Tea House Chair - Posts and Spindles
Brian Holcombe
Good morning! I'm riving away on my chairs, please have a look at the latest round of work performed;
As I always I very much look forward to your comments.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tea House Chair - Posts and Spindles
Brian Holcombe
Good morning! I'm riving away on my chairs, please have a look at the latest round of work performed;
As I always I very much look forward to your comments.
Method
Jack Guzman from Maine
Brian,I always enjoy your posts but this one caught my attention. You entered into my world here. I build windsor chairs exclusively. Your methods of operation are much more precise than mine. More ordered. I like your rounding plane.I have a couple homemade ones and a couple bought from other makers.
Keep sharing your builds.---Jack
Re: Method
Brian Holcombe
Thanks Jack! I very much appreciate a positive reception, especially from a dedicated windsor chair maker. Your posts, along with Curtis Buchanan's videos, A Riving Home, and Dennis Young's blog have been incredibly helpful as I search for a footing while progressing through each stage.
It's been a very enjoyable break from cabinetwork, which I also enjoy but occasional nice to break away from that sort of thing and deviate entirely, and not without trials of its own.
I'm working on the comb now, and after one glue-up failure I'm back to the drawing board.
I hope to take on a bit more of this work, should it come my way, so that I can make some dedicated fixtures for steam bending and so forth. I'm doing bent laminations in kiln dried material currently and would happily ditch the process for steam bending green or air dried wood, but it takes a certain volume of this work to go out and acquire such material and use it in a timely manner.
Re: Tea House Chair - Posts and Spindles
steve voigt
I'm glad to see someone else made a reamer without a lathe! Though you have more chutzpa than I do--I cut the slot on the bandsaw.
As usual you look like you are doing great. One very minor suggestion I have is that you skew the drawknife a little, especially when you hear the grain tearing.
I'll mention one other thing, though I have no idea if it's relevant to your process. My background in craft is primarily machining, toolmaking, and cabinetry & studio furniture. I know you've also done machining, and your furniture shows the same level of precision and detail that a toolmaker needs. Anyway, I found that mindset to be something of a liability in green chairmaking. While certain things like tenons need to be precise, a lot of the work just needs to look right, and you can drive yourself crazy and waste enormous amounts of time if you're used to checking everything with calipers and measuring in thousandths. Again, I have no idea if this malady afflicts you, but I thought it was worth mentioning. Carry on!
reamer question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I made one to use with maple stool seats. It was slow cutting in this hard wood. I was left unsure if this style isn't appropriate for a very hard wood, or I didn't make/use it right.
I abandoned stool making. I didn't thrive on the execution "freedom" it offered that Steve referred to.
You can get rift cuts without the expense of rift cut lumber. Search out wider 8/4 planks. The way they are sawed will yield post sized rift material from the edges and quartered material from the middle.
I have 4 "factory" Windsor chairs. Soon after purchase a back spindle broke because the grain was 30" to the length.
Re: Tea House Chair - Posts and Spindles
Brian Holcombe
Thanks Steve! I appreciate the suggestion as well, just getting a handle on the draw knife, everything prior has been in green material (peeling bark).
I agree completely, and have tried my best to completely put aside the wood machinist mentality for this project. It's a bit built in, but I am beginning to appreciate things like the spindles not being perfectly straight or perfectly round, since after all, they will have a curve bent into them and they'll look right on at that point.
Re: reamer question
Brian Holcombe
It's possible that you had too much blade showing, I trimmed this one back and further I trimmed the better it cut.
It doesn't cut like my steel reamers by any means, but it's pretty good all things considered.
That is exactly what I do to get rift material when possible. I picked a wide board for the white oak, then my sawyer ripped it down and sold me the rift material. Normally I buy the full board and do it myself, but I don't use a whole lot of white oak in any format other than rift or quarter.
Re: reamer question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I use a tapered reamer for this work. Here is a similar one; mine has more taper.

This type is a bit more sophisticated to sharpen because the depth of cut is kind of built into the angle, but they cut more than scrape. We usually use something like pine or poplar for a chair seat, both for easier working and lighter chair. However for making spinning wheels we use a tapered joint at ten places or so, in white oak and hard maple.
Re: reamer question
Brian Holcombe
Thanks for commenting on this thread Warren, I did a bit of searching for a bit like that, but without having a specific name my searches were flooded with a host of bits that are similar but don't quite serve the purpose so well.
