Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sofa Table: a beginning

Posts

Sofa Table: a beginning

#1

Sofa Table: a beginning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Now that the kitchen is done, I am free to build a piece that has been on my mind for a while. No, nothing as complex as the lingerie chest! Just something I want to do, and that is to replace a sofa table I built a dozen years ago. This one ...


I'm courting trouble here since everyone, especially Lynndy, loves this table ... except me. I am not fond of it (I built is as a challenge to myself - the only plane was a jointer ... I was in an Alan Peters phase). Friends love it, and I have built a couple of similar versions for others. This one was a house warming gift several years ago. I like it better than mine ...


The top of the latter is Cherry. Ours is Jarrah. Both tables are about 1300mm long and essentially rectangular, with curved ends ..


My idea is to build the base of the replacement sofa table in Hard Maple, which is left over from the kitchen. As with the kitchen doors, the base will be finished in water-based poly to retain the light colour of the Hard Maple. The table will stand opposite the kitchen, and I see it as a link between the kitchen and the livingroom. The table top will be made of Black Walnut. This will be finished in oil. All of the timber comes from the USA.

The design? the aim is to create something with a simple "sophistication" :) . Most here are somewhat aware of my tastes: clean, simple lines and soft curves. I am hoping that I can also design in warmth and avoid anything too clinical. To this end, I will show my design, explain what I have in mind, describe the construction, and be open to your critique. I have already begun roughing out parts.

There are two parts to the table. First the front view (I draw all my builds life size on 3mm MDF sheets) ...


The curve and tapered legs will have a splay of 25mm (this is a better profile of a leg than the other photo) ..


The centre rail is a compound curve, that is, the underside is curved, and the rail itself is a bow front.

This bow will be the same as the top, which is curved the entire front and rear ...


The top is 1250mm long and 35mm wide at the centre point.

That is the simple part. The interesting part is that there will be two hidden drawers, one on each side of the table. This is one of the reasons for the design of the overhang (100mm/4"): it cannot be too long as to make it hard to reach under to grasp the drawer. The long bevel under the top at the ends is not only a design feature, but also to make this easier. The base of the drawers will be 500mm long, and this creates a long extension, enabling a shorter drawer to slide out and be fully accessible beyond the table top. The fun part is that there is space to add a secret drawer behind the drawer compartment.

I'm not sure if this plan can be easily read ...


It details the bowed sides being joined with a 1/2" wide mortice-and-tenon into the legs. The ends are dovetail rail at the top and sliding dovetailed lower rail. Standard stuff.

Comments?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#2

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

William Duffield

Very elegant design. I'll be interested in following along. I was going to suggest that the front apron would look better with a little stronger curve (maybe 5 or 6 mm or so), but then I realized that would be a functional disadvantage because it would reduce the height of the secret drawers by the same amount, and they are going to be pretty shallow as it is. With a little finesse, you could tease a few mm more depth for the drawers if you tilted the runners slightly, so the top of the drawer cleared the top end rail at the drawer front, but just about brushed the bottom of the table top at the back.

Will you be using black walnut from the east or claro walnut from the west coast?

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#3

Agree with apron comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

forget the drawers. They will be too inconvenient to use. Creativity better channeled elsewhere.

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#4

some comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I like the cherry table and agree with you on the Jarra one. The Jarra design is a bit dated.

Walnut goes well with maple. It is one of the few mixed wood combinations that make any sense to me. Stop by and we will see if I can find a single board for your top. ;)

Have you finished, or seen finished, walnut with oil before? And by oil I am taking the description literally, "oil", like linseed and not oil that in fact is a formulated varnish?

I don't think there is any reason to ever use an oil finish on walnut. The look people think of for an "oiled" finish can be achieved with an oil based varnish. The result is more durable and arrived at quicker.

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#5

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

Kees

It's all a bit too elegant for my taste, but I like how you incorporate some curves.

I don't know about that shallow overhang on the sides. It doesn't look so nice in my eyes. I agree with Bill, forget about the drawers. And add more overhang.

Just my opinion. I am looking forward to your build reports.

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#6

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Derek,

Thanks for your generosity in sharing the whole process! Here's my free advice, which is worth its price:

Build the gift table with the divided rail. But take a look at using your splayed legs--a subtle splay, perhaps less than 25mm. No drawer. I really like the divided rail. Suggest all walnut--understated but riveting.

