Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Power to hand tool transition

Posts

Power to hand tool transition

#1

Power to hand tool transition

Josko Catipovic

I want to buy a set of mortise chisels. There'd be no reason to post this if I didn't have a hollow chisel mortiser that works just fine. I know it, and I knows me. I'm somehow tempted to do more of my work with hand tools, but I don't quite understand why. Will I cut better mortises by hand? Kind of doubt it. I don't have any mortises planned that my mortiser can't do. Will cutting hand mortises somehow improve my other aspects of woodworking? Dunno. Is it more fun to chisel mortises than do them by machine? Maybe???

I would hope there are folks here who understand this headscratcher that I can't seem to explain to myself. (I'm a hobbyist so can afford the extra time to use hand tools.)

Can somebody help me understand why I'm drawn to this power to hand tool transition?

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#2

Suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For $20 you can do an experiment to decide yourself. Buy one mortise chisel for whatever sized mortises you typically make. I recently tried the Lee Valley Narex and they are quality tools for little money. Once you own a mortise chisel you will see for yourself if you are drawn to using it.

You might be drawn to hand chopping mortises because you find it enjoyable. That is for you to decided. Or, if your interest lies in making stuff you may find that for a few mortises it is easier to chop them by hand than to set up the machine. Or you may find this hand tool exercise tedious today yet change your mind years hence.

If I owned a quality mortise machine I would never pick up a mortise chisel. I find the inexpensive hollow chisel machine I have to be annoying to set up and use. It gets used when there are a lot of mortises to be done.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#3

Re: Power to hand tool transition

david weaver

I'd second the recommendation for Narex that Bill gave you.

And allow yourself to cut a certain number of mortises before you form much of an opinion. Mortise 30 will be far different (and easier) than mortise 1. 30 is probably a round number that I'd use as a minimum before I'd form an opinion (it'll take a while, but you'll be surprised how good you get at it). Kees' video was excellent technique and it would leave you with little to remove in terms of trapped waste.

As far as why you'd do it? Working with hand tools feels good. That's all the reason you need.

There are mortise chisels that don't work that well - I've gotten poorly made vintage sash chisels that bind in the mortise, so going with a known workable chisel is a good idea. Something 1/4th or 5/16th would be a good starting point and be something that you'd be likely to use a lot if you're building furniture.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#4

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Jim Goldrick

I have the same compulsion. It's not logical, I will say that. I just find using hand tools "cool", intriguing, etc. It certainly is not easier, at least for me. At the moment I am learning full blind dovetails in white oak. I've done about 15-20 so far and I think I am staring to get it. But I have a desire to learn hand tools so I keep at it.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#5

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Hank Knight

I've been a "blended" woodworkers for many years. While I use both machines and hand tools in my shop, I generally enjoy hand work much more than machine work. My machines generally take care of the work I consider drudgery - dressing and dimensioning rough stock primarily. Much of my joinery is hand work that I enjoy. That said, I find hand mortising to fall in the drudgery category. I had a Delta bench top mortiser for years and, like Bill, I found it a PITA to use. I hand cut mortises if there were only a few, and resorted the the tailed mortiser only when a large number of mortises justified dragging the beast out and setting it up. A year or so ago, I found an almost new floor standing mortiser for not a lot of money and I snapped it up. It has changed my life. I no longer dread using mortise and tenon joinery. It's so easy and accurate with this machine. My point in writing all of this is to say that I completely understand the attraction of hand tools; it has beguiled me for many years. But The intrigue doesn't extend to hand chopping mortises - at least it doesn't for me. Bill's advice is good: Buy a mortise chisel and see how you like it. It may appeal to you; it's not all that hard. If it doesn't, don't feel defeated if you decide to return to your tailed mortiser. After all, the object of a hobby is enjoyment. If, like me, you don't find hand cutting mortises enjoyable, don't do it. It's that simple.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#6

Re: Power to hand tool transition

John Pappas

In a way, the person who uses hand tools enjoys the journey and the destination, whereas the power tool user is focused more on the destination and less on the journey.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#7

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Josko and all,

Bill T. has the right advice, seconded by others as well.

As to motivation, I think there is a genetic human desire to make things--to see a thing emerge under our own hands. This doesn't necessarily translate to hand tools and past centuries. Years ago, I went to a demonstration by Sam Maloof at his home/workshop. He was 79 at that time--had arms that looked like cables twisted on each other. He had a wall full of shaves and suchlike that people had given him that he didn't use. But he gave us a lecture on making a rocking chair arm, and did it right in front of us. After he made his template marks on the walnut blank, he took it over to his huge bandsaw with a 1" wide blade, turned it on, and started shaving that blank down. His nose was a few inches from the saw blade, and his arms and hands were just flying on both sides and even behind the blade, as he flipped the piece around into position, again and again, shaving closer and closer. He was talking all this time, telling us not to do this at home, though he was happy as a clam, and really loved that machine, which had a story about eastern Europe associated with it. Then he picked up a big 3HP D-handle Porter Cable router, and facing us, held the blank in one hand and the router in the other, and free hand carved and rounded-over that arm. It was tense and transfixing to watch this split-attention demonstration, though the catastrophe never occurred.

