Badger and panelraiser
Kees
What is the exact difference between badger and panel raiser planes? I googled around, but the names seem to be mixed up and I'm not getting any further.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Badger and panelraiser
Kees
What is the exact difference between badger and panel raiser planes? I googled around, but the names seem to be mixed up and I'm not getting any further.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Kees
I think I can kind of answer my own question, so I probably asked too soon.
A badger is a rabetting plane with a skewed iron. The corner of the iron is poking out at the right side of the plane. So the iron must be leaning over a bit to the left. This means there are three angles, the bedding angle, the skew angle and the lean angle. Makes for a rather complex mathematical puzzle!

A panel raiser, at least in good old England, seems to be a similar plane, but it has it's iron straight up, no lean to the left. In order to get the rabetting feature, a bit of wood has been removed at the right side of the sole, creating a shallow rabbet. Later on in the 18th century these planes got all the bells and whistles, but this example of a Wooding plane is very simple, just a flat sole, the small rabet and a skewed iron.

That's what I found, but I am open for more ideas.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
David weaver
A badger plane is as you've shown-no fixtures. A panel plane has one or two fixtures or fences to set the depth of the fielding or the width of the bevels.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Kees
Well, not neccessarily, if my in depth (ho hum) research is correct.
Richard Arnold, the well known joiner/plane collector from England, published a series about panel raisers recently on Instagram and Facebook. He shows that these planes got more and more features, handles, fences, nickers, depth stops, shaped bottoms, along the years. But the basic model is like the Wooding plane I showed, about 1710. Flat sole, small rabbet on the right hand side of the sole and a skewed but non leaning iron. That's a panel raiser's bare bones. All the rest is extra. It was used slightly tilted , probably with a batten nailed to the panel to be raised.
So I was pretty sure about the panel raiser allready. It was the badger that got me confused. But I think I got the clue now, what distinguishes the badger from the panel raiser is the iron leaning over to the left, so the corner of the iron peeks out of the side right where the sole meets the side of the plane.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
david weaver
I probably didn't say that right. I consider the plane you showed to have a permanent fixture on the side (The rabbet) that you wouldn't find on a badger plane.
As cheap as badger planes are (at least from the UK - the going rate here in the states used to be about $125 for one), I think the easiest way to make a panel raiser would be to find a badger plane and install a moving fillister style fence on the side of it to make an adjustable fielding fence, and install a similar fence on the bottom.
The guilty types who wouldn't ruin a nice plane could easily find one that's not quite so nice, block the front of the mouth (where they are frequently worn) and have a panel raiser for about $20 plus whatever the shipping cost.
(I have a suggestion on making the wedge - one without math. I'll withhold it until you decide on what you are going to build).
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Kees
Hopefully the blade arrives next week. Then I can see what I've got.
It's all to cure a curiosity scratch. I don't really have a need for a panel raiser now and I allready have a Dutch plane able to do the same work, in rather neglected state.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Kees, David, and all,
I am curious about that Wooding plane. Particularly one detail about that rebate on the right side....Does the iron on that side have a sort of upward-angled return, which is sharpened so as to shave (and define) the sides of the field?
My reproduction panel raiser (C&W) has this feature, which is why I ask. Although it is a later 18th century repro, as it has a fence to it, though not a vertical depth stop or a nicker.
Wiley
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Kees van der Heiden
Good question. i would say, No. I didn't find detail pictures of the iron of this plane, but there is a good view of the iron from a 1720 Moody plane on Instagram. Google for "instagram richard arnold", select the correct Richard and scroll down to find all the panel planes. He has quite a collection.
You could also send him an email, i am sure he will respond because he is a very nice chap.

Badger & panelraiser subtle issues to consider
John Aniano in Central NJ
Hello Kees, David and Wiley,
In this discussion, there is a subtle issue I think has not been raised, so to speak!...
In some, but not all true panel raising planes, the sole is often not flat and the angle to the edge of the edge-cut field, not 90 degrees, but something greater. I can illustrate with a picture showing the profiles of a John Bell architectural panel raiser, an English panel raiser and a Badger plane by Malloch & Son. The Bell is single iron, the overstamped "Prince" and the Malloch are both double iron. All have skewed irons.

