New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Cap Irons

Posts

Cap Irons

#1

Cap Irons

Gary B.

I started looking at Richard Maguire's video on cap iron's. It was interesting enough. Then the you tube channel moves on to another video on Cap irons effect on Tear out, and up pops Bill Tindall's name. I had to take a look. Enjoy!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56DpxEOpxz0

Re: Cap Irons

#2

Re: Cap Irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you found either Maguire or Tindall discussing the cap iron before David Weaver and I talked about it on this forum 12/15/2011 or 3/26/12, that would be interesting.

Re: Cap Irons

#3

Re: Cap Irons

Gary B.

Hi Warren,

I have no idea when it was published, just found the content interesting. I also figured it was somehow related to this forum, as you've pointed out. What I found most interesting was the controlled testing environment, and the videography. The motion scene reminded me of pictures in my textbooks from my BS in wood Engineering.

Re: Cap Irons

#4

Wow, I'm famous

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Or at least what passes for famous now days, a citation on U-Tube ;)

Now if I just had enough internet capacity to watch an 18 min video and not use up my month's allowance of Internet usage.

Re: Cap Irons

#5

Re: Cap Irons *LINK*

steve voigt

The link you posted is from someone who lifted the video from Wilbur Pan's site, without his permission. I am sure you meant no harm, but it would be great if you could delete the copycat link and replace it with the original, below.


Kato/Kawai cap iron video

Re: Cap Irons

#6

The original source of the Kato video is me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I received the video from Professor Kato along with copies of all his scientific planing study papers. He said it could be shared so long as he was credited for making it and it was not used for commercial gain. A friend, Mia, did the translation. She does not care if the translation is shared. Wilbur got the Mia translation and Kato video from me.

That said, with my limited Internet capability I don't watch Utube videos so I don' t have first hand knowledge of what was on it. Maybe something from Wilbur was on it, I don't know, or care. The bottom line is that the video can be shared if the request of Professor Kato is honored. Pay the shipping and I will send a copy to anyone. Lots of people now have it.

Re: Cap Irons

#7

Re: The original source of the Kato video is me

steve voigt

Hi Bill,

The youtube guy most definitely IS using it for commercial gain--his channel is monetized, so if you watch the ad that precedes the video, he makes money. So professor Kato's request in NOT being honored.

(on the other hand, Wilbur now seems to have ads on his blog as well, though not directly on the video, so he would seem to be making money from it as well. That's disappointing. But at least he credits you and everyone else underneath the video)

Re: Cap Irons

#8

Is there an email address where I......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...can contact this person? I will pass on to him Kato's request and see what he does about it.

Re: Cap Irons

#9

The best solution to link to the video

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We received permission to post the video right here on WoodCentral in the Articles Section under the title "setting the cap iron".

Re: Cap Irons

#10

Re: The best solution to link to the video

steve voigt

That sounds like a good solution, Bill. I would also be happy to host the video on my blog, which has no ads. if you want to do that, shoot me an email and let me know how to pay for shipping.

Re: Cap Irons

#11

Re: Is there an email address where I......

steve voigt

You can leave him a comment on his channel. Good luck with that.

Professor Kato can flag the video and youtube will make the guy remove it. It would only take him (Kato) a minute to fill out the form, but unfortunately only he can do it--at least as far as I understand the process.

Re: Cap Irons

#12

Re: The best solution to link to the video

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

no payment necessary but I do need your address.

Re: Cap Irons

#13

Re: The best solution to link to the video

Gary B.

Wow guys....Sorry about that, I had no Idea I was stirring up controversy. I just liked the video.

I do have a question. Let's say you are taking the .1mm (0.004") cut like the video shows, with .1mm setback on the chipbreaker. What's an easy way to set it up? I'm thinking a thin piece of paper on the bench?

How are you handling the camber of the iron at that point? If it's flat, what about plane tracks on the final product?

Re: Cap Irons

#14

Re: The best solution to link to the video

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The article by Dave (in Articles) has a dead link to the video.

A new link is https://vimeo.com/158558759

This appears to have been uploaded by Wilbur to Vimeo. No adverts there.

I am happy to host the video as well on my website (in addition to Steve doing so). Alternately, I can link to Vimeo from my site.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cap Irons

#15

Re: The best solution to link to the video

steve voigt

Derek, it's Bill's call of course, but my opinion is the more the merrier. The people who visit your site are not necessarily identical to my blog viewers, so the more ad-free locations, the better.

It occurs to me that what is missing in the various versions floating around the web is context and interpretation. I think I'd like to post on a page with some explanation of the video's strengths and limitations, and address some of the common criticisms. I'd encourage you (Derek) to do the same.

Bill, I'll email you my address.

Gary, we know you meant no harm…the fault belongs, imo, to the people seeking to cash in, not those innocently posting a link. Glad you enjoyed it!

Re: Cap Irons

#16

agree and agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"but my opinion is the more the merrier." yes

"It occurs to me that what is missing in the various versions floating around the web is context and interpretation." yes again.

