Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

For all who have built a kitchen

Posts

For all who have built a kitchen

#1

For all who have built a kitchen

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have been reading a marvellous book by Nancy Miller, "Making Things Work". This is the story of her life as a cabinetmaker. I really recommend this to any aspiring amateur seeking to turn pro. I think I shall remain a happy weekend warrior.

One of the paragraphs that leapt off the page was this .. "You might imagine that full-overlay doors and drawer faces make for the simplest-possible installation. They do - when these elements have enough space between them to make any inconsistencies in the margins unnoticeable...... each adjustment of one door or drawer in any of its three planes affected every other one nearby. Not only did the margins need to be consistent, parts in such close proximity must also be in plane. For example, if the right edge of one drawer protruded even just a little relatove to its neighbor, the neighbor, too, had to be adjusted ... ".

I think Nancy wrote this to mock me as I began installing doors and drawers this weekend.

The installation so far. My work in Hard Maple ...



Lots still to do ...

I cannot wait to get back to building furniture!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#2

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

William Duffield

I cannot wait to get back to building furniture!

It looks like furniture from here. I like you clean, neat design. Very nice work.

There must be some reason mine were always fully inset doors and drawers in face frames.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#3

Problem solved

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Through dumb luck I used this hinge on the first kitchen I built. I didn't fail to take advantage of its convenience the second time around.

Daughter's kitchen in recently purchased house has doors like yours, 12' of them in a row. I gave up in despair getting them all adjusted.

I was not optimistic that a kitchen of plain maple was going to look attractive, but I was wrong.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#4

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

david weaver

Looks good, Derek.

I worked in a cabinet factory (not a woodworking shop, a straight up do one thing over and over all day factory with 500 employees) when I was in college.

I still do remember what we sold a lot of back then (1996-1998) at the height of loose credit in the US (which translated to the first real wave of people pulling money out of their house to get improvements done).

We had light and dark oak doors, the light oak were the biggest sellers back then by a wide margin (it was the era of honey oak and brass hardware). White RTF was the second biggest seller - I hated the looks of those, they looked like plastic, I guess because the cover on the doors is similar to plastic. Probably about 10-20% of the sales were plain maple and red stained maple, which is still popular now, including flat panel doors like yours. I could tell back then that they looked better than the rest of the stuff, and the wood characteristics were much more desirable to look at and touch.

They (the maples) have stood the test of time well, and will do so for a long time. The rest of the stuff we made in droves...not so much.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#5

What hinge, Bill?


Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#6

Re: What hinge, Bill?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Note how much lighter the inside of the ash cabinet is after 25 years.

And the cabinets were all built chugging along in first gear with a dull plane and a poorly set cap iron, but a strong motivation to build stuff, in this case our second house.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#7

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

steve voigt

That looks good, Derek. It's the spitting image of a kitchen I built in Brooklyn about 10 years ago. Wish I could find those pictures. Are you using Euro hinges?

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#8

Re: What hinge, Bill?

steve voigt

I could be wrong, but I don't think those will work for full overlay like Derek has. I think there are similar ones that work, but they are bulky contraptions. The Euro (cup) hinges are pretty good though, much better now than in the old days.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#9

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

Yep, euro hinges. They are a different design to those posted by Bill. The ones I have are made by Grass ..


I am not sure if they are any easier to adjust - all these bloody hinges will try the patience of a saint. :(

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#10

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

Kees van der Heiden

Looks good Derek, very stylish.

I recognise the comment about adjusting those doors. The Euro cup hinges have quite a bit of adjustablity, but still... It all starts with the cabinets themselves and the often very crooked walls and floors. It takes some attention to get them to line up nicely in the first place. And then, the door of my sink cabinet has warped considerably over the years, despite using quarter sawn wood for the rails and styles. So that one doesn't look so hot anymore.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#11

problem solved, not equivalently

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...the problem being alignment.

