Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

No 6 Norris copy in process

Posts

No 6 Norris copy in process

#1

No 6 Norris copy in process

david weaver

I can't bear to cut and paste posts, so this one is short like they should be.

Finally getting back to building infills after a 7 year layoff (maybe it was 6). Learning to use the cap iron took the fun out of making large boat anchors.

I had these metal parts laying around for a Norris 6 copy, and finally smashed them together this past week. The main objective is to get clean metalwork and try to make the dovetails disappear. The metal here isn't quite finished, just draw filed (and will need to be cleaned up after peening in the cross pins.

Thankfully, these metal parts aren't that thick, so the resulting plane won't be monstrously heavy. I hope it works as well as a stanley 4.

I'm done with buying purchased rough finished parts, though, because they never turn out quite right once you finish file them. This one is only as wide as the iron, so I will have to taper an already hardened iron to have some lateral adjustment.

https://s11.postimg.org/jn90xhhjn/20170610_142449.jpg

https://s11.postimg.org/dnl9ttwr7/20170610_142500.jpg

I think a nice set of fresh good quality files to do the work is just about as nice as a freshly sharpened plane on wood. Very physically satisfying, and like working by hand, almost completely without risk.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#2

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

Brian Holcombe

Nice work David! Those dovetails are nice and tight!

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#3

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

John in NM

Looking good David, this is a project that has long been on my list, but I never seem to do it!

I didn't know anyone was making kits since Shepherd closed up. Is it an old one of theirs?

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#4

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

David weaver

The bottom and sides are from st James bay tool ccompany. I think the rest, ill do on my own. Definitely a project to do if you want to. Not hard to do, as long as you have some files and a machinist vise. Getting cosmetics right is hard, but if proportions are good, you'll end up with a good plane to use. Surprisingly good.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#5

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

John in NM

I though St. James only made castings.... but then I've not kept up on them. My impression of their products was always that they were a decent starting point, but that there was a ton of fitting and finishing to do. Might want to temper that blade too, when I talked to the owner around 1999, he said he didn't temper them ( :O )

I have a big sheet of 3/16 brass I was going to use. Not as nice as using bronze, but still will make a nice plane. I'm getting a freebie milling machine in a couple weeks, maybe that will finally get me going on it.... then again, I worked for about 7 years with free run of a small machine shop at the telescope and I never got on it then. Made a lot of other stuff though :D

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#6

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

David weaver

If you're familiar with machining, you are far far ahead of me.

The only real issues I've had are the width of the bottom being too narrow and breaking a tap.

St James bay sells all of their stuff on eBay now. You can find it there.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#7

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

david weaver

Status update - out of town last week, and broke a tap off in the lever cap right before I left. It's not a problem to make another lever cap, it's just a pain when this plane is sort of a warm up.

I did manage to order a new tap while I was out so that I would be able to chase the threads after getting the tap out. It was broken off clean at the lever cap hole and sunk all the way in, so I had to heat the bronze lever cap to cherry red to be sure I ran the temper out of it, and then I drilled it out.

Today, I cut the infills, cleaned up and finished (trizact belt then buffer) the lever cap and managed to get the front lever cap fitted. Tons of work left to do, but moving along.

https://s29.postimg.org/9l4b7sznr/IMG_20170618_120510021.jpg

https://s8.postimg.org/huuopdr6d/IMG_20170618_132329246.jpg

https://s1.postimg.org/ps3ftu8a7/IMG_20170618_132401435.jpg

https://s24.postimg.org/amkmes991/IMG_20170618_152048089.jpg

https://s23.postimg.org/qkj6gx7cb/20170618_211746_1.jpg

https://s24.postimg.org/t4r9hmu5h/20170618_211507_1.jpg

The dovetails, of course, show back up when you wedge the sides straight up so that the infill will fit. Hopefully they will disappear with final draw filing, but the seasons may bring them back - who knows? As humid as it has been lately, the wood shouldn't be able to get any larger than it is.

Not a fan of the grain orientation since it's obvious that this was a cocobolo bowl blank, but you can't get that picky when you're digging through your piles and looking for something that's dry and dense.

For what it's worth, I started planing this billet and then planing the resawn boards (hand saw, of course) with a high speed steel ironed plane, but ended up reverting back to my favorite stanley plane ( a type 20 no less ). I made the iron, it's O1- not soft, and not too hard. I sharpened once at the outset of this and again in the middle of it. Billets like this are the reason that I bought the high speed steel iron continental plane, but I just favor the stanley now, even for this (and this wood is full of sparkling silica particles).

i might have a different idea about that if I was making a dining room table, but that's not going to happen with cocobolo.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#8

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

CJ in MPLS

Your plane is coming right along and looks to be an outstanding piece of work. I'll share one I'm working on soon (from an SJBTC casting).

