Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

Posts

Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#1

Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

Bruce Mack

In my experience a final strop on this medium refines both an edge from 1 micron diamond paste and from a 15,000 grit Shapton stone. I know the effect is ephemeral, but want to praise this inexpensive honing compound.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#2

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

William Duffield

I have found that to be true for most of my edge tools. I use 0.3µ chromium oxide powder mixed with mineral oil on a horse butt strop. But it's much finer than the chrome in the green sticks and doesn't have any alumina mixed in.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#3

Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

Tom Colligan

Where is the powder available? Thx.,

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#4

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

William Duffield

I got it through Amazon almost 4 years ago, from American Strop Company, but Amazon now lists it as "currently unavailable."

http://straightrazors.com/brands/American-Strop-Company.html still carries it.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#5

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

Bruce Mack

Not doubting that the pure powder is better, my results are with Veritas bar which has both chromium and aluminum oxide.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#6

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

William Duffield

Better? I'm not convinced the improvement was worth the effort and mess to make it up, but it's what I found and tried. It might be educational to compare the resulting scratch patterns to the sizes of the wood fibers you're cutting and the thickness of the clear finish you are applying over the resulting surface. It might also be educational to compare the number of passes or chops before the blade works no better than whatever you were using before. Another reason I chose it was experimental: It is easier to interpret the results of an experiment if you have fewer unknowns. It would be easy enough to interpret the results of a comparison to loose diamond on cast iron, for example. Green stick, with an unknown chrome grit size distribution, an unknown alumina grit size distribution, and an unknown binder might be a meaningless experiment, if your next green crayon is from a different source.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#7

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best e

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Another reason I chose it was experimental: It is easier to interpret the results of an experiment if you have fewer unknowns. It would be easy enough to interpret the results of a comparison to loose diamond on cast iron, for example. Green stick, with an unknown chrome grit size distribution, an unknown alumina grit size distribution, and an unknown binder might be a meaningless experiment, if your next green crayon is from a different source.

William, my argument is that the green compound from Lee Valley is a known variable. While the constituent parts may not be as uniform as pure green compound, the Lee Valley compound is consistently Lee Valley. That is what makes it repeatable, and what makes it possible to recommend.

A few months back on another forum (or two), there was a debate as to whether the LV compound was as usuable as a more pure version (the LV compound as an "average" of 0.5 micron grit, which means some can be larger). The point I - and others - made is that it did improve the edge, and significantly so ... and that is what counts in the end. The LV compound is easily available, while purer compounds are not.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#8

Ellis Walentine

Alternative strop

Ellis Walentine

I wanted to mention my favorite, unscientific stropping regime: Years ago, I hand-planed a hard maple 2x4 and charged it with a wet slurry from a nagura stone (sold for use with Japanese polishing stones). I have no idea what grit this might be, but it's very fine, and apparently fairly friable. When dry, this block makes a wonderful strop. The fact that the maple is not (very) compressible means that it doesn't dub over or round the edge the way a leather strop can.

Two somewhat unrelated cents...

Ellis

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#9

Example

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ellis, my strop is similar, except I load it with green compound.

I find it interesting what we call a strop these days. In my opinion, a true strop is either a linen or leather strap that is used to polish a razor's edge. It is generally used without any compound or rouge. As soon as one adds compound/grit, it is no longer stropping but honing. Whether leather or wood or cast iron, when used with compound, it becomes a sharpening tool.

I would also also suggest that polishing (as in the razor strop) involves moving steel, while sharpening involves removing steel.

We use the term strop these days to refer to a leather substrate, when we really are just using another sharpening medium. Leather is not a good sharpening medium for plane or bench chisel blades as it flexes and eventually rounds the edge (dubs the front and back of a blade). A non-flexible substrate is better.

Hence my strop is planed Tasmanian Oak (a piece of scrap, and happily the wood is quarter sawn) ..


That's the strop on the right. (The other stones are a Shapton 1000 - in the orange box - with the alternative, a worn-in Ezelap 600 grit. Below that is a Spyderco Medium and Spyderco Ultra Fine). I try not to add fresh green compound too frequently. It is better when it gets blacker ... indicating that the grit is being used and broken down into a finer abrasive. It continues to work for a very long time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#10

Re: Alternative strop

Mark Nowicki

My strop is a piece of an aluminium extrusion, not anodized.

I have six feet of 4" X 2" hollow that has lasted me over 15 years.

I charge it with LeeValley green compound.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#11

Why strop at all. Use a finer rock?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I agree with Derek's analysis of "stropping" as normally practiced. It is abrading by another name with a finer grit past the last one you did with a rock, or what ever. So why do it at all instead of owning a finer rock?

There may be an answer. Even on Tasmanian oak the substrate has some deflection at the blade tip, which results in a slight convex edge. I have been told by knife makers that convex edges are more robust than edges made by the intersection of two planes.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#12

Re: Why strop at all. Use a finer rock?

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

Some use a plain strop, which does work best after a fine stone.

I use a plain strop only very rarely anymore, and only on western tools. I found on my Japanese tools that a clean strop after my finest Nakayama stone was actually doing my edges a disservice and I discontinued the use of a strop on Japanese tools.

I use it occasionally on western blades if I'm left with just a hint of a wire edge that won't come off on the stone and I'd like to remove it without grinding the edge back further. This situation can be avoided most of the time.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#13

Re: An infinite succession of micro bevels.

TomD

A convex edge is more robust only in relation to the included angle at the edge. In fact, a convex grind is less durable to the extent to which it represents an included edge that is unsupported, relatively. But the way it works is that for a given thickness of blade, or axe, you can have a more obtuse edge, which you can also have with micro bevels. A convex edge is just an infinite succession of micro bevels.

And then there is the matter of sharpening. While you can freehand convex blades on stones, and with filing actions, or stationary flat bets, they are normally done with some form of specialized tool. This has effects of its own. For instance when belt grinding a convex edge you can control the cut with excellent support, freehand, on powerful belt grinders, with the amazing abrasives available on belts, right down to the edge.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#14

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#15

Re: An infinite succession of micro bevels.

William Duffield

Infinite? Are you sure they're not pico-bevels?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pico-

…or even yocto-bevels?

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#16

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#17

Re: An infinite succession of micro bevels.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One should bear in mind that what's being sold in wax stick form, only contains 20-30 % of actual Chromium Oxide.

Stewie, it's irrelevant. That was the point of my earlier post. The Lee Valley green compound, for example, is a known and available item. It produces an excellent result, and it does so reliably. The price is right. By contrast, purchasing 100% chromium powder to create a compound is neither easily obtained nor cheap. It may do a better job, but I fail to see a reason to need it since I get the performance from the cheaper product. In my opinion 100% is reserved for those more interested in sharpening than using.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#18

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#19

to Derek's point

w. tindall

For the practical woodworker, you can't get better than good enough.

Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#20

Re: to Derek's point


Re: Have you found chromium oxide gives the best edge?

#21

Amen