Point: Sam visibly enjoyed watching the arm emerge from the blank, even if he had to explain to amateurs as he went. And those machines were not jigged--it was freehand work.

Some tools get you closer to the object you're making, but it's different for every one of us. I would say planing gets more comment on this forum; but for me, there's nothing like sawing for satisfaction, though edge-joining is a supreme pleasure. I enjoy the results of stringing, but do not enjoy doing it, simple as it is, because getting the string planed down to a consistent 25 or 32 thousandths is tense work if it's ebony. To me, bench planing to flatness is a bit of a chore, but edge-joining or ploughing I really love. Mortising is sort of in-between.

So it's all different for each of us. But what is common to us all is getting into a work rhythm where there's nothing but you, the tool and its sounds and feel, and the object as it emerges from the blank. It also goes through my mind in those moments who made the tool.

Wiley

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#8

So many reasons why to do it.

Joseph Piotrowski

First of all is a new skill your learning. So that brings excitement to the mix.

There will be times that it makes sense to do it by machine and other times by hand is more appropriate.

I recently plunged into the hand tools. Even though I was very satisfied with the results of using my power tools. I wasn't happy just being so mechanical. I'm enjoying the new skills and feel more like a woodworker now even with the dodgy results so far.

After a while I might be more of a hybrid Woodworker but is great to know how to complete operations either way.

Personally I'm enjoying the freedom hand tools present. Less jigs, noise and dust thrown about.

The biggest thing you will need to do is learn to sharpen the tools. It's amazing the difference in using the tools when they are sharp. Just when I go wow that's a nice shaving, I get better at sharpening and then I go wow again!

Is worth a small investment to start but Its hard to resist spending more on the hand tools than my machines! 😁

Go for it and enjoy yourself!

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#9

Re: Suggestion

TomD

Better yet, if you are near a place that sell antiques, get some pigstickers. They are better than anything made in the west today, and prices start around 4 dollars but more likely around 10.

You don't really have to have a reason for wanting to use hand techniques. Are you going to fire yourself for not having only the most utilitarian approach to your craft, circumscribed by conventional needs? At the end of the day it is undeniable (at least without massive dollars invested in 5 axis CNC, etc..) that you can do things with hand tools that you can't do with power tools. It's just a fact. But as the saying goes, if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail, or like it needs a nail. Why would any of the mortises you currently can see coming at you not be machinable, it is the only tool and skillset you currently posses. Does that mean mortises only come in forms machines can do, certainly not. If you ease into it, your boundaries will expand, that should be reason enough to do it.

The easiest way to get hand skills is to do at least some of the things you normally do by machine, by hand. You could have a piece that is uniform in look, and has a little extra on one end. You can fire in a hand mortise, and if it doesn't turn out, you can still cut a machine one and trim the hand one off. Go for it.

While this isn't much of a skill builder, when doing 9" deep mortises of 5/16" in stretchers, the best way I can do it is with a mortiser (I have two, plus 3 milling machines, 2 drill presses, and a plunge router) and a very long mortising chisel. So as Klauzs reminds up "hand work is production".

I don't find chisels generally the most productive tools for doing very many things, but they are probably the most versatile tool there is, and so skills learned will be very useful to you in time.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#10

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Kees

Funny, I really like hand mortising. It's kind of getting back to my primitive inner self, or so. I dont like sawing the tenons half as much, probably because I am not very good at doing them.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#11

Re: So many reasons why to do it.

Brian Holcombe

There are plenty of practical reasons for understanding and applying hand tools to your work.

I prefer crisp corners and transitions in my work and planes are really the only way to achieve those. Sanders smooth the transitions that I fight so hard to retain so I avoid using them in my work with few exceptions.

I started using hand tools in my work because I felt that I was a lousy wood machinist. Attempting to use a machine for every task was getting me to the point where I felt I needed to buy the latest and greatest machines and still not getting quite where I wanted to be. Frankly, I could not afford to go the full 'Martin' and did not have the space available to me to do so. I looked around and noticed that people utilizing hand tools were doing extremely accurate work and producing it in relatively small spaces.

As someone who worked in a machine shop I understood accuracy and reference but until I began flatten surfaces by hand I did not understand how relevant hand tool work was to making accurate work without reliance upon factors which I could not affect.

I wanted self reliance but did not have the want to purchase serious machinery required to flatten big surfaces with reliability. Instead I decided to proceed with hand tools and as I began to understand them I also began to understand how their process differs in the most basic aspect. I then also began to form a better understanding of woodworking on the whole and most importantly...Trouble shooting.

Wood machining drives toward making the wood as accurate as possible and utilizing all four surfaces. Any error in the wood will then transfer to an error in the work.

