Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

What happens to worn diamonds

Posts

What happens to worn diamonds

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

What happens to worn diamonds

Jack Guzman from Maine

I bought a diamond sharpening plate at rockler about ten years ago. I believe it is 400 grit. This is not one of those plates with the round holes in it but a solid flat plate with a consistent surface. I've used it to flatten waterstones and flatten the backs of chisels and the soles of small handplanes.It has seem much use in the ten years I've had it.

I seem to remember reading somewhere that these plates change with use to a finer grit. Is this a fairy tale or is there any truth to it? Do the diamonds break down into smaller particles or something similar? It seems to me to leave a smoother surface that it used to. Am I imagining this?---Jack

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#2

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have tried to get micro-photographs of a worn plate but have not been successful. So I don't know.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Hmmm.

Jack Guzman from Maine

I thought for sure someone here would have an answer to my question. I guess this area hasn't been explored . It doesn't much matter. I like the results I get from the plate. Diamonds are making sharpening alot more fun for me.---Jack

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#4

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

don stephan

Great question for the manufacturer if the plate is labelled. And the manufacturer can be believed.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Jack Guzman from Maine

No label but Rockler should know the brand. I bought it from them.---Jack

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#6

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are two kinds of diamond abrasive- single crystal and polycrystalline. I suspect they wear differently. A single diamond crystal will be exceptionally tough and resist fracture. After all they crush rock to free them.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#7

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

AZ in Colorado Springs

Is it possible that the swarf gets lodged in the spaces between the diamond abrasive, filling in the"background" and creating the the effect of a finer grit?

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#8

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

William Duffield

I have a theory, based on my observations using several diamond "stones" and descriptions of the the manufacturing processes. The diamonds are sorted by size, and distributed on a steel plate. They are then "glued down" to the plate with a thin layer of nickel, which is deposited by electroplating. The diamonds are not all the same size, and different manufacturers use different criteria for selecting diamonds by size. Since the plate is flat, the larger diamonds protrude further above the surface of the plate. They are thus more likely to encounter the blade than smaller stones. I suspect that they are also more likely to fracture and more likely to be dislodged from the nickel adhesive. So the number and depth of the largest scratches decrease with time, while the smaller diamonds continue to abrade the blade.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#9

according to Norton.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"After several thousand passes through the material being cut, the exposed diamonds begin to crack and fracture. The matrix holding the diamond also begins to wear away.

Eventually the diamond completely breaks up and its fragments are swept away with the material that it is grinding."

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#10

maybe yes, maybe no

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I bought some diamond paste at Rockler a few years back, distinctly remember doing it. I went in a few weeks back looking for a different grit and no one remembered ever carrying it.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#11

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have a "fine" (600 grit) diamond plate from Easy-lap. This is well over 10 years old. It remains in use, but clearly dos not have the bite, nor leave the scratch pattern of 600 grit (I have another stone which is new and does). The scratch pattern is closer to 2000-3000, that is, it will leave a polished surface, but is refined by a 6000 grit ceramic stone. I often use it in place of a 1000 Pro Shapton to achieve the first wire edge.

Using the eye, I do not detect a loss of diamonds, per se, just a smoother surface to the touch.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#12

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Steve Elliott

I've had the same experience with diamond plates and have heard it described by others both as "wearing out" and "breaking in." I find new fixed diamond plates a little harsh at first and like the fact that they don't retain their original bite. On the other hand, I've had a few that finally just didn't cut quickly enough to keep using.

I like diamond paste on cast iron for finer grits partly because I can get back to the original cutting/polishing power by adding some paste.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#13

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Great question, Jack! I've wanted to know the same thing, for a long time.

I have had several DMT Dia-Sharp monocrystalline, 8x3 plates, in the various meshes they make. I've been disappointed with all them, and for the same reason, losing bite, to the point where they fairly quickly became useless to me. I quickly add that others have had much better experience, and it might very well be a case of me being ham-fisted with perfectly good plates.

On the other hand, I have been very happy with Atoma 400g and 1200g fixed diamond plates, from Lee Valley. I use the 400g for flattening water/ceramic stones, and the 1200g to raise an initial burr in routine sharpening. Neither is losing bite after a year or so of light use.

Wiley

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#14

Paste vs plate- doing some experimenting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been quietly experimenting with plates vs paste. Paste wins by a wide margin for speed. I just have not figured out the best way to use it. It will grind the 7" wheel hollow out of a blade in no time.

The experiment has been to compare 15 micron on cast iron to "Fine" EZ Lap. The plate is some years old and at the well broken in stage of its life. Paste cuts way faster. I have actually heard the cast iron plate "ring" while cutting.

The problem is what to do next. If one jumps to 1 micron, not an unreasonable jump with diamond, there is the fear of carry-over. I need to come up with a test to see how significant this problem is when the loose diamond is properly charged.

For now I am trying 15 micron on cast iron, quick cleaning swipe on fixed plate, then 1 micron, or, 15 micron followed by green stuff on leather. The later would not satisfy the most demanding sharpeners but it may be fine for a lot of cutting.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#15

Re: Paste vs plate- doing some experimenting

Steve Elliott

My cast iron plate has one side dedicated to 3 micron paste and the other to 1 micron. Whatever particles might be carried over from the 3 micron side haven't caused any problem I've noticed in ten or so years of use. The 3 micron paste cuts pretty fast compared to the waterstones I've used, even ones of coarser grit.

When I sharpen at work I hollow grind and then use a medium Ezelap plate followed by a fine waterstone. The method was chosen to reduce time spent and amount of gear, also to give me something I can lend to fellow workers without having to explain anything.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#16

that is an odd combination

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One can easily go from 15 to 1 micron. What is the rest of this sharpening regime that comes before the 3 micron? It is not apparent yet why you are using 3.

That said, there is so much overlap between these actual grit size distributions that I am not surprised that you see no carry-over effects, whether there are, or not.

Re: What happens to worn diamonds

#17

Re: that is an odd combination

Steve Elliott

I use the 3 micron to speed up honing worn edges. It cuts much faster than 1 micron, fast enough that I don't see a need for something as coarse as 15 micron.

When I grind and then hone I skip the 3 micron because I can grind very close to the existing edge, leaving very little work to do with the 1 micron.