I am just writing to say that the advertisements on the image sharing site you are using create an amazing juxtaposition. ;)

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#9

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

david weaver

I can't see them because I have an ad blocker on, but I once viewed one of my pictures on a phone instead of on the computer (so sans ad blocker) and recall some of the pictures being a little close to the family friendly line (that site is supposed to be family friendly).

I'm open to other image sharing sites that don't require registration and specification of public or not, and that don't cut down file size a ridiculous amount.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#10

Re: Look forward to seeing your casting kit..

david weaver

...by the way. Did you get a rough casting or a machined casting? I understand making dovetailed and secondary-angle pinned type planes, but I'm afraid of castings because I know nothing about machining other than that I don't want to know anything more about it for fear that I might start buying machine tools.

Finish filing (cleaning up the pins and tails and putting a secondary angle on them) put too much of a gap in this St. J. B kit, so my dovetails are not as tight underneath the surface as I'd like - not a problem, but can lead to inaccuracy. I can't deny the time savings in getting metal parts where the rough work has already been done, though, and think I may at least try to buy soles from St. J. B for future kits, and then supplement with my own sides so that I can get tighter dovetails. Perhaps lever caps, too. His castings cost about the same as brass. I don't know if there is much time savings there as there is a lot of work to do to them, but they definitely don't take longer than working from bar stock.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#11

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

steve voigt

The infill is looking great, David.

CJ beat me to it on the ads…Russian brides? Really? ;)

I hear you on the file sharing issues, though. I frankly almost never post images here because the hassle of shrinking stuff below 100 MB (while still keeping reasonable resolution) is just not worth the trouble.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#12

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

david weaver

to paraphrase a Ron White joke:

"You can have deez infill, or you can have a Russian bride....it iz de same price!"

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#13

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

Kees

Aren't these adds cleverly selected to the perfect audience? So I guess us basement and garden shed woodworkers are considered to be the ultimate target for Russian brides...

Great work David. I like that levercap a lot. How the heck do you manage to mark overstuffed infills so precisely? Or is it a matter of paring the cutouts little by a little until they fit perfectly?

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#14

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

david weaver

I think if you had a more accurate process, you could do it pretty easily without measuring by using a mill to do both the metal and woodwork. All I can do is measure the space between the sides at the bottom (since they don't stand up straight until you put an infill in them). In order to measure in the center of the plane, I take a piece of small dowel, point it on both ends and shoot it to length until it just fits between the sides and then measure that with a caliper.

This kit wasn't ideal to fit together (cleaning up the pins and tails left too much gap between them, necessitating less than ideal peining. I didn't make the peining block that well on top of that - it was a fraction narrow, so it is different in width internally by 1 1/2 hundredths in the center vs. the back (not that it's important to state numbers, but maybe easier to understand with them - the space between the sides at the top of the sole - that is the bottom of the sides inside the plane - is 2.03 inches wide in the front and at the mouth block in the middle, and 2.015 at the rear. That's not a deal breaker when fitting by hand, but it's just something else to keep track of. )

For fitting the front, I marked the depth lines (where the overstuffing fits atop the metal) manually about a hundredth short of their final height, and then cut them flush at the end after cutting the width. It's a multi step process and to cut the front block and fit it took an hour and a half. The bottom was marked a couple of hundredths wide and then slowly reduced in width until it could be measured at 2.03 inches or a thousandth or two shy of that. You can see that I hadn't marked the billet square (by the fact that the overstuffing is wider at the front than the back - that will disappear when I trim everything). This check and take a little off and then check again and take a little off allows you to clean up width and squareness at the same time so that there is very little error in any direction. If I had marked it to size and cut it right off of that, it would've been catastrophic - the infill in my 55 degree smoother sits askew a little bit because of that, and it wasn't even overstuffed. Even little errors show up as gaps if you overshoot correcting squareness, and those gaps can be filled, but hand made planes like this will end up far out of square if the infill doesn't dictate the squareness and get driven in firmly and clamped. Even then, they never end up dead square for me. I was hoping for faster, but the rear of the plane is going to be a pain in the butt because of the curves - it's not the free and easy process that comes in making a wooden try plane.

I gather looking at some of my older planes (vintage planes, not the ones I made) that the infill was put in place in the plane and then the overstuffing was glued to it on the top instead of making it all as one piece. I doubt the modern makers ( who are making super precise planes and can do more accurate metal work than me) do that, but my spiers coffin infill and lots of others look to be two pieces (I think Konrad Sauer said that's true a couple of weeks ago when I asked the question).

This is all a bit new to me. This plane is already a little squirrely, but I feel obligated to do a good job and not rush it - or at least try to. If I fall short, that's OK, but I have a history of doing half the job with patience and then going fast - a personality trait that I'd like to change - anxiety, I guess.

