Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sargent plane

Posts

Sargent plane

#1

Sargent plane

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Fixed up a Sargent #4 for son-in-law this weekend. I have a fair amount of experience grinding Stanley blades. Club members come by to get lessons on hollow grinding and in general sharpening. Stanley steel grinds easily, the most easily of anything I have ground. It makes sense these blades would be optimized for the abrasives of that day.

This Sargent blade ground more like a modern steel. It took a long time to grind away the camber and establish a new bevel angle. I set him up with abrasive sheets and in no time he had a blade that made nice shavings on a test piece. Amazing what a useful tool one can find for $20.

Re: Sargent plane

#2

Re: Sargent plane

david weaver

Agree on the usefulness. I don't know if that's universally true of sargent (the harder grinding), I've had two, but never got along with either quite as well as the stanley.

As to the stanley planes, there has been a noticeable difference in some of the irons. Some of the old laminated irons were almost as hard as modern irons. The irons from the '70s are almost down to saw temper. The irons in between there are just lovely, especially on an oilstone.

Any of them are lifetime tools aside from possibly needing to replace an iron if you could manage to work your way through one - something no amateur will do with proper grinding and honing.

The English have it even better. Their record planes are about 20 pounds over there pretty much all the time, and they are the equal of the stanley planes but with laminated irons through a much later time. The SS planes with a two piece cap are heavier-made. The wooden planes over there are absurd. I bought a try plane from over there for the equivalent of about $35 (it cost another $35 to ship). It had a brand new ward double iron in it. I couldn't make a better plane (it did need a little bit of refitting, but after that) with $100 in materials. The response I heard from their folks on the UK forum was essentially "i'd never pay $35 for a plane. That's too much".

Pretty sure that in the days those planes were made, they'd have cost a journeyman a day's wage - until later in time when wooden planes became really cheaply made and cost half as much new as a stanley.

Re: Sargent plane

#3

Re: Sargent plane

Darren Brewster

That matches my experience as well. A couple of Sargent planes are my go-tos and they seem very hard. Even raising a wire edge on my stones seems to take more effort.