Re: Power to hand tool transition
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Josko and all,
Bill T. has the right advice, seconded by others as well.
As to motivation, I think there is a genetic human desire to make things--to see a thing emerge under our own hands. This doesn't necessarily translate to hand tools and past centuries. Years ago, I went to a demonstration by Sam Maloof at his home/workshop. He was 79 at that time--had arms that looked like cables twisted on each other. He had a wall full of shaves and suchlike that people had given him that he didn't use. But he gave us a lecture on making a rocking chair arm, and did it right in front of us. After he made his template marks on the walnut blank, he took it over to his huge bandsaw with a 1" wide blade, turned it on, and started shaving that blank down. His nose was a few inches from the saw blade, and his arms and hands were just flying on both sides and even behind the blade, as he flipped the piece around into position, again and again, shaving closer and closer. He was talking all this time, telling us not to do this at home, though he was happy as a clam, and really loved that machine, which had a story about eastern Europe associated with it. Then he picked up a big 3HP D-handle Porter Cable router, and facing us, held the blank in one hand and the router in the other, and free hand carved and rounded-over that arm. It was tense and transfixing to watch this split-attention demonstration, though the catastrophe never occurred.
Point: Sam visibly enjoyed watching the arm emerge from the blank, even if he had to explain to amateurs as he went. And those machines were not jigged--it was freehand work.
Some tools get you closer to the object you're making, but it's different for every one of us. I would say planing gets more comment on this forum; but for me, there's nothing like sawing for satisfaction, though edge-joining is a supreme pleasure. I enjoy the results of stringing, but do not enjoy doing it, simple as it is, because getting the string planed down to a consistent 25 or 32 thousandths is tense work if it's ebony. To me, bench planing to flatness is a bit of a chore, but edge-joining or ploughing I really love. Mortising is sort of in-between.
So it's all different for each of us. But what is common to us all is getting into a work rhythm where there's nothing but you, the tool and its sounds and feel, and the object as it emerges from the blank. It also goes through my mind in those moments who made the tool.
Wiley