Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Rust Removal

Posts

Rust Removal

#1

Rust Removal

Gary B.

I'm digging through some of my boxes of tools, and I found a Stanley No. 48 that was gifted to me by a family friend 20 years ago when they heard I was going to start woodworking. Like most, it's taken me a long time to get back toward hand tools.

My version of this plane is nickel plated. The plane has its fair share of rust on it. How can I clean it up while perserving what is left of the nickel finish? If that's simply not possible, what is the best way to remove both the nickel finish and the rust so I can japan it? (Some stanley no48's did some jappaned, and this will be a user). Thanks for any insight.

Re: Rust Removal

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

electrolosis

Jack Guzman from Maine

For years I have used this method to remove rust from old tools. A plastic bucket of water treated with a couple tablespoons of washing soda. 12v battery charger. Clamp the positive lead to a piece of sacrificial steel and submerge in the electrolitic solution. Clamp the other lead to the object needing derusting and submerge. Don't let these leads make contact with each other. Turn on the charger and look for fine bubbles. If you have done this right the process should start immediately.Any nickel plating that is firmly attached will not be affected but if there is rust under it,it will come off with the rust.---Proceed with caution.---Jack

Re: Rust Removal

#3

Electrolysis.....

Brian Roberts

Electrolytic rust removal works well....BE SURE TO READ THE FOLLOWING AND FOLLOW THE WARNINGS!!

http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/andyspatch/rust.htm#top

http://www.oldengine.org/members/orrin/rustdemo.htm

http://1bad6t.com/rust_removal.html

Re: Rust Removal

#4

Agree on all points....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Look for our article on this process in the Articles Section of WoodCentral. The process will be less cruddy if you use a stainless steel anode. I use a big spoon for small baths, and a friend uses a large wrap around screen for his big bath.

The process is largely- straight line so you may have to rotate the rust relative to the anode to get it all.

Perform where there is good ventilation.

Re: Rust Removal

#5

some details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you pour the juice to the object it will be cleaned both by electrolysis and mechanically by the massive amount of hydrogen bubbles exploding off the surface. These scrubbing bubbles will dislodge anything loose or anything that they can get under the edge of. Paint will be removed and maybe even plating, though I have no experience with plating. Less current will result in less bubbles and less loose stiff dislodged.

Re: Rust Removal

#6

The safety issues

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Washing soda is such a mild base that it is essentially harmless. After all it used to be commonly added to laundry to "soften" the water.

Hydrogen gas diffuses away at a rapid rate. It is not an issue unless confined and then it is a serious issue. Occasionally some site suggests using table salt. Don't, for a great number of reasons.

Most sites warn against the use of stainless steel. There are lots of grades of stainless steel. At least in my experience with whatever grade was recovered from junk yard as a screen, or a large kitchen spoon, there is but a tiny attack on the stainless steel and no significant amount of chromium (about 1 ppm of any form, most likely trivalent chromium) detected in the electrolysis bath after days of operation.

For years I have challenged the chromium alarmists to provide proof of chromate generation and none have offered any. They prefer the self satisfaction of being alarmists. There are chemical reasons to assume none would be formed, or if it was, it would be destroyed by reduction at the cathode or by ferrous iron in solution.

That said the bath could contain lead from lead paint, an all sorts of other junk, especially if rebar is used as an anode. So don't drink it or pour it on the roses.

Re: Rust Removal

#7

Re: Rust Removal

Gary Smyth

I have been severely frightened of electrocution. Several times I have thought about electrolysis but I have this fear of me or a curious animal getting zapped or starting a fire. To me electricity and water is something to be avoided at all costs. What are the risks? How to minimize them?

My go to these days for rust removal is Evaporust. Available at Tractor Supply for $20/gal. Resuable and non toxic and can be used without gloves. The name sound hokey, but it's legit.

Four to 24 hours is all most items need. DO NOT NOW ABOUT NICKEL FINISH. Call them.

Re: Rust Removal

#8

Re: Rust Removal

Gary B.

Thanks everyone. I have a rusted stanley blade and chipbreaker in vinegar as we speak. I don't have high hopes, but we'll call it an experiment. I'd love to try the electrolysis route, as I also have a #6 ohio fore plane that was given to me. It's as rusted as can be. If I can, I'll try to setup an electrolysis station in a few days and let you know the results.

I also have a gallon of evaporust under my bench I bought at Harbor Freight last year. I'll try and contact them and see what they have to say about the nickel plating. I hate to experiment on this plane though.

Re: Rust Removal

#9

Electrolysis, An Unattractive Gray

Tom Colligan

I've used this method a number of times and while it is effective it does leave the metal an unattractive, dull gray color.

No more for me; a wire brush or steel wool, etc. will be my route.

Re: Rust Removal

#10

Re: Electrolysis, An Unattractive Gray

Gary B.

FWIW, I emailed Evaporust and they responded promptly this morning. They said that their product wouldn't directly affect the nickel, but may remove any plating with rust underneath it. I'm going to give it a try let you know how it works.

Re: Rust Removal

#11

Re: Electrolysis, An Unattractive Gray

Gary B.

Well, my "heirloom" plane is taking a dip in evaporust. We'll see how she looks in 10 hours or so. :D

Re: Rust Removal

#12

The results are in...

Gary B.


I'm very pleased with the outcome. I soaked it for 3 cycles, about 8 hours a piece. I scrubbed between cycles. Since I already had the solution out, I also decided to dunk an old rusted rasp. It's like new again. I definitely recommend evaporust.