Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hand Tool Aids

Posts

Hand Tool Aids

#1

Hand Tool Aids

Gary B.

I've been thinking a lot about the way of hand tools lately. It's great that you can simply mark a line, and cut to it. But sometimes, for some things, it's nice to have something to speed it along.

I've been a production woodworker for nearly 20 years, focusing mostly in cabinets. I've often wondered how pieces were produced in a typical shop 150 years ago. I'm sure they had production demands back then also. And I think they were smarter than they get credit for. Surely they came up with some innovative ways to reduce the work required for a given joint, or a given product. For instance, it's fine to cut M & T joints to a knife line when there are 5 or 10 to do. What about 20 or 30? If you were making anything in a mission style, it may get tedious quickly.

Two examples I've recently become aware of are Paul Sellers dovetail setup, and Richard Maguire's Bridle joints. Does anyone know of any other instances where a typical worker might have made things easier on themselves than we would notice at first glance?

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#2

Re: Hand Tool Aids

Brian Holcombe

You need to go back further still if you want to know what they did when they were building furniture entirely by hand.

Mortises were cut by chisel and mallet. It's not a very long process for someone who is doing it daily, maybe 2-3 minutes per mortise. If you had 30 of them to cut, then it took you maybe 2 hours. Labor was not priced at $100/hr then... :D

Aides slow you down when you can cut to a line and chop to a line.

WRT Arts and Crafts furniture, I've yet to see anything which really strikes me as being completely hand made. I think it was more along the lines of what we see coming from Denmark today, mostly machine made but with hand detailing. Likely it was a great majority machine made with some hand work. They had competition and so likely they were not doing everything by hand. I've also not seen any errors in the furniture like I do when I'm looking at really handmade furniture.

WRT truly handmade furniture, the furniture was planned to be efficient in its build. As someone who transitioned from making by machine to making nearly entirely by hand (I use some machines again) it changes how you approach certain aspects of the craft to eliminate real time sinks all the way down to stock selection.

When your working by hand you begin to greatly appreciate how much easier it is to work with a nicely chosen piece of wood, vs picking something that fits the dimension and going with it. When I look at stock I'm looking to see very little grain run out, very little knots and/or other things that are going to slow me down I'm also avoiding flat sawn lumber if at all possible.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#3

Re: Hand Tool Aids

CJ in MPLS

I believe that the most important part of getting stuff done in the shop is the ability to move, quickly and efficiently, from one part of a project to another. Another important attitude is the ability to accept that 'this is how this is done' and then get grinding.

I tend to perseverate on how to 'best' do things and am a bit too self-congratulatory when an operation is completed. Takes longer to start and I don't get on to the next thing quickly enough to get things out the door.

A couple of specialized hand tools that I have only recently become aware of are the shoulder chisel for inlay work and this weird, bow driven router type device that was held between a plate strapped to the user's torso and the workpiece. The router's bit was constrained by a template, had a fixed depth, and was used to create shallow mortises for inlaid materials.

Both of these would have sped up otherwise tedious tasks, but were still hand driven tools.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#4

Re: "work in rhythm"

david weaver

I recall reading an accounting of someone meeting a Japanese cabinetmaker or carpenter (or maker of some kind) that they considered to be a hero. The maker was too sick to talk much to whoever was blogging about the encounter, but the spouse of the maker was well versed in what the maker did and what their views were.

The only thing I got from reading the story (which seems to be the only thing the writer got) was that as they were leaving, the spouse of the maker grabbed the person and "begged" them that whatever they do, they should do it in rhythm.

If I get a rare clear four hours of time in the shop (because I have small kids), I recall that comment and try to keep the rhythm going. It does two things: 1) it keeps me from hurrying, which is just a way to end a shop session earlier either being exhausted or from the frustration of a stupid error, 2) it keeps me from standing around just as you said - self congratulating or pondering. A gentle self-reminder gets me back into the flow, and without hurrying.

I get a lot more done and it feels a lot better. When I first read the article, I thought it was kind of dopey, but I get it now.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#5

Re: Hand Tool Aids

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I do agree with you, Brian, the idea that aids, jigs or gizmos, are going to help is more power tool thinking than hand tool thinking. The time saving from hand work is that you mark a line, you saw to the line and the joint is done. There is no messing around with trial cuts before sawing or cleaning up after sawing.

