Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planing MDF

Posts

Planing MDF

#1

Planing MDF

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lets broaden our thoughts to machining. Apparently it is well known in the trade that MDF "wears" cutters by both abrasive and corrosive wear. This fact is readily revealed by checking the machining MDF literature or consultation with tool makers and tooling coaters. Corrosion resistant coatings prolong tool life. I have wondered for some time why a simple mix of wood fibers and resin (which is not particularly hard and abrasive) leads to a material, MDF, that requires carbide, where the corrosion resistance of the cobalt binder is essential, or coated tool steel to get acceptable edge life.

Could it be that the LV test using MDF was biased toward steel with corrosion resistance, an attribute irrelevant to ordinary wood planing?

Re: Planing MDF

#2

Re: Planing MDF

Paul in NJ

Perhaps they used mdf because of its uniformity, one less variable to worry about. We all know that wood properties can vary from board to board within the same species.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Planing MDF

#3

MDF is not uniform

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

MDF is more dense at the top and bottom surfaces as a result of the manufacturing process. They likely used MDF because they were in a hurry and wanted a result quicker than they would have gotten from relevant wood.

Re: Planing MDF

#4

Re: Planing MDF *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Could it be that the LV test using MDF was biased toward steel with corrosion resistance, an attribute irrelevant to ordinary wood planing?

Hi Bill

From what I have read, MDF will certainly test corrosion resistance. Whether this biases the testing towards corrosion resistant steel is another matter. What do you believe is the degree involving abrasion resistance?

My own understanding is that MDF was simply chosen as it presents a medium that enables the testing to be more easily replicated by others - this is the essence of scientific research.

I came across an interesting article (link below), in which the researchers commented on MDF as follows:

Medium density fibreboard are more homogeneous materials than solid natural wood, but wood is an anisotropic material, while wood-based materials (MDF) can be assumed as a stock of several isotropic layers (Boucher et al. 2007), consequently density distribution on the board thickness almost follows a parabolic curve (Fig. 2). On the other hand, MDF is more abrasive than natural wood (Labidi et al. 2005).

Regards from Perth

Derek


APPLICATION OF SURFACED CUTTERS FOR MACHINING OF W

Re: Planing MDF

#5

Just a guess..

david weaver

..but I would figure that it's also preferable because it accelerates the testing somewhat vs. using wood. It seems like a good idea, I just have seen differences in wear in different materials where the "easy" materials don't have the same spread as something "abusive" like MDF would.

I regard this method as far more accurate, though, than one that's commonly done with chisels - which is to bash them as hard as possible into something hard so that the testing can be done quickly.

At least in your testing, you have shown us how far chisels will go in actual work. And then because of that, of the chisels you have that I also have, I can see that your experience matches mine, and thus I can rely on your results rather than guessing "what ifs".

Re: Planing MDF

#6

Then a poor choice was made

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"My own understanding is that MDF was simply chosen as it presents a medium that enables the testing to be more easily replicated by others "

While a given lot of MDF from a single supplier will likely be uniform there is nothing uniform about MDF products. They will differ some in density, a lot in what wood source is used and what resin is used and how much resin and other components are used, and what pressure, temperature, and time it is mashed at. The MDF we used in the Latta shop was significantly harder than what I can get locally, for example.

I think the true reason MDF was used was that LV was in a time bind to make a steel decision. MDF simply showed wear differences among steels in less feet of planing. If you study the planing research of Elliot or Kato one sees that it takes hundreds of feet of planing to establish the behavior of the metal over its useful edge life.

The problem with accelerated testing, no matter the research, is that one needs to know a lot about the process to choose an accelerated test that is meaningful.

A friend made plane blades from M4 and 3V. M4 grinds so slowly (abrasion resistant) that he was charged a substantial premium to surface grind it, even compared to 3V! When PMVII seemed to be equivalent in an accelerated abrasion resistance test to M4 it should have been a red flag that the accelerated test was flawed, and not that PMVII was magically as abrasion resistant as a steel loaded with wear resistant carbide forming elements.

Re: Planing MDF

#7

Look at it a different way

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, you appear to have only taken notice of part of my observation - that MDF is a medium for easier replication. Yes, MDF varies, but within one experimental episode it stands a better chance of offering the same conditions for a variety of steels on test. Wood, by contrast, is far more variable, not only from tree to tree, but within each tree. The aim of experimentation is to find methods/conditions that may be replicated by others.

The other point I made was bound up in the question I asked you: "What do you believe is the degree involving abrasion resistance?" You will recognise that MDF is more abrasive than wood (that is stated in the quotation). Abrasion speeds up wear. Speeding up tests in a uniform way is very reasonable and, in fact, desirable when time is not free.

Bottom line: I really doubt that Lee Valley would have entered into a test that would predetermine the results and bias them towards their chosen steel. They were testing a lot of steels (I was one of several testers for them, each in our own way, at the same time), and the aim was to discover if any steel types offered an advantage over A2 and O1.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing MDF

#8

Or another way...

John in NM

Why perform a test with a material that the end user will never use? That is adding uncertainty, not reducing it.