This video is often misinterpreted because most do not know the history. It was made to be a demonstration of the equipment. It was not meant to be a tutorial on setting up the cap iron. To that end......

I am in the midst of preparing to teach two long classes that I need to have done Monday. After that task is accomplished, I will (1) arrange to get the video to Steve, who presumably with adequate Internet capacity, can forward it to wherever it is needed.

2. I will prepare some context in text form derived from my first hand discussions with Professor Kato. I will forward this text to Derek and Steve to do as they wish with it.

Re: Cap Irons

#17

Re: agree and agree

steve voigt

Sounds great Bill; I'm really looking forward to hearing what Professor Kato had to say to you!

Re: Cap Irons

#18

Re: The original source of the Kato video is me

wilbur

I sent a takedown notice to YouTube. This has happened once before, where a YouTube channel starts reuploading woodworking videos, and the Kato-Kawai video is one of them.

Not to put too fine a point on it, but Mia and I worked together on the translation of the audio. We used a process similar to what was done for the translation of the Roubo books: Mia did a literal word-for-word translation of Japanese to English, and I reworked the wording using what I know of woodworking into a translation that would work well for readers of English. Then I made the subtitles.

As far as ads on my blog, I've always deliberately set things up so that ads are not a real factor. The only reason ads appear now is because I'm using Disqus as a platform for comments. Also, you only see the ads if you go to the individual page for a blog entry. My only other options are to not have comments, or find another platform, and none of the other ones are as good as Disqus.

You can avoid the ads entirely if you read the blog from the Giant Cypress main page, where the entire blog entry is readable without going to the individual blog page. Also, you can make the ads disappear if you use ad-blocking software for your browser, like uBlock ( https://www.ublock.org ).

I have tried hard to make my blog NOT to be a way to make money. I've never accepted ads in the past, despite being approached on a regular basis to do so. I've never accepted endorsement offers. Occasionally I'll get a request from a company looking to provide a sponsored post. I sometimes quote them a fee so high that I know they won't go for it, mainly just to entertain myself.

And for the record, I have received some ad revenue through Disqus. So far, it's been a grand total of $107 over the past 7 years. You all can decide if that taints what I've written.

Re: Cap Irons

#19

That was fast

wilbur

I just now received an email from YouTube saying that the offending video was taken down. That took only an hour for them to fix it.

Re: Cap Irons

#20

New (maybe) information on the video

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


It has been so long ago I don't remember what I sent to whom. The information I recently discovered may be new information to you all or not.....

Professor Kato prepared the video to present at a meeting here in the US. After I tracked him down more than 10 years later he sent me the video. I asked Mia to translate the audio part of the video which was in Japanese, as she was already translating his paper on the effect of the cap iron on blade wear. Wilbur further refined this translation so that it is more easily understood.

I continued to correspond with Professor Kato and asked if he could send me copies of some Japanese publications on the cap iron that I had no chance of finding here in the US. (US Forest Products Library in Madison has some Japanese publications but not all the journals published in Japan.) A large package of material arrived that included all of Kato’s publications and some from others doing similar work. Later I discovered in this package an English language copy of the presentation Kato made at the conference. It was stapled to the back of the conference agenda ( well disguised for what it was ). It seems to be an introduction to the video and then a running commentary as the video ran. It provides a "from the horses mouth" translation of the video audio. I don' t know who all, if anyone, I gave this text to, or when I found it in the package. Unfortunately, it has one or more pages of introduction missing.

While gathering stuff for Steve I discovered a pdf file of this presentation in English that is complete. I presume I must have informed Kato that there were pages missing and he must have sent the complete text to me by email. Whether I sent this text on to those interested in the video or not I have no recollection. In any case it is a manageable file that I could email to those interested.

I do not know if Katos translation is significantly different from Mia’s or not. It could be in some small details, or emphasis, but unlikely the main points are different. Steve, it will be in the material I send to you.

While I have your attention......A cap iron angle of 80 degrees was used in the demonstration video. Nowhere else in any Kato or other author’s publication is this angle used. When the angle was varied it was between 40 and 60 with the preponderance of work done at 50. 80 degrees must have some disadvantage in planing machines, but this is a guess. Whether it has merit in hand planes will have to be discovered, or someone can ask a Japanese carpenter.

Re: Cap Irons

#21

Re: New (maybe) information on the video

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, I found an email I sent to you in which I quoted a 105 degree cap iron angle (75 degrees in today's convention). The date was July 19, 2007.

Re: Cap Irons

#22

Re: New (maybe) information on the video

Brian Holcombe

Mine are right around 70-80 degrees as well.

Interested to see the results of all this.

I'm happy to link to the proper form of the youtube video on my blog, should you folks deem that acceptable.

Re: Cap Irons

#23

Link to Wood Central

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Seems like a link to WoodCentral would be best. Ellis was first to step up and make arrangements to host the video.

Re: Cap Irons

#24

Re: Link to Wood Central

Brian Holcombe

That's fine for me, is the video up? If you'll point me in its direction I will begin putting together a post.