cutting angle. Well, until we arrive at the mitre box and the mitre plane. That surely is a plane for endgrain (cut at 45 degrees) but it is a 60 degree plane too! That's peculiar, an extra high bedding angle for an endgrain plane!

I think this must be a mistake in the translation. We don't use the term "end grain plane". I am looking at the French text and you are looking at an English translation, so I have no idea which plane you are talking about. If you reference a Plate and figure number the way you did for the fillister, I can look it up.

At any rate you should refer to the French. If there is something that doesn't make sense you can slog through the French and probably figure it out. And I think the new translation has a lot of stuff, whole plates worth, left out from the original.


Roubo premier partie

Re: The Roubo planes

#5

Re: The Roubo planes *LINK*

Kees

Yes it is confusing which parts are in the translation and which are not.

Anyway, i am refering to plate 21, fig 3 for the mitre plane. According to the text in your link it is a plane similar to the normal block plane, but longer at 12 to 14 inch long and the iron is set steeper. (I am not sure if my translation is quite correct..)

The short rabbet plane with steeply pitched iron is in plate 17, fig 2. The English translation sais it is an "end [grain] plane". The word grain in brackets is an addition from the translators. I can't find this in the French text (my french knowledge is very sketchy).

I thought there was another reference to an end [grain] plane, but of course now I can't find it...

The link below shows all the plates.


https://ia801000.us.archive.org/17/items/gri_33125009321916/gri_33125009321916.pdf

Re: The Roubo planes

#6

Re: The Roubo planes

Kees

Plate 17 fig 2 is called the guillaume de bout in the French edition, indeed with a 60 degree bedding angle.

Bout directly translated is "end". Guillaume is "rabbet plane". So this is the "end rabbet plane".

End as in end grain? Or end as in the last plane used on this rabbet?

Re: The Roubo planes

#7

Re: The Roubo planes

Kees

And plate 14, fig 13 shows the "rabot de bout". Again an end plane. This is also a short plane with extra steep iron.

Re: The Roubo planes

#8

Re: The Roubo planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Good analysis, Kees. I would translate rabot de bout as upright plane, an 18th century term for a plane bedded at a high angle. Holtzapffel called this half pitch in the 19th century.

The word bout has a lot of meanings besides end; in this case the context tells us we are not talking about a plane for end grain. Too literal a translation gets us in trouble here.

Re: The Roubo planes

#9

Re: The Roubo planes

Kees

Right.

That leaves us with the question why the mitre plane from plate 21, pictured next to a mitre box, is 60 degrees too?

One of those small mysteries of history I guess. Maybe we should do some tests to see if a 60 degree plane does better in a mitre cut then a 45 degree plane. Or not.

Re: The Roubo planes

#10

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I believe you're exactly right Warren. The term 'debout'--one word, not two--translates as 'standing, or upright'. Perhaps then, 'rabot debout' in modern French.

Big thanks to Kees for a very interesting post. Incidentally, my favorite foreplane is 20" long. Not much left for the try plane when you're done, and you're never planing a low place with it.

Wiley

Re: The Roubo planes

#11

Rabot debout

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, good work Wiley. This is the kind of thing that makes translating old texts difficult for non speakers. For "rabot de bout", you look up bout but do not think to look up debout.

Five years ago Denis Chenard wrote on this forum:

Hard to read, but is seems that a "rabot de bout" refers to a short, high angle plane ....Makes a lot more sense than a low angle plane. Denis is from Ontario. I remember he was bowled over by the misspellings, odd usage, and the old fashioned type for s.

Diderot, who was contemporary with Roubo did spell it rabot debout. he writes:

The rabot debout is the plane whose iron is not inclined and is used for root wood, wood from the Indies, and other hard woods. Later Diderot says that the toothing plane (Le rabot denté) is also debout.

Re: The Roubo planes

#12

Re: Agree

Kees

Funny, we have the word in Dutch "Overeind' which means exactly the same as debout with the same use of the word "end".