The test was likely flawed, because the results are clearly contradictory. Bill's corrosive wear theory sounds pretty likely to account for the contradictory results.

One of the most important parts of the scientific method is skepticism. If your results seem too good to be true - an abrasion resistant, easy to sharpen blade for example - assume it is too good to be true and figure out what gave you the unrealistic result. It's a good practice, because if you don't do it, someone else probably will!

All that said, I still don't believe there is anything untoward here. Just a poorly conceived test that yielded a mistaken conclusion.

Re: Planing MDF

#9

Re: Or another way...

Kees

100% agree. I don't think LV set out to design a fraud experiment. They just didn't think it all through carefully enoug. How they deterimined the amount of abrassion is also weird. They didn't meassure sharpness, no, they looked at the scratch patterns on the face adjacent to the edge with a microscope and scored these in a subjective manner ( no measurement, just looking). But we are not interested in those scratches. We are interested in how the edge looks like after a bunch of planing and what the worn edge does in the wood. I haven't seen any other article in the literature that tests edge wear like this ( allthough I haven't read everything of course).

Just to be sure, in real wood the shaving tends to polish the face of the edge to a pretty high degree. The scratches are typical for MDF.

Re: Planing MDF

#10

Re: Planing MDF

John Schtroumpf

"Could it be that the LV test using MDF was biased toward steel with corrosion resistance, an attribute irrelevant to ordinary wood planing?"


I question your whole hypothesis. Corrosive wear in the absence of a contaminate, would be triggered by heat causing interactions between the materials and/or the air. Your stating that corrosive wear doesn't apply in the case of hand planing wood, implies a lack of heat (due to lower speeds involved), which would likely also not be present in the case of hand planing mdf.

Re: Planing MDF

#11

Spoken like....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....you have been around research projects and seen them poorly designed and interpreted. Amen to all you said. There is a reason for peer review of research results before publication. Company's can hide a poorly designed experiment with " Confidential", but the rest are subject to embarrassment.

Re: Planing MDF

#12

Absence of Heat

david weaver

While an iron does not get heated through and through, the cutting edge can be heated in hand planing. I don't think it takes that much speed to heat it, either.

I recall reading something about stropping razors heating the very edge, which I thought was odd - of course I have no way to measure that.

You can warm an iron with hand planing if you plane for a while. The other thing that pops into my head is hand scrapers, though I don't know how they compare to planing. You can burn your thumb on a scraper in one or two strokes.

Re: Planing MDF

#13

Re: Spoken like....

Kees van der Heiden

Of course one shouldn't forget that http://www.pm-v11.com/story.aspx# is not a scientific research paper, it is an advertorial. It leaves out all the relevant data.

Who knows, equating PMV-11 to M4 may just be their way to communicate that PMV-11 is great stuff and worth purchasing.

Re: Planing MDF

#14

Re: Absence of Heat

William Duffield

Of course, it is much more difficult to get your thumb down into the mouth of a plane to find out how hot the edge is getting than with a card scraper.

A plane blade is thicker, and therefore carries the heat away from the edge faster than a scraper. A thicker blade should dissipate heat faster than a thin blade. A double blade plane has more thermal mass close to the edge than a single blade plane. The closer you set the chip breaker, the better it should dissipate heat from the edge. A metal plane with a chip breaker has more thermal mass than a wooden plane or even than an infill plane. Do different steel formulations dissipate heat at significantly different rates? My hypothesis is that these differences should affect the maximum temperature the blade edge reaches during planing and the time it remains at elevated temperatures. Should it therefore also affect the corrosive wear rate? Until some of these questions are answered, it might be unwise to dismiss corrosive wear in hand planing.

One might be able to get a more accurate measure of edge temperatures with a thermocouple attached to the back of the blade than with the thumbs.

Re: Planing MDF

#15

Re: Absence of Heat

david weaver

I think the area of the blade that's heating is very small - that is, the immediate part creating the heat (and I don't know why I'm going down this rabbit hole when I'm partially mentally incapacitated with a headache). That part can't be greater than the part that's actually in contact with wood - the rest of the blade is touching air.

I don't know that much about the dynamic of temperature in a solid object when the object is heated at a small point, but I would suspect that the plane iron is very hot at the very edge during the stroke if it's enough to heat the iron.

I have pulled plane irons out of a plane before and found them to be warm. Of course, I have no clue what the temperature differential is at the very edge vs. the iron perhaps a 16th away from the edge. Or 1/4th.

I do recall that Rob has several time mentioned speed of planing as a wear factor. I can't imagine that's due to anything else but heat. I don't know that I've seen anyone else mention that, but in my blathering about stropping a razor (unless I didn't include that in the post above), I mentioned the theory that the very edge of a razor gets hot in stropping, but you'll never actually feel it because the razor is too small and the heat dissipated by the time you touch the edge. I recall Warren also suggesting that he believed that this is one of the things that goes on with stropping.

Re: Planing MDF

#16

Re: Absence of Heat

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have detected damage to the iron from heat occasionally. It is noticeable on certain timbers when the iron is used too long after it has become dull. After this kind of damage, you sharpen the iron and it doesn't perform as well. After a few rounds of use it gradually gets back to normal. The difference is quite subtle; you would not notice it unless you had a lot of experience and were very attuned to your iron.