My opinion on the overstuffing, especially at the back with the curves is that it's probably going to be hard to get right the first time. A good maker would be able to get it right, but it could trip me up - we'll see.

Someone using a mill and templates could get the width between the pins on the sole to be accurate to within a thousandth or so and make the pins and tails really tight fitting before peining so that a straight infill could be made, but the overstuffing would still be there. On top of the fit quality, there is also the issue of proportion and cosmetics, and because a mediocre maker, I get lots of planes and look at lots of pictures rather than just winging those things. And I still print a scale picture of the handle on the handle blank to get it started so as to remove the risk of making a costly mistake there.

(more detail than you need to know, but certainly it is a bit of a pain and not quick work unless you could make templates with a mill and batch things - it would still be slow, but not so much fitting and fiddling).

Konrad Sauer and Wayne Anderson (and others) have been making superb planes for a long time like this, as does Karl Holtey. Karl has extremely accurate fixtures, like steel or aluminum peining blocks that are set for the exact measurements of the infills, and even he has had it with wood movement and went to a preferred design that is essentially a metal plane. Ron Brese has gone in that direction, too, and he does a more modular build type. My preference is to have the dovetails and the imperfection - it's frustrating to make, but full of life when you're done if you do it well. Like the old norris planes. They are well executed, but not absolute perfection in every single detail, and have a quality that new perfect planes miss in my opinion. Those old norris planes are still made to a better standard than I can make, though - certainly not sloppy. The newer norris planes were cheapened a lot - slab lever caps, castings and C channel steel, softer R. Sorby irons, sloppy adjusters and now shrunken infills that they ultimate went to holding down with a screw on smoothers. I think I can make a better plane. I hope. It was easier to buy 10 usable vintage planes than it is to make 1.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#15

Re: two by the ways...

david weaver

..people always say " you never need a caliper in woodworking". This is one case where it makes things a lot easier. A 5 thousandth error in width (overshot) would make a visible gap - an ugly one, and after filling, maybe most people wouldn't notice it, but I would.

I could make little test dowels for depth, etc, all over the place and eschew the calipers, but I like them! I can sort of check squareness of the sides with the calipers at the same time I'm checking width.

The tools I use to trim this little piece of cocobolo are a paring chisel, a carter-esque blunt scraper chisel, a bullnose plane and a super shear (a coarse file would do just as well).

A cheat in making this a lot easier would be to mark where the front and the back infills actually were and undercut everything between and then glue in with epoxy filled. The plane would be just as good and nobody would ever know unless they took the plane apart.

The other aside is in the precision of fit in not overshooting, one I learned the hard way. If you overshoot the width a few thousandths and try to drive the infill home, anyway, it will separate the dovetails you peined and be visible. It won't look horrible, but it will look bad, at least. So you have a margin of error of a thousandth or two if you want it to look nice.

(I nearly forgot - I made the first cuts on the sides with a dovetail saw, which got rid of about 85% of the waste before precise trimming starts).

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#16

Re: two by the ways...

Kees

Thanks for all the detail. The one infull I ever made wasn't overstuffed. It had a handle and I decided to make the rear infill from three pieces. The handle and the two filler pieces at the sides. Much easier but still very fiddly.

I've got a precission job now too that needs some exact meassurements. I am fitting the top of a cabinet with two sliding dovetails. I have made one sliding dovetail nice and tight. Now onto determining the position of the other one exactly! I think I'll make a few storysticks. Luckilly it won't be visible.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#17

Clint Searl

Speaking of a cocobolo dining table

Clint Searl


Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#18

Re: Speaking of a cocobolo dining table

david weaver

welllll....I'm not sure if I could stand planing that just with a stanley plane and a house-made O1 iron, but that's likely what I'd resort to. I think that table would dull any iron pretty quickly. Bet it's not light in weight!

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#19

Re: two by the ways...

david weaver

I think I was (Admittedly) entertaining myself with the details more than I was being instructive (sometimes it helps to write what you're thinking, as I was pondering what I'd do to get the sides right).

I realized that the overstuffing on the sides shouldn't be that hard because the sides in the back are separate from the handle - and a large part of the rabbet for the overstuffing goes all the way through the back of the plane - you can just mark it reasonably and cut right to the line with a dovetail saw (slow, but far better than any other way of removing the waste, and risk free - relatively. I can just imagine the velocity that a router-flung piece of cocobolo could attain).

Plus, the three piece setup means the overstuffing rabbet can be done accurately and then the whole infill can be made to proper width by planing the back side of those pieces (or the handle if less handle width is desirable).

I'm sure these things would help me build better furniture if I actually had interest in that. The more planes I build, the less interest I have in building more furniture.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#20

Re: front infill glued and side pieces fitted

david weaver

Getting the overstuffing for the sides was a lot easier than I guessed it would be. They're long enough to cut like a tenon slowly with a dovetail saw (the overstuffing is 1/8th plus a little slop to be trimmed off later).

