Re: No 6 Norris copy in process
david weaver
I think if you had a more accurate process, you could do it pretty easily without measuring by using a mill to do both the metal and woodwork. All I can do is measure the space between the sides at the bottom (since they don't stand up straight until you put an infill in them). In order to measure in the center of the plane, I take a piece of small dowel, point it on both ends and shoot it to length until it just fits between the sides and then measure that with a caliper.
This kit wasn't ideal to fit together (cleaning up the pins and tails left too much gap between them, necessitating less than ideal peining. I didn't make the peining block that well on top of that - it was a fraction narrow, so it is different in width internally by 1 1/2 hundredths in the center vs. the back (not that it's important to state numbers, but maybe easier to understand with them - the space between the sides at the top of the sole - that is the bottom of the sides inside the plane - is 2.03 inches wide in the front and at the mouth block in the middle, and 2.015 at the rear. That's not a deal breaker when fitting by hand, but it's just something else to keep track of. )
For fitting the front, I marked the depth lines (where the overstuffing fits atop the metal) manually about a hundredth short of their final height, and then cut them flush at the end after cutting the width. It's a multi step process and to cut the front block and fit it took an hour and a half. The bottom was marked a couple of hundredths wide and then slowly reduced in width until it could be measured at 2.03 inches or a thousandth or two shy of that. You can see that I hadn't marked the billet square (by the fact that the overstuffing is wider at the front than the back - that will disappear when I trim everything). This check and take a little off and then check again and take a little off allows you to clean up width and squareness at the same time so that there is very little error in any direction. If I had marked it to size and cut it right off of that, it would've been catastrophic - the infill in my 55 degree smoother sits askew a little bit because of that, and it wasn't even overstuffed. Even little errors show up as gaps if you overshoot correcting squareness, and those gaps can be filled, but hand made planes like this will end up far out of square if the infill doesn't dictate the squareness and get driven in firmly and clamped. Even then, they never end up dead square for me. I was hoping for faster, but the rear of the plane is going to be a pain in the butt because of the curves - it's not the free and easy process that comes in making a wooden try plane.
I gather looking at some of my older planes (vintage planes, not the ones I made) that the infill was put in place in the plane and then the overstuffing was glued to it on the top instead of making it all as one piece. I doubt the modern makers ( who are making super precise planes and can do more accurate metal work than me) do that, but my spiers coffin infill and lots of others look to be two pieces (I think Konrad Sauer said that's true a couple of weeks ago when I asked the question).
This is all a bit new to me. This plane is already a little squirrely, but I feel obligated to do a good job and not rush it - or at least try to. If I fall short, that's OK, but I have a history of doing half the job with patience and then going fast - a personality trait that I'd like to change - anxiety, I guess.
My opinion on the overstuffing, especially at the back with the curves is that it's probably going to be hard to get right the first time. A good maker would be able to get it right, but it could trip me up - we'll see.
Someone using a mill and templates could get the width between the pins on the sole to be accurate to within a thousandth or so and make the pins and tails really tight fitting before peining so that a straight infill could be made, but the overstuffing would still be there. On top of the fit quality, there is also the issue of proportion and cosmetics, and because a mediocre maker, I get lots of planes and look at lots of pictures rather than just winging those things. And I still print a scale picture of the handle on the handle blank to get it started so as to remove the risk of making a costly mistake there.
(more detail than you need to know, but certainly it is a bit of a pain and not quick work unless you could make templates with a mill and batch things - it would still be slow, but not so much fitting and fiddling).
Konrad Sauer and Wayne Anderson (and others) have been making superb planes for a long time like this, as does Karl Holtey. Karl has extremely accurate fixtures, like steel or aluminum peining blocks that are set for the exact measurements of the infills, and even he has had it with wood movement and went to a preferred design that is essentially a metal plane. Ron Brese has gone in that direction, too, and he does a more modular build type. My preference is to have the dovetails and the imperfection - it's frustrating to make, but full of life when you're done if you do it well. Like the old norris planes. They are well executed, but not absolute perfection in every single detail, and have a quality that new perfect planes miss in my opinion. Those old norris planes are still made to a better standard than I can make, though - certainly not sloppy. The newer norris planes were cheapened a lot - slab lever caps, castings and C channel steel, softer R. Sorby irons, sloppy adjusters and now shrunken infills that they ultimate went to holding down with a screw on smoothers. I think I can make a better plane. I hope. It was easier to buy 10 usable vintage planes than it is to make 1.