Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Shopping note on a slow day

Posts

Shopping note on a slow day

#1

Shopping note on a slow day

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Gentlemen,

Why is it that free shipping is a powerful magnet? Seems like it shouldn't be that way--dollars is dollars isn't it? Anybody know? Today being the last day for this session of LV free shipping, I kinda drifted over there. Slow like, after reading the news looking for a grain of corn. Just looking. At sharpening stuff.

Then: 10,000K Sigma Power. All those zeros, doncha know.

Then I found out something. If you're US, you need to select US up at the top of the LV homepage. Somehow mine had gotten onto Canadian, so I was looking at quotes in Canadian money. They have their own money. At checkout, What a goodly surprise! When do surprises ever be good? Toast falls butter side down, but not this time. I may have to go back.

Wiley

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#2

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you use the Woodcentral link it come up in US dollars.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#3

Free shipping...

John in NM

Just some random ideas -

People like free shipping because then the price advertised is what they pay rather than some figure slightly over that. I've noticed that people fix on a figure and remember that rather than remembering a formula of several figures. Not that I know anything on the subject, but I would bet that the part of the brain that associates that single $$$ figure with an object is the same as the part that likes shopping, yet different than the part that analyzes costs and does arithmetic.

Similarly, people like being offered a "deal" even if it's a minor savings. They get a positive feeling from it and tend to like vendors who offer them a deal.

The flip side of that is that people hate to feel like they got took - and seeing a great deal on something they want gets spoiled when they get to the checkout and realize shipping makes up the difference and then some. Not that the vendor is actually trying to cheat them, its just the gut reaction people will have.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#4

I did my part....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I ordered pulls for a future chest of drawers and a half inch Narex mortise chisel to try.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#5

Re: I did my part....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Where are you going to make 1/2" mortises? Or is this just a size you've always wanted?

Wiley

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#6

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

John Schtroumpf

I ordered the MINI-BUS :)

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#7

Re: Free shipping...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"people like being offered a "deal" even if it's a minor savings. They get a positive feeling from it and tend to like vendors who offer them a deal."

I find myself fitting that theory. For example, I do grocery shopping at a Safeway affiliate. There comes a particular point in the checkout where the register has rung up the top line, and then it starts counting backward as it rings up the specials. Sometimes the price will come down $75 or $90, from say $350 to something in the high $200's. I love watching that thing count downward and get under $300! I won!! Isn't that the dumbest thing you've ever heard. I get home and tell my wife how much we saved, and she just laughs and laughs, like there's one born every minute. Which there is.

Wiley....fessing up

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#8

Would that be the

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

mini bevel-up smoother?

Wiley

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#9

Yes

John Schtroumpf

"Would that be the mini bevel-up smoother?

Wiley"

Yes

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#10

Lots of places and an experiment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When we made tools, somehow I never made the 1/2" mortise chisel. 1/8, 1/4, 5/16, 3/8 but no 1/2" . I have used them all(3/8 rarely) but had to borrow a 1/2" for bench, bed and large table mortises.

I have been curious about the Narex chisels and with Free Shipping! it became a cheap experiment. I get suckered into buying something every time LV has free shipping. With a sample in hand I can get the steel analyzed and see what it is, in fact. And I will pound on it to test its toughness. I have used chisels enough by now that I can assess the steel in short order through use.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#11

Re: Lots of places and an experiment

Kees van der Heiden

Oh no! Now you'll never receive it! The composition of the steel is a trade secret...

(Allthough Narex themselves say it is a traditional Cr-Mo steel).

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#12

traditional Cr-Mo steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anybody know what that means in fact?

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#13

Re: traditional Cr-Mo steel

Kees

Something like 4161, but with more carbon so it can be hardened to 59 HRc?

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#14

Re: traditional Cr-Mo steel

Steve Voigt

*traditional* Cr Mo seems a bit of an oxymoron. ;)

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#15

Narex chisels = chrome manganese *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Kees, Bill, and all,

Here is Narex' writeup on their chisel steel:

http://www.narexchisels.com/Narex_Chisels/Narex_Cr-Mn_Steel.html

It's low-alloy, high carbon and isothermally tempered, which they explain in great detail in the link.

I couldn't find a standard AISI chrome-moly steel with C content higher than 0.6%.

Wiley


Narex chisel steel, Cr-Mn

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#16

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Kees

Sorry for the confusion. I read Cr-Mo where I should have read Cr-Mn.

Mn, manganese is the stuff you find for example in O1 to slow down the quench time, so you can harden it in oil instead of water.

Mo, Molybdenum is one of the wear resistant alloys in steel. It makes heat resistant carbides, it helps to avoid oxidation of the iron in some stainless steels. It is used in high speed steels, like M2.