A first reaction: The shortened overhang seems too big a compromise of the design, in order to gain the drawer feature. It would be possible to make a curved drawer + an articulated hinge, so that the drawer would actually swing around and open to the front, under the wide overhang, but that would be an incredible feat to get a smallish drawer. You'd prolly be better just building a sofa table with frank drawers, which is a different design altogether. I really like that gift table.

Again, I much appreciate your community spirit--it's a pleasure to participate.

Wiley

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#7

Afterthought

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

You could also add a drawer feature by making a companion piece for the table. This piece would simply be a smallish drawer, or side-by-side drawer pair, designed to sit on the table top, on four little feet which echo the table's leg splay. The whole business in walnut. If this were done, the solid rail would perhaps be better--just a thought.

Wiley

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#8

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

TomD

Nice table. Great looking chair in the background...

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#9

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

I have been back-and-forth on that curve. Increased it, decreased it, made it wider, shallower. This is what it kept coming back to.

My original idea was to add a whimsical touch to the build ... piercings all along the apron ... piercings of abstract dancing figures. The piercings would lighten the apron. I went so far as to transfer the details onto a 4mm thick Maple veneer (which would be attached to a dark wood so that the figures stand out). Then I practiced sawing out these figures with a fretsaw ... and made such a mess of it! It is fairly straight forward when the saw cut is a forward direction, however the length of the apron is such that the blade must be turned in the saw frame, and then it is difficult to control. The figures looked like they were gnawed out by a rat! If I could figure a way to do this, I am tempted to try again.

I am on my iPad at this moment, and will post the original drawing when I get back to my laptop.

As to the type of black walnut .. when what does a lad from downunder know about walnut? :) East or West coast .. I have no idea.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#10

Re: Agree with apron comment

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It's hard to forget the drawers .. they were in the frame from the start. This is a reason for the solid apron.

I am thinking what needs to change ....

Thanks

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#11

Re: some comments

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oil? When I wrote oil, I was thinking Livos Universal Wood Oil, which is a type of danish oil (made in Germany).

I am ignorant with walnut. What would you suggest?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#12

Re: Agree with apron comment

William Duffield

But if they're hidden, secret drawers, they're not supposed to be convenient, and you would expect them to not be used often. :)

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#13

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Build the gift table with the divided rail. But take a look at using your splayed legs--a subtle splay, perhaps less than 25mm. No drawer. I really like the divided rail. Suggest all walnut--understated but riveting.

Thanks for the comments Wiley. Your ideas are unsettling! :) (that is always a good thing).

I cannot build the table I made as a gift. It was a gift, and one of a kind.

I also do not have enough Walnut for a complete build. Plus, the idea was to use predominantly Hard Maple to link to the kitchen. All maple is too much, hence the decision to add a contrasting walnut top.

Actually, the original idea was to use Tasmanian Blue Gum. I have a piece that I board specifically for the table top. It is somewhere between the maple and the walnut in colour, and highly fiddleback and incredibly dense and heavy wood. Stunning! However, I was resawing the board on the bandsaw, and the kerf kept closing up. My bandsaw is pretty powerful, but it stalled, even with wedges. I gave up on it after numerous attempts, thinking that this did not bode well for stability. Any advice, anyone?

Anyway, I am left with the choice of maple and walnut or all maple. I prefer the former. I have laid up the top, and cut out blanks for the legs. That is all the work to date. I will have to think about the drawers and the compromise it creates.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#15

Re: Agree with apron comment

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That is a good point!

A compromise by shortening the apron ... ? It could not be by much, however, since a long overhang would interfere with access. But a centimetre or two may make a difference.

My plan today is to shape the legs (safe enough for now). That will allow for some experimentation on the mock up. I'll post this when done.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#16

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

William Duffield

From here, it's just a pencil line on a pieced of paper. It will look different in solid wood. Go with what feels right to you. You can always shave a little more off the center or off the ends when you dry fit it.

On the east coast and midwest, black walnut, Juglans nigra, grows naturally. It is a furniture wood. On the west coast, they grow English walnut, Juglans regia, for the nuts. The problem is that neither black nor English walnut will grow in California, due to a fungus in the soil that kills them. To get around this, the California nut growers graft the English walnut onto other, local species of walnut, typically Juglans hindsii, which is immune to the blight. The wood around the graft often gets all mixed up, with wild figure and swirling colors, and is highly prized for furniture.

I found many pictures of exceptional boards using Google images. Here are a few examples:




The lighter, redder colored part of the wood comes from the English walnut. English walnut is also called Carpathian Walnut, and is originally from central Asia, centered in Kyrgyzstan.

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#18

Answer started on Main Message Board

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You need more than one opinion and there will be more finishers on the Main Board. In any case experiment on a test piece.

I see no reason to ever use a pure oil finish. Something needs to be done to preserve the walnut color and provide protection to a table top. I want scratches to be in the finish not the wood. Stain or pure oil followed by a varnish or shellac finish will look good on your table top and provide some protection. I think you want a bit of gloss in the top to match the bottom finish.

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#19

Ellis Walentine

A fine beginning

Ellis Walentine

Hi Derek,

Thanks for asking for input on your table design. All I can give is opinions and suggestions, so forgive me if I come off a bit pedantic here. Your choices are yours alone to make and I'm just shooting from the hip.

Contrast.

Personally, I rarely incorporate big value differences in a piece, so dark walnut supported directly by pale maple would be a bold leap for me. I know it's been done successfully by others, so it's not an absolute judgment. When I do use highly contrasting elements, I generally try to have a transitional element between them, specific to the piece at hand.

Function.

Tables are, after all, horizontal surfaces of a particular size and shape to suit their intended use. How they are supported is primarily an aesthetic concern as long as the structural engineering is sound, and that is governed by things like the load and the tipping forces, whatever they might be. All engineering should include a safety factor, too, which can vary depending on forseeable risks. In this case, the only unaddressed tipping forces I can see would be in the front-back dimension because of the narrow footprint in that dimension and because the legs are only splayed in the side-to-side dimension. Since a sofa table stands adjacent to a wall or sofa generally, there shouldn't be any trouble there. And, the legs, while slender, are plenty stiff enough to hold up even a collection of heavy sculptures and resist moderate lateral forces.

Form.

In elevation, the table is very delicate, perhaps a bit more delicate than I would have designed for the overstuffed sofa behind it. But, it is in keeping with the delicate demilune and the Wegner chair in this particular interior, so it works. It also works on a more absolute scale, since freestanding furniture isn't obliged to assume any set form or other visual aspect; it only needs to be visually consistent within itself. Regarding the boat shape of the top, I've never been a big fan or it. I think of it as a 50s-vintage furniture meme. That said, I don't know what shape I would to complement the various other forms in the room. I guess any eclectic shape you like would work, but here's another thought you might consider: What about having the back edge be straight, so it fits directly to the back of the sofa or the hallway wall? For what it's worth, I'd consider something like this, but again, this is a design I've used several times in the past and have come to like. It has a slightly eased edge around the top and a 3/4" round-over on the bottom. To me, it serves your intention of soft curves and relative simplicity.


One other note on form, and that is to let the ends overhang a proportionate amount. I agree with others who feel that 4" is not enough relative to the overall width of the piece. And, if you do proceed with the boat shape, I suggest making the top wider so the legs are set in further. From your drawing it appears that the legs are only tucked under the edges of the top by half an inch or so. I wouldn't make the stance any narrower because of tipping thresholds. You might be able to continue the curve of the front rail onto the front faces of the legs to offset this proximity issue, though it would disrupt the splayed leg theory. A wider top would be the simplest solution. I would also suggest making the table longer overall. The existing table looks a tad short compared to the width of the sofa.

As for the drawers, that would depend on how motivated you are to have drawers. If the ends overhang more than the 4" you've proposed, the drawers will require even greater length if you want to access them at all. One possibility would be a partner's-desk type drawer that would slide out from either end of the table. You could pull it out three quarters of the length of the table and it would still be stable and the overhang wouldn't matter.

So there you have it. Just a few thoughts for you.

Best,

Ellis

Re: Sofa Table: a beginning

#20

Re: A fine beginning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

Thanks so much for the many ideas and obvious thought you have given to this project.

Your comments really drive home how many issues need to be overcome to create harmony among seemingly conflicting features! I hope I can rise to the occasion and not instead bury my head in the sand. :)

The idea of a straight rear edge did occur to me. I even laid it out, and drew up the construction details ...


I thought that it was stodgy and dull. It lacked a light feel. I do have a couple of demilune side tables I built, and the similarity of these is too much in one area.

It did occur to me that I should not be introducing another curved piece, that a curved top is OK. especially as the curve is mild, but the bow to the apron may be too much of a good thing, and that it would be better if this was rectangular. It certainly would simplify the construction .... however I never design with construction in mind - first comes the design, then work out how to do it. The point you made about design in the context is appropriate - the context here is all the furnishings together. The reason the existing sofa table works is that is blends in. Your point is taken.


Regards from Perth

Derek