Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Posts

Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#1

Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Mihai

I need a new 1/4" Mortise chisel and I settled to choose between Narex and Veritas PM-V11. I do lots of mortises - no drilling here.

Did anyone get a chance to work with both of them? Over the long term, is the PM-V11 really worth almost 6 times more?

Thank you

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#2

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been whacking out mortises all day. I can not imagine doing it with a round handled chisel. My home made chisel has a handle like a butcher knife. I can easily feel how it is oriented in my hand relative to the mortise to be.

Pretty easy to make one from a 1/4" lathe tool bit.

I suspect you will be able to sharpen the PMV11 to a more acute angle given how tough the steel is.

Try the Narex and report back. It's a cheap experiment.

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#3

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Mihai

Bill, Thank you.

My 5/16" Mathieson pigsticker indeed has an octagonal handle that I love exactly for the reason you describe - allows me to keep it aligned. Acute is not important in mortising chisels - toughness and ease of sharpness are. As for the Narex and trying it - I simple do not have the time in hand for experimentation - it is one or the other.

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#4

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would buy the Narex even the Veritas were cheaper. The Veritas has a really thin and chintzy tang, the kind of thing that would suffer fatigue over the long haul. The tang should be roughly the same size as the shank is on the other side of the bolster., roughly1/4 x 5/16 or 3/8. The Narex has a robust tang and a more robust bolster. Because we ride the bevel when mortising, the Veritas would have to have its bevel completely reground in order to have a flat bevel in the 30 32 degree range. The Narex comes with a reasonable bevel.

Here is a traditional mortise chisel:


Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#5

i have a set of Narex mortise chisels

Bruce, a MN Galoot

They work fine. They sharpen easily, they hold an edge, and they chop mortises. They're cheaper than the Veritas mortise chisels. At that price, you can afford to experiment. I'm not wild about the handles and will replace them at some point. I also think they're too long. I can't imagine how many mortises you'd have to chop to bring them down to a decent length. Just to be fair, except for paring chisels, I prefer short chisels.

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#6

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I need a new 1/4" Mortise chisel and I settled to choose between Narex and Veritas PM-V11. I do lots of mortises - no drilling here.

Did anyone get a chance to work with both of them? Over the long term, is the PM-V11 really worth almost 6 times more?

Hi Mihai

I was one of the testers for the Veritas mortise chisels before production (evaluating different handle sizes and A2 and PM-V11 versions).

Having for years used RI (in D2) and vintage Wards (in laminated steel), I would happily recommend either these types for chopping mortices. In design, these chisels are identical, only the steel composition changes. The D2 hold an edge longer, but the Wards will hold an edge long enough to complete several mortices. That's long enough.

I could say that holding an edge "long enough" is my definition of "good enough", but then we begin to throw in the woods we use, and how they differ in hardness. That is when our requirements for steel change.

It is only really possible for me to comment more equivocally about steels in the Veritas chisels. The Veritas mortices chisels I have arrived with a number of different handle sizes, which was one of the areas I needed to provide feedback about.

Through these distractions, it was apparent that these mortices chisels worked a little better than the English bolstered types. The blades are deeper at the bevel end of the blade, and this creates a little more registration.

I was very impressed with the A2 steel versions. In practice I could not tell which steel was actually better because they both held an edge so well that I ran out of time before they dulled. The point is, if one can afford the extra, get the PM-V11 (tests show they hold an edge very well), but the A2 chisels are darn good, so do not ignore them. They hold an edge long enough to be more than simply "good enough".

Comparing the Veritas to the Narex is difficult as I have not used the Narex. I don't like the look of their handles. Of all the handles, I prefer the oval bolstered types, but then I am also most used to them. The Veritas handles are directional, as are the Narex handles - both have flats on the sides - however, what is great about the oval handles is that they taper, and this enables one to find the ideal grip area. I cannot comment on the Veritas here as I have a variety of sizes, some large and some smaller. I do like the Veritas handles, nonetheless. They feel solid, and the chisels I used are very well balanced. At this time I prefer them to the oval bolstered types because the blades offer more bite and directional control.