Chrome Moly is used often in tools like spanners.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#17

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Kees,

I'm glad this topic came up. I learned something, actually a couple or three things. Note to self: don't ever think Lee Valley just carries 'house brand' stuff. The name 'Narex' had me imagining that this was just a cheap no-name line they carried.

I was wrong about that. LV doesn't do that, in the first place. I found this page in the Narex story, giving its history as a small but high quality tool maker:

http://www.narexchisels.com/Narex_Chisels/Narex_Bystrice.html

Narex use isothermal tempering, or austempering, as discussed in the previous link, was also an interesting piece of knowledge.

Thanks to Bill for his review, and for you to bringing up the composition.

Wiley

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#18

I have a couple of their bench chisels...

John in NM

Excellent value, they are on a par with my Sandvik's that I bought for $6 each at a used tool store in Tucson.... I always wanted pretty bench chisels like Ashley Iles or Blue Spruce, but when there are durable options at such reasonable prices the cheap gene always kicks in! :D

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#19

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Kees

That is the first time I see someone using austempering for chisels. I didn't know you could get the steel hard enough with a bainite structure.

When reading up on all things steel, I came along this austempering but didn't really pay much attention. It is not very suitable for the backyard shop. Working with molten salts is as dangerous as it gets! I am sure they have a good handle on it in the Narex factory, but the idea of blowing up my garage (with me inside) didn't really appeal to me...

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#20

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Steve Voigt

I looked into it too. Here's an abstract from one article:

Traditionally it have been reported that bainite microstructure has better impact properties than tempering martensite at the same hardness level. In this work a comparative study was performed using samples of 2 different steels: SAE 4140 and SAE O1 (tool steel) under different heat treatment conditions: austempering; quenching and tempering followed or not by a cryo bath. At the total 47 samples were Charpy impact tested. Hardness, microscopy (optical and SEM) and fractography analysis were performed. No matter the steel analyzed, better performances were obtained for the tempering martensite followed by the cryo bath.


I should add that I haven't read the actual paper (it's paywalled) and I don't have the technical chops to evaluate the claim, but I thought it was interesting. Reading the Narex page on heat treating, it seems pretty clear that they chose the isothermal route not to make a better tool, but because it's easier to manufacture (once it's set up). Same reason that other companies go the A2 route; it's done for ease of production, not tool quality. All the claims about how wonderful the steel is are just rationalization for a more profitable process.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#21

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Kees

I could read a bit more form that article from the Sao Paulo university. Here is the conclusion:

Conclusions

Considering the heat treatment parameters and test conditions performed in this work it can be concluded that for

same hardness level quenching and tempering followed by cryogenic bath gave better performance in terms of

impact toughness for both studied steels. Even comparing with tempered martensite without cryogenic bath, bainite

microstructure did not show higher values of absorved energy.

They presume that the apparently better impact resistance of bainite in previous studies, was due to the quenched steel in those was tempered in the embrittlement temperature range, which would have reuced the impact resistant of the traditional method quite a bit.

In the Sao Paulo study they found that the traditional method of quenching and tempering gave far better impact resistance results then the austempering method. And indeed, cryotempering bettered those results even further.

The two steel types were tested at 40 HRC (pretty soft for a chisel!). I guess that is as hard as 4140 ever gets. O1 can be hardened to much higher values of course. But now we of course don't know if the same test results would be valid for the Narex steel at 59 HRC.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#22

Re: Narex chisels = chrome manganese

Kees

No, 4140 can be hardened to higher values, but not as high as O1. I posted a bit too quickly, like I usually do...

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#23

The bottom line of it all

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Narex chisel was significantly more robust than the Sorby bench shisels I had/tested and about equivalent to Two Cherries, each costing substantially more.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#24

how to judge success

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Narex seems to be able to make a chisel that performs better than the Sorby chisels I had, and about as good as the Two Cherries I owned and tested a while back.

Maybe their goal was not to use the best steel they could find like the LV $80 chisels,but to deliver good value in a $20 chisel through choice of steel and manufacturing process. If the goal was value, I think they succeeded.

Re: Shopping note on a slow day

#25

For practical purposes..

david weaver

..the V11 steel (presume that LV makes that in some mortise chisels) and the steel in the narex chisels are about the same.

If someone has a long sharpening routine, they won't think that - maybe. Both types have about the same work time vs. sharpening time for me, though. And to be honest, I'd rather have the steel that raises a wire edge on a washita stone.

I think most of the current buying public would prefer the opposite, though.

I have had vintage chisels that were not as good in use as the narex shape that you're showing. If they are as big as a 2 cherries chisel, though, I probably would prefer something that's about 2/3rds as massive. I bought MHG's version of those a LONG time ago, and sent them back, as the ones I got had edge holding problems. They were so large that they're bigger than the I&H sorby oval bolstered chisels that I got - by a fairly large amount.