Just mark them with a pencil, cut the tenon, stick a bullnose or shoulder plane in a vise and work them over it. The only check necessary is to place the sides on the plane from time to time to make sure no gaps are developing, and then use a cheap square to check the depth of the cut being made and make sure it's uniform and square (same thing, no gaps).

The curves aren't quite right, but I need to make the handle first before I finish them off as the front curve of the handle hole looks better if it's a reasonable match to the curve on the overstuffing (or the other way around, I guess). I always have to do that type of stuff in two steps, anyway - it's the curse of ADD, that I lose the ability to think and judge within an hour or so and have to set something aide and look at it later.

https://s1.postimg.org/sxio8vwtr/20170622_071008.jpg

https://s9.postimg.org/zflqadjkv/20170622_071016.jpg

https://s22.postimg.org/x2l46uqw1/20170622_071042.jpg

The front was worse because the piece is too small to use easily with a bullnose plane - easy to round over the tenon sides.

(the slater bullnose was thrown out by a friend of mine - it was his dad's - sentimental guy!! It had no iron, but the irons are tiny and easy to make. It is really a great working plane, and they sell for about 50-75 bucks on the uk ebay site for what it's worth to folks who have tried and lost with a stanley 75).

White pencil marks will come off with final trimming, and glue should fill any small gaps and make them invisible since the wood is dark.

I noticed on the two overstuffed commercially made planes I have (a mathieson and a norris - old ones), the fit of the overstuffing is dead perfect, even after a hundred years. I'm pleased with the first try on this, but it's not the equal of the work that was done on those planes.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#21

Re: Almost ready to seat the rear infill

david weaver

Starting to look like a plane, at least to some extent. I copied some of the lines on this handle from a custom gunmetal Norris 6 I found online. I found it after I roughed the handle, so it doesn’t look quite as good as the original. If you look closely, you can tell that the bottom of the handle needs to be let in toward the front of the plane a little bit, it’s a bit straight up and down and fat at the bottom rear.

The top near the tuck-in could be a little thinner, but I’m going to let that go. I have a huge nick in the side of the handle at the top (left side) and have no clue how it got there. I might make it disappear with a shellac burn-in repair. Not sure. I will correct the bottom back as the last thing I do after I have this thing up and running.

Somehow, I got the infill undersized by 4 thousandths at the back. The epoxy should erase that problem when I seat the infill.

[url=https://postimg.org/image/gamo0nd6h/][/url]

And from the other side. Never mind the titebond bottle, I wouldn’t ever use it on something like this. The glue for this is liquid hide glue on the lamination and seating the infills is done with epoxy.

[url=https://postimg.org/image/ohj95ysmx/][/url]

I am learning a lot, at least, and it should pay off for future planes.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#22

Fin

david weaver

Fin

[url=https://postimg.org/image/p9mwotq7r/][/url]

[url=https://postimg.org/image/8n5cfqx9z/][/url]

[url=https://postimg.org/image/ozfe5hblj/][/url]

Cap iron has to go (to be replaced by a vintage one). The one that comes with this kit is 1/2 as thick as it should be and way too sprung. I think I'll gun blue the iron, too - it looks too modern. That combined with an old cap should help things.

More chips and cosmetic issues than I would've hoped for, but it's done (I will touch up the filing and clean up any metal areas that haven't been made totally uniform) and I learned a lot - most notably how to make a bottom absolutely dead flat by hand with mild steel. Not 3 thousandths, but no light from anywhere on a starrett edge flat.

Ever so slightly shy of four pounds and nice to use.

Norris 13 next after some wooden planes. I don't have an A6 on hand, but I do have a norris 13 on hand, so there should be no excuses. I want to make a dead copy of it other than the front bun.

I can make these planes, but the challenge is to make them really well.

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#23

Re: Fin

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

It is looking good .... if you can see it!

Have a look above the thumbnail pic on postimage.org. You will see a "share" icon. Choose "Direct Link".

On the forum Reply page, type in "img", paste the link, and then close with "/img". Use square brackets in place of " " (website thinks I am trying to post an image).

This is what you will see:



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: No 6 Norris copy in process

#25

Fin plus 1

david weaver

The plane was in fine shape the last time I posted here, just needed some cosmetic clean up and it didn't need to have the bottom finished (most of it was in plane and flat, but some wasn't quite yet on the periphery), but I did both.

And then I gun blued it just to see what it would look like. I expected it to look horrible, but I don't think it's that bad. Wish I could remember when I put the big ding on the side of the handle.

http://postimg.org/image/msyczw6e3/

https://postimg.org/image/9niutscij/

I want to do something to add a little shine to the sides, maybe buffer then blue then buffed wax.

I won't do this to more planes in the future, but it was fun.