Do you recall the degree of taper on your bit? This 6 degree taper seems to make for a fairly tight fitting tenon that is easily made into spindles. I had contemplated using my 12 degree bit, but it seemed it would enlarge the hole to rapidly before plumbing any real depth of cut.
Re: reamer question
William Duffield
Some tips from Tim Manney on making rounding planes to match the taper of the reamer:
The first one has a frog, for adjustability, maybe.
http://timmanneychairmaker.blogspot.com/2013/09/frankenstanley.html
The later one dispenses with the frog, changes from bevel down to bevel up and adjusts with a plane hammer..
http://timmanneychairmaker.blogspot.com/2015/06/use-your-reamer-to-make-matching-tenon.html
Peter Galbert prefers a rounder with a handle, which makes it easier to turn if you clamp the spindle, instead of clamping the rounder and trying to turn the spindle.
Elia Bizzarri makes them with handles, and Drew Langsner sells them.
Re: reamer question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I am not sure how these angles are measured, Brian. Mine has about 6 degrees of taper measuring from center line to the cutting edge, or about 12 altogether. Charles Hummell calls these reamers in the Dominy book and among woodworkers we have always just said reamers with the context suggesting what type.
There is "chairmaker's tapered spoon bit" in an old Woodcraft catalog (1995) with 5/10 degrees stated. These have a tapered square shank for a bit brace. Other firms have sometimes sold them as well.
Peter Galbert demonstrated at the Williamsburg conference last weekend. He had a reamer like you are making that is being made by one of his friends. It worked reasonably well and it is probably easier to manufacture and maintain than the traditional tool. I would say it is not a traditional design. Peter seemed interested in replacing traditional techniques with tricks and jigs, to help a guy get started and assure a beginner can walk out of a workshop with a chair- helpful for a hobbyist. I didn't notice, but some at the conference suggested that Peter's reamer had a thicker blade than a common saw blade, and thought this might be sturdier and helpful.
Ray Iles
Jack Guzman from Maine
Ray Iles also makes a decent rounder for chair tenons. Joel at Tools for working wood sells them.I use two of them.---Jack
Re: reamer question
Brian Holcombe
Thanks Warren, appreciate your further comments!
I believe that most are using both sides in the measurement, for instance, Lee Valley has a 12 degree bit that measures 6 degrees per side. I own that bit, but decided on 6 degrees (total) for the posts due to the fact that I've planned them to go through the seat so that I can wedge them on the underside and the 6 degree taper worked out better given the measurements of the parts involved.
I've been continuing my searching for the 'chair maker's tapered spoon bit', the Woodcraft name for it must have caught on as it brings up much more relevant results in searches.
Searching for a tapered reamer brings up mostly metal working tools.
I've also seen where a few are now using a heavy blade. The only complaint I have with the wooden bit is that chips are able to squeeze between the wooden holder and the blade, not sure if the thicker blade fixes this or if it does not. It's a nuisance and something that does significantly slow my progress. I will likely stay on the search for the chair maker's bit mentioned to have it handy in case I receive more chair orders.
I also find that it's fairly difficult to correct angles with the wooden holder, so if I'm not spot on accurate with the bit and brace than I'm not going to be able to move the hole much as I taper it. My experience with metal tapering bits is that they make it fairly easier to change the angle as progress is made.
I've been avoiding the purchase of any jigs or fixtures, though if I continue with more chairs I will likely build a shave horse. I'm prototyping this chair design, so I expected it would take some time to complete the build, but I'd like future work to proceed at a more reasonable pace.
For instance, shaping and fitting 18 spindles took me about six hours, where I would expect an experienced chair maker to work through a similar amount of spindles much faster.
Re: Ray Iles and other rounders
Brian Holcombe
Thanks for the tips/suggestions on these.
The shavings I'm getting are closer to that of those shown with the Ray Iles rounder and less so than that of the Tim Manney photo, but I'm using white oak and white ash for spindles so the shavings seemed appropriate.
Tim Manney seems to be using maple and taking a very nice shaving.
I have a bunch of LN blades laying around that I've removed from their planes and replaced with blades that I prefer, so I may use them to make 1/2" and 3/8" rounding planes
Reamer ID
Brian Holcombe
John Aniano and I were discussing tapered reamers this morning, he has a bit stamped 'WCV' but unsure of who the maker is.
It's a single cutter reamer and the maker also did make spoon bits to go along with it.
Curious to know if any of you are familiar with that maker?
Re: Reamer ID *LINK*
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Ernie Conover used to sell nice reamer and spoon bit sets 25 or 30 years ago. Maybe WCV is NOV.
Conover bits
Re: Reamer ID
Brian Holcombe
Here's a photo, which is probably more helpful than the description I gave earlier;

Re: Reamer ID
Larry Barrett
Brian and John, I have a similar set of spoon bits with the WCV stamp on them. I don't remember the gentleman's name but I do recall that he was a machinist who took a Windsor chair class with Mike Dunbar about 20 years ago. Shortly after that he started making tools for Mike and Mike's students. I didn't take a class with Dunbar, but did read about these tools, contacted the gentleman and bought my spoon bits from him.
Re: Reamer and spoon bits made by Fred Emhoff... *LINK*
John Aniano in Central NJ
Hi Brian, et. al.,
Did a little searching and found the maker of the reamer and spoon bits. Was a man named Fred Emhoff, who may be retired at this point. Don't remember why the tools were stamped "WCV" within an oval - I have no idea what this stood for, or what Fred's company name was.
Do a search on {"Fred Emhoff" tools} and you will find that folks raved about his work.
Anyway, here's the initial link that I found...
Re: Reamer and spoon bits made by Fred Emhoff...
Kevin Adams
John is correct that Fred Emhoff was the maker of that tapered reamer and spoon bits. The initials are something like Wharton Valley Chairworks (I believe that was the name of the region he lived in upstate NY). He is long since retired and I am not sure if still living. At the time, he was one of the few who were making these bits. I believe Mike Dunbar connected with him and Fred had quite a market for his tools when Mike was still using traditional methods (and before he went to battery powered drills and marketing his own tools).
I own one of his solid reamers (similar to the one LV sells) and also a couple of sets of his spoon bits. Fred was the nicest gentleman you'd ever want to talk with and his tools are absolutely impeccable in every way. When I had heard he was retiring due to health reasons, I contacted him for the second set of spoon bits (this was years back)...I'll never need them, it was just the thought that they wouldn't be available ever again. LV sells spoon bits now, which are not bad, but no where the quality of Fred's.
Hope that helps, good luck with your chair, Brian!
Kevin
Thank you!
Re: reamer question
William Duffield
Peter Galbert's/Tim Manney's reamer is 1/16" thick with a total angle of 6°.
Re: Tea House Chair - Posts and Spindles
TomD
I have 6 or 7 lathes, but the only time I wanted one of those reamers it was when I was at the farm, and didn't have much of anything to work with. It turned out great, though not perfect, but that really doesn't matter much in this design since the saw blade is constant, the rest only keeps it centered.
I have used all 4 types of reamer, the conical ones, and I have the best made, work great; The metal working reamers, they work OK, particularly the ones set up to cut violin pegs and sockets, but fairly slow, and they can cut a faceted inner surface; the spoon version, mine doesn't work, I need more practice I guess; And the saw blade type, I found they worked best of all, which was a surprise to me, so low tech.
Re: Reamer and spoon bits made by Fred Emhoff...
TomD
I have the fred emhoff set, they are great, but I preferred the reamer action on the one I made. Of course home made tools get a bit of a pass, but I preferred the taper, and given that the taper was slight it doesn't take a heavy cut to get the taper out of the hole, so speed is fine. One of the benefits of the Emhoff product is that it can be steered. The other types substantially follow the direction of the hole, but the Emhoff can be started, sighted against bevels, then when all is right you run it through. You can both steer it and also leave it hanging in the hole and step back for the sight. All this makes it very beginner friendly.
That Emhoff style of reamer is a variant on the kind of bits metal workers make for themselves, from D bits to that style. Given that Brian has a milling machine, and I am guessing a lathe, not much to hold him back. All those score marks look like the work of repetitive saw cuts, but it seems like it would be easier to just take it in two cuts.
The Emhoff spoon bits are awesome though.
Re: Reamer and spoon bits made by Fred Emhoff...
TomD
My Windsor teacher was trained by Dunbar, and Dunbar used the Emhoff bits, which is how I got on to them. At the time they were pretty much the only source for good spoon bits.