Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

hybrid saw tooth patterns

Posts

hybrid saw tooth patterns

#1

hybrid saw tooth patterns

Joseph Piotrowski

has anyone used a saw setup like this? in particular, Bad Axe tool works has this often time as the recommend tooth pattern.

sometimes, when 1 things does two things. it does neither well. but what do i know about saws? nothing!

TIA,

Joe P.

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#2

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

david weaver

I'm sure the hybrid is just (view it either way you want to):

* a relaxed-rake rip saw with some fleam

* an aggressive cross cut saw with more aggressive rake and less fleam

I'd buy two separate saws.

The lovely thing about a rip saw is that it's aggressive at severing fibers and easy to file (when it loses aggressiveness, then you will have the urge to get that back).

A crosscut saw will work fine for a long time severing fibers laterally (that's my opinion, that a crosscut saw with some wear on it is a lot less annoying than a rip saw that has lost its bite).

I'd hate to have to file my rip saw in crosscut pattern every time it loses its bite, especially when it's already behind from the state because it's going to have relaxed rake and a fair amount of fleam.

So, only if you just have no room in your shop, budget or heart for more than one saw. I understand the attractiveness of the concept, but don't think it's as good in practice as it seems in concept.

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#3

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

joel moskowitz

I think we introduced the first combo filed saw about 8 or so years ago. maybe more. What it is is a fairly aggressive rip saw with a tiny bit of fleam. On hardwood combo saws work like a charm - our Dovetail saw is is just filed rip - also crosscuts like a dream because with hand filing you actually get enough fleam for hardword naturally.

Our hardware store saw is also combo filed but completely differently. Here we actually have different teeth for different purposes - more like a lumber saw. That was does fine on softwood.

So - my recommendation - for regular hardwood joinery or smaller poplar stuff a combo filed backsaw will do great. For regular work on larger softwood pieces two traditional saws will give the better cut, inless you have a special tooth pattern designed for combo work.

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#4

using only a dovetail saw

david weaver

If one has a reasonably well filed dovetail saw with small teeth and some plate depth, it's not hard to use such a thing for small work both for rip and crosscut.

At one point, I filed fleam onto a rip saw on purpose to try to clean up the back side of a cut, and I asked Mike W. if he had ever done the same and he said 5 degrees. I've since figured that's kind of a waste of time unless you can't hide the waste side of your cut and you're getting unacceptable blowout. (In Mike's defense, if customers ask for a saw that doesn't blow out anyway, then it's not a waste of time for him).

At any rate, I've made 10 kitchen cabinets all M&T (except for coped doors) and have only used a dovetail saw to cut all of the tenons and shoulders. I have the hardware to use both types of saws, but it's easier and faster just to use the dovetail saw unless you're batching a bunch of crosscuts together.

That may not work quite as well if tenons were larger and a dovetail saw too slow.

I do think that the argument for a hybrid saw as a matter of cost doesn't hold much water, because the cost of materials for any substantial project will be more than the cost of a saw. In the end, the saw can be resold if it's unwanted - I'd bet the average woodworker using decent materials would have some difficulty recovering the cost of materials and supplies used.

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#5

Re: using only a dovetail saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Many years ago I purchased a new Independence Tools dovetail saw on eBay. This is the forerunner of the Lie Nielsen IT dovetail saw (LN bought the company from Pete Taran around 1995, I think). I had been using the LN saw at that stage for a short time only, and found it grabby. So I had the IT saw shipped directly to Mike Wenzloff, who was starting up around that time (Mike and I used to chat a lot in those days - I have not heard much from him for some time. I do hope he is well).

Mike mentioned to me that the teeth were sharp and new. The saw had not been used. Knowing the hard woods I worked, and my experience with the LN, he chose to add a little fleam.

I was in a position to use the two saws alongside one another. The IT was a little softer and did not cut as aggressively as the LN. Over time I came to prefer the LN, and minimised the fleam with touch ups. Today the two saws cut in a very similar manner, largely due to both having zero rake and 15 tpi.

Adding fleam does soften the cut, but for a dovetail saw I do not see this as an advantage.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#6

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

AlanWS

Quoted from the Bad Axe website: "So is hybrid-cut THE saw-filing panacea? Heck, no. Nothing beats dedicated rip for tenon cheek ripping, or dedicated x-cut for tenon shoulders and carcase work. But--if you're new to hand tools and on a budget, a hybrid-filing will keep you from having to buy two saws up front. And, you'll be quite surprised at how effectively this filing rips, and how clean a finish the filing offers when used in x-cut mode."

Bad Axe hybrid filing explained: http://www.badaxetoolworks.com/Filing.php (Source of quote.)

The other approach to using only one type of saw is that of Tage Frid: just use a rip filed saw. You can clean up the edge with a plane, and/or knife the line beforehand to keep it clean.

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#7

Re: using only a dovetail saw

david weaver

Derek, by softer do you mean in how it felt in the cut, or by the amount of torn out material there was on the back side of the cut?

I may not have done that great of a job describing why I thought that was an issue.

Before I went to that saw, I was using only japanese saws, which have very little blowout or really anything at all on the back side of a cut (which faces you, of course).

At the time, I thought I'd like to have a saw that cuts like that. Since then, I've just made sure the far side of my cut is material that will be hidden, or in a spot that it doesn't matter (I can't remember the last time I looked at the back side of a cut now, but it seemed relevant then because I didn't know any better).

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#8

Re: using only a dovetail saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, by softer do you mean in how it felt in the cut, or by the amount of torn out material there was on the back side of the cut?

Hi David

I am referring to how the saw feels. More specifically, more relaxed rake means that the teeth do not bite into the wood as much as with a more vertical rake. The saw will slip through the wood with less resistance. This is at the expense of a deeper bite of the wood, and sawing rip will need more strokes. That is a disadvantage when sawing dovetails. Fewer strokes lead to greater speed and less errors.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

#9

Re: hybrid saw tooth patterns

philip f Duffy

If I am not mistaken, Sellers advocates more numerous teeth in the first couple inches of a saw so that the starting is made easier?? Philip