Although my cell phone image is also skewed (hey, great technology, but often a bit screwy), it shows the Bell profile as flat on the bottom, with a roughly 90+ degree fielding side. The English plane at center shows a distinct non-flat sole so the panel's tongue that is formed is more parallel to fit in the surrounding frame's rail and stile groove. The sole is actually two intersecting flats. Also, the fielding side is almost 30 degrees greater than 90, so about 120 degrees when formed. This prevents an undercut when the plane is tilted when fielding. This is illustrated in the next image showing a sample cut in pine:

The mouths are pictured next - disregard the recess I cut when patching the mouth on the Bell plane. A project still not completed...

The Badger plane corner is 90 degrees, as would be expected for a true rebating plane.

So, just a few extra items to consider!
John
Re: Badger & panelraiser subtle issues to consider
david weaver
Thanks, John - I had a Jon Bell panel raiser very early on (since I'm in PA, they're common here as they probably are where you are - well, as common as a plane of that age could be). It was difficult to use!! I'm guessing they were for large doors or architectural work - to use one in hardwood, I think I'd have needed a hitch on the front and a horse.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
steve voigt
Hey Wiley, any chance you could show us some pictures of the CW panel plane? I don't know they made any.
Re: Badger & panelraiser subtle issues to consider
Kees
Thanks for the pictures. Nice to see so many options.
In the last picture you can see very well how the iron in the badger leans over to the left (viewers right). This allows the iron to peek out through the right side, low down where the side meets the sole, as you can see in the picture before your last picture.
The blade arrived!
Kees
The skewed blade that made me initiating this thread finally arrived! It's brilliant! I made a quick mockup and if I would make a 45 degree bedded panel raiser, then the skew angle would be 20-21 degrees. Does that sound usefull?
It's made by Ward, which started in 1803. Because it has a rather 18th century-ish shape, I'd suggest that it is a very early Ward iron. I totally dig how the capiron has that "Steel" stamp and the coarsly filed surface. It's top is square with bevels, while the cutting blade is round topped. But one of the Seaton chest planes has the same configuration, so probably not unusual.