Hand work relies upon making a reference face then a reference corner and relying upon those two surfaces to transfer marks. Eliminating the need to rely upon extremely accurate wood thickness and width removes the errors associated with it.

When you learn how to layout by hand and rely upon your layout, you begin to apply those same principles to woodworking as a whole and can then begin to do accurate work by either method.

Start any place that you like.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#12

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Josko

I am technically a blended woodworker, which means I use both power and hand tools. However, I think of myself as a hand tool worker primarily, with power tools in the background to take up some of the grunt work.

Grunt work is breaking down heavy and large rough sawn boards to manageable sizes, flattening and resawing this into boards that will be used in building furniture. Once this is done, my hand tools take over.

What I especially appreciate about hand tools is the feedback and sense of connectedness to the timber. Hand planes, saws, and chisels offer something here that one cannot experience with a power tool. There is nothing like a shaving peeling out of a handplane or a spokeshave - its sound and shape - to set the heart racing.

My shop is set up to mortice with either a router or a mortice chisel. There are no good or bad tools. I prefer to mortice with a chisel, but I will use the router if it were the better tool for the situation. By contrast, I saw all joinery by hand. I trust my hand more than a machine to achieve the accuracy I seek.

With regard to mortice chisels, the recommendation to purchase a cheap Narex to try out is a good advice. The subtlety of different mortice chisels will be lost on you at this stage. The Narex have a good reputation and should work out of the box. A vintage oval bolstered chisel is excellent, but finding a good one may be tricky. The Ray Iles modern versions are superb but costly, as are the Veritas. These are superior mortice chisels, but there will be time to try them out and compare at a later date.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#13

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Hank Knight

That's probably a big part of why I don't like chopping mortises: I'm not very good at it.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#14

Power tools are better

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"There is nothing like a shaving peeling out of a handplane or a spokeshave - its sound and shape - to set the heart racing. "

Well that may be sufficient stimulation for you but for me a robust kickback from the table saw is a more effective means to get my heart racing. A spoke shave just doesn't yield the same level of adrenalin ;)

Now cuddling my marking gauge, oh, that gets the dopamine going.

(sorry, I couldn't resist. )

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#15

Re: kickback

david weaver

I had the benefit of experiencing a significant kickback early on, below the belt line but just above a very key area. It certainly got the heart racing and caused a flurry of adrenaline and checking "what just happened, is everything OK, should I look in my pants, check my fingers, look at my elbows, where did the board go?"

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#16

Re: sometimes you don't have to be

david weaver

The lovely thing about mortises is that you can chop and make any adjustments that you need to, shimming or whatever. Eventually, that will go away. Whether it does in 30 or 300 joints is probably a matter that differs from person to person. For me, it was about 30, but even if it wasn't, I wouldn't worry too much since most joints are hidden.

If you're into building craftsman style furniture with a lot of through mortises and tenons, that's entirely different. I'd want a power mortiser to build that kind of stuff (But it goes against my nature of covering up end grain).

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#18

another thought

John Pappas

Paul Sellers uses bevel edge chisels to chop mortises. It might not be your long term answer, but you could experiment with chopping mortises using a chisel you already have. I have experimnented with a bevel edge chisel (successfully, I might say), but I prefer using a regular mortise chisel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_NXq7_TILA

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#19

Re: another thought

William Duffield

There are times I have used a hybrid approach, removing the bulk of the material with a drill press and Forstner bit, and finishing up with a bevel edged paring chisel. This saves a lot of chopping and can give a much more precisely fit mortise. It can be especially useful when the mortise is not aligned with the grain direction.

Another reason for using hand tools, even if you still rely on power tools for some of your work, and that doesn't rely on mysticism or that touchy-feely life style stuff that you find in Sellers' and Krenov's writings, is that you can learn a great deal about the physical properties of the particular wood and about your tools, that you can use immediately and in the future to get a better product more easily and more safely, and with less wasted effort and wasted materials.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#20

Re: another thought

Josko Catipovic

Well, thank you all. I think you've succeeded in putting into words a lot of threads that have been running disorganized in my mind. Yes, I'm very intrigueed by this progression to hand tools, ' just to see how it works'. And it's working out well, at least from the enjoyment point of view. Thank you.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#21

Re: Ditto

david weaver

Ditto on the comments about "feeling" and seeing the material a little more. That's a nice side benefit.

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#22

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Ron Harper

I switched about 6 years ago. Frankly, I am not as good a hand tool wood worker as I was with machines BUT, I an having a lot more fun

Re: Power to hand tool transition

#23

Re: Power to hand tool transition

Bob Lang

I'll pile on in the "buy one and see how you like it" camp. There are some good reasons to have a mortise chisel on hand even if you cut mortises with machines. The heft of a mortise chisel makes it ideal to pare a little bit off the end of a mortise made with a hollow chisel machine, or to square the corners of a router cut mortise.

Bob Lang