Getting high performance from a plane is an art. Hiring technicians to test irons will not result in the highest quality.

Re: Planing MDF

#17

Re: Absence of Heat

John in NM

The reason a plane blade can have a surprising heat differential from the edge to the blade body during use is that there is so little mass available at the edge for conduction away from it -- same reason it is very easy to burn an edge while grinding.

A chip breaker set very close would help a little, but the mass of the plane body itself is largely irrelevant because it is so far from the edge -- again with the grinding example, it doesn't help the edge at all to clamp an aluminum heat sink to a blade vs just holding it in your hand. I suspect the chip breaker is still too far from the edge to have a very significant effect, but then I've not got any way of quantifying my assumption.

I would imagine that it would be very difficult to measure this directly, because where the blade will see the crucial friction induced heating is right at the very edge of it - place anything there and you will interfere with the cutting action. The further away you are with the measuring device, the more variables influence your measurement - chip breaker, cap iron, etc.

On the other hand, if one is fond of math, you could get a pretty good idea of the energy transfer at the blade edge through calculation alone, and thus a pretty good idea of how that would effect wear rates.

Come to think of it, you could measure directly, though I bet you'd have to sacrifice a plane to do it. Use a laser thermometer, through a hole bored behind the blade. In front would be easier, but the shaving coming off would block the beam. I wonder if something ultrasonic could do it? Probably not, but I know who I could ask :D

Re: Planing MDF

#18

Re: Larry's video *LINK*

steve voigt

You guys need to get out more. ;) Larry Williams posted a short video on Instagram of some thermal imagery of a fillister iron. Link below.

For me, this is cool and fun to watch (and read about) but has absolutely zero effect on anything practical.


Thermal imagery

Re: Planing MDF

#19

And also

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

lest we forget, LV Free Shipping lasts til April 18.

Sent for another Atoma diamond plate. It was either that or the Sneeboer garden tools.

Wiley

Re: Planing MDF

#20

Re: Larry's video

david weaver

Presumably, there must be something interesting going on at the edge to get the target area to increase 4 or so degrees in one shaving.

The color of the shaving reminds me that if you stick your hand where the shaving comes out of a plane, you can feel that the shavings (and the surrounding empty space near the mouth) are warmer than the ambient temperature.

Re: Planing MDF

#21

Re: Larry's video

Kees

The video doesn't have enough resolution to conclude anything meaningfull, regrettably. When you are interested in the tip temperature, them measuring 0.5 a cm above the edge is too far away. Steel is not a great heat conductor.

Interesting, but I agree with you Steve, not very usefull for our daily handplaning endeavours.

Re: Planing MDF

#22

Re: Larry's video

John in NM

Get out more? Heck, my day job gets me out so much I don't have much time for woodworking and have to enjoy it vicariously on forums! :D

Neat video, though I suspect the actual temperature at the tip of the iron is higher than a ~6 F differential from ambient. He's reading the temperature a good 1/4" or more away from where it would be highest, not even touching on some of the other problems in this method. Its a great illustrative tool, but hardly quantitative.

Re: Planing MDF

#23

Does anyone know....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The velocity of the edge relative to the wood will be the most important variable. Do we know the planing velocity of the LV test? Since they were in a hurry, maybe it was high.

Larry's video and other's observation show that there is significant heat generated in planing. This heat is generated at the surface. If the temperature some removed from the surface increases I would expect that the surface temperature is substantially above ambient. It's at the surface that corrosive wear will occur, the first atomic layer.

PMVII is a corrosion resistant stainless, as much so as 440 series stainless. None of the other steels revealed in the testing are corrosion resistant.

This has been an interesting conversation.

Re: Planing MDF

#24

Re: Does anyone know.... *LINK*

Kees

You can see the test setup in this video. The speed doesn't look exceptionally fast, compared to a spirited handplaner.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ew79SeiDrE

Re: Planing MDF

#25

Re: Does anyone know....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for the video, Kees. I don't think speed was a factor in the tests. Interestingly, the test planing machine was able to lift the sample away from the plane on the return stroke, something Tesolin was unable to do. Also the machine in the video seemed to be planing real wood.

Several places I have read the claim that they made 1.6 miles of shavings with the plane irons and chopped through 10 feet of "oak" in order to complete their tests. Maybe this sounds like an awful lot of testing to some, but I have sometimes planed two miles in a day's work. I tested a 19th century chisel, chopping through 10 feet of walnut in one hour, after which it still cut pine end grain nicely. Two weeks ago I had to chop through six feet of white oak end grain; I did so without sharpening and afterwards the edge was still in good shape. There were no chips visible with a 30X loupe.

As others have suggested, we are probably getting an infomercial picture of the testing. Lots of considerations were not shared with the public. (Did they disqualify any steel that did not machine well, for instance). Lots of our questions went unanswered. I wonder about the real hand woodworking experience of the testers. I think Kees' tests have been more helpful, even though he is an amateur woodworker with much less time and budget than the Veritas people.