Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

Posts

Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#1

Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I ordered a 1/2" Narex mortise chisel for evaluation.

If you are not embarrassed by having a $20 chisel in you bag this chisel is an acceptable candidate for a mortise chisel.

As received: It appeared nicely made. It arrived with an oval handle with a nice unvarnished grip. Blade was finely ground with sharp edges and flat where it should be. Blade is tapered just enough to release in a deep mortise. Blade was lacquered with something that was not hard to remove by abrasion. (It was insoluble in anything I had on hand.) Bevel was ground at a surprising 25 degrees.

Tuning it up: It took about 20 min to flatten the back and bevel, remove an annoying ding on the corner and sharpen. I added a small additional bevel at 30 degrees. It sharpened like the steel is as abrasion resistant as our typical blade steels. It is certainly harder to grind than Sorby or the Blue handled affairs.

In use: The oval handle enabled it to steer well when chopping. It penetrated well. The tapered blade released easily. Edges of the mortise were shaved sufficiently smoothly by the sharp blade edges. I would prefer a bigger striking area on the top. I suspect I will cut off the ring. To test its robustness I whacked it harder than typical, chopping a 1 1/8" deep mortise in this poplar. It felt up to the task prying out chips, again stressing it more than typical. If it was going to fail I wanted it to fail sooner than later. It held up.

Post evaluation: After the mortise chop I examined the edge with 10X magnification. There was no chipping. There was some deformation which was cured by a quick trip to a 1 micron diamond plate. I may increase the microbevel up past 30 degree for the next trial.

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#2

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

Good review. Please take a look at the post I made in a different thread below, headed 'Narex = Cr-Mn Steel'. There is an extensive write-up on the steel composition and tempering, directly from Narex.

Two excerpts from Narex' write-up are interesting here:

"For mortice chisels grind at 25 and hone at 35 degrees. For paring chisels grind at 20 and hone at 25 degrees.".....

and " Narex chisels are ground before being hardened, so you may find that edge retention improves significantly after the first couple of honings, this is completely normal and once the first couple of millimetres have been sharpened away you will begin to experience what a pleasure Cr-Mn steel is to use. "...

Thanks for the test results!

Wiley

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#3

Re: The paring chisels

david weaver

I haven't had any narex bench chisels, but I did get their paring set when they came out. The set turned out to be too bulky and heavy for me, but the steel was very satisfactory. I remember it having a desire to hold its wire edge for a while compared to old steel, but it was workable.

"real" paring chisels in the US are really expensive, but there are several UK tool dealers who will sell old marples, ward, sorby etc chisels that are ground properly for about $30-$40 each. A lot of the US tool dealers seem to think the same chisels are $100 each - thank goodness for the internet and global shipping.

At any rate, if anything, the steel reminded me of the bright steel that's in two cherries chisels that seems to be a bit strong holding its wire edge - maybe a click softer than 2 cherries. Not nearly as strong at holding it as V11, though.

As another aside, the price of narex chisels is just below the price of oval bolster chisels from England if you have some patience to get a set, but I'm sure they take less time to prepare.

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#4

thanks for extra information

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They are good value indeed. If I was to buy the bench chisels I would simply rehandle them.

The mortise chisel had a handle that suits me to near perfect.

These tools are obviously a well thought out product. And I like that they are thoughtful in telling about the manufacturing process.

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#6

Re: forgot the PIC

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Had I known you were interested, you could have tried out the Narex mortises I have. My impression is the same as yours, they do a good job, hold an edge. I'm not wild about the handle, though.

Re: Evaluation of Narex Chisel from Lee Valley

#7

Re: forgot the PIC

david weaver

Pretty much looks like a piece of drill rod that a mill cut four sides off of.

Handles a lot like the stubai chisels I got a hold of.