(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Posts
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#2(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#3What are they used for
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Pretty saw without question.
What do people typically use a back saw for? Probably seems a dumb question to someone that uses them regularly. For me they seem to occupy a no man's land between what ever the small version of this saw is called and a small hand saw. I don't like their weight compared to a small hand saw (I have a short Sandvik). For sawing small stuff I will grab an inexpensive Japanese saw or the small LV cross cut saw or even my dovetail saw if it happens to be on the bench. I haven't run into an occasion where the tall, long blade of the saw you show would be useful.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#4fine looking tools
Joseph Piotrowski
by fine, i mean wow! that is some craftsmanship.
the only problem is that it hard to judge by a picture because after all, a saw is only as good as it cuts.
you can send me a few and i'll be sure let you know how good they are 
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#5Re: What are they used for
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Traditional use for a large back saw is for cross cutting the shoulder of a tenon at the bench. The stock is held with the left hand against a sawing board or a pair of side hooks for cross cutting. The cheeks are cut with a hand saw (ripping). A lot of tenon saws today have a very great depth of cut which makes them awkward and heavy and prone to buckling.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#6thanks
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I suppose the longer blade made sawing it quicker.
I have not been able to saw shoulders so I chisel them.....That said, I probably can't saw shoulders because I only practice chiseling them. so much to learn, so little time to learn it. I still struggle with M&T joinery to get it near perfect. I have an easier time with dovetails, for whatever reason. Maybe because I make more of them.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#7(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#8(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#9Re: thanks
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) I have not been able to saw shoulders so I chisel them.....That said, I probably can't saw shoulders because I only practice chiseling them. so much to learn, so little time to learn it. I still struggle with M&T joinery to get it near perfect. I have an easier time with dovetails, for whatever reason. Maybe because I make more of them.
I suppose the longer blade made sawing it quicker.
Bill, a longer saw plate enables a longer stroke, which is a smoother and more efficient movement. Short plates with relatively larger teeth or more vertical rake with create a jerky, staccato-like movement. A long plate will even out the cut. Larger rip teeth are needed on a tenon saw for sawing cheeks. We are likely to be sawing 2 - 3" lengths here, and 10 - 11 tpi are typical for the saw. I use two tenon saws, one 14" and the other 16" long. By contrast, the shorter dovetail saw, also making a rip cut, will have the same shaped (vertical) teeth, but only has to cut 1/2 - 3/4". The plate may be shorter and the teeth smaller, generally 14 - 16 tpi. Dovetail saws tend to be about 10" long.
When you mention chiselling shoulders, you are clearly referring to joinery that would involve sawing across the grain (rather than with the grain, as above). Ideally, this is done with cross-cut teeth. Nevertheless, the rule still applies: the longer the plate, the smoother the movement, and the more accurate the cut. For most tenon shoulders, I use a saw with 14 tpi and an 11" long plate. One could use a dovetail saw for this since the teeth are small, although you may have to put up with a tad more spelching.
The really big crosscut backsaws are those used for mitre- and crosscuts in a mitrebox. My smallest mitrebox uses a 16" saws, while the largest has a massive 26" saw. Again, longer plate enable more efficient movements, but saws like these benefit from guides to keep them on track. By contrast, the tenon cheek is less precise and benefits from later fine tuning with a chisel or plane.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#10Re: What are they used for
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Peter Nicholson was a cabinetmaker in the 18th century. He apprenticed in Scotland and worked as a journeyman in Edinburgh and London. Here is what he said about the tenon saw:
Here is his section on making a tenon.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#11Re: Backsaws
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Stewie and all,
Wonderfully fine craftsmanship! i am enjoying all your posts and photos. In regard to the saws, I am curious about the details of the teeth. Do you have some standard rake and fleam that you use, or do vary these to optimize the saw to a particular hardness of wood? Do you use rakers on crosscut saws? If a rip saw, same question as to rake, and do you use zero fleam, or do you sometimes use a little angle?
Whatever you might say on these points would be interesting. I am just curious, and especially curious about saws, due to their complexity as tools.
Thanks again for your contributions,
Wiley
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#12Re: Backsaws
Frank D. In Montreal
Thanks for these posts,
As others have said your saws are stunning. I was wondering what tools you use to shape the handles. They are so crisp. Do you use a roundover bit on a router, or start by hand with rasps and files?



