Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

I see some forgeries coming soon..

Posts

I see some forgeries coming soon..

#1

I see some forgeries coming soon..

david weaver

First plane I got from LN had cocobolo handles on it. At the time, it was a $25 option, and, of course, it made sense to me on an expensive plane like that - cherry looks cheap, and we've gotten used to it on their planes, but it still looks cheap.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Lie-Nielsen-No-4-Smoothing-Plane-Cocobolo-Handles-/172573086633?hash=item282e2853a9:g:a4EAAOSw32lYxeeq

Anyway, when I sold my LN #6, I got zero extra for having cocobolo handles even though LN was discussing stopping them at the time (I didn't try to get extra, either).

Now, it appears that some relatively greedy folks (my opinion) are trying to create a market where cocobolo makes the plane worth another $350. If that happens for long, it won't take a genius to start duplicating those handles and flipping them onto planes and reselling them (of course, checking off the check box that says "cocobolo" on the end of the plane).

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

#2

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

John in NM

Hell, I've seen people on ebay selling EMPTY Lie Nielsen boxes! If some chump will pay extra, someone will feed the chump's needs.

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

#3

Re: the shame of that...

david weaver

is that LN will send you those boxes for free, or at least they used to (and I doubt they've changed).

I got some used planes in the past that didn't have boxes. I called them asking if I could buy boxes for them because the seller lost theirs. I could not convince them to let me pay for the boxes - it's not LN's fault that the boxes were lost. They sent them without charge - I couldn't even convince them to let me pay shipping.

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

#4

Re: LN O1 Irons and the No 9

david weaver

I suppose this probably means we're going to see some very expensive LN 01 irons.

A few years ago, I had a LN #9. Nice plane, old style with the knob. I think I sold it for about $300, which is probably what I paid for it used. At the time, I got a lot of tire kickers who didn't want it because I didn't have a "hot dog". Remember the hot dog craze?

I found the knobbed 9 pretty easy to use, some others didn't.

The other day, I saw a knobbed "rare" Ln #9, used, for sale for $700. :b

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

#5

Re: I see some forgeries coming soon *LINK*

William Duffield

Dalbergia retusa has recently be added to Appendix II of the Convention on International Trade of Endangered Species. That in itself may explain the price increase.

There are those who claim the L-N planes themselves are just forgeries of Stanleys. Sour grapes.

Others will sic their patent attorneys on you if you try to sell any interface between your hand and a tool, because it violates their handle patent.

If you fashion your own tote to fit your hand specifically, and make it from some other endangered wood species, is it still a forgery?

Is anything made by a blacksmith in a forge a forgery?

Where should we draw the line between a forgery and a reproduction?

But, Wait! There's more! https://add-a-handle.com At $20 each and made in the U.S.A., how long before Alibaba is selling knock-offs at a buck three eighty seven each? Is mine a forgery or prior art?


Re: I see some forgeries coming soon..

#6

Re: LN O1 Irons and the No 9

ian neuhaus

Maybe I shouldn't mention that LN #9s are still available via special order.

Then I could quietly order a few and ebay them as "rare" NOS :)