If you really want to speed things along with production work here are some hints from 200 years ago:

Make a dedicated mortise gauge for an individual mortise chisel. That way you save set up time and the inaccuracy that comes with each set up. If you find that when sawing to the line your tenons tend to be a little fat, or a little loose, you can make a slight adjustment to the gauge that will be there the next time you use that chisel.

Use a tenon saw for the shoulders, cutting right on the line. Use a rip saw for the cheeks, again cutting right on the line.

Making a large number of tenons is a chance to improve skills. If a large number sends you to the machinery, you can manage to avoid skills.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#6

hand tool aids in general

ian neuhaus

I suppose the principal "production enhancers" were:

only those parts of a piece that were on display were finished -- e.g. cabinet backs, the underside of drawer bottoms, cabinet insides were often left with an off-the saw finish, or scrub plane tracks.

master craftsmen and the journey men they employed used templates and story sticks to mark out components -- so no measuring was required.

a skilled craftsman can cut the tenons for M&T joints "off the saw". If you're making 20 to 30 M&Ts per day you'll get very good at it very quickly.

dovetails and other similar details were mostly spaced by eye rather than measurement.

the fineness of everyday pieces was much less than we think.

This is I think very relevant. Most of the furniture which has survived from 150+ years ago and is accessible for examination and copying is the higher quality pieces. The stuff which might be considered equivalent to today's mass market furniture has generally not survived.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#7

Re: Hand Tool Aids (this topic)

david weaver

Every time I see this topic, I read it as a disease.

"I have hand tool aids. It's incurable :b I will have hand tool aids for the rest of my life. It's like regular aids, except that it's not similar to regular aids at all, and it just makes you annoying to power tool woodworkers....and nobody is looking for a cure for it "

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#8

Re: Hand Tool Aids (this topic)

Gary B.

First of all, thanks for all who've responded thus far. Perhaps it would be helpful to understand where I'm coming from. At the risk of offending purists with offensive (man made) materials, I'll give you an example straight from our shop.

As a shop manager, I feel it's my duty to ensure we're producing quality products, as fast as we reasonably can. This allows us to remain competitive in today's economy. I doubt it was much different 150 years or more ago. There was always more than one shop around, and always someone willing to do it for less than you. I'm guessing you needed to focus on quality, with a reasonable price instead of competing on price alone. Unless you were lucky and perched at the top of the pyramid, doing work that few could, and even fewer were willing and able to pay for.

Few are willing to work for less, so things that save time, save money. Innovation and continuous improvement provides the competitive edge required. Wood and Shop shows some video's inside the Anthony Hay Shop at Colonial williamsburg. They mention how progressive that particular shop was compared to most in the area at the time. The example I believe was being able to cut their own veneer in house.

Anyways, within our product line it is very common to cut a 45 degree cut across a built up 1-1/2" thick ACX plywood counter before laminating. For years, we would mark points, draw a line, cut to the line with a jigsaw, then belt sand to the line. This required one to do their layout, pull out the extension cord, plug in the Jigsaw, make the cut, unplug and put away, pull out the belt sander, plug in, sand, then put everything back. This would take maybe 5-7 minutes or so. We did this hundreds of times before I walked by one day and really noticed it. So, that day, we purchased a new cordless circular saw, made a repeatable fence jig for that cut which now hangs on the wall. Now it's a matter of pulling down the saw and jig, making the cut, and putting them back. 7 minutes to less than a minute, after one observation and a bit of work.

This is one tiny example of how we try to continuously to improve.

I've no doubt shop leaders and journeymen of our trade in the past would look at their processes in the same light. I'm thinking they prided themselves on a good days work and their productivity. I think I remember Toshio Odate saying in an article that the worst thing a Japanese Shoji maker could be called was slow.

To be clear, I'm not talking about aids because of a lack of skill. I'm talking about things that speed up the process. Take my two examples above (Paul Sellers, Richard Maquire) I'm sure these guys can saw to a line. The aides they present speed the process by eliminating repetitive layout.