Re: The blade arrived!
david weaver
20 degrees will be plenty of skew to cleanly cut across the grain. It's also good because if you make a plane with abutments, it will have a chance of surviving (that's about what badger planes are).
Looks good and there's a lot of iron left there.
Re: The blade arrived!
Kees
Yeah and no pitting! I'm happy with it. Now to find some time, don't hold yur breath!
Re: The blade arrived!
david weaver
I agree on your comment: it's old. That style of stamp (presume that has the postage stamp border) and the rounded top. Not that someone couldn't have rounded it, but the stamp is not one I've seen in person and I have quite a few ward irons, many from the mid to late 19th century. *every single one of them has been a good iron, and very consistent (they're all very hard for the era, too)*
I'm guessing some of the old wards that are hard even for ward irons have managed to survive in long lengths because users didn't find them very favorable to hone.
Once you have a chance to cut with it, you can see if the nonsense statements about old irons being inconsistent holds up.
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Steve and all,
Here are some photos of the C&W panel raiser and also a moving filletster.
Just a couple of notes:
1. Panel Raiser.....Skew = 20 degrees
2. Moving filletster.....Boxing and fence are persimmon, a Diospyros (ebony).
https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157681100349591
Wiley
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Kees
Thanks for the pictures Wiley. While browsing through the invenory of some English toolshops I came along this Higgs panel raiser. It has a similar bevel on the side of the blade. Do you really sharpen this, or is it more for clearance?
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Kees and all,
Yes, you do sharpen that upswept return. It actually shaves and shapes the sides of the field. It is angled so that the final profile of the field's walls is not undercut.
If you think about it a moment, as the field deepens with each pass of the iron, the sidewalls change shape slightly, until the final shape is not reached until the final pass. This is why C&W did not include a nicker (which you sometimes see), because the nicker would be fouling the profile.
Having done a few of these panels, I have come to think there was probably a roughing out stage, done with rebate planes, or possibly your badger, with the panel raiser brought in at the end to do the finish work. Similar to the way moldings were planed.
Wiley
Clarification
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Kees,
When I said 'Yes', that the blade's return edge on the field side was to be sharpened, I was referring to the C&W plane. As I look at the Higgins plane, I cannot see that it has this feature--you would expect the blade to look 'clipped' on the field side, if it did. It does look a little rounded there, but I can't truly see that blade's geometry. Perhaps the C&W type iron is historically later in the century.
Wiley
Re: Clarification
Kees
There was another picture, but it isn't quite clear how the return is shaped. If it is sharpened or if it is just extra clearance. It does look like it is 90 degrees to the side of the plane, so it would cause some undercutting. You can see a fold in the bevel on the corner just as if the side has a bevel too.
Those corners are almost always rounded on old blades. On the Ward blade I bought, I need to remove some material too to get a sharp corner again.
How was the panel actually executed?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Kees,
My Guess: The tool and its configuration will reflect the actual procedure to be used. Which could change from time to time. For example, it could be on the Higgins that the only thing required of the 'return' edge, is that it make a sharp base for the field, with no concern for undercutting. The field's edge could be squared up or angled as desired with a rebate plane. Just guessing.
Will mention one bit of personal experience: When I first used mine, I just picked up that panel raiser and make every stroke from first to last with it, with just a few finishing touches with a shoulder plane set fine. It then occurred to me that that was probably a stupid way to go about it, and that someone in the old days doing a whole bunch of these would likely rough in the panel with a rebate plane; maybe define the field with a cutting gauge and maybe a saw; and hold the panel raiser back for the final cuts. Do the rough work, the hogging, with a rebate plane for example. Similar to the way I've been told to use a molding plane.
Reason: You don't want to dull a molding plane (or perhaps a panel raiser) doing the hogging off part of the job. Use a more easily sharpened and maintained tool for that work. Just my 2 cents.
Wiley
Re: Badger and panelraiser
steve voigt
Hi Wiley,
Sorry for the slow response and thanks for the pictures! I am curious about one thing. I notice that the working edge of the fence is perpendicular to the part of the sole that cuts the bevel. Unless I am missing something, this means that in use, only the bottom corner of the fence will ride against the side of the panel, and will not provide any registration.
Looking around, I see that there are plenty of historical examples of this, so it's not an isolated thing. On the other hand, there are also examples of the converse, where the working edge of the fence is beveled, so it will register flat against the edge of the panel when the plane is held at the appropriate spring angle.
So, what is the advantage of doing it one way or the other? I have no experience with panel raisers, so I've no opinion yet…
Re: Badger and panelraiser
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Steve and all,
Well, this is only my guesswork and limited experience.....
I doubt it matters whether the fence's edge is vertical or slightly beveled, so long as it stays put. Here's why....When you start a raised panel, there are some strokes of preliminary planing to hog off the lower part of the bevel. This can be done with the panel raiser, or with a rebate plane. (I suggest don't use your panel raiser to do the roughing.) The panel raiser comes into its own after much of the waste is gone, as you begin to shave down the field wall. Can you visualize that the panel plane is describing an arc--a short segment of a circle--as it works itself lower and lower, shaving by shaving, approaching the final cut when the depth control bottoms out. With a vertical fence, like mine, or with a beveled fence as you describe, the plane will be working itself through a slight arc, working itself lower, exposing more field wall and approaching the final cut. Because of this arc, the plane is creeping lower and inward, shaving by shaving, until it bottoms out.
It seems to me that whether the fence is anchored along its lower edge or along its base as you make the final cuts, the process will be the same. It is the slight inward creep that keeps the fence geometry from making a difference, so long as the fence is anchored along the same line. And remember--there are a range of panel bevel widths and slopes; only one of these will exactly complement the fence bevel.
Start sermon (optional reading!): More generally, these are hand tools. They're not machine tools that you have decided to push. It really is your hand, your eye, your knowledge and decision making that makes the finished surface. With a raised panel, and even with an edge joint, it's not just pushing a plane--you're sculpting it by eye. Here endeth the sermon
.
Wiley
Re: Badger and panelraiser
david weaver
One of my favorite online tool haunts in the UK just got in a continental panel raiser.
http://www.oldhandtools.co.uk/new-arrivals/european-panel-raising-plane---peugeot-freres-1529
Little late on the discussion, and not something I'll buy because I already made one, but I think it's an interesting plane (has both fence fixtures), and look at the length of the cap iron - it is almost as long as the primary iron. You'd question whether or not it was set in the one picture, but the mouth view of the plane suggests it is.