These hinges are a seldom used option for those that want a hidden hinge and don't mind frame exposure. Because they are seldom used I thought it useful to introduce them.

The idea behind overlay doors as they are executed in "modern" kitchens is to minimize door frame exposure as well as hide the hinges. Minimizing door frame exposure leads to the problem Derek encountered. Kitchens and cabinetry hung in them does not have the precision of a well made chest of drawers. The European style hinges enable some adjustment. In the case of my daughter's house it leads to 9 degrees of freedom(doors) to be diddled with to get the reveals equivalent.

In my case I wanted to not see hinges and but didn't care if frames were exposed. The use of rift grain in the door frame and cabinet frame result in a blended look. Lipped doors are self aligning, if the case is square so the adjustment problem is eliminated.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#12

Re: For all who have built a kitchen 

Jim Matthews

I've followed this closely, contemplating a similar remodel.

I believe this may latest entry may explain the phrase -

"He came unhinged" - when the most difficult sequential task is the last part of a project.

It looks terrific. As always, I would be proud to call such fine work my own.

Kudos


img

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#13

Re: What hinge, Bill?

William Duffield

Maybe one of these would work for your application?

https://www.brusso.com/li-97/?utm_source=Brusso+Hardware+Newsletter&utm_campaign=0b359d6020-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2017_03_10&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_c537605627-0b359d6020-113147465&mc_cid=0b359d6020&mc_eid=19b8135e60

But, you'd better sit down before you scroll down to the price. :D

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#14

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

Jeff Heath

Nice work, Derek.

There are euro-style 35mm hinges available that allow for a 3/8" rabbeted inset door, just like Bill's picture.

They mount just like the one's you show in your picture, except that they are designed to work with the 3/8" inset rabbeted door.

I just finished a big job using them, as the customer insisted upon this door style, which kept the new cabinetry in period to their mid-century modern home, which they were doing a complete remodel on, but wanted custom cabinetry throughout.

The hinges are $50 a set, so not as bad as the $112 brass ones, but still pretty pricey for hinges on a kitchen with 30 doors.....

I said it before, but this time I swear by it.....that was my very last kitchen job....EVER.

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#15

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

TomD

How is it possible the grass hinges are hard to adjust, they are the dead easiest ever. That is their raison d'être. Do you just mean is it is hard because of the multiple doors? The adjustments are simple: I have gone into non-woodworker's kitchens, and fixed them all in a mater of minutes.

The guy who lived here before me was a cabinet maker, and he made some Krenov inspired (I would guess) doors for his kitchen. He was a solid woodworker, his joints are clean, but he did stuff like use flat sawn oak for the doors. The result is that decades hence, not all the doors are flat, or all the screw solid, and the doors can't be made perfect, and the drawers, they were not as well worked out. So it isn't possible to make everything perfect around here, but it has nothing to do with the hinges. which are the euro type.

Given your Ubermensch woodworking skills, Derek, the elements have to be right on, so what is the problem the hinges can't solve

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

#16

Re: For all who have built a kitchen

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

The hinges I am using come from the previous kitchen, which was about 25 years old. All use the same hinge as I have shown above, with the exception of the pantry. In general, replacing the doors using the old hinges (and old carcases) has been straightforward unless an adjustement is needed in the vertical. These hinges are finicky in this regard. For the remainder, I just needed to be accurate in transfering the hinges to the new doors.

The exception has been the corner pantry. This has a split door and is required to open wider, so has 170 degree full overlay hinges. Setting up this particular door has been very hard work. The Grass hinges in this situation have been difficult to adjust and now one has locked up in full extended position. As currently installed, the split door works adequately - sits well when closed, but the split sections do not remain aligned when the door is opened. From this I suspect that the frame on the one side is slightly out-of-straight. I shall pull it apart and check where it is not plumb, then set it up again, replacing the hinges with newer versions.

Regards from Perth

Derek