You've all brought up great points. The story pole, Dedicated marking gauges, and others are exactly what I was looking for. There are definitely times when you need to just accept the process and push through. Working in a rhythm actually is a big deal in a production shop. It's funny when you watch older workers, ones that have been at it a long time. You can glance at them and it doesn't really look like they've done much all morning, then next thing you know, a bunch of work is done.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#9

Re: Hand Tool Aids (this topic)

TomD

"As a shop manager, I feel it's my duty to ensure we're producing quality products, as fast as we reasonably can. This allows us to remain competitive in today's economy. I doubt it was much different 150 years or more ago. There was always more than one shop around, and always someone willing to do it for less than you. I'm guessing you needed to focus on quality, with a reasonable price instead of competing on price alone. Unless you were lucky and perched at the top of the pyramid, doing work that few could, and even fewer were willing and able to pay for."

I think you want to be very careful about imposing ideas that weren't even universal in the united states till quite recently, to some period hundreds of years ago. For instance, Deming the post war (say that again) genius of quality and efficient manufacturing, had his ideas proven in Japan, and then they fed back here, maybe as late as the 80s in areas like autos. A major purpose of the guilds was to ensure that competition was minimized but that quality was held high. When Adam Smith came along and later was expanded upon by early 19th century economists, the result wasn't the invisible hand of the market, but mass protests that led to unions. When the first sewing machines were used to replace hand work, it led to violent confrontations.

The ability to have a lot of competition and to smash the trades has in part been made possible by the crash to crap of the standards in almost everything. Furniture today, including most so called custom cabinetry is garbage, and clothing and footwear is unimaginably shoddy. The standards we expect in modern products like cars and phones are very high, but look at the crud Steve Jobs wore in announcing his contributions. It is amazing to go to some mall in a rich part of the US and see people making the trek from Mercedes to Mall dressed in clothes of lower quality (though fresher) than the rag and bone man from the 60s in the UK. You can't train for 7 years if you are going to be displaced by a guy who cleans out his garage and goes into competition with you. And he can only do that if expected standard of work is very low. But, of course there are many conveniences and features that make up the difference. Synthetic counter tops can be easier to maintain, hinges can be made for fold well out of the way. So the refinement comes in different forms.

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#10

Re: Hand Tool Aids

TomD

"Two examples I've recently become aware of are Paul Sellers dovetail setup, and Richard Maguire's Bridle joints. Does anyone know of any other instances where a typical worker might have made things easier on themselves than we would notice at first glance?"

Do you have links, it is impossible to keep up with everything.

If you have looked at Franz Klauzs' Dovetail a Drawer, you will have noted that he quotes 20 minutes per drawer in making a drawer with hand cut dovetails, that includes marking and dimensioning stock from the opening, through to fitting the drawer. The drawer in the video is commercial grade, not fine woodworking, however FK's hand work would have produced a drawer that could have gone into many studio furniture pieces or fine antiques, those details would just be extra.

20 minutes doesn't sound that long to me.

One can learn to cut dovetails as he does, direct from the video (and videos on Youtube by FK). It is not only a good way to make them, but an efficient way to practice as so little time is wasted with layout. In particular the exact way he chops out is hard to beat.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-o4jryTkUc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrAAglKLPh8

Re: Hand Tool Aids

#11

Re: Hand Tool Aids

Gary B.

Hi Tom,

Yes, Frank Klausz is a great example. The way he cuts out pins without marking is pretty fast. IIRC, this is how he learned to cut them from his Father (who he apprenticed under), and his grandfather. So, certainly that was a technique they used to speed things up.

Here is the paul sellers example:

https://woodworkingmasterclasses.com/2016/04/dovetail-technique/

Paul admits somewhere in there, he'll only do this if he has a bunch of repeat cuts.

You may have to create a log in, but only for the free version. Lot's of good free content in there anyways.

As far as Richard's, I've haven't paid for any of his videos yet, so I only know what we see on the trailer here: http://www.theenglishwoodworker.com/the-side-table-bridle-guides/

, but it's obvious from the trailer how to make these.