What I would want to know about the Narex is whether the blades are tapered, as the Veritas and the traditional oval bolstered types are? The taper makes for easier release. Also, the Narex steel is likely to have less impact resistance than either A2 or PM-V11. The question is question is whether it remains good enough for your wood.

Narex ...


The Veritas primary bevel is ground at 25 degrees, compared to the RI and Wards at 20 degrees. All have a secondary of 35 degrees. The photo below was taken after I renewed the primary bevels of two Veritas chisels. The centre chisel is a RI ...


Below are the primary bevels of three 1/4" chisels: from top, Ward, RI, and Veritas. Note the extra depth of the Veritas. I also found that they levered chips better ...



Above: RI, Ward and Veritas. Note that this handle is a little wider than the production version. It feels more substantial than the impression from this photo as it is wider than the tapered handles. I recommended a reduction in diameter. I am sure others did as well, as that was the result.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#8

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Mihai

Warren,

Thank you - your points carefully considered. Now - it surprises me what you are saying about Veritas tang: because to my eyes, the Veritas blade being double as thick as the Narex, although visually the tang looks small, that is only because of the very wide blade. As a matter of fact, it seems to me that the Veritas tang it is at least as big as Narex, if not bigger.

now - I do not have the chisels in my hand to confirm this... but, from the pictures, the tang and bolster do not seem to be undersized in Veritas.

If you have them both in your hand maybe you can measure them and confirm

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#9

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Mihai

Derek,

Thank you very much for your thoughts.

1. I am surprise to hear that "The D2 hold an edge longer" than Ward, as from my experience O1 it is tougher than D2.

2. I rarely work with hard woods. Most of the times cherry, walnut and african mahogany (khaya).

3. I guess the Veritas blades "are deeper at the bevel end of the blade, and this creates a little more registration" simply because their main bevel is 25. For that registration that you mention I put on my mortises chisels a 30 main bevel. And that can be grind on any chisel.

4. Handles: my practice taught me to use any mortise chisel by gripping the blade and NOT the handle. I am holding it like a pencil and the handle is there just for hitting. This way I can assure right registration for a square mortise. It is true that the bottom half of the mortise I am chopping it holding the chisel by the handle - but, by that time, the walls already created provide plenty of registration to hold the chisels straight. now, that being said, I love the hexagonal design on my Mathieson mortise chisel handles, because the back side of the handle allows for easy visual confirmation of the squareness. That is why I am surprised that all modern manufacturers are making their handles round or oval... hexagonal/octagonal are a better design from my perspective.

5. Narex: yes their blades are tapered.

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#10

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Perhaps I am mistaken about the tangs, Mihai. Just now I am having trouble finding pictures of either the Narex or the Veritas without handles. And it has been a while since I held either in my hands.

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

#11

Re: Narex or PM-V11 mortise chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

3. I guess the Veritas blades "are deeper at the bevel end of the blade, and this creates a little more registration" simply because their main bevel is 25. For that registration that you mention I put on my mortises chisels a 30 main bevel. And that can be grind on any chisel.

Hi Mihai

The extra registration on the Veritas (compared to the oval bolstered chisels to which I referred) is not due to the higher primary bevel, but due to the blade being deeper. Look at the pictures I posted.

4. Handles: my practice taught me to use any mortise chisel by gripping the blade and NOT the handle. I am holding it like a pencil and the handle is there just for hitting. This way I can assure right registration for a square mortise. It is true that the bottom half of the mortise I am chopping it holding the chisel by the handle - but, by that time, the walls already created provide plenty of registration to hold the chisels straight. now, that being said, I love the hexagonal design on my Mathieson mortise chisel handles, because the back side of the handle allows for easy visual confirmation of the squareness. That is why I am surprised that all modern manufacturers are making their handles round or oval... hexagonal/octagonal are a better design from my perspective.

5. Narex: yes their blades are tapered.

This opens up your choices widely since you no longer have to consider the ergonomics imparted by the handle! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek