Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Hide glue question(s)

Posts

Hide glue question(s)

#1

Hide glue question(s)

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

How many times can hot hide glue go through heat up and cool down cycles before it shouldn't be used?

I know I should only mix what I need, and about freezing excess and so on, but I've been working on something where I've been working weeknights and strange times on it so I just plug my glue pot in (a crappy little crock pot thing) and heat it up.

The glue still tacks up nicely between my fingers, and it seems ok, but I got to wondering at what point should new be mixed up.

I probably would use liquid hide glue, but I haven't been able to find any close by. WoodCraft (hour+ round trip) is the only place local that has it and it might be somewhat fresh.

Also, I seem to recall reading or seeing a video where some type of salt was added to hot hide glue to make it essentially liquid hide glue. Any thoughts on that?

Thanks!

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#2

Glue misconceptions and chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In Chris Schultz's recent article on liquid hide glue he quotes an interview with the Franklin technical staff where they quote liquid hide glue life times of many years (was it 10?). I have gotten the same story from them and my experience confirms long shelf life. Missing was a discussion of why Franklin glue lasts a long time and the "fan favorite" traditionally made glue doesn't.

Hide glue is traditionally made a liquid by incorporation of urea. Over time urea hydrolyzes to ammonia which is basic. A basic solution will hydrolyze the protein that makes hide glue work, rendering it no longer tough. The other thing that destroys hide glue is bacteria and mold. Stop hydrolysis and mold growth and the glue lasts a long time.

Franklin doesn't use urea to liquefy hide glue. Nothing happens to degrade the protein so the glue lasts a long time. I keep my liquid hide in the frig until I am ready to use it.

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#3

Re: Hide glue question(s)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was taught to use hot hide glue in 1966. In 1983 I was given some Franklin "liquid hide glue" for free. I used some of it, but it went bad after a year or two and I threw it out. Franklin's glue my be different today, but I can't think of a single reason to use it.

You can heat the glue up multiple times. Workers who keep it hot all day long usually throw the remainder away after a week, but a great part of the deterioration is caused by length of time it is hot, not the number of times it is heated. Also you can heat it hotter than the oft recommended 140 degrees, but it will deteriorate faster. So 160 degrees is fine for a guy who is just heating it up for individual jobs, but not so much for a guy who is going to keep it on constantly. If you leave it just sit in the pot at room temperature for long periods, It will either get mouldy (ruined) or dry out (usable).

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#4

I can think of some reasons

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I can't think of a single reason to use it."

1. Foremost of the reasons to use it above any other glue is its property of "greasing" sliding joinery. If I have any reservation about a complex assembly involving M&T or dovetail joints assembling with out seizure, I use liquid hide glue. Joints that must be tapped together dry slide together easily when greased with liquid hide. (otherwise I use "yellow" glue)

2. I don't know about hot hide but liquid hide offers exceptional open time as well as closed working time. I have assembled large case work with two dozen joints all at once using liquid hide glue. I have confidence that the working time will enable these large assemblies.

The rest of the advantages over hot hide are already apparent to anyone gluing joints and edges. The exception is marquetry where the properties of fast tack apparently make hot hide the glue of choice. I don't do marquetry but professionals that do used it in the demonstrations I have attended.

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#5

Experience

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Without experience, judgement is limited.

I wrote on this forum in 2007:

the double iron is a sophisticated instrument. ... There is no shame in having trouble with it. If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it. I can say that the benefits of learning are well worth the effort and I would not want to be without it.

The benefits of learning to use hot hide glue are well worth the effort also.

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#6

Experience- worked first try

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it."

Your claim that this planing technique is difficult to learn has not helped in spreading its benefits.

I got the impression from Professors Kato and Kawai that it is taught at the beginning level of Japanese trade schools. I don't know anyone that has tried setting the cap iron close that has not seen a benefit from employing this technique. After first seeing the Kees demonstration it was just minutes before I was benefiting from setting a cap iron closer than I ever had before. In short order I was using a plane in situations where I would have not risked using a plane before. Once introduced, this set up procedure spread rapidly through our club members.

Now I don't doubt that to plane surfaces as well as Brain will take experience. But this task is not the only task a plane is useful for, or a task that many aspire to. To fit a drawer divider with grain reversals, or a drawer for that matter, won't take much experience at all to avoid tear-out. .

For those that haven't tried it, there is now a lot of information out there on how to get started.

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#7

Re: Experience- worked first try *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Your statements are just not supported by the record of this forum.

On 6/13/13, you wrote:

In this case there were areas of early wood that easily tore regardless of planing direction or cap iron setting, in addition to the more apparent small grain reversals among otherwise straight grained wood. The #5 was nearly useless, the high angle block plane was more useful but the scraper became the weapon of choice.

and

I need to further explore the chip breaker. I had it set close but not extremely close. You know what I say...If Keys can plane ash I can :) Well, not so far.

More than a year after you publicized the Kato video and Kees demonstrated, you were still having trouble figuring it out.


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/md/read/id/467828/sbj/the-curl-is-not-the-problem/

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#8

Seriously?

John in NM

Its odd how different grudges look from the outside...

How does Bill changing his mind on planing over the course of years work to refute anything he thinks about hide glue?

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#9

Ellis Walentine

Style vs substance

Ellis Walentine

This thread started with some good information about hide glue, then went down a rabbit hole. I suggest that we keep personal differences out of these discussions.

Ellis

Re: Hide glue question(s)

#10

Re: Style vs substance

TomD

I can answer that. Bill is one of the top poster here or anywhere because:

He posts build alongs, and is prolific;

Has some kind of technical education or understanding as on display above;

Will do actual experiments;

Will dig into scholarly publications;

Seems to dig out info at a time when it is useful to a lot of people;

++++

When limitations show up they are often on experience (recent Noris post is an example), though it is like watching Norm Abrams who whatever he may have known about hand tool woodworking or cabinetmaking, at the rate of 3 pieces a show and 235 shows, pretty quickly outpaced most people.