Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Setting the cap iron

Posts

Setting the cap iron

#1

Setting the cap iron

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As part of son-on-laws training we watched the Kato video. I had not watched it in a long time. (we also abandoned his near useless modern "plane" he owned and conditioned a Millers Falls #4 for service that I had bought at some flea market years ago)

It struck me upon watching it this time that tear-out was suppressed by a cap iron setting well removed from the close setting that straightened the shaving. This observation left me wondering if I have been setting it closer than necessary. Thoughts?

Re: Setting the cap iron

#2

Re: Setting the cap iron

david weaver

I used the term back stop in the article posted on here. As far as your asking the question, I don't know if it's related to the 80 degree cap iron angle where the shaving was further from the edge. It's been too long since I watched the video.

There is some influence on a shaving before there is so much that it straightens. Or to be clearer, there is some reduction of tearout without having to straighten a chip.

I usually (99% of the time or more) set the cap iron so that it will straighten out a significant shaving, but not do much to a thinner one. I only set it closer in the rare instance that a shaving between those can generate some tearout. A "back stop" setting that keeps you from doing what you can encounter with an errant stroke of a single iron plane - huge tearout pried off the surface of the wood.

Re: Setting the cap iron

#3

Re: Setting the cap iron

Hank Knight

I don't know if this has any relevance to your question, Bill, but I have Never been able to set the cap iron on my Norris A5 as hair-splittingly close as then Kato video would seem to suggest. If I do, other cap iron chokes the mouth of then plane and everything comes to a halt. I set it back about 1/16" to 3/32" from the edge and still get excellent results. My Norris isn my go-to smoother; I get better results from it than I do from by Stanleys with the cap irons set close.

Re: Setting the cap iron

#4

Re: Setting the cap iron

david weaver

Early A5?

I just got a later one in the mail, and it's got enough room (and a well designed cap iron) to set the cap iron close.

If you are getting better results with a close mouth than you get with a cap iron, something is wrong with the cap iron setup or setting.

But, you use what works.

I find the A5 to work about as well as my favorite stanley. Both with the cap iron set will (unfortunately) beat my 55 degree smoother with a mouth in the 3-4 thousandth range, though it's rare to find wood difficult enough so that the latter won't plane it well in the first place.

Not to suggest there's anything special about my favorite stanley, they are all the same when it comes to setting the cap iron. What makes it "favorite" has more to do with the proportions and its smoothness of adjustment.

Re: Setting the cap iron

#5

Re: Setting the cap iron

Hank Knight

"Early A5?"

I wish! No, mine is a post war model. The issue of choking the mouth has to do with the iron. Mine has an after-market iron that is a little thicker than the original Sorby iron. That little difference is all takes to prevent setting the chip breaker close. But, as I said, it works great even with the chipbreaker set back a little.

I probably erred when I said my Norris outperforms my Stanleys. My Stanley's work fine and I can get nice gossamer shavings with them. But that has not always been so - it's a long story that I will spare you. Suffice it to say that I got my Norris up and running long before my Stanleys, and I developed a preference for it that persists to this day. I posted my original comments to respond to Bill's remarks about the necessity, or lack thereof, of setting chip breakers hair-splittingly close as suggested by the Kato article. I get wonderful results from my Norris with the chipbreaker set back a little.

Re: Setting the cap iron

#6

Re: Setting the cap iron

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have Never been able to set the cap iron on my Norris A5 as hair-splittingly close as then Kato video would seem to suggest. If I do, other cap iron chokes the mouth of then plane and everything comes to a halt. I set it back about 1/16" to 3/32" from the edge and still get excellent results. My Norris isn my go-to smoother; I get better results from it than I do from by Stanleys with the cap irons set close.

Hank, I wonder what the shape of the leading edge of the cap iron is like - rounded, sharpish? Have you increased its angle?

I was surprised to find that the cap iron worked so well on my Spier since the mouth is quite tight. I suspect that the slightly higher bed (47 1/2 degrees) offers a little leeway, that is, the cap iron does not need to be quite as close as a plane with a common angle (45 degree) bed.

The Veritas Custom #4 has a 40 degree bed, and the leading edge of the cap iron is 50 degrees. I am thinking of increasing this to 55- or 60 degrees as it requires that the distance is a little less than a common angle frog of either a LN #3 or a Stanley #3, both of which have 50 degree leading edges.

I am still surprised when I read of others setting the cap iron about 0.1mm from the edge of a blade. If I did this, all I would experience is a plane struggling to cut and creating very concertina-like shavings. Generally, I find somewhere around 0.3 - 0.4mm works on my smoothers when taking fine shavings. A smidgeon more if using the jointer and taking thicker shavings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Setting the cap iron

#7

Re: Setting the cap iron

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You probably have been often setting the cap iron closer than necessary. You were only interested in a one-size fits-all setting, and have dismissed any suggestion that skill and judgement were involved. You are stuck driving in first gear just to avoid stalling.

Setting the cap iron is an art. The best surface comes from having the cap set as far away as you can get away with, not jammed up close enough so that it works for every situation. As I wrote ten years ago on this forum: It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it [the cap iron].

Re: Setting the cap iron

#8

Re: Setting the cap iron

Brian Holcombe

Depends on the wood and thickness of shaving. In normal planing I would not typically set it that close but there are times when it is very very close to the point where I can see a very small sliver of light on the iron.

I haven't measured the settings in a number of years.

Re: Setting the cap iron

#9

Re: I agree on that, and maybe I..

david weaver

..need perspective sometimes. It definitely does take a little bit to make a stanley the way you want it, plus some time invested.

I'll bet if I put a thicker iron in the A5 that I have, most people would prefer it because there are fewer variables.

I think most people would prefer my scratch made infill to my stanley's too, because they'd feel safe with it. That being the reason I made it that way.

The one surprise with my norris is that the bottom was horribly out of flat, and not in a way that planed well. It would skip across a freshly jointed board, but not take a full shaving. I have lapped all of my stanley planes, just because I have a good lapping setup. They haven't all required it, but some have (at least to get a reasonable level of performance smoothing).

(I did look for a decent pre-war norris, but at this point, I'm not sure what the advantage to it would be other than that the mouth might be tighter, it might be slightly heavier, and the wood would have a lower shrinkage factor. The fact that the one I got with beech infills works as well as my stanley makes me pleased. It actually couldn't work any better - there's not a thing loose or out of place in it).