Re: Need slipperiest oil
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Tom and all,
When the reproduction plough came out, I bought the irons that Jim Reed made for it. The plane ploughs very well, at least as far as 1/4" deep grooves. There is a reason I mention depth, which is explained below. The Miller Patent has a powerful action and feel, because the metal concentrates the weight and gives it a lot of momentum in a very compact frame. And one complaint one could make about wooden ploughs is that they tend not to be compact, some more than others, but that's another long story...
I have a personal preference for wooden ploughs. In fact, I love 'em. Specially the smaller, more compact ones. So they're what I have used for real life ploughing. Right now, I'm down to my last favorite vintage plough, and a Clark & Williams model. And the Miller Patent.
Back to your question on the Miller Patent. There are two arguments one could make against it as an all-purpose plough:
1. The first is that the irons are not tapered. Vintage irons, and the C&W irons, are double-tapered. They narrow slightly as you go up the cutting face, and they narrow slightly behind the cutting face, i.e., they are relieved behind and above the cutting face. This gives traditional irons clearance in their depth, and also in their height. Which makes them more free-cutting, and less likely to foul the surface edges of the groove as you go deeper.
2. Secondly, the smallest Miller Patent iron is the 3/16", because the skate itself is a bit more than 1/8" thick. In practice, with traditional irons, I have used the 1/8" iron for small drawers, and consider it important to a set. The Miller Patent will plough close to the edge with the smallest 3/16" iron, so the plane is a contender for those who never need a 1/8" iron.
All this said, within its limits, the Miller Patent is a capable and even powerful plough. IMO.
Wiley