Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Need slipperiest oil

Posts

Need slipperiest oil

#1

Need slipperiest oil

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Don't laugh please. Am getting a Paul Hamler reproduction of the 1882 Miller Patent plough plane back in smooth working order. It's a metal plane, of course, and the fence slides on two polished steel arms. What's the best oil for these arms? I am using a light machine oil, but is there anything slipperier that won't gum up over time?

That is all.

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#2

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Jeff Heath

To prevent sawdust "gunking up", I use a product made by PB Blaster called "DryLube". It's a spray on, and it dries very fast (evaporates) leaving behind a residue that is an excellent lubricant. I use it on all my metal to metal surfaces on all my woodworking machines. Oil just creates a "sawdust gunk" buildup.

Gunk is, of course, a highly technical engineering term.... :D

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#3

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Paste wax is ideal for metal to metal slidy things on table saws

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#4

Oil

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a gun smith. He claims that oil is good for his business, which is to say too much leads to crapped up parts that he gets to repair.

A pure petroleum oil can not do anything to get thicker over time. Do the lesser grades contain reactive groups that polymerize slowly to increase viscosity? Or is it particles that accumulate to thicken "old" oil? Don't know. It doesn't get thick in the can. I have gun oil that is decades old. So must be particle accumulation.?.

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#5

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

The slipperiest oil I know of is silicon grease. However I would not use it if you are planning to take the plough to wood. You know why. :)

My choice would be Renaissance Wax, which is what I use on my planes ... and, in fact, used on my Paul Hamler "1882" ...


This is the only plane of mine that lives in the house, on display in the living room. The house is air conditioned (try the West Australian heat without it!) and this has played havoc with the steel in the form of rust. Oil just did not hack it. The Renaissance Wax has had the best results.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#6

Need slipperiest oil

Tom Colligan

Wiley, do you, or would you, use this plane for plowing?

I believe Paul said at the time his reproduction wasn't necessarily meant to be actually used.

Derek, how 'bout you?

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#7

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom and all,

When the reproduction plough came out, I bought the irons that Jim Reed made for it. The plane ploughs very well, at least as far as 1/4" deep grooves. There is a reason I mention depth, which is explained below. The Miller Patent has a powerful action and feel, because the metal concentrates the weight and gives it a lot of momentum in a very compact frame. And one complaint one could make about wooden ploughs is that they tend not to be compact, some more than others, but that's another long story...

I have a personal preference for wooden ploughs. In fact, I love 'em. Specially the smaller, more compact ones. So they're what I have used for real life ploughing. Right now, I'm down to my last favorite vintage plough, and a Clark & Williams model. And the Miller Patent.

Back to your question on the Miller Patent. There are two arguments one could make against it as an all-purpose plough:

1. The first is that the irons are not tapered. Vintage irons, and the C&W irons, are double-tapered. They narrow slightly as you go up the cutting face, and they narrow slightly behind the cutting face, i.e., they are relieved behind and above the cutting face. This gives traditional irons clearance in their depth, and also in their height. Which makes them more free-cutting, and less likely to foul the surface edges of the groove as you go deeper.

2. Secondly, the smallest Miller Patent iron is the 3/16", because the skate itself is a bit more than 1/8" thick. In practice, with traditional irons, I have used the 1/8" iron for small drawers, and consider it important to a set. The Miller Patent will plough close to the edge with the smallest 3/16" iron, so the plane is a contender for those who never need a 1/8" iron.

All this said, within its limits, the Miller Patent is a capable and even powerful plough. IMO.

Wiley

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#8

The Paul Hamler 1882 Plough

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, do you, or would you, use this plane for plowing?

I believe Paul said at the time his reproduction wasn't necessarily meant to be actually used.

Derek, how 'bout you?

Hi Tom

I am not exactly shy of plough planes! :) I do recall my old friend Mike Wenzloff saying that he had a weakness for ploughs. I cannot say that I am in his league - outside of Paul's 1882, I have four other ploughs (although I have had more in the past), and so there is no need to use this one (although at the time I was thinking about doing so). These include the bridle plough I built, a Rapier #043 (tiny one), the Veritas Small and the soon-to-be-released Veritas Large for preproduction testing (Rob Lee has posted about this on a few forums). I really do not need another plough! ;)

Although it was not Paul's intention, the 1882 is a fully functioning working plane. It was supplied with just a single 1/4" iron (Wylie was able to obtain a set from Jim Reed, who was making them at the time - I discovered that the blades for the Small Plow would fit, but would require a small modification of a groove to seat on the skate). The steel in my blade was soft, and I heat treated it with a torch. Once sharpened up, it worked a treat ...


I did write a short review at the time: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/1882MillerPatentPloughPlane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#9

Ditto on the paste wax


Re: Need slipperiest oil

#10

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you very much Gentlemen!

I ordered both the DryLube and the Renaissance wax, so I can't go wrong, right?

No recommendations for K-Y jelly, I note.

And thanks to Derek for the photo, so folks can see the patient!

Wiley

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#11

Re: Need slipperiest oil

david weaver

You'd only need that if someone tells you "Hey Wiley, you can take your plane and stick it where the sun doesn't shine!"

:b

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#12

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Paul in NJ

If Todd was still posting he would recommend whale oil. :D

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#13

Re: Need slipperiest oil

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Paul and all,

LMAO!! Great reminder--I had clean forgotten about that. What a character, and I never knew if it was all true. Like when he found a dead guy under a chest of drawers in Philadelphia, that had turned over on him. Or that time he 'killed' a piano with an ax out by the parking lot to get at the ivory--he described the clanging and likened it to a prehistoric beast. I seem to recall one of his later exploits was to mount a WWI machine gun on his pickup, to take a little target practice. Oh yeah, and when his presa canario when through the front window to get at the postman--don't think he got him, though. Todd had two of them, in case one wasn't enough.

Yeah, the whale oil.......I just went and looked for him on Ebay, and couldn't find 'mrsdeadhorse'. Is he still doing it. He had gone bad and was doing steampunk, so I quit watching, though he usually had some military stuff that was cool.

Anyway, thanks,

Wiley

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#14

Re: Need slipperiest oil

david weaver

There could be an archive of stories. I remember him talking about feds who came to his door, but not in the house, as it would've been a "small problem" due to having 7 skeletons ("i sort of collect them" was his line for everything that he had piles of).

Or the story where he was dating a lady, and then decided to date her daughter instead and the mother had a "severe reversal of affection" and tried to slice and dice him.

One thing is for sure, I harassed him once about harassing people - nobody else could tell a happy new tool owner that "I think the dealer saw you coming from a mile away" and let the air out of their tires. He took the term that I used and scrawled it into a hammer handle that had an anatomical shape - nicely made handle otherwise, and put a very nicely smithed brass hammer head on the end of the whole apparatus.

He was right about the double iron, too, got Larry wound up a significant amount, and all he had to guess was that there must've been a pretty good reason to go to the trouble to slot an iron and make a cap iron in the days when that wouldn't have been that easy to do.

Every acquired tool started with "my girl ____ found this at an auction and brought it to me", often with pictures, and the girl who brought the tool was always different in each picture.

Wish he'd still post from time to time!

Re: Need slipperiest oil

#15

Re: Need slipperiest oil

William Duffield

I found several current listings offered by Todd. You have to select advanced search criteria and enter mrsdeadhorse at the bottom under "seller" to find him.

He told us the mastiff's name was "Tonton Macoute" or "Tonton" for short. I've said enough about that; you can look it up if you are interested.